I don't think the dots connect that simply. The civil rights movement was essentially economic in nature -- access to jobs and economic services -- and its seeds go back to the abolitionists of the pre-Civil war era. Nowhere in that 100 years+ of American history do we see among the civil rights advocates the homicidal rage that we see today directed by the the savages among us, the homicidal and crazed -- and I hate these labels but, here they are, "liberal/progressive/etc." (and not every one, of course not, I mean the ones that make the news for the reasons they do, shouting screaming damning burning and rationalizing it all with a damnation and pointed finger).
We are way beyond the economic realm here. We are at some foundational level of psyche, something "pre-economic", something embedded so deeply in the confused life force that even Freud was perplexed and called it "thanatos". Dostoevsky called it "demons". Joseph Campbell chronicled the ancient myths and cultures where strange battles occurred between male and female energies constellated in their shamans, the gender dsyphorias have ancient pedegrees.
This stuff is weird. Waaay beyond civil rights resentments and idealisms.
Where did it get toxic and murderous -- even at the philosophical level which is almost always a necessary antecendent to action? In our time it was probably Herbert Marcuse and that Frankfurt school who unleashed the flood gates here in the USA of a philosophical rebellion based on the complete subjugation of your opponent. Camus in the Rebel took a very different path and found rebellion an affirmation of the individual, whereas the logical extreme of Marcuse was the annihilation of the opponent justified by the opponent's irredeemable supposed inhumanity in the manner of burning witches. That was the philosophy Camus sought to utterly destroy throughout his whole career. Strange to think Marcuse came from the same culture that produced Mises! Look at Albrecht Durer's portait of Oswald Krell painted in 1499. It's all there. Strange Bedfellows.
People think there has been some sort of shift. I see a continuum. The progressive movement didn't appear out of nowhere, and KKK members didn't evaporate into space. They are the same people, reshaped somewhat in tune with the times.
The mistake that people keep making (including progressives) is in thinking that the KKK hated blacks. They did not. The KKK was born of the feudal system, the American aristocracy. Those who capitulated to that system faired reasonably well, black and white. Those who insisted on individual rights and the constitution, got lynched.
Today, it is not much different, even to the point of Clarence Thomas stating that he was being subjected to a "high tech lynching." Look at those blacks who are reviled by progressives, and those blacks who dovetail nicely with them. There is little essential difference from the nineteenth century.
I've oversimplified, for sure. But I didn't come to this on my own. Libraries are full of books, written in the nineteenth and twentieth centuries, that go deep into the institutional racism that democrats did, and still do, practice.
I tend to think this has always co-existed from the beginning, yes, of time.
Even the extremes become more extreme, that is, until it breaks.
All of history, back to the ancients, is a series of choices of up/down, dark/light, ying/yang. The fringe is what pushes the change, not the moderate go-along people, but the fringe.
The 'choices' have been obviously bad along a continuum otherwise we wouldn't be in this extreme period of time.
Now, thanks to technology and some weird accelerating cosmic events, we are watching history! Personally, I think we are actually witnessing empires rise and fall because of the extremes on an accelerated continuum. If I'm right, and I think Chris wrote a great piece with a picture of a tumbling Jenga tower, we're in the thick of things but for some reason we think we 'see'. Personally, I think of it like Babel, not literally a structure, but a kingdom, the inhabitants in this story reached beyond some kind of limit and bam! Likewise, Eve reached by eating (not looking at or even desiring, but it was the choice to act) the fruit of the tree of 'knowledge of good/evil' that is another example of a 'cosmic change', defined limits were broken.
The cosmic part we are sensing is that we are reaching a limit. Even the lies are extreme and they can't keep track of them and no one seems to have the capacity to question them without being called an 'extremist'. The nutty thing is that most aren't even aware, they are eating it up like insane people-like a zombie like state and here we are trying to make logical sense of it. Could this be the ptsd from the 2020 coof psyop?
I think we are watching it fall down. And because we know it's rotten, there is a part of us that is glad. And another part of us that wonders where we, as individuals, will journey and land.
We all must constantly choose 'sides'. The question is will we choose Lady Wisdom or her 'evil' twin sister, Harlot Folly.
Keep in mind, I am no philosopher. I am a mere acute observer of any 'idea' that attempts to trap me into cultish like behaviors, I am a Christian but an enemy of religion. This is a vent, plain and simple. These are the worst of times and the best of times to be alive..
I would literally repeal or override that whole ball of mess along with Hart-Celler which fundamentally changed our country and will continue to change it if we don't do something
Its what makes Charlie's Kirks loss so profound. Aside from becoming an accomplished religious and civics historian...He excelled at arguing the facts and prosecuting his arguments with cold hard data and examples.
To often today, constructive arguments of every kind are almost immediately thwarted by what about ism and little to no data or prosecutable evidence to provide for so many issues. And depressingly, to often, any "facts" they do provide are usualy manipulated, overstated or just flat out false. Crime is a feeling, handing parents sex assignment paperwork in delivery rooms. In arguable. Anyone listening knows this. Charlie's ability to tap into anyone listening and thinking the same thing was such a powerful force. With him others felt legitimate in the right and wrong decisions so many of us make on a moment to moment basis inside our guts. They felt confident behind his calm patient steadfast integrity.
That man held his paint...and did so stoically. He was truly doing God's work.
The current situation shows that the fringes of each "side" are driving the narrative. Within minutes of Kirk's assassination videos were posted by many similarly positioned people to the effect that the gloves are off and it's time to take action against the Trans-whoever else deemed radically librhul.
Then that video with the kid singing We got Charlie in the neck. Probably others.
IMHO, more of the former than latter, but that's irrelevant. What's relevant is that extremists meet on the circle, not opposite sides of a line. They are driven together by grievances, real and imagined.
Social media algos drive their messages and drive out any discourse. Without discourse, we are rent asunder. The Widening Gyre. Kirk taught against exactly what is happening. As Chuck Palanihuk said "When did the future change from a promise to a threat?"
Anyone else revisiting famous legislation/ events and reconsidering what did happen? For example, originally I saw the civil rights act as an absolute necessity. Now I’m not so sure, especially if I was a voter grappling with it in that era. It’s not open and shut.
I don't think the dots connect that simply. The civil rights movement was essentially economic in nature -- access to jobs and economic services -- and its seeds go back to the abolitionists of the pre-Civil war era. Nowhere in that 100 years+ of American history do we see among the civil rights advocates the homicidal rage that we see today directed by the the savages among us, the homicidal and crazed -- and I hate these labels but, here they are, "liberal/progressive/etc." (and not every one, of course not, I mean the ones that make the news for the reasons they do, shouting screaming damning burning and rationalizing it all with a damnation and pointed finger).
We are way beyond the economic realm here. We are at some foundational level of psyche, something "pre-economic", something embedded so deeply in the confused life force that even Freud was perplexed and called it "thanatos". Dostoevsky called it "demons". Joseph Campbell chronicled the ancient myths and cultures where strange battles occurred between male and female energies constellated in their shamans, the gender dsyphorias have ancient pedegrees.
This stuff is weird. Waaay beyond civil rights resentments and idealisms.
Where did it get toxic and murderous -- even at the philosophical level which is almost always a necessary antecendent to action? In our time it was probably Herbert Marcuse and that Frankfurt school who unleashed the flood gates here in the USA of a philosophical rebellion based on the complete subjugation of your opponent. Camus in the Rebel took a very different path and found rebellion an affirmation of the individual, whereas the logical extreme of Marcuse was the annihilation of the opponent justified by the opponent's irredeemable supposed inhumanity in the manner of burning witches. That was the philosophy Camus sought to utterly destroy throughout his whole career. Strange to think Marcuse came from the same culture that produced Mises! Look at Albrecht Durer's portait of Oswald Krell painted in 1499. It's all there. Strange Bedfellows.
People think there has been some sort of shift. I see a continuum. The progressive movement didn't appear out of nowhere, and KKK members didn't evaporate into space. They are the same people, reshaped somewhat in tune with the times.
The mistake that people keep making (including progressives) is in thinking that the KKK hated blacks. They did not. The KKK was born of the feudal system, the American aristocracy. Those who capitulated to that system faired reasonably well, black and white. Those who insisted on individual rights and the constitution, got lynched.
Today, it is not much different, even to the point of Clarence Thomas stating that he was being subjected to a "high tech lynching." Look at those blacks who are reviled by progressives, and those blacks who dovetail nicely with them. There is little essential difference from the nineteenth century.
I've oversimplified, for sure. But I didn't come to this on my own. Libraries are full of books, written in the nineteenth and twentieth centuries, that go deep into the institutional racism that democrats did, and still do, practice.
I tend to think this has always co-existed from the beginning, yes, of time.
Even the extremes become more extreme, that is, until it breaks.
All of history, back to the ancients, is a series of choices of up/down, dark/light, ying/yang. The fringe is what pushes the change, not the moderate go-along people, but the fringe.
The 'choices' have been obviously bad along a continuum otherwise we wouldn't be in this extreme period of time.
Now, thanks to technology and some weird accelerating cosmic events, we are watching history! Personally, I think we are actually witnessing empires rise and fall because of the extremes on an accelerated continuum. If I'm right, and I think Chris wrote a great piece with a picture of a tumbling Jenga tower, we're in the thick of things but for some reason we think we 'see'. Personally, I think of it like Babel, not literally a structure, but a kingdom, the inhabitants in this story reached beyond some kind of limit and bam! Likewise, Eve reached by eating (not looking at or even desiring, but it was the choice to act) the fruit of the tree of 'knowledge of good/evil' that is another example of a 'cosmic change', defined limits were broken.
The cosmic part we are sensing is that we are reaching a limit. Even the lies are extreme and they can't keep track of them and no one seems to have the capacity to question them without being called an 'extremist'. The nutty thing is that most aren't even aware, they are eating it up like insane people-like a zombie like state and here we are trying to make logical sense of it. Could this be the ptsd from the 2020 coof psyop?
I think we are watching it fall down. And because we know it's rotten, there is a part of us that is glad. And another part of us that wonders where we, as individuals, will journey and land.
We all must constantly choose 'sides'. The question is will we choose Lady Wisdom or her 'evil' twin sister, Harlot Folly.
Keep in mind, I am no philosopher. I am a mere acute observer of any 'idea' that attempts to trap me into cultish like behaviors, I am a Christian but an enemy of religion. This is a vent, plain and simple. These are the worst of times and the best of times to be alive..
I wish you all,
Godspeed.
I would literally repeal or override that whole ball of mess along with Hart-Celler which fundamentally changed our country and will continue to change it if we don't do something
Wow. Exteeamly well written. Well thought out.
Its what makes Charlie's Kirks loss so profound. Aside from becoming an accomplished religious and civics historian...He excelled at arguing the facts and prosecuting his arguments with cold hard data and examples.
To often today, constructive arguments of every kind are almost immediately thwarted by what about ism and little to no data or prosecutable evidence to provide for so many issues. And depressingly, to often, any "facts" they do provide are usualy manipulated, overstated or just flat out false. Crime is a feeling, handing parents sex assignment paperwork in delivery rooms. In arguable. Anyone listening knows this. Charlie's ability to tap into anyone listening and thinking the same thing was such a powerful force. With him others felt legitimate in the right and wrong decisions so many of us make on a moment to moment basis inside our guts. They felt confident behind his calm patient steadfast integrity.
That man held his paint...and did so stoically. He was truly doing God's work.
The current situation shows that the fringes of each "side" are driving the narrative. Within minutes of Kirk's assassination videos were posted by many similarly positioned people to the effect that the gloves are off and it's time to take action against the Trans-whoever else deemed radically librhul.
Then that video with the kid singing We got Charlie in the neck. Probably others.
IMHO, more of the former than latter, but that's irrelevant. What's relevant is that extremists meet on the circle, not opposite sides of a line. They are driven together by grievances, real and imagined.
Social media algos drive their messages and drive out any discourse. Without discourse, we are rent asunder. The Widening Gyre. Kirk taught against exactly what is happening. As Chuck Palanihuk said "When did the future change from a promise to a threat?"
We'll see, I reckon.
Anyone else revisiting famous legislation/ events and reconsidering what did happen? For example, originally I saw the civil rights act as an absolute necessity. Now I’m not so sure, especially if I was a voter grappling with it in that era. It’s not open and shut.
The time for dialogue is over.
PROGRESSIVISMUS DELENDA EST!