The problem is falling prices do, in fact, hurt people "in the middle." There are those who have paid their houses off and plan to live there "forever." These folks are fine where they are. There are those who are renting, and can now afford a starter home. Great!
Some of us, however, through divorce or other financial setbacks, still have a mortgage later in life. For us, if our house value drops significantly, our mortgage goes upside down. At 60+ years old, if this happens, you might as well walk away and hand the bank the keys ... your financial situation is never going to get anything but worse.
Which means we're condemning those who have worked their entire lives, being productive members of society--like me--to living in a rental on fixed income until we die.
You blithely throw out how useful it would be the overall society to take everything I've tried to build and give it to others without thinking about me as a person.
This theory assumes falling prices persist forever, or at least for a period of decades, and that the entirety of one's wealth is tied up in the home. It's not about the number of dollars one holds in a deflationary situation, but the purchasing power of those dollars.
People pay for their homes over time. The value of that home dropping over the time they pay for it is financially destructive for those people. It doesn't matter if "all your money is tied up in your house." If you're underwater by $50k on your mortgage, that $50k has to come from someplace--or you hand the bank your keys and walk away.
It doesn't matter if prices fall over a month or a decade ... once you go underwater on your mortgage, unless you have a couple of million in the stock market, you're done.
Saying "prices should fall" might say great--but there are tradeoffs. We are, as always, ignoring the tradeoffs ... and taking money from some people to give it to others. You want a "simple solution." There isn't one. You are still taking money from some people to give it to other people.
The irony here is incredible. You are blaming the author for willful blindness to externalities that you yourself are demonstrating. You are stuck in narrow concepts related to hard numbers and not thinking about how static or slight decline in asset values versus currencies would affect the overall market for these assets.
Banks don't come after your house because you have negative equity - they come after your house for non-payment. If everything else you buy becomes cheaper and cheaper over time, it makes it more likely you can pay your mortgage, rather than less so. It decreases the need for mortgages entirely, in fact. Over time, in your fairly extreme example, the same income buys more and more assets, including housing. You might be upside down on your first home, but own two others outright because of deflation.
So your suggestion is that folks should just pay their mortgage even if they are underwater? Instead of walking away and paying less someplace else, they should just "take one for the team," and pay whatever extra required while forfeiting investing that money someplace else?
What if they lose their jobs and can no longer afford the mortgage--but they are $50k under water now because of deflation? Perhaps you don't live in the real world, but in my world people's lives are not static, and not everyone has a million or two sitting around in the stock market to "play with."
Deflation and inflation are both tradeoffs. They both take money from some people and give it to others. The primary argument here is "inflation takes money from the poor or middle class and give it to the wealthy, while deflation always reverses this process."
The truth--whether you or the author want to accept it or not--is things are messier than this. You can call me names all you want to, but you cannot change reality. Some individual people--and they are real people--who "played by the rules" would be screwed by deflation.
I always have to laugh about so-called smart people who claim we are going to have a deflationary depression or crash. Helicoptor Ben Bernanke was right on this point.
Eventually the currency will collapse. Eventually. But it’s not a good bet on the when. Meanwhile inflation as far as the eye can see.
However, it’s important to consider what we measure against. Assets may go up in value against USD, but not against gold, or a basket of commodities. People can feel like they’re better off and richer when actually they are getting poorer.
Von Mises “crack up boom” idea is sound — and happening in slow motion. Financial assets have been where all the money has been made since roughly 1983.
People start converting their financial assets into real property and commodities. That’s the crack up boom. Prices will be increasing. More money will be “printed” to buy government bonds, and more people will start heading for the exits by selling currency and buying real things.
1/3 of people own their homes "free and clear" (except for the ongoing taxes on unrealized gains that is the property tax, which falls with deflation. 1/3 rent and they benefit from deflation as rents are stable or get lower. 1/3 have mortgages, and based on rank speculation, half of them are working, and could refinance at lower and lower rates. So yes, for some portion of the population, deflation is sub-optimal and has harmful effects. This is a thought exercise, and I posit that inflation is far more insidious on everyone, you included. It's been shown that every fiat currency economy suffers from/encourages inflation because governments need it to pay down debt, and fails over time, to the detriment of everyone.
Deflation benefits savers and harms debtors, which is why the government will never let it happen - the US is a nation kept afloat by massive amounts of debt, from the federal government down to the working poor.
Prices do fall as technology evolves. Look at TV's - 20 years ago a 32" flat screen cost (weighed 80 lbs) cost $1500. Today you can go to Sams Club and get an 85 inch tv for $900. Similar to computers. Falling prices allows more people to afford items that previously they may not have - also it has them replacing their devices on a regular basis - creating more GDP. Think of how often people rotate their cell phones, 40 years ago - you bought one phone and hung it on the wall of your kitchen.
The items that do not fall in price (long term) are hard assets - things that you do not replace or expire. Homes, gold, ect. Those increase in value mostly due to the M2 money supply.
When I teach Junior Achievement - I give the kids the example:
Each of you have $10.
I bring in a large pizza with 10 slices - but there are 20 kids in the class room.
How much are each of you willing to pay me for a slice of pizza.
Then I tell them - well the government magically sent you another $10, so you have $20 now. Same story with one pizza - how much are the willing to pay to get one slice of pizza? Now they are able to pay more for a slice, the pizza did not change - the kids just had more money in their pockets.
Same things with houses - only so many are available, but if we add 40% to the M2 supply in 4 year window.........prices will go up.
I apologize that I am bouncing around. My 2 cents on getting the economy going is: 1. Cut government spending to a min. a balanced budget. Treasury allowed to increase M2 by only 2% a year.
2. Change the tax code to have income tax rates be the same as capital gains - this will spur small business transactions. Sellers want top price with cap gains - but buyers are paying them with money they have to pay 40%+ after tax money (depending on the state you are in).
3. Get the government out of virtually everything - anything the government touches turns to shit. Government officials are not spending THEIR money and make lazy expensive decisions (probably ones that benefit themselves or friends). The private sector can do everything better / more efficient than the government.
The problem is falling prices do, in fact, hurt people "in the middle." There are those who have paid their houses off and plan to live there "forever." These folks are fine where they are. There are those who are renting, and can now afford a starter home. Great!
Some of us, however, through divorce or other financial setbacks, still have a mortgage later in life. For us, if our house value drops significantly, our mortgage goes upside down. At 60+ years old, if this happens, you might as well walk away and hand the bank the keys ... your financial situation is never going to get anything but worse.
Which means we're condemning those who have worked their entire lives, being productive members of society--like me--to living in a rental on fixed income until we die.
You blithely throw out how useful it would be the overall society to take everything I've tried to build and give it to others without thinking about me as a person.
This theory assumes falling prices persist forever, or at least for a period of decades, and that the entirety of one's wealth is tied up in the home. It's not about the number of dollars one holds in a deflationary situation, but the purchasing power of those dollars.
I said none of the above.
People pay for their homes over time. The value of that home dropping over the time they pay for it is financially destructive for those people. It doesn't matter if "all your money is tied up in your house." If you're underwater by $50k on your mortgage, that $50k has to come from someplace--or you hand the bank your keys and walk away.
It doesn't matter if prices fall over a month or a decade ... once you go underwater on your mortgage, unless you have a couple of million in the stock market, you're done.
Saying "prices should fall" might say great--but there are tradeoffs. We are, as always, ignoring the tradeoffs ... and taking money from some people to give it to others. You want a "simple solution." There isn't one. You are still taking money from some people to give it to other people.
The irony here is incredible. You are blaming the author for willful blindness to externalities that you yourself are demonstrating. You are stuck in narrow concepts related to hard numbers and not thinking about how static or slight decline in asset values versus currencies would affect the overall market for these assets.
Banks don't come after your house because you have negative equity - they come after your house for non-payment. If everything else you buy becomes cheaper and cheaper over time, it makes it more likely you can pay your mortgage, rather than less so. It decreases the need for mortgages entirely, in fact. Over time, in your fairly extreme example, the same income buys more and more assets, including housing. You might be upside down on your first home, but own two others outright because of deflation.
So your suggestion is that folks should just pay their mortgage even if they are underwater? Instead of walking away and paying less someplace else, they should just "take one for the team," and pay whatever extra required while forfeiting investing that money someplace else?
What if they lose their jobs and can no longer afford the mortgage--but they are $50k under water now because of deflation? Perhaps you don't live in the real world, but in my world people's lives are not static, and not everyone has a million or two sitting around in the stock market to "play with."
Deflation and inflation are both tradeoffs. They both take money from some people and give it to others. The primary argument here is "inflation takes money from the poor or middle class and give it to the wealthy, while deflation always reverses this process."
The truth--whether you or the author want to accept it or not--is things are messier than this. You can call me names all you want to, but you cannot change reality. Some individual people--and they are real people--who "played by the rules" would be screwed by deflation.
I always have to laugh about so-called smart people who claim we are going to have a deflationary depression or crash. Helicoptor Ben Bernanke was right on this point.
Eventually the currency will collapse. Eventually. But it’s not a good bet on the when. Meanwhile inflation as far as the eye can see.
However, it’s important to consider what we measure against. Assets may go up in value against USD, but not against gold, or a basket of commodities. People can feel like they’re better off and richer when actually they are getting poorer.
Von Mises “crack up boom” idea is sound — and happening in slow motion. Financial assets have been where all the money has been made since roughly 1983.
People start converting their financial assets into real property and commodities. That’s the crack up boom. Prices will be increasing. More money will be “printed” to buy government bonds, and more people will start heading for the exits by selling currency and buying real things.
1/3 of people own their homes "free and clear" (except for the ongoing taxes on unrealized gains that is the property tax, which falls with deflation. 1/3 rent and they benefit from deflation as rents are stable or get lower. 1/3 have mortgages, and based on rank speculation, half of them are working, and could refinance at lower and lower rates. So yes, for some portion of the population, deflation is sub-optimal and has harmful effects. This is a thought exercise, and I posit that inflation is far more insidious on everyone, you included. It's been shown that every fiat currency economy suffers from/encourages inflation because governments need it to pay down debt, and fails over time, to the detriment of everyone.
Deflation benefits savers and harms debtors, which is why the government will never let it happen - the US is a nation kept afloat by massive amounts of debt, from the federal government down to the working poor.
Prices do fall as technology evolves. Look at TV's - 20 years ago a 32" flat screen cost (weighed 80 lbs) cost $1500. Today you can go to Sams Club and get an 85 inch tv for $900. Similar to computers. Falling prices allows more people to afford items that previously they may not have - also it has them replacing their devices on a regular basis - creating more GDP. Think of how often people rotate their cell phones, 40 years ago - you bought one phone and hung it on the wall of your kitchen.
The items that do not fall in price (long term) are hard assets - things that you do not replace or expire. Homes, gold, ect. Those increase in value mostly due to the M2 money supply.
When I teach Junior Achievement - I give the kids the example:
Each of you have $10.
I bring in a large pizza with 10 slices - but there are 20 kids in the class room.
How much are each of you willing to pay me for a slice of pizza.
Then I tell them - well the government magically sent you another $10, so you have $20 now. Same story with one pizza - how much are the willing to pay to get one slice of pizza? Now they are able to pay more for a slice, the pizza did not change - the kids just had more money in their pockets.
Same things with houses - only so many are available, but if we add 40% to the M2 supply in 4 year window.........prices will go up.
I apologize that I am bouncing around. My 2 cents on getting the economy going is: 1. Cut government spending to a min. a balanced budget. Treasury allowed to increase M2 by only 2% a year.
2. Change the tax code to have income tax rates be the same as capital gains - this will spur small business transactions. Sellers want top price with cap gains - but buyers are paying them with money they have to pay 40%+ after tax money (depending on the state you are in).
3. Get the government out of virtually everything - anything the government touches turns to shit. Government officials are not spending THEIR money and make lazy expensive decisions (probably ones that benefit themselves or friends). The private sector can do everything better / more efficient than the government.
Spot on. How much "growth" is enough?