15 Comments
User's avatar
Bill Petersen's avatar

Funding for DHS passed the House. It failed in the Senate. The offered solution was to carve out ICE and CBP. In effect, Shumer was in effect exercising a line item veto. This was not the normal legislative process.

Allan Richard Wasem's avatar

No question the Democrats are responsible. That’s their right under Senate procedures – and the results are on them.

Allan Richard Wasem's avatar

It's perfectly legitimate under the Senate's own procedural rules - which are the prerogative of the Senate itself!

Bill Petersen's avatar

Of course, but then the House had to reapprove which they did not. Zero doubt the shutdown was 100% democrat under regular procedures.

Bill Lacey's avatar

I laugh at these think tank discussions about the Constitution, checks and balances and the power of the purse.

Let's see, where in the Constitution is the silent filibuster that prevents debate on an issue that has 80% support from the American voters? Where in the Constitution does it allow that "power of the purse" given to Congress to spend the country into a debt crisis? And to "unlawfully" spend money ad hoc because there hasn't been a annual budget since 1997? Where in the Constitution does it allow the Executive Branch to ignore existing immigration laws in order to throw open the border to a foreign invasion, shower the invaders with US taxpayer money and count them in the census for Congressional representation allocations to each state? Where in the Constitution does is allow the Judiciary take on the powers of the Executive Branch and act as a de facto President?

My point - we are so far beyond even pretending this country is operating in compliance with its Constitution that to nit pick certain areas of non-compliance is a complete joke. All three branches are functioning extra-Constitutionally, it's getting worse every year and frankly, there's no putting the fart back in the asshole. The scum in DC like operating without restraints and are going to continue doing so until they are stopped.

badnabor's avatar

In light of the Congress' inaction and disregard for their duties to pass funding legislation, it's hard to fault the executive branch for implementing a work around. The Congress in recent years has become one long game of "kick the can down the road". They welcome the executive branch filling the vacuum, so that they can hide their failures from the voters and put out a self favoring narrative. It's bad precedent, but I can't lay all the blame on Trump. Someone's got to nut up and make the hard decisions.

Lawrence Fossi's avatar

Yeah, when the constitution becomes too inconvenient, let’s just ignore it.

Leskunque Lepew's avatar

Being elected to Congress/Senate is akin to hitting the lottery. That's all they care about.

Laura Wilson's avatar

Maybe if Congress could skip all the dog any pony show hearings they have on issues that go nowhere and actually took on their biggest Constitutional duty of passing a budget the executive branch could back off on executive orders. But actually agreeing to a budget removes things both sides like to use as campaign issues pointing at the other side. That is why immigration will never be seriously addressed, it would remove their favorite wedge issue.

Allan Richard Wasem's avatar

I agree wholeheartedly with Bill Lacey's prior comments. BUT - the formalities still do exist and could be restored to their proper function in the proper circumstances. I'm hopeful that this Fourth Turning will provide those circumstances. I just think that a Hell of a lot of the American people will die in various (mostly unpleasant) ways first, and probably even higher percentages of people in many other countries.

Allan Richard Wasem's avatar

Regrettably - Donnie-boy is beginning to look as if he's a wanna-be Dictator. The restoration of America was always going to be a "Slog" -not a "Sprint". Not a good operating environment for a volatile narcissist.

Norb Warnes's avatar

Alas, the US Senate at one time had the nickname of "The 100 Kings" to convey that body's legislative power, influence, and authority. It was amusing and somewhat ambiguous in the context of "100 Kings" to see the participants of this past weekends "No Kings" rallies. I'm sure that the irony was lost. No longer does the US Senate have 100 kings. It does have, however, 100 buffoons, which in the long run might be worth something. What exactly that is I can't say. Hail to the Chief whose actions and decisive action, right or wrong, legal or not, broke the gridlock at US airports. Thank you for the very informative article.

billmatt2's avatar

The problem is Congress failure to act in a human way through the federal employees. They’re impotence is absolutely disgusting and they’re not trying to participate as an equal branch of government, but it’s just as a political enemy.