If the major frontier labs are worried about what they are creating there is a simple response - slow down and safety test more. But they don't. This whole push to make a FDAI and regulate the companies is an attempt at regulatory capture by OpenAI and Anthropic. They want a government sponsored monopoly so the can reap trillions. Guaranteed they will try and ban open source models and Chinese models in the US so they can sell tokens for ridiculous prices. Wake up. Every one should listen to the last several episodes of the All In podcast where this is discussed at length.
coordinated agent swarms that shut down the Internet for days—it’s why I changed my mind on this because I think the points you make are valid but I think with trillions of dollars at stake nothing is fully knowable
AI has been a godsend for me so I hate to be the one defending Pacing but this (Astra) version is at the edge of what’s prudent so let’s catch our breath here
The main problem with choosing a side is that verifiable facts are an almost extinct metric. It alarms me when the media, regardless of politics, all jump on the same bandwagon with coordinated messaging, and I don't mean it's the "truth" they sell that gets my hackles up. It has a familiar tone of previous psyops.
It’s a psyop. It’s that simple. Open Source is coming fast and hard. And the tech bros and the Dems are out to stop Open Source and influence the election.
It’s nearly analogous to Amazon being propped up for years while they lost billions, crushed 1000s of retail businesses, and finally got AWS spun out. The CIA was their first client and they became profitable within months.
You cannot hate these people enough.
The real question now is what virus have they loaded and what critical infrastructure will they take down. Finance. Transport. Grid. Military. Communication.
Absolutely. And we need open source to fact check the closed loop models and keep them in line.
I find it incredibly useful for researching medical issues and analyzing legal issues. But it’s not always correct, it always has to be fact checked with at least a second opinion, and I maintain it still cannot do moderately complex math problems with multiple variables.
I use it as a search engine on steroids, which is a nice to have, but not required and I wouldn’t pay for it At least not in its current iterations
I’ve been paying for Claude for a while to greatly enhance my productivity writing Elixir code and it’s been worth it. but the open source solutions AI may supply the same functionality for a very small fraction of the cost. I still have to test that.
There is zero chance of any rollback of AI. Its adoption by users globally is staggering and will continue to follow an even-steeper adoption path than so many other IT technologies of the past 50 years. It does not even depend on rapid advancement of frontier models. Slower improvement based on existing models is more than enough for the investment numbers to add up.
Processors, memory, energy, and all the other "AI" plays will do fine regardless of this current nonsense. Anthropic and OpenAI are not the AI industry. The technology AS IT IS NOW is valuable in ways businesses are just now beginning to unlock. Rapid improvement of the frontier is not the investment case.
QTR correctly identified the issue at play today: regulatory capture, but then trivialized these objections by saying that "those aren't trivial objections" and then blowing past them.
Two near-IPO juggernauts want to lock down the regulatory landscape before a thousand open source flowers can bloom. I would not want my fortune linked to either of them. But Nvidia, AMD, INTC, MU, SK Hynix, the GRID and AIPO and SOXX ETFs? I am DCAing the dip.
This is further proof the Democrats have no issues that people support. They bitch about Iran but don’t acknowledge 7 presidents have said it’s a threat but did nothing other than Obama sending them billions. They butch about affordability ignoring the massive inflationary pressures unleashed by Biden policies including 15 million illegal mouths to feed. And they ignore the real accomplishments which are truly epic. As for AI, of course we need to understand it, but to stop gives it yo the Chinese. Long ago, Bernie sanders would have wanted to outlaw electricity. The discourse is pathetic. Critical thinking is non existent.
With money getting very expensive and the Chinese products like DeepSeek proving they can do 90% of what the Big US companies can do for 20% of the cost, a new fancy regulatory moat might be the new edge these US companies need to try to ward off the competition. Will the PsyOp work this time … probably. You have to admit the timing is very curious. Like many, I also doubt their “altruistic” motives in this “winner-take-all” scenario
I anyone thinks President Xi, an engineer by trade, isn't informed and ready to constrain AI the moment he thinks it is a threat to him they should ask Jack Ma how power works in China.
I'm still trying to figure out why it's a foregone conclusion that whoever "wins" the AI race (whatever that actually means...) wins ALL THE THINGS? Is anybody thinking outside the box? Like, if we raised boys to be men, girls to be women, fixed the education system so that we ended up with intelligent, smart Americans with good work ethics, put masculine men in our military and just defended the HELL out of our infrastructure... embraced a bit of austerity and produced our own goods and services.. You know... MAKING AMERICA GREAT AGAIN...?
But no. We need to manage more "data," because, apparently, "data reigns!" WTF? No, it doesn't! REAL STUFF REIGNS! Stuff you can touch. And count. And operate. And receive REAL utility from!
We have completely lost control of the story. The story owns us, now. And it has a HORRIBLE ending. Thank you, Donald J. Effing-Trump. Thank you for your attention to the exposure of your dip-shittery!
With hyper partisan politics, whatever one side supports the other side automatically supports the opposite. Everyone is upset about the data centers so you switch the topic to AI and suddenly you get the left vs. right again. If I were the dems I’d just stick to the data centers. This just seems like the big circus of ensuring everyone is divided.
Ed Dowd did an interesting breakdown of the "whistle blower" Twitter drop.
It all stinks of contrivity.
If human nature has shown us anything it has shown us we cant help but press the self destruct button for no other reason but to see what happens. So there's always that.
Idk....Im just getting depressed that we have silmutaneously witnessed so much progress and so much failure as a society.
The inflation situation is doing incalculable damage to our younger generations and I dont see AI fixing that. Sorry.
If the major frontier labs are worried about what they are creating there is a simple response - slow down and safety test more. But they don't. This whole push to make a FDAI and regulate the companies is an attempt at regulatory capture by OpenAI and Anthropic. They want a government sponsored monopoly so the can reap trillions. Guaranteed they will try and ban open source models and Chinese models in the US so they can sell tokens for ridiculous prices. Wake up. Every one should listen to the last several episodes of the All In podcast where this is discussed at length.
I think Anthropic realized its IPO wasn’t going to price, and Altman already knew his wasn’t, so they phonied this up.
What, exactly, are we supposed to be so afraid of? Interesting that Jensen said it was all bull. Cracks appearing in the cartel.
coordinated agent swarms that shut down the Internet for days—it’s why I changed my mind on this because I think the points you make are valid but I think with trillions of dollars at stake nothing is fully knowable
AI has been a godsend for me so I hate to be the one defending Pacing but this (Astra) version is at the edge of what’s prudent so let’s catch our breath here
It's simple, let the free market work or let the gov. come in. I vote for the free market.
You're missing an obvious target: OPEN SOURCE MODELS
EXACTLY
When I look at both sides of an issue, one thing I consider is who is promoting which side. It usually helps me to determine what side I want to join.
The main problem with choosing a side is that verifiable facts are an almost extinct metric. It alarms me when the media, regardless of politics, all jump on the same bandwagon with coordinated messaging, and I don't mean it's the "truth" they sell that gets my hackles up. It has a familiar tone of previous psyops.
Definitely the signs if a democrat attempt at a psyop to gain control of ai imo: https://x.com/nichulscher/status/2099669714259612028?s=46
Ironic that this article was illustrated by AI.
I use it for illustrations and grammar all the time. Less keen on using it for world domination.
It’s a psyop. It’s that simple. Open Source is coming fast and hard. And the tech bros and the Dems are out to stop Open Source and influence the election.
It’s nearly analogous to Amazon being propped up for years while they lost billions, crushed 1000s of retail businesses, and finally got AWS spun out. The CIA was their first client and they became profitable within months.
You cannot hate these people enough.
The real question now is what virus have they loaded and what critical infrastructure will they take down. Finance. Transport. Grid. Military. Communication.
It’s coming.
And if we’re worried about what AI can do, wouldn’t we want open source? There’s nothing like a little sun light.
Absolutely. And we need open source to fact check the closed loop models and keep them in line.
I find it incredibly useful for researching medical issues and analyzing legal issues. But it’s not always correct, it always has to be fact checked with at least a second opinion, and I maintain it still cannot do moderately complex math problems with multiple variables.
I use it as a search engine on steroids, which is a nice to have, but not required and I wouldn’t pay for it At least not in its current iterations
I’ve been paying for Claude for a while to greatly enhance my productivity writing Elixir code and it’s been worth it. but the open source solutions AI may supply the same functionality for a very small fraction of the cost. I still have to test that.
There is zero chance of any rollback of AI. Its adoption by users globally is staggering and will continue to follow an even-steeper adoption path than so many other IT technologies of the past 50 years. It does not even depend on rapid advancement of frontier models. Slower improvement based on existing models is more than enough for the investment numbers to add up.
Processors, memory, energy, and all the other "AI" plays will do fine regardless of this current nonsense. Anthropic and OpenAI are not the AI industry. The technology AS IT IS NOW is valuable in ways businesses are just now beginning to unlock. Rapid improvement of the frontier is not the investment case.
QTR correctly identified the issue at play today: regulatory capture, but then trivialized these objections by saying that "those aren't trivial objections" and then blowing past them.
Two near-IPO juggernauts want to lock down the regulatory landscape before a thousand open source flowers can bloom. I would not want my fortune linked to either of them. But Nvidia, AMD, INTC, MU, SK Hynix, the GRID and AIPO and SOXX ETFs? I am DCAing the dip.
This is further proof the Democrats have no issues that people support. They bitch about Iran but don’t acknowledge 7 presidents have said it’s a threat but did nothing other than Obama sending them billions. They butch about affordability ignoring the massive inflationary pressures unleashed by Biden policies including 15 million illegal mouths to feed. And they ignore the real accomplishments which are truly epic. As for AI, of course we need to understand it, but to stop gives it yo the Chinese. Long ago, Bernie sanders would have wanted to outlaw electricity. The discourse is pathetic. Critical thinking is non existent.
With money getting very expensive and the Chinese products like DeepSeek proving they can do 90% of what the Big US companies can do for 20% of the cost, a new fancy regulatory moat might be the new edge these US companies need to try to ward off the competition. Will the PsyOp work this time … probably. You have to admit the timing is very curious. Like many, I also doubt their “altruistic” motives in this “winner-take-all” scenario
I anyone thinks President Xi, an engineer by trade, isn't informed and ready to constrain AI the moment he thinks it is a threat to him they should ask Jack Ma how power works in China.
I'm still trying to figure out why it's a foregone conclusion that whoever "wins" the AI race (whatever that actually means...) wins ALL THE THINGS? Is anybody thinking outside the box? Like, if we raised boys to be men, girls to be women, fixed the education system so that we ended up with intelligent, smart Americans with good work ethics, put masculine men in our military and just defended the HELL out of our infrastructure... embraced a bit of austerity and produced our own goods and services.. You know... MAKING AMERICA GREAT AGAIN...?
But no. We need to manage more "data," because, apparently, "data reigns!" WTF? No, it doesn't! REAL STUFF REIGNS! Stuff you can touch. And count. And operate. And receive REAL utility from!
We have completely lost control of the story. The story owns us, now. And it has a HORRIBLE ending. Thank you, Donald J. Effing-Trump. Thank you for your attention to the exposure of your dip-shittery!
With hyper partisan politics, whatever one side supports the other side automatically supports the opposite. Everyone is upset about the data centers so you switch the topic to AI and suddenly you get the left vs. right again. If I were the dems I’d just stick to the data centers. This just seems like the big circus of ensuring everyone is divided.
Ed Dowd did an interesting breakdown of the "whistle blower" Twitter drop.
It all stinks of contrivity.
If human nature has shown us anything it has shown us we cant help but press the self destruct button for no other reason but to see what happens. So there's always that.
Idk....Im just getting depressed that we have silmutaneously witnessed so much progress and so much failure as a society.
The inflation situation is doing incalculable damage to our younger generations and I dont see AI fixing that. Sorry.
If I was Big Brother, Hal, or Skynet I’d want the government involved so the government would provide for and protect me.
We need a color-coded AI threat level. Is Tom Ridge handy? Today feels like a 3.