I agree the job revisions are real problem, but to jump from the revisions are problematic to the economy is weak doesn’t take into account the current state of things.
We’re in a transition where jobs aren’t the clean signal they used to be. A lot of firms aren’t hiring because AI and automation are soaking up work that would’ve meant headcount in prior cycles. That puts structural drag on payroll growth. And if productivity is rising, slower hiring is what you’d expect. So yes, treat the data carefully. But the story may be less collapse and more output, fewer workers.
Yes, but wouldn't that still result in less workers with expendable income? The bottom line of corporations may be improved by the shift to AI production but, it appears to me, it will result in a negative result in consumer numbers.
We have seen poor data collection, analysis and reports from the BLS for years now. Their data collection models need correction and revision, as they are obviously flawed and/or antiquated. I would have thought, that knowing this, the Trump administration would have put personnel in place to correct the issues. Effective fiscal policy can not be implemented based on incorrect and unreliable data. This is a problem both Trump and Bessent need to prioritize.
I know they have been in the past. That’s another issue which needs to be resolved. Economic data MUST be politically neutral. One way to help ensure that is to require revisions to be announced early in the workweek and be given the same media attention as the original analysis. Political manipulation requires darkness to thrive.
As I have mentioned online previously, if we use “legitimate” numbers for such statistics as income, inflation and jobs the US has essentially been in a permanent recession (of varying severity in varying time frames) since the GFC. This fact account for the increasingly desperate financial straits of much of the middle class and for much of the contemporary political and social “angst”.
The fedgov is inversely leveraged in that inflation decreases the debt burden by devaluing the federal debt AND increases the tax burden by ratcheting taxpayers into higher brackets.
And if the government used real GDP instead of nominal GDP numbers we’ve been in recession for decades and that would still using the phony CPI numbers that understate true inflation by probably 50%.
I agree the job revisions are real problem, but to jump from the revisions are problematic to the economy is weak doesn’t take into account the current state of things.
We’re in a transition where jobs aren’t the clean signal they used to be. A lot of firms aren’t hiring because AI and automation are soaking up work that would’ve meant headcount in prior cycles. That puts structural drag on payroll growth. And if productivity is rising, slower hiring is what you’d expect. So yes, treat the data carefully. But the story may be less collapse and more output, fewer workers.
Yes, but wouldn't that still result in less workers with expendable income? The bottom line of corporations may be improved by the shift to AI production but, it appears to me, it will result in a negative result in consumer numbers.
We have seen poor data collection, analysis and reports from the BLS for years now. Their data collection models need correction and revision, as they are obviously flawed and/or antiquated. I would have thought, that knowing this, the Trump administration would have put personnel in place to correct the issues. Effective fiscal policy can not be implemented based on incorrect and unreliable data. This is a problem both Trump and Bessent need to prioritize.
Indeed.. but somehow, in the cobwebs of my mind, I feel these reports are very political.
That should be corrected.
I know they have been in the past. That’s another issue which needs to be resolved. Economic data MUST be politically neutral. One way to help ensure that is to require revisions to be announced early in the workweek and be given the same media attention as the original analysis. Political manipulation requires darkness to thrive.
Waiting for trump to fire director over these numbers. There obviously fake (tic)
As I have mentioned online previously, if we use “legitimate” numbers for such statistics as income, inflation and jobs the US has essentially been in a permanent recession (of varying severity in varying time frames) since the GFC. This fact account for the increasingly desperate financial straits of much of the middle class and for much of the contemporary political and social “angst”.
All the numbers are smoke and mirrors....and the government is leveraged along with their citizens.
Succinctly put, and perfect.
The fedgov is inversely leveraged in that inflation decreases the debt burden by devaluing the federal debt AND increases the tax burden by ratcheting taxpayers into higher brackets.
And if the government used real GDP instead of nominal GDP numbers we’ve been in recession for decades and that would still using the phony CPI numbers that understate true inflation by probably 50%.