37 Comments
User's avatar
NJ Transit Commuter's avatar

Chris, allow me to propose an alternative theory. A billionaire with a dedicated tax agent will have a dedicated government official reviewing and approving every tax minimization strategy s/he decides to employ. And given human nature, one assumes that billionaires will have substantial leverage to make sure a low paid government bureaucrat is incentivized to find “creative” means to minimize taxes.

It’s the UK equivalent of 401K millionaires that should be nervous. They don’t have a government appointed tax concierge, and will continue to have half their earnings taxed away, wasted on frivolity, for having the audacity to work hard and save diligently. Same in US high tax jurisdictions like NJ, with which I am all too familiar…

Bill Theobald's avatar

Thank the gods I left California when the getting was good and moved to the great state of TEXAS. We have minimal government intrusion, can own guns and defend our property and our individual rights within the constructs of constitutional carry and the second amendment. Not difficult to understand why folks are bailing out of the socialist states, coming here, bringing their money and businesses with them.

Laramie's avatar

I left CA in 2012 when they passed a prop raising state taxes to 13.3%. I'm no billionaire but if you scare away enough aires it eventually has an effect. Also in TX now. Love the state.

Dean Whiting's avatar

yes, as with all of these tax programs they use the threat of billionaires to legitimize the enforcement regime. Then they can get the non billionaires exactly as you say.

If the governments really cared about fairness they would be enforcing existing laws on anti trust and (for America at least) employing illegal labor.

barnabus's avatar

Basically, the tax agent will be a direct conduit to the government. However, as there will be leaks, government won't be able to budge aggressively. In the end, most billionaires will leave as government will not be able to offer them protection because public scrutiny.

NJ is different - it is permanently blue, so public scrutiny tends against zero. Was the senator with gold bars from NJ or Maryland, by the way?

NJ Transit Commuter's avatar

barnabus, maybe I am being too cynical but here why I don’t think public scrutiny will be a disincentive to aggressive tax “minimization.”

A billionaire can hire an army of lawyers to draft legislation that avoids the taxes s/he doesn’t want to pay. It’s is slipped in a few lines in a thousand page bill that is enacted by the government. The “dedicated tax agent” confirms that the billionaire does not need to pay tax on this income.

After a few years on the job, the dedicated tax agent leaves to head an NGO: Tax Equity for the UK!!!, a “progressive” organization. 10 times the government salary, softball interviews on the BBC, monthly trips to France, Germany, and Washington DC for speaking engagements with lucrative speaker fees. If someone spends days digging through the paperwork, they’d find that 5-6 organization down the paper trail, the billionaire to which the tax agent was assigned is bankrolling Tax Equity for the UK!!!

I wish I were being too cynical, sadly I don’t think so.

barnabus's avatar

Lawyers only work so far. British Parliament is something very different from US Congress, because the UK government works under the principle of "the king in parliament". No checks and balances.

The Color Of Air's avatar

One must ask why the gov needs to constantly try to extract more money from the billionaires. Nothing is solved as long as the gov keeps spending more money than it has to spend. Bernie S wants to tax over 900 billionaires hoping to get an extra $4 trillion over 10 years. That will cover about two years of government deficits. But heck, for the gov that is enormous progress.

Pyrrho of Elis's avatar

Will the HMRC assign one of these to King Charles?

Petra Kehr's avatar

Love that question 😁😁😁

Petra Kehr's avatar

Well, the communsists just found out what Maggie Thatcher predicted. It works until they run out of other people money.

Steve Mudge's avatar

Except in this case our $40 trillion debt has largely benefitted the wealthy via tax cuts, large bondholders, corporations, and retirees.

Mezzanotte's avatar

And a bloated, unnecessarily large military that if approx double an appropriate size, has contributed at least $20T to that debt over the last 20 years. I hope all those "defense" hawks feel it has been worth it.

J-9's avatar

Well thank goodness that could never happen in the USA!

Right, Senator Wyden (D-OR)? Senator Crapo (Uniparty-masquerading-as-R, ID)? And King, Warren, Kaine, Whitehouse? (https://www.king.senate.gov/newsroom/press-releases/king-colleagues-introduce-bill-to-strengthen-tax-enforcement-services-against-high-dollar-tax-dodgers), and the House rats parroting the call for specific billions more in IRS funding year-by-year (https://www.govtrack.us/congress/bills/119/hr9736/text).

But of course we mustn't mustn't mustn't hassle the babymammas and shackups grabbing $10K refund in refundable "tax" "credits" every year based on their children with so much as a audit-by-mail asking them to prove that the child exists and actually lived with them. Or the ones who magically claim just the right income level from a phony hairdresser/barber self-employment operation to max out the Earned Income Credit. That would be racissssst.

It's so much easier to make election ads about those evil billionaires.

Tax Simplification is the only answer. Rand Paul, spare us your annual Festivus List theater. Not helpful.

Leskunque Lepew's avatar

The WEF/Transnational gangsters ( Their King and PM included) are assaulting the UK in order to completely destroy it and mold it into their CCP/feudal style of government that they crave.

Millionaires will be next.

Bill Lacey's avatar

Exactly. When you look at all of the bad policy coming from the UK, from open borders, two-tiered justice, weaponized policing, flirting with WWIII in Ukraine and now driving the rich from the island, you have to wonder - are they really this incompetent or is this intentional?

As you say, it's intentional, designed to destroy the country and usher in autocratic CCP-style tyranny.

Andy Fately's avatar

One has to wonder, will King Charles have his own concierge as well?

Petra Kehr's avatar

Love the idea 😁😁😁

ScottyG's avatar

So, in essence, the chosen few will be wined and dined and will be paid under the table to scrutinize a little less than warranted. Not a bad gig if you can get it. 🤷‍♂️

Doug Camden's avatar

The fact that they have so few that they can assign an agent to each one tells you everything you need to know about the UK.

Andrew Marsh's avatar

A bit of non-news.

The wealthy around the world employ small armies of well qualified people to negotiate with tax collection authorities with the view of agreeing scope, and making prompt payments. This system has led directly to the most complex tax code in the world (UK) where the opponents swap sides so often 'bolt holes' and more are built into the law.

Meanwhile the masses pay.

And keep paying.

Arturo's avatar

Just check out how many Americans have moved to Puerto Rico in the last 15 years or so. Act 60 (formerly Acts 20 and 22) gives them tremendous relief.

Andrew Simpson's avatar

There are the wealthy, who are paying heavily, and then there are the hyper-wealthy, the subject of this article, who likely are not. This so called announcement is theatre: people in that class won't just have a dedicated account manager in HMRC, they will have a department, or major portions of departments assigned to them, because what they pay isn't determined by formula as it is for even the very wealthy peasants, it's a matter of discussion and negotiation.

Nick Farr's avatar

Simple message.

GTFO.

Take grandma with you.

David Carroll's avatar

They are begging for Capital to flee.

TimCNY's avatar

I’m surprised that the wealthy are so passive about taxes.

TimCNY's avatar

Meaning the $40 trillion debt will be paid by the wealthy not the poor or middle class. There are less than 10 million households with a net worth over $1 million excluding the primary home and high income wage earners (top 10%) already pay 70% of income tax. I would think those people are smart enough to realize they will eventually get the shaft, but it seems large numbers are okay with the current trajectory. Puzzling.

Matt's avatar

Anything other than cut spending or even attempt to be more efficient. This is 100% an idea that blue states will latch onto in the next few years