Not even a month since Trump took the heroic move to put one of the world's most evil regimes out of business and the whiners haven't stopped sniping, attacking and undermining him - and the brave pilots, soldiers, marines who understand what needs to happen. You people need to grow up and wise up. 'Trump is right, the Middle East will be more stable than ever before'. Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang. Clearly he knows more than you losers. Plenty of other Middle Eastern governments know this also.
There is room on both sides. Any honest person would concede the Mullahs are a menace to humanity and the world a better place without them. I suspect this may ultimately be scored a mistake, but sending Iran pallets of cash was a much bigger mistake. Further, the difficulty factor in clearing this regime is much higher than solving this nation’s same sex bathroom crisis. Love him or hate him, The Donald is playing for all the marbles.
You write as if you have no idea what the strategy is of controlling the supply chain for energy across the entire globe and removing impediments and threats to that supply would be like versus 50 years of terror, murder and extortion. Grow TF up.
Yes, let's rule the world while knowing full well that all Empires fall, right? The Empires of Europe went out in a blaze of wars, making Britain not even an island nation now and Germany and France all but kicked out of Africa. You are witnessing America's late stage effort before final collapse. Why?"
$40T debt and growing
Lack of materials to replace expended munitions (which have also been proven to be ineffective)
Plenty of pissed off people now that the world economy has been forever altered.
You have just summed up all the correct reasons for why we must do it. For yearly 75 years the USA has made stupid deals at the BS of European partners that have not endured to our benefits. We have to change the way the world does business.
This has been a complete disaster. I voted for this man for the SOLE reason as I felt he would be an anti war president. What a fool I am. He's NO different than any other president, completely bought & paid for, and now us - the American consumer will pay the price, along with American military who will pay the ULTIMATE price and God only know how many innocent Iranians will die. For what? That idiot Netanyahu has been spouting the same lie for over 30 YEARS!! Israel HAS nukes, why didn't we bomb them instead ?
The U.S., Israel and others have been working for decades to deny Iran a nuclear weapon, and warning anyone who would listen that Iran continues to get closer and closer to obtaining a weapon and the means to deliver it. None of these incremental and sometimes clandestine moves have stop their forward progress. Slowed, yes but not stopped. The fact that few people listen or are capable of understanding the threat does not mean the warnings should not be taken seriously.
Iran has been weeks away from a nuclear weapon for 30 years. What intelligence was there to say they were imminent and who was the source? Also, why is it assumed that Iran will use a nuclear weapon? Seems to me that nuclear weapons are a deterrence to being attacked. North Korea being the obvious example. If your answer is “because they are crazy!”, go look at how every enemy of the United States has been portrayed in our media since the Spanish American War.
I remain disappointed and underwhelmed by the Big Brains like Joe Kent and places like Cato that point out the failures or shortcomings of the current effort to deny the leading state sponsor of terrorism a nuclear weapon. Were we supposed to do nothing? Negotiation have been going on for decades yet Iran did not suspend, reduce or forfeit their nuclear ambitions. Sanctions have been in place for years including broad sanctions and demands by six UN resolutions demanding Iran stop its nuclear weapons development and missile programs. So I again ask those critical of the current operation - what should we do or should have done and how confident are you that these alternative actions would successfully make the world safe from a nuclear armed Iran? Because peaceful negotiations and economic sanctions have not worked.
I suspect we’ll find out the hard way. Why would a nuclear armed Iran be any more dangerous than a nuclear armed North Korea or a nuclear armed Russia. Or China. Or Israel. Or Pakistan. The question isn’t a crazy as it seems. There’s a lot of Great Game stuff going on, lots of propaganda, lots of global chessboard stuff. It’s easy to Mock the Mullahs, and yeah, I get the religious fanatic stuff is not our cup of tea here in the USA. But we just blew up the one religious fanatic who prevented the Islamic Bomb due to his religious theology — so is the Islam that says you can’t have a nuke the Islam you’re scared of having a nuke — hello? — and that was Khameini himself. You blow him up and you get worse. Well we’ve go it now.
I’’d say this misadventure has radically raised the odds of nuclear Iran. I mean, if you’re Iran wouldn’t you — unless you can work out a security gaurantee from Russia or China or something but I suspect they’ll go for the bomb. Or what’s our option now, a WW2 style invasion to do to them what allies did to Germany with 2 million troops and WW2 style or higher KIAs? That’s about the only option left. Either that or nukem. What was that about religious fanatics? We have them too.
Global geopolitics has its own religion — power. I suspect If Iran actually did have a nuke or nukes, probably nothing would actually happen except they’d get invaded less frequently. The place has been around for 3000 years and it’s not going anywhere. I don’t buy the hysteria around it. Religious hysteria is for little people. Geopolitics is the only law when you have nukes and everybody at that table plays the same poker game, by and large, power/security/statecraft/alliances/etc.. Especially in that part of the world. Just my one cent from the cheap seats.
craazyman needs to add a few more "a's" and "z's" to his crazy. "Why would a nuclear armed Iran be any more dangerous than a nuclear armed North Korea, or Russia, or Israel, or Pakistan?" Why would a machine gun armed homocidal psychopathic maniac be any more dangerous than an armed policeman, or Army soldier, or Navy solider, or Marine? Yeah, why?
That’s a spurious analogy not an answer. I know this only a comment section on the internet — all fair, no worries. But seriously, What about Putin — wasn’t he going to overrun Europe? What about Xi, first Taiwan and then San Francisco? What about Kim Jong Un? What about Pakistan Islamic crazies? They’ve all got the bomb. What makes the Iranian leadership any different — in terms of geopolitics? Oh . . . It was something somebody said on Fox News? Or MSNBC? Or Gateway Pundit (I actually like Gateway Pundit, or the Washington Post (which I used to delver as a paper boy)( I do like gateway pundit to be honest, on lots of stuff, ha!). Oh boy. Maybe it’s a Kurtz in Heart of Darkness moment “exterminate the brutes”. Well? We all feel that a little bit. Even me.
Probably be a waste of time explaining the obvious to you, but I've got a few minutes. None of these other nations have clearly expressed their intention to totally destroy and eradicate another nation with a nuclear weapon. Iran has repeatedly expressed their desire to destroy America ("Death to America," "Death to the Big Satan"), which is insane but shows the apocolyptic insanity of the mullahs as they await the coming of the 12th Imam. Iran has repeatedly expressed their desire and intention to destroy Israel ("Death to Israel," "Death to the Little Satan"), which might actually be possible if they obtained a nuclear weapon.
Others have already addressed why Iran would be dangerous. But this response contains a number of incongruous points, like "Islam says you can't have a nuke" and then "this misadventure raises the odd of a nuclear Iran". Which is it?
Not sure where all the Post Hate here comes from. This Post is pretty mild criticism, and quite factual — I see a lot of geopolitical podcasts of senior intelligence/military people and Whoa Nellie! If you think this post is too critical, well . . . Hmmm. I voted for the Orange Man and there’s a lot there to like, but I did not vote for this and I don’t like it. The world is not a WWE Event. There actually is something called “Reality” and eventually you have to live there.
I wonder what my thinking would be if I grew up in Iran, heard my parents talk about what it was like before the shah and then later lived through the revolution of 79? Would I be thinking, oh America, please come save me? Or would it be the opposite?
How can we start behaving in a way that leaves the world better off and exhibits the responsibility of those deserving the power they hold.
Go look up Tousi TV on youtube. Livestreams everyday, publishes a few videos from inside Iran. A pro US/Israel - anti Islamic Regime channel. He is Iranian, whose father still lives in Tehran. Soo, I did not know until recently that most Iranians are Persian. The Islamic Regime is Arabic. Many in Iran consider themselves as oppressed by a foreign occupying force! Sometime he struggles trying to pronounce the Arabic name of the latest Islamic leader that was killed. When the Ayatollah was killed, they showed people dancing in the streets, in many areas in Tehran and other parts of Iran. If you really want a deep dive - lookup "Sheep among Wolves II". 2 hour documentary on the Christian Church in Iran. One person said that Islam has be fully discredited by the ruling Clerics in the eyes of many people since the revolution of 79.
"There is now considerable evidence that Trump’s chief negotiators on the Iranian nuclear file—Jared Kushner and Steve Witkoff—fundamentally misunderstood at least some of the technical issues at the heart of the dispute, undermining their ability to conduct informed negotiations."
He is being extremely charitable with this assertion. The Arms Control article linked in the foregoing quote makes clear that the focus of "fundamentally misunderstood" is Witkoff, based mostly on his comments to the press on March 3, 2026, after the war kicked off.
The less charitable but more accurate interpretation is that he lied. He hardly needed to lie to Trump. Trump is in on the game. But, his comments to the press about Iran's positions and its motivations were not misunderstandings. They were lies meant to justify the war. The whole pretext for this war is utter nonsense: Israel was going to attack, and we knew that they would attack us back if Israel went alone so, rather than wait to get hit, we joined in as a defensive measure. Sure. All a bunch of liars.
Does anybody still take the Cato Institute seriously? If so, not after this essay. The author's nonsensical point that Iran is stronger now than before the bombing started on February 28th is like a fight announcer describing a boxer who has been getting the shit kicked out of him for 4 rounds with barely landing a blow in return, is now stronger and more powerful than when the fight began. Not only is he more powerful, but the winning fighter has lost because they haven't yet knocked the slaphappy stumbling bloodied fighter unconscious yet. The winning fighter should just cut his losses, quit on the stool, and go home. I hope this essay was printed for satirical value.
It is revealing that no other country has come to Iran's aid in the war. One reason is, I think, that nobody wants Iran to possess a nuclear weapon. The group of nuclear armed nations is the most exclusive club on Earth. It is surprisingly stable and collectively the members do not want any new members.
What are you talking about? Russia is openly aiding Iran and has said so publicly. It's almost certain China is, if only by purchasing Iranian oil with yuan, but it's highly likely in other ways, too. Yemen is threatening to close the Red Sea in solidarity. Lebanon initiated attacks against Israel to open another front.
Now, put the shoe on the other foot. How many NATO allies have joined the US and Israel? Britain lets us use their bases for "defensive" purposes. Germany laughed in our face when asked to participate. Spain responded just short of using expletives.
I am not saying the whole world is cheering for Iran. But, if you think they're cheering for the US and Israel, you've been smoking too much of the propaganda.
What specific new intelligence is Susannah George citing? What agency? What credibility - Wapo? Sure doesn't seem like that is happening. I'm more inclined to think we are actually living through The Fourth Turning which will set the stage for a new more peaceful world order.
There are so many variables happening at once from financial, geopolitical resets, about face alliance changes, what were once geopolitical quagmires are now just rendered inconsequential and will resolve themselves on their own (Ukraine), authoritarian regimes are collapsing under their own weight and lack of sustaining partners.
Iran has alienated the entire world and that world is now aligned against it. Not something they can hope to beat. When Trump gets you in this position the screws will only continue to turn.
We are only 4 days away from the promised end of Trump’s “4-week war.” It will, of course be like his “two weeks to flatten the curve” during the COVID debacle. So if “two weeks” became 3 years then, can we expect “4 weeks” to become six years now?
In the meantime, as we begin the 9th month of his “4-week war” on midterm election day, Democrats will overwhelmingly take the House and immediately begin impeachment proceedings. The difference is that this time, some Republicans in the Senate might just be fed up with his crap and join the vote for removal.
Yeah, I'm sure the folks at home were ready to throw in the towel when Hitler didn't surrender 2 weeks after D-Day.
I'm sorry. It's hard to take this seriously. Or mayber you were taking the under on Iran loading up a nuke onto one of their missile frigates and lobbing it into Central Park. Remember they believe that God has commanded them to kill us.
We'd then spend a year trying to figure out who did it with forensics constrained by nuclear contamination. Oh, and the markets might be disrupted a little, too.
This reads like the result of a prompt to ChatGPT asking for a negative article about the intervention in Iran.
Let's hope Chris takes note of the majority of readers' opinions and doesn't keep pushing the TDS rock uphill.
100000 'likes'
Curiosity I guess
Not even a month since Trump took the heroic move to put one of the world's most evil regimes out of business and the whiners haven't stopped sniping, attacking and undermining him - and the brave pilots, soldiers, marines who understand what needs to happen. You people need to grow up and wise up. 'Trump is right, the Middle East will be more stable than ever before'. Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang. Clearly he knows more than you losers. Plenty of other Middle Eastern governments know this also.
Wow, open a history book for Gods sake!! Just make sure you ALWAYS capitalize the "M" whenever you mention MY precious Marine Corps....
Evil is in the eye of the beholder.
There is room on both sides. Any honest person would concede the Mullahs are a menace to humanity and the world a better place without them. I suspect this may ultimately be scored a mistake, but sending Iran pallets of cash was a much bigger mistake. Further, the difficulty factor in clearing this regime is much higher than solving this nation’s same sex bathroom crisis. Love him or hate him, The Donald is playing for all the marbles.
You write as if you have no idea what the strategy is of controlling the supply chain for energy across the entire globe and removing impediments and threats to that supply would be like versus 50 years of terror, murder and extortion. Grow TF up.
The supply chain was fine until the US acted to brake it, to control it.
Funny how Russia, an Orthodox Christian majority, is able to get along with Iran and make Strategic Agreements, no?
Yes, let's rule the world while knowing full well that all Empires fall, right? The Empires of Europe went out in a blaze of wars, making Britain not even an island nation now and Germany and France all but kicked out of Africa. You are witnessing America's late stage effort before final collapse. Why?"
$40T debt and growing
Lack of materials to replace expended munitions (which have also been proven to be ineffective)
Plenty of pissed off people now that the world economy has been forever altered.
You have just summed up all the correct reasons for why we must do it. For yearly 75 years the USA has made stupid deals at the BS of European partners that have not endured to our benefits. We have to change the way the world does business.
This has been a complete disaster. I voted for this man for the SOLE reason as I felt he would be an anti war president. What a fool I am. He's NO different than any other president, completely bought & paid for, and now us - the American consumer will pay the price, along with American military who will pay the ULTIMATE price and God only know how many innocent Iranians will die. For what? That idiot Netanyahu has been spouting the same lie for over 30 YEARS!! Israel HAS nukes, why didn't we bomb them instead ?
The U.S., Israel and others have been working for decades to deny Iran a nuclear weapon, and warning anyone who would listen that Iran continues to get closer and closer to obtaining a weapon and the means to deliver it. None of these incremental and sometimes clandestine moves have stop their forward progress. Slowed, yes but not stopped. The fact that few people listen or are capable of understanding the threat does not mean the warnings should not be taken seriously.
Iran has been weeks away from a nuclear weapon for 30 years. What intelligence was there to say they were imminent and who was the source? Also, why is it assumed that Iran will use a nuclear weapon? Seems to me that nuclear weapons are a deterrence to being attacked. North Korea being the obvious example. If your answer is “because they are crazy!”, go look at how every enemy of the United States has been portrayed in our media since the Spanish American War.
Threat to who? I don't want our kids getting killed for Israel. If they weren't such assholes, everyone wouldn't want to kill them.
I remain disappointed and underwhelmed by the Big Brains like Joe Kent and places like Cato that point out the failures or shortcomings of the current effort to deny the leading state sponsor of terrorism a nuclear weapon. Were we supposed to do nothing? Negotiation have been going on for decades yet Iran did not suspend, reduce or forfeit their nuclear ambitions. Sanctions have been in place for years including broad sanctions and demands by six UN resolutions demanding Iran stop its nuclear weapons development and missile programs. So I again ask those critical of the current operation - what should we do or should have done and how confident are you that these alternative actions would successfully make the world safe from a nuclear armed Iran? Because peaceful negotiations and economic sanctions have not worked.
I suspect we’ll find out the hard way. Why would a nuclear armed Iran be any more dangerous than a nuclear armed North Korea or a nuclear armed Russia. Or China. Or Israel. Or Pakistan. The question isn’t a crazy as it seems. There’s a lot of Great Game stuff going on, lots of propaganda, lots of global chessboard stuff. It’s easy to Mock the Mullahs, and yeah, I get the religious fanatic stuff is not our cup of tea here in the USA. But we just blew up the one religious fanatic who prevented the Islamic Bomb due to his religious theology — so is the Islam that says you can’t have a nuke the Islam you’re scared of having a nuke — hello? — and that was Khameini himself. You blow him up and you get worse. Well we’ve go it now.
I’’d say this misadventure has radically raised the odds of nuclear Iran. I mean, if you’re Iran wouldn’t you — unless you can work out a security gaurantee from Russia or China or something but I suspect they’ll go for the bomb. Or what’s our option now, a WW2 style invasion to do to them what allies did to Germany with 2 million troops and WW2 style or higher KIAs? That’s about the only option left. Either that or nukem. What was that about religious fanatics? We have them too.
Global geopolitics has its own religion — power. I suspect If Iran actually did have a nuke or nukes, probably nothing would actually happen except they’d get invaded less frequently. The place has been around for 3000 years and it’s not going anywhere. I don’t buy the hysteria around it. Religious hysteria is for little people. Geopolitics is the only law when you have nukes and everybody at that table plays the same poker game, by and large, power/security/statecraft/alliances/etc.. Especially in that part of the world. Just my one cent from the cheap seats.
craazyman needs to add a few more "a's" and "z's" to his crazy. "Why would a nuclear armed Iran be any more dangerous than a nuclear armed North Korea, or Russia, or Israel, or Pakistan?" Why would a machine gun armed homocidal psychopathic maniac be any more dangerous than an armed policeman, or Army soldier, or Navy solider, or Marine? Yeah, why?
That’s a spurious analogy not an answer. I know this only a comment section on the internet — all fair, no worries. But seriously, What about Putin — wasn’t he going to overrun Europe? What about Xi, first Taiwan and then San Francisco? What about Kim Jong Un? What about Pakistan Islamic crazies? They’ve all got the bomb. What makes the Iranian leadership any different — in terms of geopolitics? Oh . . . It was something somebody said on Fox News? Or MSNBC? Or Gateway Pundit (I actually like Gateway Pundit, or the Washington Post (which I used to delver as a paper boy)( I do like gateway pundit to be honest, on lots of stuff, ha!). Oh boy. Maybe it’s a Kurtz in Heart of Darkness moment “exterminate the brutes”. Well? We all feel that a little bit. Even me.
Probably be a waste of time explaining the obvious to you, but I've got a few minutes. None of these other nations have clearly expressed their intention to totally destroy and eradicate another nation with a nuclear weapon. Iran has repeatedly expressed their desire to destroy America ("Death to America," "Death to the Big Satan"), which is insane but shows the apocolyptic insanity of the mullahs as they await the coming of the 12th Imam. Iran has repeatedly expressed their desire and intention to destroy Israel ("Death to Israel," "Death to the Little Satan"), which might actually be possible if they obtained a nuclear weapon.
Others have already addressed why Iran would be dangerous. But this response contains a number of incongruous points, like "Islam says you can't have a nuke" and then "this misadventure raises the odd of a nuclear Iran". Which is it?
Spot on.
Three sentences into the article the author references a story from WaPo. I knew pretty quick where this article was going.
Not sure where all the Post Hate here comes from. This Post is pretty mild criticism, and quite factual — I see a lot of geopolitical podcasts of senior intelligence/military people and Whoa Nellie! If you think this post is too critical, well . . . Hmmm. I voted for the Orange Man and there’s a lot there to like, but I did not vote for this and I don’t like it. The world is not a WWE Event. There actually is something called “Reality” and eventually you have to live there.
I wonder what my thinking would be if I grew up in Iran, heard my parents talk about what it was like before the shah and then later lived through the revolution of 79? Would I be thinking, oh America, please come save me? Or would it be the opposite?
How can we start behaving in a way that leaves the world better off and exhibits the responsibility of those deserving the power they hold.
Go look up Tousi TV on youtube. Livestreams everyday, publishes a few videos from inside Iran. A pro US/Israel - anti Islamic Regime channel. He is Iranian, whose father still lives in Tehran. Soo, I did not know until recently that most Iranians are Persian. The Islamic Regime is Arabic. Many in Iran consider themselves as oppressed by a foreign occupying force! Sometime he struggles trying to pronounce the Arabic name of the latest Islamic leader that was killed. When the Ayatollah was killed, they showed people dancing in the streets, in many areas in Tehran and other parts of Iran. If you really want a deep dive - lookup "Sheep among Wolves II". 2 hour documentary on the Christian Church in Iran. One person said that Islam has be fully discredited by the ruling Clerics in the eyes of many people since the revolution of 79.
"There is now considerable evidence that Trump’s chief negotiators on the Iranian nuclear file—Jared Kushner and Steve Witkoff—fundamentally misunderstood at least some of the technical issues at the heart of the dispute, undermining their ability to conduct informed negotiations."
He is being extremely charitable with this assertion. The Arms Control article linked in the foregoing quote makes clear that the focus of "fundamentally misunderstood" is Witkoff, based mostly on his comments to the press on March 3, 2026, after the war kicked off.
The less charitable but more accurate interpretation is that he lied. He hardly needed to lie to Trump. Trump is in on the game. But, his comments to the press about Iran's positions and its motivations were not misunderstandings. They were lies meant to justify the war. The whole pretext for this war is utter nonsense: Israel was going to attack, and we knew that they would attack us back if Israel went alone so, rather than wait to get hit, we joined in as a defensive measure. Sure. All a bunch of liars.
Does anybody still take the Cato Institute seriously? If so, not after this essay. The author's nonsensical point that Iran is stronger now than before the bombing started on February 28th is like a fight announcer describing a boxer who has been getting the shit kicked out of him for 4 rounds with barely landing a blow in return, is now stronger and more powerful than when the fight began. Not only is he more powerful, but the winning fighter has lost because they haven't yet knocked the slaphappy stumbling bloodied fighter unconscious yet. The winning fighter should just cut his losses, quit on the stool, and go home. I hope this essay was printed for satirical value.
The Cato Institute. The Rand Paul wing of the RINO Party.
It is revealing that no other country has come to Iran's aid in the war. One reason is, I think, that nobody wants Iran to possess a nuclear weapon. The group of nuclear armed nations is the most exclusive club on Earth. It is surprisingly stable and collectively the members do not want any new members.
What are you talking about? Russia is openly aiding Iran and has said so publicly. It's almost certain China is, if only by purchasing Iranian oil with yuan, but it's highly likely in other ways, too. Yemen is threatening to close the Red Sea in solidarity. Lebanon initiated attacks against Israel to open another front.
Now, put the shoe on the other foot. How many NATO allies have joined the US and Israel? Britain lets us use their bases for "defensive" purposes. Germany laughed in our face when asked to participate. Spain responded just short of using expletives.
I am not saying the whole world is cheering for Iran. But, if you think they're cheering for the US and Israel, you've been smoking too much of the propaganda.
What specific new intelligence is Susannah George citing? What agency? What credibility - Wapo? Sure doesn't seem like that is happening. I'm more inclined to think we are actually living through The Fourth Turning which will set the stage for a new more peaceful world order.
There are so many variables happening at once from financial, geopolitical resets, about face alliance changes, what were once geopolitical quagmires are now just rendered inconsequential and will resolve themselves on their own (Ukraine), authoritarian regimes are collapsing under their own weight and lack of sustaining partners.
Iran has alienated the entire world and that world is now aligned against it. Not something they can hope to beat. When Trump gets you in this position the screws will only continue to turn.
We are only 4 days away from the promised end of Trump’s “4-week war.” It will, of course be like his “two weeks to flatten the curve” during the COVID debacle. So if “two weeks” became 3 years then, can we expect “4 weeks” to become six years now?
In the meantime, as we begin the 9th month of his “4-week war” on midterm election day, Democrats will overwhelmingly take the House and immediately begin impeachment proceedings. The difference is that this time, some Republicans in the Senate might just be fed up with his crap and join the vote for removal.
Yeah, I'm sure the folks at home were ready to throw in the towel when Hitler didn't surrender 2 weeks after D-Day.
I'm sorry. It's hard to take this seriously. Or mayber you were taking the under on Iran loading up a nuke onto one of their missile frigates and lobbing it into Central Park. Remember they believe that God has commanded them to kill us.
We'd then spend a year trying to figure out who did it with forensics constrained by nuclear contamination. Oh, and the markets might be disrupted a little, too.