19 Comments
User's avatar
Mrs Bucket's avatar

I'd rather be governed by a DICTATORSHIP of serious economists and people who have run companies successfully than a load of barmy Democrat Communists who have only ever lived life large off the public purse and couldn't run a coffee stall....and their ultra low IQ, state 'educated' supporters.

James's avatar

Gonna be an ugly open today.

craazyman's avatar

According to the laws of the market, if the shipwrecked sailor circled by sharks is hungry enough he will eat the sharks. if he doesn't, he is inefficient and deserves to be creatively destroyed.

Right?

Am I now "an economist"?

bowahahahahahahaha

Allan Richard Wasem's avatar

Economics is NOT a science, at least not in the strict sense of mathematically verifiable theorems. It IS the study of ALL interactions between human beings involving exchange of value.

Bill Theobald's avatar

Maybe you can help me understand the math that contributed to the crash of 2008?

Allan Richard Wasem's avatar

It wasn't "math" per se; it was "mania" - a Ponzi "bubble"

Bill Theobald's avatar

So then what was the infamous formula all the Wall Street Brokers were using. I get the ponzi bubble for sure.

Jim Brown's avatar

Sorry, this article does not advance understanding. Any field of study is in fact "about" something, or several things. But no field is about everything and no field is about nothing. Economics is circumscribed. The best definition of economics I know of comes from George Reisman: Economics is the science that studies the production and distribution of wealth within the context of the division of labor.

Leskunque Lepew's avatar

Interesting. But these days...the baby was thrown out with the bath water.

badnabor's avatar

Well done and thanks for sharing. I just went to the source to copy and paste the link for spreading the article. I too read through articles on the Misses Institute site occasionally. I needed this little reminder to encourage myself to "preach" the word. I hope that my kids and grandkids will read this and begin to understand that there are sound reasons against the MMT horseshit espoused by our leaders. Theory is right there in the name.

PrinceOfTheRavens's avatar

Is Economics really a science?

I spent 45 years working as a commercial software engineer, a large portion of that at Microsoft. The title "Engineer" before the days of computers was a professional title that was earned by someone trained in the physical engineering disciplines (Chemical, Electrical, Mechanical, Civil, etc.) To obtain and use that title, an engineer was required to pass a board certified tests pretty much the same as any Medical Doctor.

During my career (now retired) the software engineers always got a load of heat from the professional engineers who scoffed at the idea a computer programmer could be certified to do anything with a high level of confidence. Software Engineers are one of the only highly compensated disciplines that are not subject to professional certification and continuing education. My wife who has been a practicing Pharmacist and my brother in-law an Accountant both are required to take continuing education course to maintain their professional licenses.

Software Engineers are writing the code every other profession uses to take those tests but we alone are not subject to any formal certification / testing regime what-so-every.

We (Coders) are not much different from anyone that has the title Economist in so far as being subject to a formal testing / evaluation process to certify competency in the field.

I find that fascinating.

Perhaps both disciplines will be replaced someday soon by AI and we will then be able to codify what either discipline really means.

Until then both fields at least in some part are as much Art as science.

Thanks for the post Raven.

-Prince of the Ravens

(Reference: Wheel of Time, Matt Cauthon, aka The Gambler)

PS. Ditto on your suggestion to read Mises!

Bill Theobald's avatar

I was in tech since there was a tech and “in my opinion” you’ve been drinking at the certification trough way, WAY too long. Mostly all these certifications were created by folks trying to scam money from people seeking validation for their incompetence. If you blow away all the smoke most founders were HR people trying to herd groups into small piles to cherry pick the best from. No offense but MBA’s, PMP’s are the worst and you might as well throw PHD’s ontop of the pile in an engineering organization. When I was forced into engineering management, against my strongest protests, Id inherit groups with PHD’s that HR dumped on previous management that I ended up having to clean up their mess. Few made it past the annual turkey day culling, nough said.

PrinceOfTheRavens's avatar

Professional Engineering certification is institutional, has nothing to do with any company. Same goes for Medical Doctors, Dentists, Accountants.

- I don't feel scammed that my Doctor had to pass multiple levels of medical boards.

- I don't feel scammed when the bridge, skyscraper, or Hoover dam was designed by Engineers that were certified.

- I don't feel scammed when the Airplane i fly in was designed and built by people that could prove they know what they were doing.

I think perhaps you are referring to certifications that might be issued in the tech industry. There are whole industries that make money for those certifications and you are not wrong in saying perhaps some of that is unnecessary.

Sounds like you worked for some HR folks that lived by petty rules.

Fortunately, i did not share your experience. I worked for Bill Gates, he was not an HR person herding anyone. He had vision and then he shared equity in Microsoft and made thousands of us rich beyond our imagination. The guys that I built Windows with are not and never have been "drinking at any certification trough". Never have, never will.

The point of my post was Economics is not a Profession in the same way other careers are. Careers that are Science based, where laws of physics applies in a non-arbitrary way are considered "hard science".

Economcs is a "social science" because it is not bound by laws of the universe the way (at least as we understand today) all of the hard sciences are. Economics is a study of human behavior which is far more complex and subject to far more uncertainty than things in the hard sciences.

The Mises Institute is a foundation that is committed to a deep study of human action and how economic systems work. As Chris suggested, maybe go visit their website and see how interesting their thinking is:

https://mises.org/

Bill Theobald's avatar

Hmm, I also had an Engineering career in aerospace before tech and worked for a company that designed and manufactured critical flight control systems for aircraft and space vehicles. We were the go to guys for Boeing and Airbus. All of the guys in the design department (of which I was one) were pretty much all Cal. Tech grads but it never came up. We kept score by the amount of intellectual property each of us had, not worthless paper certifications. Matter of fact: when you fly commercial carriers YOUR life is in my hands.

PrinceOfTheRavens's avatar

So it sounds like you were a professional engineer.

To be a professional engineer today, you have to pass an exam. When i started in 1981 i worked in Aerospace and at least 1/2 of the Engineers were not required to have the PE designation. Today it's different. I lived in Seattle and had friends working for Boeing. The engineers at Boing were all PE's.

That's all i was referring to.

Of course, communication is the hardest thing humans do. As a coder i was probably particularly terrible at it.

Cheers & thanks for not killing us!