13 Comments
User's avatar
rtko's avatar

A centralized economy would be rigged to benefit a few and keep the rest in check.

Steve Mudge's avatar

My friend is in Cuba right now, while the common folks are living meal to meal, word on the street is the ruling family has quite a lavish lifestyle: " All pigs are equal but some pigs are more equal than others".

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Mar 25Edited
Comment deleted
craazyman's avatar

So true. Rtko, SM, BH . . . All so true.

Why does it all have to be made so complicated?

It isn’t complicated.

You just have to understand what it is . . . And then it’s easy.

The Radical Individualist's avatar

I've lived a somewhat unconventional life. No, I didn't get my private parts rearranged, but I did earn a fairly unconventional living. No AI, and no central planner could have made allowances for the ways I earned a living.

And I'm not that unusual. There's the old saying, mediocracy thrives on standardization.

craazyman's avatar

Adult films?

(Just kdding hahahahah . . . . Actually that might be the big AI use case. If they can get video to persist across scenes. Even the Cro Magnons had the Venus of Willendorf.)

fab's avatar

Mises is correct. And even if we get a super intelligent AI, corruption will not disappear because its conclusions will be implemented by humans in power.

Leskunque Lepew's avatar

Please, don't give those ding dongs any ideas.

Allan Richard Wasem's avatar

Well "AI" is definitely Artificial and definitely not "intelligent". If you need any proof just take a look at a few of the "AI"-generated stories on Faceplant.

DLB's avatar

You cannot program Human Nature, nor can you program Mother Nature, and both affect a local economy in different ways every day.

Mikael's avatar

First, on Cybersyn and the Chilean government more broadly: the relevant context is Project FUBELT - a CIA program to destabilize Salvador Allende’s government. It didn’t specifically target Cybersyn, but it significantly constrained the broader attempt to build a socialist model.

Second, your point about prices is correct. Several schools of thought retain prices as informational signals while removing private ownership of the means of production. The harder issue is avoiding incompetence without traditional competitive pressure. That’s not fatal - you can introduce competition among publicly owned firms within the same sector, combined with hard constraints: performance benchmarking, restructuring or shutdown of persistently underperforming units, and limits on recycling failed management into new entities.

Overall, the problem looks solvable in principle. The real obstacle is that capitalism is highly self-reinforcing - via incentives tied to ownership, accumulation, and status. So transitioning away from it is more politically and institutionally difficult than the abstract economic design problem.

Idaho_7's avatar

Guaranteed to provoke a horrendous civil war. Human nature does not comply, never has.

Steve Mudge's avatar

AI for central planning is ridiculous but with the recent spate of presidential candidates made an AI chief executive would be better🤣