This is my industry. I don’t work for Kalshi, but I clear these types of contracts. The whole argument was that this stuff would be fully collateralized and immediately they want to open the door to leverage…because of course they do.
The scuttlebutt is that Kalshi needs this or they are going to go bust. Prediction markets are still marginal and weird. Without strong market making they don’t have the liquidity to present meaningful markets. This stuff can’t exist naturally, not at an enterprise level anyway, because most people aren’t gamblers. Let’s keep it that way.
And prediction markets might soon find themselves regulated by state gambling authorities instead of the CFTC. Then they'd be in the same taxation bucket as DraftKings and Fanduel.
This is the big question right now and why a lot of people in my corner of the financial industry were hoping the Clarity Act would pass—the cftc is trying valiantly to manage this stuff with no meaningful input from congress. At least that’s how it feels.
And it seems true that this could tip either back into a purely ‘state’s right’ issue. I can’t speak for Fan duel but DK is specifically operating on CFTC guidance allowing them to operate in states that don’t allow gambling. That could all dry up in an instant.
On the other hand, it’s not clear to me that states can actually manage sports betting and prediction markets. It’s trivial to skirt state restrictions and the conversation presumes that only Americans are betting on American sports, which isn’t the case. We’ve limited which banks can fund these accounts, but there are definitely foreign traders operating in these markets. It seems like a reasonable idea to handle this at the federal level, but I could have my mind changed.
States run lotteries. Many have horse or dog tracks. There's an infrastructure for state regulation. More importantly, the US Constitution is completely silent on the issue so the SCOTUS originalists will probably green light state regulation and taxation.
Right on!! All gambling apps, especially the sports themed ones are a hidden problem right now but will raise it ugly head in the middle class for sure. Lots of broken homes and hearts because daddy spends all the family money on thinking the Dallas Cowboys will cover the spread each week.
We're discovering in real time why past societies outlawed gambling. Actually, in recent decades, we've been finding out in FAFO fashion why lots of things used to be illegal. The pendulum swings between society being too restrictive and too libertine. We've been in "too libertine" mode for a while -- longer than I thought possible. The question is when the turn will finally come, and how violent and disruptive it will be.
Apropos my comments yesterday I believe that Reality and the climax of this Fourth Turning are going to render all of Chris' concerns (and mine) moot! It's all going bye-bye, boys and girls, along with (most probably) a lot of the population when large sections (or even all) of the Grid goes down.
Indeed, the End Times are upon us. I don't know squat about the prediction markets and couldn't care less. Leverage and margin only works for so long or for the very few. Take a look at all the gambling applications in society. They could never survive if more than a few handfuls of gamblers were winning. The vast majority must lose for the few to be winners. Hey wait a minute...that's how Wall Street has always worked. Copycats!
What a bonanza for corruption. Just think of how enticing a leveraged bet on a government produced index will be. Given the nature of the accounts, just think how easy it will be to cover your tracks. The level of corruption will make Minnesota look like handicap parking fraud.
All these new betting markets seem only good for connected people with inside information and the owners of the platforms. Seems like it is all bad for the general public whom has no edge. And just creates more distraction from things that matter in life.
Asking for margin on contracts that were sold as fully collateralized changes the risk profile entirely, since forced liquidations on thin event markets could move prices away from actual probabilities. That would undercut the main argument that these markets produce useful forecasts.
The states are not going to go against these efforts. Years ago, many states opted to allow gambling in order to collect the revenue they needed to balance their budgets. Now 48 states allow some form of gambling, and each one of them includes the revenue they collect from gambling when they create their budgets. Most states, especially those facing large deficits, are not going to give up this revenue without a fight.
This is my industry. I don’t work for Kalshi, but I clear these types of contracts. The whole argument was that this stuff would be fully collateralized and immediately they want to open the door to leverage…because of course they do.
The scuttlebutt is that Kalshi needs this or they are going to go bust. Prediction markets are still marginal and weird. Without strong market making they don’t have the liquidity to present meaningful markets. This stuff can’t exist naturally, not at an enterprise level anyway, because most people aren’t gamblers. Let’s keep it that way.
Interesting take. Thanks for the contribution here...
And prediction markets might soon find themselves regulated by state gambling authorities instead of the CFTC. Then they'd be in the same taxation bucket as DraftKings and Fanduel.
This is the big question right now and why a lot of people in my corner of the financial industry were hoping the Clarity Act would pass—the cftc is trying valiantly to manage this stuff with no meaningful input from congress. At least that’s how it feels.
And it seems true that this could tip either back into a purely ‘state’s right’ issue. I can’t speak for Fan duel but DK is specifically operating on CFTC guidance allowing them to operate in states that don’t allow gambling. That could all dry up in an instant.
On the other hand, it’s not clear to me that states can actually manage sports betting and prediction markets. It’s trivial to skirt state restrictions and the conversation presumes that only Americans are betting on American sports, which isn’t the case. We’ve limited which banks can fund these accounts, but there are definitely foreign traders operating in these markets. It seems like a reasonable idea to handle this at the federal level, but I could have my mind changed.
States run lotteries. Many have horse or dog tracks. There's an infrastructure for state regulation. More importantly, the US Constitution is completely silent on the issue so the SCOTUS originalists will probably green light state regulation and taxation.
If I had to make a prediction I’d buy “states right” for around $0.55-0.60
I understand polymarkets is taking bets on whether Kalshi's request from the CFTC to allow margin leverage will be approved. Any takers?
LMFAO!
Right on!! All gambling apps, especially the sports themed ones are a hidden problem right now but will raise it ugly head in the middle class for sure. Lots of broken homes and hearts because daddy spends all the family money on thinking the Dallas Cowboys will cover the spread each week.
And suddenly unlimited construction budgets for Vegas hotel casino complexes become a thing of the past.
We're discovering in real time why past societies outlawed gambling. Actually, in recent decades, we've been finding out in FAFO fashion why lots of things used to be illegal. The pendulum swings between society being too restrictive and too libertine. We've been in "too libertine" mode for a while -- longer than I thought possible. The question is when the turn will finally come, and how violent and disruptive it will be.
Superb observation. Western societies are in a long term bear market.
Apropos my comments yesterday I believe that Reality and the climax of this Fourth Turning are going to render all of Chris' concerns (and mine) moot! It's all going bye-bye, boys and girls, along with (most probably) a lot of the population when large sections (or even all) of the Grid goes down.
Indeed, the End Times are upon us. I don't know squat about the prediction markets and couldn't care less. Leverage and margin only works for so long or for the very few. Take a look at all the gambling applications in society. They could never survive if more than a few handfuls of gamblers were winning. The vast majority must lose for the few to be winners. Hey wait a minute...that's how Wall Street has always worked. Copycats!
The level of gambling is an indicator of the stage of the market bubble. Lots of cash here.
What a bonanza for corruption. Just think of how enticing a leveraged bet on a government produced index will be. Given the nature of the accounts, just think how easy it will be to cover your tracks. The level of corruption will make Minnesota look like handicap parking fraud.
All these new betting markets seem only good for connected people with inside information and the owners of the platforms. Seems like it is all bad for the general public whom has no edge. And just creates more distraction from things that matter in life.
Insider trading is probably the only consistently successful kind.
A fool and his money are soon parted
"I'd gladly pay you Tuesday for a hamburger today, if there's only two pickles on it"
Wanna bet there's less than two pickles?
Asking for margin on contracts that were sold as fully collateralized changes the risk profile entirely, since forced liquidations on thin event markets could move prices away from actual probabilities. That would undercut the main argument that these markets produce useful forecasts.
And if you don't pay up on your levered lossed an AI robot comes to break your kneecaps.
A gambler's money has no home.
The states are not going to go against these efforts. Years ago, many states opted to allow gambling in order to collect the revenue they needed to balance their budgets. Now 48 states allow some form of gambling, and each one of them includes the revenue they collect from gambling when they create their budgets. Most states, especially those facing large deficits, are not going to give up this revenue without a fight.
QTR is documenting the decline of US finances into 6% t-bill yields.