Was going to post that inflation is the tax on the poor. In order to sustain an economy that continues to generate tax revenue the government has adopted a 2% inflation target which is largely passed to the working class. While they do not get a direct bill, they are victims of government just like the top 50%. There is no adopted % increase in minimum wage, yet somehow people are expected to pay their basic bills to survive through a 2% cost increase annually, which compounds. This equates to longer hours and a lower quality of life, something that doesn’t show up in a balance sheet. The only truly fair tax system is an asset tax, where you pay a percentage of whatever assets you own in cash. Not only does this help prevent accumulation of assets and concentration of wealth it encourages liquidity and promotes economic mobility. Those with wealth must continue to work to justify their existence, rather than accumulate assets and borrow on them. This reduces unproductive debt. An owner of a large commercial structure must find renters because not only are their property taxes but there’s federal equity taxes to pay. So it forces the owner to make a deal with prospective tenants rather than preserve asset values by refusing to accept a lower rent/sq fr that allows them to borrow heavily and create debt bubbles. And giant stock portfolios are forced to sell some equities in order to pay taxes, which prevents giant bubbles forming. QTR always talks about the passive bid, well an asset tax would help negate because there are always those that must sell to pay taxes. In fact the plague of any institution is the concept of an employee, or member of a team, that has no incentive to work or contribute and is allowed to be a privileged spectator in an organization. Imagine a football QB that one the Super Bowl last year and now gets to show up on the field and continue to win just because they won last year. The writer that can write a single book and never write again, the teacher that teaches one student and can retire. Society deserves more than those above the tax system.
Warren Buffett conveniently wants higher taxes on higher incomes, while he continues avoiding paying himself a high income. Elizabeth Warren is the same way. She wants a wealth tax but with the minimum threshold conveniently higher than her own wealth.
Forbes' flat tax proposal was to eliminate the income tax and tax all purchases at 10%. Then the rich who consumed more, and more expensive items would pay more of the tax burden.
It's not about taxes. It's about the abuse of taxes by those who collect them. For the taxpayer...is he getting his "fair share" back in the form of government payouts or services? Not unless he is able to steal and grift for his fair share.
"Inflation is a tax on the poor!" is another slick word game. Don't fall for it. Inflation is a tax on EVERYBODY. And those with more disposable income pay proportionately more.
what if you included payroll taxes like SST, medicare, people pay. I know that SST is 50% EE and 50% paid by the business, but my calculations smooth it a bit. like to see what you all think.
There is no fair share when you are paying protection money to an organized crime organization. Failing to pay income taxes under penalty of imprisonment is the same as "Nice store you got here. Shame if something happened to it."
The criminal organization sets the amount it thinks it can extort. It doesn't account to the victims of that extortion how the mob bosses are spending their money. You pay and you shut up.
That's our system of government. If the mob boss politicians decide to launder the extorted tax dollars through a Somali daycare center, a contrived war in Ukraine, or a non-governmental organization wholly-owned by the government, your job is not to ask questions but to make sure you have the requisite amount when Vito and Rocco come to collect next month.
humans aren't genetically equipped to navigate this topic. 50,000 years of anatomically modern humans and 100,000s of years before that with very close genetics -- neanderthal, etc.
So 99.99+% of human wiring is based on small tribal groups where "fairness" was subjective and often defined by obvious group survival needs -- like hunter gatherers each contributing -- or the advantage of the stronger. and you had direct human contact to mediate.
Now? Taxes? Rich? Poor?
These categories don't easily resolve. it's abstraction piled on abstraction.
Not only is disagreement likely but agreement is impossible.
This article avoided what created the insane wealth- public sector debt has quadrupled since 2008.
The $29 trillion in added debt pushed up assets, especially stock portfolios to insane levels.
Deflecting to incomes is a form of dishonesty.
Was going to post that inflation is the tax on the poor. In order to sustain an economy that continues to generate tax revenue the government has adopted a 2% inflation target which is largely passed to the working class. While they do not get a direct bill, they are victims of government just like the top 50%. There is no adopted % increase in minimum wage, yet somehow people are expected to pay their basic bills to survive through a 2% cost increase annually, which compounds. This equates to longer hours and a lower quality of life, something that doesn’t show up in a balance sheet. The only truly fair tax system is an asset tax, where you pay a percentage of whatever assets you own in cash. Not only does this help prevent accumulation of assets and concentration of wealth it encourages liquidity and promotes economic mobility. Those with wealth must continue to work to justify their existence, rather than accumulate assets and borrow on them. This reduces unproductive debt. An owner of a large commercial structure must find renters because not only are their property taxes but there’s federal equity taxes to pay. So it forces the owner to make a deal with prospective tenants rather than preserve asset values by refusing to accept a lower rent/sq fr that allows them to borrow heavily and create debt bubbles. And giant stock portfolios are forced to sell some equities in order to pay taxes, which prevents giant bubbles forming. QTR always talks about the passive bid, well an asset tax would help negate because there are always those that must sell to pay taxes. In fact the plague of any institution is the concept of an employee, or member of a team, that has no incentive to work or contribute and is allowed to be a privileged spectator in an organization. Imagine a football QB that one the Super Bowl last year and now gets to show up on the field and continue to win just because they won last year. The writer that can write a single book and never write again, the teacher that teaches one student and can retire. Society deserves more than those above the tax system.
"Taxes for thee, but not for me"
Warren Buffett conveniently wants higher taxes on higher incomes, while he continues avoiding paying himself a high income. Elizabeth Warren is the same way. She wants a wealth tax but with the minimum threshold conveniently higher than her own wealth.
Forbes' flat tax proposal was to eliminate the income tax and tax all purchases at 10%. Then the rich who consumed more, and more expensive items would pay more of the tax burden.
It's been decades, and I'm still waiting for a socialist to tell me exactly how much the 'fair share' is that they insist rich people are not paying.
It's a spending problem - not a taxation problem.
It's not about taxes. It's about the abuse of taxes by those who collect them. For the taxpayer...is he getting his "fair share" back in the form of government payouts or services? Not unless he is able to steal and grift for his fair share.
"Inflation is a tax on the poor!" is another slick word game. Don't fall for it. Inflation is a tax on EVERYBODY. And those with more disposable income pay proportionately more.
what if you included payroll taxes like SST, medicare, people pay. I know that SST is 50% EE and 50% paid by the business, but my calculations smooth it a bit. like to see what you all think.
There is no fair share when you are paying protection money to an organized crime organization. Failing to pay income taxes under penalty of imprisonment is the same as "Nice store you got here. Shame if something happened to it."
The criminal organization sets the amount it thinks it can extort. It doesn't account to the victims of that extortion how the mob bosses are spending their money. You pay and you shut up.
That's our system of government. If the mob boss politicians decide to launder the extorted tax dollars through a Somali daycare center, a contrived war in Ukraine, or a non-governmental organization wholly-owned by the government, your job is not to ask questions but to make sure you have the requisite amount when Vito and Rocco come to collect next month.
RICO was never meant to be inwardly directed.
You wouldn't need a bloated IRS and Tax Accountants would have to learn how to code.
Is that good or bad? IMHO....it depends how you look at it.
humans aren't genetically equipped to navigate this topic. 50,000 years of anatomically modern humans and 100,000s of years before that with very close genetics -- neanderthal, etc.
So 99.99+% of human wiring is based on small tribal groups where "fairness" was subjective and often defined by obvious group survival needs -- like hunter gatherers each contributing -- or the advantage of the stronger. and you had direct human contact to mediate.
Now? Taxes? Rich? Poor?
These categories don't easily resolve. it's abstraction piled on abstraction.
Not only is disagreement likely but agreement is impossible.
and so we have politics.
Just in time for the midterm campaign blather, here comes idiot Senator Angus I'm-an-Independent No-Kings King rerunning his "Stop CHEATERS Act" IRS class warfare scam that he tried four years ago. It would throw billions at the IRS to audit Those Wicked Rich People. https://www.congress.gov/bill/119th-congress/senate-bill/4298/text?s=1&r=3&hl=STOP+CHEATERS
And we all know the IRS would never let itself become politicized and target some individuals but not others.