The absurdity is part of the point. It allows Woods' fans to respond to skepticism with "Ok, let's pretend Musk fails and the deployment comes in 90% below projections. In that case, a mere $1Trillion annual revenue. The current valuation is still an amazing investment opportunity!"
The game is more fun if you don't let yourself take it seriously.
She belongs in outer space. I know a couple of people that drank her Kool-Aid a little late and got hammered. Btw absolutely love, "...do more heavy lifting than the elevator at Jerry Nadler’s apartment building."
An investor that followed her March, 2020 forecast for Tesla and actually sold the November, 2021 peak made nearly 20X. Most bought too late, and sold too late. But many millionaires were made.
This was her only success and the entire basis for her "reputation." Her career batting average is humiliating, but she still drinks free for that one perfect home run.
I’m not saying I believe Wood’s math anymore than I believe the data center build out math…I’m simply saying that both dreams can’t co-exist. There’s not enough funding nor critical materials
I think the sole reason for Cathie Wood's post on X was to provide material for Chris. Are you colluding with her Chris? Perhaps offering her 10% of your lemondade stand profits.
You made some valid points, and I understand you calling out Cathie Wood's very optimistic valuation, but you missed some more important points. SpaceX has no competent competitor. The others have not launched rockets or have had their rockets blown to bits on launch. SpaceX does more than 90% of the world's launches. Who has demonstrated a reusable rocket? No other competitor has caught a rocket as SpaceX has. SpaceX has Starlink. Is there a competitor to Starlink? Will Starlink enable the next Worldwide wireless mobile phone carrier? SpaceX has AI data Centers and many other potential revenue sources and ways to lower costs. SpaceX seems to have an amazing future based on its previous historical performance, as long as Elon Musk lives.
I didn't "miss" those points because they're not important to what I'm arguing. None of what you said makes 10,000 launches a year at $1 billion each within 5 years any more sane of an analysis.
Broadly agree with the message here. It brought to mind Fermi estimation—the old “how many piano tuners are there in Chicago?” approach. You don’t need perfect information; break a huge question into smaller, reasonable assumptions and see whether the order of magnitude makes sense.
Just for fun, I tried the same exercise on the entire global stock market. Start with roughly $120T+ of world GDP, estimate the corporate profit pool and the share earned by publicly traded companies, then assume a long-run ROE of ~12% and nominal growth of ~4.5%. To sustain that growth at a 12% ROE, you need to retain roughly 37.5% of earnings, leaving about 60–65% available to shareholders.
Then assume a normalised long-term risk-free yield of ~5.5% plus a ~4% equity risk premium, for a required equity return of ~9.5%, with 4.5% perpetual nominal growth, leaving a 5% spread. A 60–65% sustainable payout divided by that 5% spread gives a back-of-the-envelope fair P/E of roughly 12–13x.
The actual global market is around 22x trailing earnings.
Obviously this isn’t atomic physics (and not an investment recommendation either), and changing the assumptions changes the answer substantially. Nor is 12–13x meant to be a precise valuation target. That’s the point of a Fermi estimate: it’s a sanity check. When a reasonable order-of-magnitude calculation comes out very differently from the market price, you at least know which assumptions you need to start questioning.
Same with 10,000 Starship launches × $1 billion. The multiplication is the easy part. The assumptions are the valuation.
Anyone else remember the one-hit wonders Elaine Garzarelli, who predicted the 1987 crash, and Meredith Whitney, who called the GFC in 2007? Both subsequently became gurus worshiped on the Street, then promptly lost billions for their clients. As far as I know, Wood has made one good call and made big money in 2000. The real story here isn't Cathie Wood; it's Wall Street's unending tendency to latch onto a goofy guru. As Jim Grant says, progress in science is cumulative, but in finance it is cyclical.
On a similar lookout period, Cathie's TSLA bull case in 2022 was the company would have $486 billion in robotaxi revenue in 2026. 2026 actual? Basically $0.
I actually think the jury is not in on Cathy wood. But it should be in the next 10 years. She may be correct but early. I own both Tesla and circle internet group. But I got both of them pretty cheap. And I would also buy SpaceX at $70. Maybe more we'll see. I think it's fun to listen to all kinds of people and then just kind of curate what you consider valuable information. Obviously before you buy you have to do your own research.
I feel like Cathie Wood is a human manifestation of Ed Zitron's brilliantly snarky quip about how no matter the cycle, Wall Street always has the same reply to bears' skepticism of nonsensical valuations: "But......number go up"
Typical reuse cycle for rockets is 20-30 days. Pad reuse record is 2.1 days. 32 non-China launch sites worldwide for 10K yearly launches = 1 launch every 7.5 hours if no anomalies that is supposed to support a gross margin of 98%. Insanity visits the financial markets once again.
The absurdity is part of the point. It allows Woods' fans to respond to skepticism with "Ok, let's pretend Musk fails and the deployment comes in 90% below projections. In that case, a mere $1Trillion annual revenue. The current valuation is still an amazing investment opportunity!"
The game is more fun if you don't let yourself take it seriously.
She's obviously using the Stardate calender (Captain Cathy's log?) and factoring in the onset of hyperinflation.
Uranus is no longer big enough to fit a Buc-ee's. Too many people are using GLP-1.
Astute observation.
The twin thoughts of Uranus and Buc-ee's are causing me massive cognitive dissonance.
I think this is another attempt by Ms Woods at comedy.
She belongs in outer space. I know a couple of people that drank her Kool-Aid a little late and got hammered. Btw absolutely love, "...do more heavy lifting than the elevator at Jerry Nadler’s apartment building."
Has she actually made any money for her investors?
An investor that followed her March, 2020 forecast for Tesla and actually sold the November, 2021 peak made nearly 20X. Most bought too late, and sold too late. But many millionaires were made.
This was her only success and the entire basis for her "reputation." Her career batting average is humiliating, but she still drinks free for that one perfect home run.
I’m not saying I believe Wood’s math anymore than I believe the data center build out math…I’m simply saying that both dreams can’t co-exist. There’s not enough funding nor critical materials
Critical Materials = cash
I think the sole reason for Cathie Wood's post on X was to provide material for Chris. Are you colluding with her Chris? Perhaps offering her 10% of your lemondade stand profits.
Are you kidding? Chris probably has a wood chipper with Cathy’s name on it.
Doubt Chris ever lost a penny betting on anything Cathy wrote or promoted. She lobbed an easy one, soft, slow, in the middle of the plate.
C'mon QtR, she did say "if"... LOL.
Excellent article !
Maybe Woods has tapped into some quantum mechanism where you can make things materialize by writing about them?
You made some valid points, and I understand you calling out Cathie Wood's very optimistic valuation, but you missed some more important points. SpaceX has no competent competitor. The others have not launched rockets or have had their rockets blown to bits on launch. SpaceX does more than 90% of the world's launches. Who has demonstrated a reusable rocket? No other competitor has caught a rocket as SpaceX has. SpaceX has Starlink. Is there a competitor to Starlink? Will Starlink enable the next Worldwide wireless mobile phone carrier? SpaceX has AI data Centers and many other potential revenue sources and ways to lower costs. SpaceX seems to have an amazing future based on its previous historical performance, as long as Elon Musk lives.
I didn't "miss" those points because they're not important to what I'm arguing. None of what you said makes 10,000 launches a year at $1 billion each within 5 years any more sane of an analysis.
Broadly agree with the message here. It brought to mind Fermi estimation—the old “how many piano tuners are there in Chicago?” approach. You don’t need perfect information; break a huge question into smaller, reasonable assumptions and see whether the order of magnitude makes sense.
Just for fun, I tried the same exercise on the entire global stock market. Start with roughly $120T+ of world GDP, estimate the corporate profit pool and the share earned by publicly traded companies, then assume a long-run ROE of ~12% and nominal growth of ~4.5%. To sustain that growth at a 12% ROE, you need to retain roughly 37.5% of earnings, leaving about 60–65% available to shareholders.
Then assume a normalised long-term risk-free yield of ~5.5% plus a ~4% equity risk premium, for a required equity return of ~9.5%, with 4.5% perpetual nominal growth, leaving a 5% spread. A 60–65% sustainable payout divided by that 5% spread gives a back-of-the-envelope fair P/E of roughly 12–13x.
The actual global market is around 22x trailing earnings.
Obviously this isn’t atomic physics (and not an investment recommendation either), and changing the assumptions changes the answer substantially. Nor is 12–13x meant to be a precise valuation target. That’s the point of a Fermi estimate: it’s a sanity check. When a reasonable order-of-magnitude calculation comes out very differently from the market price, you at least know which assumptions you need to start questioning.
Same with 10,000 Starship launches × $1 billion. The multiplication is the easy part. The assumptions are the valuation.
Anyone else remember the one-hit wonders Elaine Garzarelli, who predicted the 1987 crash, and Meredith Whitney, who called the GFC in 2007? Both subsequently became gurus worshiped on the Street, then promptly lost billions for their clients. As far as I know, Wood has made one good call and made big money in 2000. The real story here isn't Cathie Wood; it's Wall Street's unending tendency to latch onto a goofy guru. As Jim Grant says, progress in science is cumulative, but in finance it is cyclical.
On a similar lookout period, Cathie's TSLA bull case in 2022 was the company would have $486 billion in robotaxi revenue in 2026. 2026 actual? Basically $0.
she's looking smarter today...
I actually think the jury is not in on Cathy wood. But it should be in the next 10 years. She may be correct but early. I own both Tesla and circle internet group. But I got both of them pretty cheap. And I would also buy SpaceX at $70. Maybe more we'll see. I think it's fun to listen to all kinds of people and then just kind of curate what you consider valuable information. Obviously before you buy you have to do your own research.
I always shop the sales rack and never pay retail. Clearances are where it's at.
I feel like Cathie Wood is a human manifestation of Ed Zitron's brilliantly snarky quip about how no matter the cycle, Wall Street always has the same reply to bears' skepticism of nonsensical valuations: "But......number go up"
Typical reuse cycle for rockets is 20-30 days. Pad reuse record is 2.1 days. 32 non-China launch sites worldwide for 10K yearly launches = 1 launch every 7.5 hours if no anomalies that is supposed to support a gross margin of 98%. Insanity visits the financial markets once again.