Yes, workers are more productive by virtue of the multiplication factor of automation.
Have they reaped the benefits of that increase? Or has it been harvested by the capital class?
Has workers tenure become more secure by virtue of their increased productivity? Or less secure?
I have no skin in the game of defending the working class, but I'm bound to observe the bulk of this essay is pure sophistry, intended to promote an agenda.
I agree. It is true that, in the past, tools and automation did increase production and decrease production costs. The spoils went to the asset owners, while the working class's wages stagnated. It is also true that, currently, the "AI revolution" isn't targeting laborers and starting to affect mid to upper management, but to surmise that laborers are "safe" is shortsighted at the least. Robot development and research (thanks in great part by our taxes funding DARPA and the DOW) are actively on the quest to replace human operations. Only an idiot would think that if a robot is advanced to the point of replacing a solider that it won't be reconfigured to replace a plumber. The point is probably mute. Since our elected (supposedly representative) government can't seem to help themselves from spending and printing dollars, the whole system is doomed to collapse anyway.
This author AGAIN gets the problem 100% wrong. AI is not destroying Marxism at all, it's a massive success for Marxism because it hugely damages society and vast swathes of workers (who are mistakenly labelled here as just manual workers). It moves power and wealth into the hands of the new elites, Democrat Communists.
Exactly. But Marxism is not a solution, it's still first and foremost a mind-fuck divide-and-conquer mechanism, turning ostensibly negotiable political differences into "unavoidable" economic jihad. But it's now been so long since Marx started, we've grown quite accustomed to the supposed complete incompatibility of freedom-focused, hierarchy-tolerant Right and the equalizing Left that is its perpetual response. Hint: At root, they each represent human needs.
The only difference now is the biggest starting point being the casualties of modern knowledge industries, not "blue-collar" work. I'm confident it'll once again be all about class, and we'll all be 110% at each others' throats until we begin to wake up after much blood and tears.
Divide and conquer is the goal. It does not matter which dimensions are used to accomplish the goal-- class, race, intelligence, and/or anything else.
The original Leftism was about confronting concentrated power, wherever it had occurred, i.e. in 1789 France, the nobility and the clergy. But a half-century later, Marx started a series of modern *intra-national* holy wars -- emphasis on *wars* -- hardening the lines via markets-based class in the vicious depths of the Industrial Revolution. The French Revolution-born integrated view of "liberte (essentially, Rightism), egalite (Leftism), fraternite (culture)" -- which nominally survives to this day as France's national motto -- was to be ripped apart, with "fraternite" as part of legitimate politics effectively thrown in the trash. He and his descendants rode that horse for a century. However, by the 1950s and the post-WW2 economic renaissances, it was clear a better approach to TPTB's real goal of perpetual division intra-nationally was by using *immutable* dimensions: race, sex, etc., as the fluid boundaries of wealth-based class were just two squishy to keep the vast majority in line. So that has been at the core of our modern "New Left". Now, as we know, hardened via recent formal education of the young and inexperienced into an insane religion known as "woke".
The indisputable 'tell', of course, that there was, and is, a full-blown con going on is that as the New Left emerged, the *old* Left (the economic basis in middle and working classes, along with the poor) had to be quietly abandoned by the shepherds (see the Democratic Party in the US). Can't *combine* the two to confront TPTB to have an actual victory over entrenched power -- oh no! As with the US MIC and militarism, the wars and manufactured enemies must be continued forever. Read Orwell!
I won't be jumping for joy until A/i is buried in a coffin right next to Marx. The ultimate grand purpose of A/i will be to surveil you to death. What the heck do you think 10,000 data centers will be used for? Predicting the unpredictable weather?
Marx is a vampire. You can nail his coffin shut, drape garlic around his neck and drive a stake through his heart. He's never going to go away as long as rich people spawn pampered, indulged and spoiled children who need to add spice to their bored lives by embracing the radical chic call to "revolution".
I think you meant to say he's never going to go away as long as the gains in wealth created by gains in labor productivity accrue disproportionately to capital.
I've been a licensed teacher and a skilled tradesman. I know history. Manufacturing efficiency has been increasing steadily ever since the beginnings of the Industrial Revolution. Jobs have been lost, jobs have been created. Jobs have been offshored.
Through it all, the talking heads have spoken dispassionately about it, in the third person, above and apart from it all. Now, AI is hitting them, and suddenly job loss and offshoring are critical issues. To them it is. To the rest of us, it's amusing to watch them squirm.
the bulk of this essay is plain nonsense.
Yes, workers are more productive by virtue of the multiplication factor of automation.
Have they reaped the benefits of that increase? Or has it been harvested by the capital class?
Has workers tenure become more secure by virtue of their increased productivity? Or less secure?
I have no skin in the game of defending the working class, but I'm bound to observe the bulk of this essay is pure sophistry, intended to promote an agenda.
Digest and integrate at your own risk.
Effectively, stats shows that productivity increases way faster than salaries.
I agree. It is true that, in the past, tools and automation did increase production and decrease production costs. The spoils went to the asset owners, while the working class's wages stagnated. It is also true that, currently, the "AI revolution" isn't targeting laborers and starting to affect mid to upper management, but to surmise that laborers are "safe" is shortsighted at the least. Robot development and research (thanks in great part by our taxes funding DARPA and the DOW) are actively on the quest to replace human operations. Only an idiot would think that if a robot is advanced to the point of replacing a solider that it won't be reconfigured to replace a plumber. The point is probably mute. Since our elected (supposedly representative) government can't seem to help themselves from spending and printing dollars, the whole system is doomed to collapse anyway.
This author AGAIN gets the problem 100% wrong. AI is not destroying Marxism at all, it's a massive success for Marxism because it hugely damages society and vast swathes of workers (who are mistakenly labelled here as just manual workers). It moves power and wealth into the hands of the new elites, Democrat Communists.
Exactly. But Marxism is not a solution, it's still first and foremost a mind-fuck divide-and-conquer mechanism, turning ostensibly negotiable political differences into "unavoidable" economic jihad. But it's now been so long since Marx started, we've grown quite accustomed to the supposed complete incompatibility of freedom-focused, hierarchy-tolerant Right and the equalizing Left that is its perpetual response. Hint: At root, they each represent human needs.
The only difference now is the biggest starting point being the casualties of modern knowledge industries, not "blue-collar" work. I'm confident it'll once again be all about class, and we'll all be 110% at each others' throats until we begin to wake up after much blood and tears.
Good points
Divide and conquer is the goal. It does not matter which dimensions are used to accomplish the goal-- class, race, intelligence, and/or anything else.
The original Leftism was about confronting concentrated power, wherever it had occurred, i.e. in 1789 France, the nobility and the clergy. But a half-century later, Marx started a series of modern *intra-national* holy wars -- emphasis on *wars* -- hardening the lines via markets-based class in the vicious depths of the Industrial Revolution. The French Revolution-born integrated view of "liberte (essentially, Rightism), egalite (Leftism), fraternite (culture)" -- which nominally survives to this day as France's national motto -- was to be ripped apart, with "fraternite" as part of legitimate politics effectively thrown in the trash. He and his descendants rode that horse for a century. However, by the 1950s and the post-WW2 economic renaissances, it was clear a better approach to TPTB's real goal of perpetual division intra-nationally was by using *immutable* dimensions: race, sex, etc., as the fluid boundaries of wealth-based class were just two squishy to keep the vast majority in line. So that has been at the core of our modern "New Left". Now, as we know, hardened via recent formal education of the young and inexperienced into an insane religion known as "woke".
The indisputable 'tell', of course, that there was, and is, a full-blown con going on is that as the New Left emerged, the *old* Left (the economic basis in middle and working classes, along with the poor) had to be quietly abandoned by the shepherds (see the Democratic Party in the US). Can't *combine* the two to confront TPTB to have an actual victory over entrenched power -- oh no! As with the US MIC and militarism, the wars and manufactured enemies must be continued forever. Read Orwell!
I won't be jumping for joy until A/i is buried in a coffin right next to Marx. The ultimate grand purpose of A/i will be to surveil you to death. What the heck do you think 10,000 data centers will be used for? Predicting the unpredictable weather?
Well worth watching this! https://youtube.com/shorts/DFhHY1T9EiA?si=JGspJseewbXhBUX_
Yes, if all you do for work is touch papers or a keyboard your days may be numbered.
Marx is a vampire. You can nail his coffin shut, drape garlic around his neck and drive a stake through his heart. He's never going to go away as long as rich people spawn pampered, indulged and spoiled children who need to add spice to their bored lives by embracing the radical chic call to "revolution".
I think you meant to say he's never going to go away as long as the gains in wealth created by gains in labor productivity accrue disproportionately to capital.
I've been a licensed teacher and a skilled tradesman. I know history. Manufacturing efficiency has been increasing steadily ever since the beginnings of the Industrial Revolution. Jobs have been lost, jobs have been created. Jobs have been offshored.
Through it all, the talking heads have spoken dispassionately about it, in the third person, above and apart from it all. Now, AI is hitting them, and suddenly job loss and offshoring are critical issues. To them it is. To the rest of us, it's amusing to watch them squirm.
The repercussions of this, if it proves to be directionally true, are delightful to contemplate.
I wonder what kind of AI Mr Marx would come up with.
Deciding immediately to demolish bureacracy is proof of the "intelligece" part.
La IA es un agujero negro.
True Marxian analysis has been a "dead letter" for at least 100 years. The "conflict" has "moved on" - as it always does.