Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Crimson Possum's avatar

I've been a small business entrepreneur since 1994 and have extensive experience in marketing. I also have a background that includes knowledge of probability and statistics, as well as science and health matters. From my experience I can tell you unequivocally that the medical industry in America has left behind patient interest for advanced methods of optimizing profits, regardless of damage to patients. That's a bold claim but let me make my case.

The wild increase in "screening" over the last 20 years is nothing more than a marketing funnel. Screen as many people for as many things as possible, and your percentage of expensive "cures" will rise. Skin cancer screening, colonoscopies, mammograms, and prostate cancer screening/treatment are just a few examples of entry-level screening that make huge profits for businesses that use M.D.s as salespeople. In each of these cases, the statistics do not bear out the efficacy of the screening. For example, mammograms for all women, re3gardless of risk factor, will catch more breast cancer than no mammograms. Good thing, right? But because of misdiagnoses, over-diagnosis, treatment injuries, biopsy injuries, and the terror caused by diagnoses of pre-cancerous cells that often never develop into full-blown cancer, the actual mortality rate is higher for women who get regular screenings. In other words, if you don't want to die from breast cancer, get regular mammograms. If you want your overall chance of mortality to be lower, and you don't have any special risk factors for breast cancer, stay the hell away from mammograms.

Doctors have plausible deniability, because they can say that they are catching "x" number of cancers that would never otherwise be caught, thereby saving "y" number of lives.

The same is true for the other procedures mentioned above.

If you don't have time or the inclination to run the numbers yourself, I suggest starting with https://johnhorgan.org/cross-check/do-colonoscopies-really-save-lives. Horgan is (when he avoids politics, which is usually the case) an astute science writer who delights in exposing bad practices with real statistics.

Recently, I finally had to tell my family doctor to fuck off with the screenings. I was as nice as I could be, but if he suggests one more bloodwork, CT scan, or other poking-around in an area where I have had no issues or history, I'm firing him and using urgent care in the future.

Julien Pervillé's avatar

Very insightful, thanks for sharing Chris.

What are the nine most terrifying words in English according to Reagan again? "I'm from the Government, and I'm here to help".

10 more comments...

Ready for more?