28 Comments
User's avatar
Lenn's avatar

You have got to be just joking around. They've actually come up with a way to spin the massive electricity usage to produce NOTHING into being a "savior" to the grid?

Manul's avatar

Hmm. The miners consume prodigious amounts of electricity solving a math puzzle and producing nothing of value in the process. Couldn’t we just as well deploy millions of computers calculating pi to the trillionth digit?

Steve Mudge's avatar

This makes no sense, turning off a wasteful process in emergencies doesn't constitute a battery--its turning off a wasteful process.

Tyler's avatar

The rub though is that the wasteful process increases the base capacity of power generation such that turning it off provides supply during spikes that otherwise wouldn't be there. Which in turn makes it not a waste.

Allan Richard Wasem's avatar

It’s “not a waste” ONLY when it’s turned off😂😂😂!

Tyler's avatar

That's not a counterpoint :)

Allan Richard Wasem's avatar

Not my concern if you don't understand. It's "logic" (I know it's

"hard" and they haven't taught critical thinking skills in Public Schools for several generations) - believe me - you can still start to acquire the knowledge necessary to use it.

Rond's avatar

Oh give me a break

HydroMT's avatar

Great explanation. Thanks!

hepps's avatar

Here in Colorado they're taking the gas they used to flare off wells, running it through a generator and using that power to mine Bitcoins. Probably cost them some taxes, as the gas is no longer worthless and now has economic value.

Allan Richard Wasem's avatar

Bitcoin isn’t “money”. Bitcoin isn’t “REAL”. Bitcoin is an IOU NOTHING SQUARED. The only “magic” in Bitcoin is the spurious sleight-of-hand of the latest (and greatest) PONZI SCHEME.

BradK (Tuckered out)'s avatar

As opposed to residential solar customers who automatically send excess electrons out to the grid during periods of peak sunshine and receive zero compensation, which the utilities then sell for market price to non-solar customers.

The power of lobbying cannot be measured in GwH.

Michael Dabrowski's avatar

Great illustration of this attribute of the Bitcoin network.

To the naysayers “use electricity to produce nothing”… if that is your argument then you have missed the point.

Would you say the same for someone who has built massive batteries that remain fully charged, but are otherwise unused until deployed during times of excess demand? Does that amount to waste? No? I didn’t think so.

The Radical Individualist's avatar

Batteries don't consume electricity, they store it.

Michael Dabrowski's avatar

…. And the electricity that charges them?

The issue of not the consumption of any specific amount of energy. The issue is the impact that the bitcoin network (or batteries) has on load balancing the network.

In both cases, however, electricity is consumed. The difference is that their load balancing response is different. Bitcoin responds by decreasing demand, batteries respond by increasing supply.

The Radical Individualist's avatar

Here's an analogy: Imagine pumping ten gallons of gasoline into your gas tank, or pumping it onto the ground.

Either way, ten gallons is consumed. But when it's pumped into your tank, you can recover the energy in a useful way. That the gas resided in your tank for some length of time isn't even part of the equation.

The gasoline pumped onto the ground isn't part of any equation, either. It's just gone.

george's avatar

I wouldn't mind so much if they sent us gold foil wrapped chocolate bitcoins on April 15th or some other holiday.

Tankster's avatar

Basic BTC mining consumes prodigious amounts of electricity. BTC miners are air-cooled metal boxes. They lack Tier III redundancy (99.982% uptime) and were built cheaply and fast. Hyperscalers need liquid cooling, high-density racks, enterprise uptime guarantees, and deep fiber connectivity. The key constraint on AI growth is limited power. GE Vernova has a 3-year waiting list, and other players have equally large backlogs. Miners (some) have a lot of power behind the grid and can pivot to AI computing at scale, say the 1,330 Mw, that Core Scientific can deploy and make more money than mining. IREN has 4.5 GW of power available to pivot, and there are others. If you can achieve an 8% return by mining BTC and double that by supplying AI, why not? Colocate with hyperscalers, and at least partially address the shortfall in power for AI and for 345 million people who want to flip switches. Power [or lack thereof] is the constraint on AI growth. By 2030, nothing's left without trillions in grid upgrades and SMR adoption. NGMI h/t Ben Hunt.

george's avatar

I think the M&M has done what they're going to do to Bitcoin and it's approaching bottom. They need to keep people interested in their ETF's so they can do this all over again.