28 Comments
User's avatar
Chris DeMuth Jr's avatar

Give me 6 million Norwegians along with $1.25 million of hydrocarbon per Norwegian and I too can cobble together a pretty great country. In fact, it would be hard to screw up a high trust society sitting atop a beautiful geography swimming in $7 trillion of oil and gas.

Graham Seibert's avatar

Well put. Look forward to hearing from you every now and again.

Graham Seibert's avatar

"The political equilibrium keeping Scandinavia afloat was, until recently, a mostly homogenous population on sparsely populated lands eerily willing to subjugate individual preferences and quirks to common, collective rules." Operative words - until recently.

Immigration never topped 30,000 per year until fifteen years ago, when it topped 70,000. The largest immigrant groups have been Poles, Ukrainians, Swedes and Lithuanians, who are physically and temperamentally similar to the natives. It is the non-European immigrants that are hard to assimilate, and destroy the fabric of the welfare society.

It is worth noting that Swedes Alva and Gunnar Myrdahl planted the seeds of the civil rights movement in the United States eight decades ago with "An American Dilemma," making the same naïve assumptions that Joakim Book cites are being made about Norway.

Joanna Miller's avatar

My best friend for about 7 years, until both of us moved, was a Norwegian. We had most of our holidays together; we became very close.

Norwegians are so rigid, in a way that few Americans would find tolerable. They can have generous benefits because almost no one takes advantage. My friend's mom walked to the job fair every day for weeks while she was unemployed, even though she was collecting very generous welfare checks. One of my friend's big hangups in the States was trying to figure out "what is done" about every issue under the sun. I kept telling her, this is America, you do whatever the heck you feel like. It did not compute.

Andrew Marsh's avatar

The Scando way is to have a series of objectives which are parroted until either they become inconveniently impossible, or if they are achieved, are then replaced with the next 'best in world' ambition.

It is literally commune-ism.

Andrew Marsh's avatar

I left Sweden when personal tax got to 40 per cent on SEK 20000 ($2054.40) per month.

That's socialist thinking right there - tax, tax, tax.

Further, as Chris DeMuth Jr points out, the entire population of Norway can fit into Greater London (UK) with 2 houses for everyone and still have room to spare.

In addition the EV capital of the world, Norway, is run on a huge 'sovereign' fund.

The question is... how will Norway cope without oil?

Heads up. Not well.

See how they went bankrupt in the 1950s trying to fund hydro-power from selling trees and granite.

Norway. Sweden, with lots of money.

pretty-red, old guy's avatar

This confirms what I figured all along: The Scandi's developed what works for them; them is an amalgam of similar peoples who are easily led and think along the same lines. It works because they are mostly law abiding and, as Chris DeMuth points out very convenient to be financed by a gusher. Heck, maybe we should get the Alaskans to spread THEIR oil wealth to the other 49 states. . . ha, fat chance.

Just wait until a full complement of Muslims are installed and the hate-invasion, rape gangs, and intifada mix with a few Russian gangs. Of course, these infections wreck all countries, America included.

george's avatar

Liberty appears to have no value nor meaning anymore. It's enshrined in our Constitution. Sad.

Dewey Hildebrand's avatar

To most euros and nordics it’s an illusion. Confiscatory taxation along with high costs eat disposable income.

Look at how stunned the ones that came for the World Cup were.

Leskunque Lepew's avatar

"Its a Republic... if you can keep it.

Ben Franklin

The Radical Individualist's avatar

There is a false equivalence in comparing Norway to the USA. Norway is one country. The USA is fifty countries. We should either compare the USA to the EU (The USA federal government was intended to be the equivalent of what the EU is today), or we should compare Norway to specific states.

I've heard all I need to of the European healthcare system, There is no such system. There is also no European educational system.

craazyman's avatar

"Not everything that counts can be counted, and not everything that can be counted counts." -Einstein

Most economic commentators aren't Einstein. It's always a huck and shuck 3-card monte. Whoa, look at taxes, look at this, look at that!

Freedom! Liberty! Prosperity! If it weren't for taxes everybody would be rich like Donald Trump.

Yeah.

Norway population: 5.6 million

Norway land: Fjords and forests. Isn't that where Santa has his vacation house?

Norway culture: high trust, ethnically monolithic

Norway revenue: Oil!

It's like the Beverly Hillbillies with elves in the backyard.

How can you compare that to the USA with tax rates and numbers.

Jesus. Is this the comic section or what??? 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

Brett Howser's avatar

One benefit of the USA becoming Norway would be how skinny we’d all get. Without GPT drugs. Jeez O Peas food is expensive in Norwegian restaurants!!

Petra Kehr's avatar

Two clarifications to start with: I´m neither a fan of Scandinavian social models nor the US way of leaving behind vast parts of the population.

If you consider that health care is free and I listen to my american friends that 20.000 USD for a family of four is standard.... than the math doesn´t match.

The biggest miscalculations in this article come with the averages. Averages are always wrong. Look up a BLS yearly report and you find out that the 3.000 top earners in the US of A equate the lowest 20% of earners. Read that again. And it´s known that 40 M in US are on food stamps, that over 40% of familys are broke when an unexpected expense of (floating figures range from 400 to ) 2000 USD.

In total, it needs a much more differentiated assessment than this here offers.

Hans's avatar

Overall I really liked reading a level-headed comparison of the systems. What you mention is what I was missing from the article. Rather than dismissing the provided healthcare and services as "shitty" (which can be argued for), the fair comparison would include the cost of similar aervices in the US. Other than hearing anecdotal horror stories of huge hospital bills I can't make that comparison myself.

However from comparing salaries and taxes and expenses and living costs in Sweden and Switzerland, it's far from obvious that one system beats the other for a skilled professional purely when looking at the taxes. Where I live, I pay around 7% in income taxes, no wealth tax but around 10% goes to the private-but-mandatory health insurance, compared to realistically paying ~30% tax for a similar pay grade in Sweden. Housing in Switzerland is way more expensive, as are other general living costs. Higher earners that hit the marginal taxes of 18% in Switzerland vs 46% in Sweden will see a much stronger tilt towards Switzerland. Quality of life is great in either of the countries.

It's also not fair to dismiss the great opportunities and lots of startup and small businesses trying all kinds of things in Sweden. The ceiling and amount of funny-money style venture capital is lower, so you won't see the next SpaceX, but the cost of failure is low with the tight social safety net, spawning lots of little businesses all the time. People do try at lots of ideas.

I've been in the US a few times and while it's a nice place in many ways, I couldn't imagine living there. Plenty of quirks that seem insane to an outsider (and normal to locals). Plus, the current cleptocracy doesn't help.

Petra Kehr's avatar

Hans, thanks for the excellent read of your deep thoughts about this. I usually get into detail much more than this time, but we are a) in the middle of emigration and b) my daily reading volume exceeds 100 pages. Simply exhausted.

Mezzanotte's avatar

Agreed. Median and/or quintiles, etc , are much more valid methods of quant comparisons.

Steve Mudge's avatar

Right, the US system is working so well we have $40 trillion in liabilities. I'd say both countries could learn from each other but I think Norway has more to teach us about fiscal responsibility with whatever system we choose to implement.

Charles Larkin's avatar

Post word war 2 fiscal responsibility is a US failure but so is the failed govt spending aimed at social engineering and policing the world since 1945. The entire non US west used the US defense spending without ever paying for it.

Here is the worldwide defense spending since 1945:

https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/0/03/U.S_-_China_-_Russia%2C_Military_Spending.svg/1280px-U.S_-_China_-_Russia%2C_Military_Spending.svg.png

The non-defense govt spending started in earnest in the mid 1960s along with Johnson’s laudable but naïve great society efforts. Government cannot social engineer anything.

pretty-red, old guy's avatar

Well, they surely could teach us a bit about fraud, political grifters, NGO's and government over reach. . . It would be interesting to know how much of the 40 trillion is represented by this stuff.

DOGE needs to continue in spades.

Thomas Hauber's avatar

And how much of that $40 trillion is due to the US being the world's cop? Or subsidizing Europe and other foreign nations for their defense or trade policies?

Also don't forget that the USD is the reserve currency and a trade imbalance is almost mandatory in that case. Without an expanding USD base, many many economies would flounder.

The Color Of Air's avatar

Nothing in the outside world is ever free.

AP's avatar

Someone has to pay for all the free stuff. The lazy get by off the backs of hard working men and women. I understand taking care of the sick and elderly. Everyone else figure it out. There is no excuse anymore. Ask ChatGPT how to get healthy, get energy and start a business or go get a job. It’s simple!

Charlie Kirk's avatar

Misery loves company. European socialists want Americans to be miserable like them. We can’t be left alone to be the capitalist exception to the socialist/communist rule. We must conform to their miserable model. I will continue to persist in trying to inculcate USA into their communist ways.

Mezzanotte's avatar

To fairly compare taxes in the US to Norway, we have to add in what tax would be needed to cover our deficits. Having low taxes, like we sort of do, but with fat deficits just *defers* the bill.

Leskunque Lepew's avatar

"the cost of everyday items is much higher"

The cost of everyday items ARE much higher.

Remedial English grammar.

See me after class.

El Doco's avatar

"Cost of everyday items is much higher" is correct. The noun being matched by the verb is "cost" which is singular.

"Cost of everyday items are much higher" is what most people would say, but it's wrong.

It's not a good look to be so condescending when the person you're criticizing is right and you're wrong.