40 Comments
User's avatar
Denis Cowley's avatar

The nugget I was hoping for; "𝘞𝘩𝘦𝘯 𝘺𝘰𝘶’𝘳𝘦 𝘣𝘦𝘵𝘵𝘪𝘯𝘨 𝘦𝘷𝘦𝘳𝘺𝘵𝘩𝘪𝘯𝘨 𝘰𝘯 𝘦𝘷𝘦𝘳𝘺 𝘩𝘢𝘯𝘥, 𝘺𝘰𝘶 𝘰𝘯𝘭𝘺 𝘩𝘢𝘷𝘦 𝘵𝘰 𝘣𝘦 𝘸𝘳𝘰𝘯𝘨 𝘰𝘯𝘤𝘦 𝘵𝘰 𝘨𝘪𝘷𝘦 𝘪𝘵 𝘢𝘭𝘭 𝘣𝘢𝘤𝘬."

Right up there with Hemingway's, ""How did you go bankrupt?". Mike replies, "Two ways. Gradually, then suddenly".

Both these arrows point at the same target.

Brian Clavin's avatar

Snap!! I was just about to paste the exact paragraph into a Comment and to give Chris some well-deserved Kudos…

“ I compared the United States to a gambler on the greatest hot streak in history, drunk on decades of winnings, blind to the reality that when you’re betting everything on every hand, you only have to be wrong once to give it all back.”

Xingyi's avatar

Meh, after the continual “prophesies” of doom since forever, one day they’re bound to come true… or not.

As I have commented for years now, the superpower of the elite is to keep the corpse limping along until it won’t affect them any longer.

Few (if any) people seem to appreciate that insight, but after 60 years on this planet I will bet the farm on it.

Quoth the Raven's avatar

You're making my point exactly...maybe 60 years and a day is the half life of this USD experiment?

badnabor's avatar

While I agree with your point about the "elite", I think that when the day of the crash arrives there will be a an unmasking of sorts. For a great number of the current financial elite, who appear amazing on paper and have cheered MMT for decades, the illusionary fiat "wealth" will vanish, and I, for one, will find it hard to empathize.

Xingyi's avatar

Mad rush on (physical) precious metals these days. I think some of them have plans to stay afloat!

curious_scientist's avatar

The US has that covered. Federal Precious metals long term capital gains tax is 28% (+3.8% if >200k of income) instead of standard 15% LTCG rate. The US will take a third of your gold appreciation against the falling dollar fiat currency.

Which is crazy considering that the mint was enacted in a way that allowed citizens to bring their own metals and have then coined for free, and have those coins legally be acceptable for all payment and debt even if the payee wanted another form of payment.

Even crazier is that this rate is a regulation by the IRS declaring precious metals collectibles.

Both these points contradict the Federalist and anti-Federalist Papers. Of course so does the Federal income tax as well.

Xingyi's avatar

I’m glad that you informed me about that. I had been contemplating converting some of my IRA to gold. But, given what you’ve said here, I would be facing the full 28% + 3.8% (31.8%) which is absolute fucken bullshit (pardon my French). My wife and I managed to get to that magic $1M in retirement accounts just this past year. So, when the dollar evaporates, I won’t be much concerned with how the wealthy are faring. I will be entirely focused on being in retirement with nothing left. I mean, I have some physical precious metals (of various varieties) in a safe deposit box, but not a whole lot (about $15K IIRC). It really just looks like there’s no way out of getting fucked even being someone whose AGI is in the (purported) top 6% of wage earners in the USA. Not sure that I believe that statistic, but I do believe that I will be getting fucked and tangible wealth obliterated when the dollar inevitably collapses. So, naturally, I hope that happens after my time on earth has expired.

badnabor's avatar

Yeah, at least all I'm trying to keep from sinking is a little john boat!

Allan Richard Wasem's avatar

The "problem" isn't the effect that the decline of the reserve status has on the "elite". They have a myriad of methods available to insulate themselves from the economic damage. The problem is the effect that the elite's actions to protect themselves have on the bottom 80% of American society.

Mrs Bucket's avatar

The 'bottom 80%' have been more damaged by the Biden-Obama regime than anything else. The elephant in the room is the DAMAGE done to the US economy 2021-25 by mass-unvetted immigration, China-loving Communist Democrats. Their Communist influence means millions of Americans are to function now as part of any economy. Most of the media is working AGAINST the USA, which makes Trump's task even bigger. What a shame that Bezos is China's department store manager and not the USA's.

Petty Rage Machine's avatar

We haven’t won a thousand spins of the roulette wheel. The wheel is a wheel that has every slot notched with a win. Every spin is the same. The market is corrupt beyond repair. Yes. But it’s still not China.

I appreciate doom and gloom as much as the next guy, but dedollarization isn’t happening in 2026. It isn’t happening in 2046. I would bet my life on it. We would have a better chance of eating a nuke or seeing terminator come true in 2026 than somehow losing the dollar as the reserve currency for planet earth.

Assuming China doesn’t want to commit suicide financially, globally, politically, and then assuming the United States and its allies literally just sat around and did absolutely nothing to counter dedollarization, conservatively it would take 15-25 years of insanely difficult work to unwind.

Imagine somehow convincing the world that the digital BRICS pay or CBDC du jour is where it’s at. Imagine it. You should know better than anyone the absurdity of business in China. How the fuck are they going to convince anyone they aren’t lying, cheating, autocratic, commie pieces of shit in a year? Nobody that’s ever done business with China thinks they are honest brokers. In ANY capacity. If you’re a foreigner you are greasing 2-10 ministries just to take a shit in Shanghai.

This isn’t even considering commodities. Even thinking about how that would be handled with China as the primary underwriter makes me nauseous.

Their current strategy of hoarding gold, export controls on rare earth, etc… are meaningless the millisecond we “tech” through the fences. Which will happen long before they can do enough damage to dedollarize while not killing themselves in the process.

China (nor BRICS at large) will ever cause the collapse of the dollar in any way. Try as they might, the problem will always be that the alternative to the dollar is China. I don’t even consider Russia, India, Iran etc… that’s laughable. So tell me how China is suddenly going to let trade flow, run trade deficits and let loose their red commie grip on the balls of humanity? The only way that would happen would be via hostile takeover. Which would last 38 seconds.

Wesley Hayes's avatar

In summary, shit's fucked.

Quoth the Raven's avatar

Nice cross section of my average reader right here ^

george's avatar

Haven't you heard? We have the F35!

Steve S's avatar

Inflating the dollar is the only way we manage our exploding debt. What the United States spends on debt interest now exceeds what we spend on national defense. Soon it will exceed what we spend on non discretionary social expenses such as social security, medicare, and medicaid. Aside from stocking up on guns, ammo, water, ammo, gold, silver, ammo, bitcoin, bicycles, e-bikes as well, did I mention ammo?, there isn't much more we can do. Doesn't mean we can't enjoy the miracle of taking breath, being of service to our loved ones, and enjoying life. The questions become: What makes you happy? What gives you joy? What sustains you? What allows you to be content and sleep at night?

The Scratch's avatar

The dollar weakening a little bit could help our debt situation.

Our trade deficit has fallen from $130B in January (Biden's last month) to $53B in September. Tariffs may have helped but a weakening dollar may have been the main reason the deficit fell- exports have been climbing.

As economist Wynne Godley pointed out, trade deficit = public sector deficit + private sector deficit. Ever since the mid 1970s, our Federal deficits have been paying for our trade deficits. Sometimes the private sector deficits are what pay for the bulk of trade deficits (for example the Clinton years up to the 2008 financial crisis). As economist Hyman Minsky pointed out, private sector debt is unstable, hence the 2008 crisis. The Obama administration stabilized the economy by moving much of this private sector debt to the public sector ledger.

Steve S's avatar

Janet Yellen didn't do us any favors when, as Treasury Secretary, she financed a larger share of our national debt with short term loans, issueing treasuries with short term notes rather than long term bonds. She did this even when interest rates were near zero, missing an opportunity to lock in low rates by financing more of our national debt with long term bonds. This missed opportunity is now costing us trillions of dollars.

Anonymously Yours's avatar

Yes, USD losing purchasing power, but no replacement on horizon as reserve fx. Not even close, for so many reasons. Trade settlement using combo of fiat and metals ok for sovereigns and maybe huge companies, no such option for anyone else. F/eg: I give you a billion Yuan, only condition, you can't convert it. Must spend in China. Now what?

Calls foe imminent end of USD as reserve fx is classic sign of amateur, at least until we get some viable substitute with requisite deep capital markets, free floating exchange rate, property rights, wide acceptance and easy convertibility, etc. (as long as you don't really piss off US gov).

Indeed, in next real crisis, watch USD soar. Can't take bullion or cryptos to the grocery, or use them to pay via dr. card or move bullion overseas easily or safely.

badnabor's avatar

In the event of a crash, the USD (as it stands now, a classic fiat currency), will NOT be viable. As far as your argument "Can't take bullion or cryptos to the grocery", I can remember when it was not common to make every purchase via a credit card, and yet consumer markets, as they always will, adapted to the available "currency".

Michael Woods's avatar

I hesitate to reply to this post, as it is the only time so far that I disagree with your opinion. While nothing is forever, the dollar, short of a world war that we are on the wrong side of, is not nearing collapse in the immediate future. Why?

1) There is no legitimate alternative currency. Brics is a group of mostly financially, non transparent countries, that, even in the case of no current alternative, would be unlikely to gain the trust of the financial world.

2) Brics does not have the developed bond structure of the United States, something that would take decades at a minimum to develop.

3) The United States IS the market to the world, forcing the rest of the world to trade in dollars if they want to access this market.

4) Rather than being backed by gold, silver or oil, the US dollar is backed by the purchasing power of our nation of consumers.

I am not saying that the reign of the dollar is forever, it isn't. But it cannot be displaced in lieu of an alternative. Nor, is there any national currency that doesn't have the same, or worse, battle with deficit spending. As far as that goes, the first currency to fail, will likely be the Euro, leaving even fewer alternatives for a reserve currency.

While the United States has continued to make mistakes regarding its fiduciary duty as the worlds reserve currency, the latest of which was to weaponize the system against Russia, it is likely to remain the reserve currency for quite some time for the multiple reasons above.

Michael Woods's avatar

That may be true, however the US market remains far and away the largest.

PG's avatar

The purchasing power of a significant portion of that nation of consumers comes from welfare. Much of the rest comes from debt they can't service.

TA's avatar

Succinct recap of the risks facing the US$, and consequently the US populace's standard of living, security and economy. The Wall Street Urinal will put the issue on the front page as soon as it can be blamed all on Trump (which is already a dominant narrative), but ignore the culpability of the Uniparty’s profligacy, irresponsibility and corruption.

Bob Nixon's avatar

That comparison is unfair to urinals.

fab's avatar

When the UDSSR collapsed in the 90's Fukuyama wrote a book called "The End of History" but in fact it was the end of ideology. Now, everybody is in for the money (except maybe NK) and they learned from us. Good students indeed. As an aside, if the dilution of the dollar becomes mainstream, I'm quietly waiting to buy, just waiting for the Economist cover page.

Ng's avatar

Aside from gold, how to hedge against this weakness, CHF? Commodities?

TA's avatar

Perhaps the standard fallbacks - water, bullets, freeze-dried foods, like-minded neighbors….?

Doge's avatar

perserverance and enduring strength of character

george's avatar

I coulda shoulda woulda got into gold last year, but it seems the taxes on this little nugget can really make an impact on one who isn't sufficiently wealthy which kept me on the sidelines. I'm old and finally got my real estate taxes frozen (NJ) but need to limit my income to keep it or make blowout returns to pay the taxes that will come back on board.

It's never discussed, but the "special" tax on gold is an unspoken reality. The government makes money off of you no matter what. Am I missing something or any thoughts?

Mike's avatar

I've tempered my heretics.

Pull that green back out in the most remote jungles of the farthest reaches of man kind and people will do litteraly anything to aquire it from you. That represents her true demand. Shit will limp along here like a corpse to credit another commenter.

I Don't see that going away anytime soon.

Joe Groover's avatar

As long as the rest of the world continues to produce so that Americans can consume, the dollar is safe.

Grateful Nana's avatar

I do fear we are heading down the terminal path for the dollar. But I'm wondering if there is any way to get gold out of the collectible category with its penalty of capital gains tax and back to what it is, real money? What would that take to accomplish?