37 Comments
User's avatar
Illinois Entrepreneur's avatar

This is all actually pretty impressive, but it overlooks the 800 pound elephant in the room: wokeness.

Speaking for me personally, I won't ever buy a Nike product again, after watching them introduce "social justice" into my sports and lecturing me on what I should be thinking, and what I've done wrong. It seems to be a brand that wants angry minorities who feel wronged by America as its customers. Very controversial and "edgy," but also to the point where I got the message, and I decided that the brand left me.

They simply don't want me as a customer and they have moved on.

So have I, and I think that both me and the company are happy about it.

Laramie's avatar

My thoughts exactly. I stopped watching the NFL when multimillionaire athletes took a knee and lectured me about how horribly unfair the USA is. Nike took that lead and ran with it. Now, I'll buy anything other than Nike. I know more people who feel the same than I do people who are indifferent. That's the heart of Nike's problem.

It's ironic that the company's most famous pitchman, Michael Jordan, intuitively understood this. Asked why he refused to endorse a Democrat Senate candidate in his home state of North Carolina, he said "Republicans buy sneakers, too."

His point wasn't about Democrats or Republicans. It was about all things political.

My one fix for Nike: Re-discover who you are. You're not a politician, you're not a social justice warrior, and you're not a thumb that can be placed on the scale of perceived social causes. You're an apparel company. Never forget it.

badnabor's avatar

I suppose Nike stands a chance of recovery, but it had better start with a revisionist history writer. An unaware future generation might forgive and forget, but speaking for myself, no way. I'm now a solid Brooks customer.

Quoth the Raven's avatar

I love their Stride running shorts and have a couple hoodies for gym, etc. But the brand has nothing else for me right now. I run in Saunconys, I train BJJ in Fuji and Lanky Fight Gear.

Leskunque Lepew's avatar

By the way...Asics is a questionable company. Many bad experiences with them.

BradK (Tuckered out)'s avatar

You might have thought these companies would remember Gillette and its ill-conceived "toxic masculinity" campaign a few years back, from which they never recovered. Or Budweiser, whose ads were at one time even more famous than Nike.

Turns out that insulting your customers doesn't drive sales growth after all.

Laramie's avatar

Worse still: Nike saw what happened to Bud Light when it trotted out Dylan Mulvaney as a spokesperson. It saw the billions in sales lost and the permanent damage to the Budweiser brand.

What does Nike do? It signs Dylan Mulvaney. https://www.newsweek.com/nike-transgender-dylan-mulvaney-sports-bra-model-days-after-bud-light-furore-1792872. This is the stuff that proxy fights and class actions are built on.

jonathan.crowell33's avatar

Illinois- you wrote my post for me. When Nike embraced the Colin Kaepernick, anti police movement it became the equivalent of Bud Light sneakers. Wearing Nike is like wearing the Maga hat. You are knowingly pissing off half the country.

Steve's avatar

Whatever internal process at Nike that thought Megan Rapinoe was a great idea needs to be excised like a cancerous tumor. And any CEO / board of directors that decides to wade into the culture wars needs to face a shareholder lawsuit.

Quoth the Raven's avatar

Wholeheartedly agree.

Frank Canzolino's avatar

“Republicans buy sneakers, too.”

- Michael Jeffrey Jordan

badnabor's avatar

Some even buy gold ones.

American Psycho's avatar

Came for the Sweeney pics, stayed for the article.

badnabor's avatar

OTR showing his mastery of the classic bait and switch!

Dadio's avatar

Your hope may be well placed, and Nike + Lululemen + Sydney Sweeney may work out great. But I remember when Sears + Kmart + the Kardashians was survived by only one of the three.

Sinking ships linking up with sinking ships may work out, but I can't think of great precedents off the top of my head.

Nike's brand can support a great, profitable, much smaller company. Current shareholders, I fear, need more than Sydney Sweeney to avoid being screwed.

badnabor's avatar

Someone might want to discuss the proposed participation with Ms. Sweeney first. I've read that she has an above average IQ, so I'm not convinced that she would risk sullying her personal branding by associating with Nike idiots.

Steve E's avatar

Apparel is a terrible business in the age of ecommerce. Anyone with a little cash can set up an online storefront and order rebranded white label products from China. After that, it's all marketing and consumer vibes. No moat, minimal barrier to entry. A sector to avoid like the plague.

Brett Howser's avatar

IMO the solution to Nike’s decline is waaaay simpler than what you propose. Make better cooler fucking shoes. There’s a reason you see people wearing Hoka & ON & adidas. And not Nike.

Greg Brophy's avatar

As soon as I saw the headline, I thought, yeah, hire Sydney Sweeney and all will be well. Should have known you’d go after Lulu as well. Lulu is at a fork, there’s a reasonable chance that they go away, if they don’t find a way to rebrand. Sydney might do that for them, but so many women in America at bat crap crazy. Maybe Lulu should rebrand by hiring Lindsay Clancy!

fab's avatar

There is also a more "global" problem in this industry ; look at ON ($ONON) stock price. A couple of years ago everybody was wearing them, now not so much. I look at people at the fitness and there is no clear trend, everybody is wearing something different. Furthermore, the moneyed baby boomers can't run anymore even with cushioned, air foam shoes. I personally go German, Puma or Adidas, I like their sober design.

ThePossum  🇬🇧's avatar

I've started wearing Mount to Coast, a niche shoe that is unfortunately made in China, and which devalues their whole proposition. But my feet are horrendous so I sacrifice my brand integrity for shoes that feel good on my feet. A typical and aggravating story.

Leskunque Lepew's avatar

I have much experience in consumer goods. The opportunity to turn Nike around should be in any executives eyes.

You are spot on.

Mezzanotte's avatar

"Maybe you don’t find Sweeney attractive, personally. That’s fine." No, that's not fine, that's great. More for me!

Agreed on all 5 concepts.

Richard's avatar

I’d submit that anyone thinking there’s a resurrection in NKE’s future should just walk into their local gym and look at feet and what’s on them. 20 years ago - 80% were wearing Nikes. Now it’s less than 20%. They should write a book on how to destroy a once great brand. And regarding LULU - the cool crowd has moved on to Alo, Vuori, - LULU will never be back to where it was.

ryadeg's avatar

Agree with everything in the article plus the wokeness problem noted by @illinois entrepreneur. But I don't think the abandonment of local retail can be overstated as part of the problem. My town used to have an independent sports retail shop - every season every athlete in town was down there getting new Nike products: cleats, wrestling shoes, baseball pants, socks, mouth guards, shin guards, etc. Or maybe just some Nike running shoes to wear to school. Then Nike intentionally cuts them out (and every other independent retailer in every other small town) to go DTC or Dick's. That retailer - local business that spends their money in the community - has been out of biz for 5 or 6 years now (and struggled for many before that).

The nearest Dick's is 60 miles away and DTC is a pain in the ass with three growing boys. I buy like nine pairs of shoes online every season and then have to repackage and mail back whatever doesn't fit. Plus whatever other gear is needed. I do it because my kids need it, but now that I'm buying online anyway I can buy any brand they want. And yeah, all else being equal I'll nudge the kids to a different brand out of spite. Me? I wear Brookes - available at my local farm & ranch store of all places.

James's avatar

If they really wanted to grab the public’s attention and make a statement that they were divorcing themselves from the woke cancer, the CEO would do what that one tech founder did last month, fire the entire HR department. After he did that, the stock jumped.

The All In guys were discussing this recently. More than one noted that, as longtime Nike users, the quality of their shoes had fallen off dramatically as well.

Definitely like the Sydney Sweeney concept with Lulu Lemon. She pisses off all the right people.

Craig's avatar

One problem with your thesis. Nike is gay.

Frank DiBernardino's avatar

The comment below hits the nail on the head. I stopped buying Nike about 10 years ago because of the woke bullshit! Until they deal with the woke issue effectively, they'll never be able to turn this ship. As you know, culture eats strategy for lunch. Sadly, their woke culture will never change. It's who they are as an organization. Btw, where in Philly are you from?