18 Comments
User's avatar
Joanna Miller's avatar

Socialists see their good intentions as more important than actual results. All the flowery speeches in the world don't matter, if none of the trains run on time, the power goes out, and everyone's hungry.

Leskunque Lepew's avatar

17% of registered "Democrats" voted on the last NYC mayoral election. Whose voice do these "Socialists" represent??

They express "empathy" as long as it suits their agenda.

Bill D's avatar

The problem is, we do not live in a free market capitalist system, we live in a crony capitalism oligarchy system. Since citizens United Uber wealthy spending in political races has skyrocketed and their ability to control the political system and tax code to their advantage and to the detriment of the average taxpaying citizen has radically increased. The privatization of gains but the socialization of losses, pass thru of profits, billionaires paying little to no taxes. Is it any wonder that the 90% are unhappy with the current system and are looking for something else?

The Color Of Air's avatar

At least with capitalism I can choose it or not. With socialism, there is no choice. All slaves are equally destitute while the masters live an opulent life.

J-9's avatar

Waiting for January media gush about "Zohran" atop the list of NYC baby names in 2026.

Jon McCarthy's avatar

For those who want a moral defense of capitalism: "Capitalism: The Unknown Ideal": https://aynrand.org/novels/capitalism-the-unknown-ideal/

Mostly written by philosopher Ayn Rand, but the essay by Alan Greenspan against central banking and the Federal Reserve is phenomenal. Too bad he didn't listen to himself!

Illinois Entrepreneur's avatar

I love reading Ayn Rand.

But watch it, Democrats loathe her. I think they dislike her more than any other, because she pokes them right in the eye for their false morality.

HardcoreVeritas's avatar

Absolutely not! That must be rhetorical question, right?

Any economic system that destroys the rights of the individual in favor of the collective is as evil as hell.

Any economic system that grants unfair advantages and privileges to the wealthy or corporation is as evil as hell.

An economic system based on DEBT….and therefore, interest……that constantly destroys the value of the money, that people are forced to take as compensation for labor, goods, and services is as evil as hell.

Yes,…..I am saying…… our economic system is as evil as hell.

RICH's avatar

Capitalism, done right, is amoral in the best sense: it doesn't force "good" behavior but creates space for individuals to act morally through consent and responsibility. The US version has drifted far from that ideal because we've let government become the referee and a major player. True reform means restoring limited government, sound money, and individual accountability—not more central planning.

HardcoreVeritas's avatar

I agree with you on that, Rich. But “capitalism” is just a term for a system of “free markets,” which no one living today has ever seen.

Hell, by 1794, we had already seen the government step in on the whiskey industry and put their finger on the scale for large manufacturers.

Anytime humanity has a role to play in ANY system it becomes a moral issue.

Proverbs 11:1 “A false balance is abomination to the Lord: but a just weight is his delight.”

DLB's avatar

One thing the socialists don't seem to understand or even bother to ask, where do they think those who have money they want to take from, got it? If the free capitalist economy is done away with, the socialists will have destroyed the hand that has been feeding them for 100 years.

It's really amazing how lazy the socialists are. They won't even pick up a book to study how socialism worked in the old Soviet Union, which eventually destroyed their economy and forced those who ran the government to concede, and let capitalism take over. Same thing happened in China, when the government stood back and turned their economy over to the capitalists. Two recent examples of how socialism works, and how it always fails.

If you remove the incentive to work harder, eventually everyone will quit.

RICH's avatar

I appreciate the essay's core argument—that true morality is individual, not collective, and that socialism relies on force while capitalism allows choice. However, I see important flaws worth highlighting.

Any economic system that destroys individual rights in favor of the collective is as evil as hell. Any system that grants unfair advantages and privileges to the wealthy, corporations, or insiders is equally evil. And a debt-based system—built on endless interest and fiat money that constantly erodes the value of people's labor, savings, and compensation—is profoundly immoral.

We the People have to accept our responsibility for allowing this to happen with our votes. The result is not pure capitalism, but a cronyist mixed system where the state distorts markets through regulation, subsidies, bailouts, and monetary manipulation. This betrays the voluntary exchange and equal rules that should define free markets.

Capitalism, done right, is amoral in the best sense: it doesn't force "good" behavior but creates space for individuals to act morally through consent and responsibility. The US version has drifted far from that ideal because we've let government become the referee and a major player. True reform means restoring limited government, sound money, and individual accountability—not more central planning.

RICH's avatar

Why is it that all comunist/socialist leaders are the ones whith al the wealth and freedom??, in their countries' of equitable distribition?? ( Momdami's suites ain't cheap.)

John Horst's avatar

I don't quite get how this article can be written and not cite Adam Smith's Theory of Moral Sentiments... He wrote it before he wrote Wealth of Nations, and describes an "impartial spectator" who sees one treat another in a way such that he sympathizes with the latter and despises the former. To the extent that we share these sentiments in common, moral values are "common" - not "only individual" as said here.

The author here leaves us with a false choice - either morality is strictly individual, or is prescribed upon us by force. This is simply not the case. If a neighbor drives his vehicle in front of an elementary school at freeway speeds such that parents are pushing their kids out of harms way and otherwise diving out of the path of the car, we - an impartial spectator - will commonly commiserate with the parents and kids and despise the driver. Out of that comes the force of law when he is arrested and taken to jail.

The other problem is the author forces an unnatural dualism with economic and political systems. All political systems have an economy and all economic systems involve politics. You cannot have a political system without some form of government (that much he sees). But you cannot have government without some level of taxation - and that means money. And once you have a common form of money you cannot escape a common sense of morality. If you look at this from the starting point of economic, you end up in the same place - money. And again - common money must mean a common sense of morality.

This is not to argue for socialism or communism. It is, rather, to argue for sound money and a common moral sense of right and wrong about money.

Imagine a farmer's wife trades $X for a 50 lb. bag of corn. She'll make tortillas from it for her family. She carries it back to the farm. Along the way, an "invisible hand" cuts the corner of the sack and drains some of the corn. Can the "purchasing power" of the farmer's wife's $X - measured in pounds of corn - be stolen by an "invisible hand" in such a manner?

This is the question Adam Smith demands we ask of our economics - and of the politics of common money around which it revolves - before we even get to Wealth of Nations.

rtko's avatar

Fully agree — in the end, it comes down to people and the quality of their character. Given how monetary policy and business are actually conducted in the U.S., it’s no wonder capitalism gets a bad name.

Bill D's avatar

Also The Scandinavian countries seem to have hit on a form of Socialism that works for them. Probably more of a cultural phenomenon.

https://www.worldhappiness.report/ed/2020/the-nordic-exceptionalism-what-explains-why-the-nordic-countries-are-constantly-among-the-happiest-in-the-world/

Jonathan Polloni's avatar

Always interested in these arguments, but I coughed up my morning coffee when I read the line about homosexuality being amoral. Also calling out Plato is a big dick energy that probably needs its own entire article of argument

HardcoreVeritas's avatar

Any form of economy......just like any form or government......will only be as moral as the people running the economy or government.

That is why in both instances, we are fk'd.