23 Comments
User's avatar
Mrs Bucket's avatar

Bert Olivier is spot on. Well meaning old 'liberals' have had their parties captured and hollowed out by Communists. Mamdani and Newsom are good examples; they will say absolutely anything to fool suckers who WANT believe the fairy stories. But look at the miserable ratholes the 'liberals' now run, into the ground, while they get rich. The Right needs to wake up and get very tough with these people.

The Radical Individualist's avatar

Many people, given a choice between blind belief and comprehension, will choose blind belief.

Tankster's avatar

Brilliant. Now discuss “Conservative,” and how it is used today to support government using majority religious beliefs into reproductive rights, and other areas (WWJD? Not what “Conservatives

“ preach and practice). Also discuss government policy and legislation on sexual orientation (people are either large gamete or small gamete), encouraging discrimination against gays, (in the military, for example), the Unitary Executive, debunking of science, and fantasy based beliefs (Surgeon General of Florida and demon sperm). Compare and contrast Edmund Burke’s Conservatism, Barry Goldwater and even Saint Ronnie, (who couldn’t win a GOP primary today) with that of say Mike Johnson, J.D. Vance, et. al. Read How America Lost it’s Mind before commenting or at least a review https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2017/09/how-america-lost-its-mind/534231/

Mrs Bucket's avatar

Oh, is The Atlantic available translated from Communist Chinese to English now?

george's avatar

Just as the Nazis remained when Germany was defeated, the Confederates remained when the Union won. The Party of Jefferson Davis and the Plantations rebranded and prevails. (If you can't see the plantation they've constructed under capitalist Republicans, no pill will ever cure you)

Tankster's avatar

The "parties" have experienced a pole reversal (in nature about every 380,000 years) since then. Just sayin'

Tankster's avatar

Players gonna play, play play/The country has gone off the rails, as evidenced by the comments so far, who obviously didn't understand that I largely agree with you, and Kurt Anderson's book was prescient.

Jeff's avatar

For several years my term has been “leftists”. The “right” is far more liberal in thinking, action, and treatment of others.

Anti-Hip's avatar

The words liberal and (especially) conservative imply the temporal, so I'm not surprised at all they are confusing when they are expected to be fixed over time. It is natural that their use has the rich and convoluted history that Olivier gets into here. But he, as so many others do, also conflates those terms with Left and Right (respectively), which makes understanding more difficult and requires the narrative Olivier gives here. In my opinion, "liberal" and "conservative" should be completely abandoned as labels for political viewpoints, fixed or not, going forward.

Right and Left are much more coherent and useful terms. They originated relatively recently in the French Revolution, the "Right" for the then-existing entrenched powers (nobility and church) and the "Left" for the then-powerless Third Estate (peasants, etc.), based on physical locations of representatives in an assembly building at that time. These should be used instead of liberal/conservative to describe a more realistic and permanent political reality:

-- The Right prefers / allows for "organic" (and unlimited) hierarchies of power, due to any number of causative factors (i.e. natural abilities + environments + technologies, of all kinds), while

-- The Left exists in reaction to those hierarchies, applying a counterweight of equalization or flattening (however interpreted and realized), in the name of "justice" or "fairness".

So we should instead look more closely at Right vs Left and their ebb-flow realization. Neither ever completely disappears, because each reflects a necessary aspect of human nature (i.e. the Right prioritizes individual power; the Left collective/social power, however interpreted). Yet today they are commonly treated as correct vs incorrect, or smart vs stupid, the former vs latter depending on which (conflated) positive-normative bucket one puts oneself in. A foolish way to go! Meanwhile, democracy (essentially, distributed power) vs authoritarianism (concentrated power) is a separate dimension that can occur with either Rightist or Leftist pretenses, and should be recognized that way.

Meanwhile, on the separate dimension of promoting implementation/realization, there are democratic societies, which differ from authoritarian/totalitarian ones. So both Left and Right today consciously call themselves democratic (or in the US 'republican', respectively), while they are called by *others* authoritarian/totalitarian, no matter what their politics. Because both sides well know that extreme power imbalance is untenable.

In the U.S., for example, the typical Democratic Party rank-and-file *voter* consciously and genuinely wants only "fairness", with a "liberal" approach to make our way there, but is too often taught and *led* by those whose methods are, in stealth, unfair and illiberal. Meanwhile, we have the ideological oxymoron of why and how the "powerless" (specifically, the Democratic Party's) could and should become permanently (and exclusively!) powerful. That is a stealth normative, a Marxism-derived contradiction, one they have, purposely, never publicly resolved. By design, the contradiction is never made explicit to the Democratic Party constituencies to sort out (i.e. vs what one ostensibly expects a democracy to resolve). So we have the absurdity of Democratic leaders both verbally promoting democracy while denying Republicans both their say and their vote-proportional power, and then even more absurdly Democratic voters not only allowing but also endorsing it, a totalitarian result. And the Right notices this. How this happens, and why it also occurs in the opposite direction (i.e. Rep's over Dem's), but I'll leave it to others to suss out.

Allan Richard Wasem's avatar

A good summary. Many others have also laid out these basic facts. All point to the reason that this Fourth Turning is not going to end peacefully - the "Left" has become a totalitarian ideological movement that will stop at nothing to obtain and retain total power over everyone, everywhere, at all times. They literally intend to enslave the entire world - but the US is the key.

We are going to have to defend the Republic and the Constitution by force.

It's Crazy Out There, Man.'s avatar

when someone asks me if I'm liberal, I say yes, in the way JFK was or Daniel Patrick Moynihan, otherwise.

Steve Mudge's avatar

Rather odd to accuse the left as totalitarianism with the current supposedly libertarian capitalist Republican administration doing everything it can to insulate itself from democracy. This kind of one-sidism is not helping anyone, at least anyone who sees the extremes of both parties as a toxic stranglehold on the US as a going concern. The author also fails to point out the significant numbers of moderate voices, left and right center, which should be vocalized rather than marginalized by biased writing.

David Ploss's avatar

When one attempts to level the playing field the side that now has to deal with a level playing field cries crocodile tears. It's so unfair! Trump's hyperbole is merely trolling the progressive illiberals and making them act out their illiberal behavior even more.

Illinois Entrepreneur's avatar

The current administration is a reaction to the totalitarianism of the left.

The truth is that moderate and Republican Americans were getting tired of the Overton window lurching to the left, and being victims of the left's bloodsport tactics.

Trump is the response, not the cause. The Republicans just got tired of being pushovers.

The left has always been this way, and you just have to look at Tammany Hall and the Chicago Machine to know it.

Dan Boehm's avatar

I'm all for individual liberty. Do you really believe the Biden admin was? Because I have a bridge to sell you. Trump is disappointingly not much better, but that's hardly surprising after how many anti-infividual administrations now?

Dan Boehm's avatar

So your argument is but the conservatives?

Dan Boehm's avatar

Late last year I responded to a post here that "liberal" and "inflation" are the two words I wish we could bring back the original meaning of. That still stands. The erosion of those words is tantamount to the erosion of those ideas. And it is imperative those ideas survive.

Christopher Gallo's avatar

The current corrupt administration is exactly what Orwell predicted. Peace through war, etc etc. Liberals aren’t in charge, this mess is from the pedo in office and his bootlickers. Nice try to put this crap on people who oppose the military thug and want individual liberty and not Putin, not Netanyahu and all the rest of these morons.

dk's avatar

You must have slept thru the Biden years. The ones with “open borders” while Mayorkis claimed they were secure, the ones where there was a coordinated effort to pump the jabs into every arm while Pfizer hid that over 1200 people died during their study, that same jab violating “my body, my choice”, or the destruction of small businesses to the benefit of major corporations by government decree of who and what was “essential”, and you most surely missed the unchecked fraud that pumped into “blue” cities to support illegals in trade for their voting fraud (cue Nick Shirley). And lest we not forget all the riots and destruction of 2020, and excusing protesters from covid mandates because protesting was more important that the mandates—the same ones NOT enforced on “migrants”.

As someone who identifies with the core positions of Democrats back to the 1980’s, I see a party completely hijacked not for the benefit of the people, but got the control of the people at the top. While embracing the idea that skin color is THE most important issue, and that men should beat up women in women’s sports no less. And while I believe if someone wants to live their life in a dress while being male is their choice, I don’t believe I should be forced to partake in their mental illness.

And let’s not forget the destructive forces of DEI (didn’t earn it), where some of the most qualified get sidelined for some of the least qualified simply by skin tone. Of course the white male is the most toxic of all species today, simply for being born white. Let them be a Christian and now they are worse that the devil, while “liberals” embrace every other idea, especially Islam as good and pure despite the fact that Islam seeks the death of homosexuals, the enslavement of women in black dress head to toe (complete with 2nd class citizenship and stoning to death for Koran violation). To the modern (brainwashed) liberal “multiculturalism” is a good thing. But if it’s so important, why is it always the western nations that are forced to embrace it? Why aren’t western liberals moving to black run South Africa (for example)?

Nah, your head is just all fooked up because you embrace “party under alles” just as the people of Germany embraced Hitlers Nazi party. Modern liberalism is no different, and certainly close to that which gave us the Soviet Union and Red China under Mao. Of course if you don’t know your history, the feeble mind embraces the messaging as the only true and pure path. Until the boot of totalitarianism comes crushing down on your face in the future.

The Democrats used to have a handful of sane & intelligent people to counter the “revolutionaries” who seek to destroy everything. Now those people are sidelined. The bomb throwers are in charge, hypocrisy rules, and a look at every major “blue” city shows the results of moral bankruptcy and stupidity. Even the wealthiest of the left are fleeing blue cities and states when called upon to support the financial stupidity and mismanagement.

The democrats have become a social and economic death cult.

Christopher Gallo's avatar

moral bankruptcy from the morons that support the most corrupt, war mongering and lawless regime that murders its own citizens. its a little rich, and you may want to wean off the conspiracy theories or have your LLM reference them less. like it, hiding behind those initials…

dk's avatar

My personal leanings are that of an 80’s Democrat. The “progressives” are insane. I didn’t leave the party, the party left me. Especially throwing around the word fascist all the time when their policies truly are fascist in nature. I spelled it out 👆. Mans when anyone comes at me to violate my bodily autonomy, they are ABSOLUTELY my enemy.

Matt's avatar

It's incredible to hear a liberal say they are on the side of individual liberty. Did you miss the Biden administration in its entirety?