23 Comments
User's avatar
Lyss's avatar

If this were a true and fair capitalist economy I would agree. But we have an oligarchy and a government that functions to enable that oligarchy under the guise of capitalism.

george's avatar

You forgot the MIC. It's budget exceeds most country's GDP.

Never Forget's avatar

It's both sides and the corners.

dk's avatar

Over the next 6-24 months, AI is going to carve off white collar jobs like a hot knife 🔪 through butter. The tax base will decrease, while wealth taxes come in to try and fleece a portable wealthy class.

As an example, in WA State, Democrats want to push thru a “Millionaires Tax”. Except those who make over a million in this work from home world will simply move. The democrats did not limit their bill to over a million, even as Republicans pushed them to do so. Given their lack of fiscal discipline, in a few short years this tax will likely be a $100,000-aires tax.

California didn’t pass their billionaires tax yet, but just the push for one has sent over 1/2 of them packing for other states. And many corporate HQ’s have been leaving for years.

Governments don’t have a “revenue” problem, they have a spending problem. Particularly the more socialist blue states.

The crash out in places like WA & CA is going to be epic.

JudyS's avatar

Another softer factor is that the definition of “rich” changes. It becomes tax that electrician, he works lots of hours and overtime and has more income to tax.

JP's avatar

It’s just amazing to me that some people just don’t understand this. However, when you get to a position of power, you have to get votes to stay there, no matter what the cost. What a shame.

Leskunque Lepew's avatar

The cost is the end of a Representative Republic.

george's avatar

America was wealthy and no one payed taxes prior to the Civil War. Republicans started the tax scheme and it's been downhill since.

Leskunque Lepew's avatar

And the Democrats co-opted it.

Dewey Hildebrand's avatar

As usual for Mises articles, spot on. Should be required reading for everyone but most emphatically, all politicians. Although they seem to believe upon being elected they become omniscient, so they probably wouldn’t pay attention.

fab's avatar

When there is a debate about rich people's taxation, the underlying thought of those against it sounds a bite like this ; without the rich we'd be all poor. I'm not so sure. Given the financialization of the economy, taxing the rich would simply be returning some of the money they got for free. Taxing the rich in a real Austrian economy would be theft. Taxing the rich in our skewed Keyneysian economy (skewed towards always stimulate) may help us avoid some deep societal problems.

Bill Lacey's avatar

Even if a wealth tax were a good idea (it's not), it would be administered by the government. You know, the people who lost the war on drugs, the war on poverty, the war on terror, the war on "why Johnny can't read". The ones who's mandatory residential housing lending policies and lack of oversight caused the Great Financial Crisis. The ones who brought us the embarrassing and idiotic COVID responses.

My point - when you have a driver repeatedly getting into horrific auto accidents, you take the keys away. You don't keep lending him money to buy new cars.

erik bjorseth's avatar

Taxing more does not solve any problems - it just creates more fraud and money funneling back to politicians or their supporters. We have never had a tax revenue issue, we have a spending problem.

Rich people have more resources to avoid taxes. If they run out of avenues to elude taxes - they will just raise their prices so the consumer absorbs that taxes.

Now if you lower my taxes, I will invest more into my company (more employees / resources). When companies hire more people - the pool of talent shrinks - when the talent pool shrinks I have to pay more to attract the employees I want.

There will always be income inequality - that is how capitalism works. However the more you tax the upper end - it will just hurt the lower end. The last person that wants to make less money is the person on the top.

badnabor's avatar

I could be wrong, but I think that if you extrapolate this message, it becomes clear that taxes on ANY level of income are harmful to the capitalist republic. There is clearly something wrong when a nation's tax base is only about half of the population.

Ryan S's avatar

There is clearly something wrong when income inequality is so great that only about half the population is part of the nation's tax base. I doubt you're advocating for less income inequality, but the reality is the tax base is a function of income distribution. If income were distributed more broadly, the tax base would broaden as well. Conversely, as income has concentrated towards the top earners, the tax base has narrowed. It's just how the math works in our tax system.

george's avatar

Remember DOGE? hahahahahahahaha The MIC got an additional $500B and they're asking for more! woohoo!

Cranky Frankie's avatar

The sad swindle is that the additional taxes collected, despite being insignificant when divided across the recipient population, never gets to them anyway since the supposed beneficiaries aren't trusted to make wise decisions. Instead new layers of administrators soak up most of the new taxes in order to guarantee the poor don't spend the money on liquor or at the track.

Susan Watterson's avatar

If the 3.5% pd by the extremely rich was tied to legislation earmarked specifically for US debt reduction, I do not agree the funds collected by the Treasury would be allocated to Congressional pork excesses. Problem is Congress appears spineless in enacting any budget, let alone true debt reduction.

george's avatar

The "Rich" live off Trust Funds, Charities and Foundations. They'll never pay taxes.

Bill D's avatar

Politicians buy votes, uber wealthy buy politicians. The current tax system is stuffed with loopholes only the really wealthy can access and is rigged against the middle class. the current concentration of wealth and therefore power in the hands of the few would make a banana republic blush. As Buffet noted, he pays less taxes as a percentage of income then his secretary does. That tells you all you need to know about the state of our current tax system.

Allan Richard Wasem's avatar

The need of the modern Bureaucratic State for MORE revenue in insatiable. The social and economic consequences are considered irrelevant.

Leskunque Lepew's avatar

And buying votes they do thru ballot harvesting.

Sounds like the author spent some time with the voluminous IRS Tax Code which has no common sense.