18 Comments
User's avatar
Steve S's avatar

Love the oasis analogy.

Bnim85's avatar

Agreed! Loved this line:

Nothing feels particularly real anymore

george's avatar

Investors added a whopping $91.9 billion to US-listed ETFs during the week ending Friday, Sept. 18. Year-to-date inflows now stand at around $1.47 trillion, just shy of the $1.49 trillion that flowed into ETFs during all of 2025, an annual record.

Longtime readers know your thesis here. Makes me wonder if these brokerages aren't in on something here with their guaranteed influx of 401k money.

Leskunque Lepew's avatar

Its getting to a point where I can't tell the difference between a roulette wheel and the stock market.

badnabor's avatar

The difference is that the casinos keep a much closer watch on the players and their possible shenanigans.

Benjamin T Dogg's avatar

The roulette wheel is the one with red.

Brad's avatar

Been this way for a while, no?

Laramie's avatar

Wondering if you caught Michelle Makori's interview of Joel Litman? The guy made me cringe a few times but then, hearing him out, he made some sense.

One of his arguments (that I'm not qualified to judge) is that GAAP rules changes over the past 30 years cause earnings to be understated by 50% today when compared apples-to-apples with the past. Thus, he argues that the true Shiller CAPE ratio is about 20.

Regardless of whether you agree with the guy, I thought it was a good interview/alternative perspective.

Brett Howser's avatar

Or maybe profits are up because prices are up? Investors consequently have a cushier “affordability crisis” than the average punter.

Eric Porter's avatar

If we are in another generational bond bear market (yields rising), it will be rough for stocks. Just adjusting for official inflation, stocks fell by about 2/3 from '65-82. It took until '95 to be ahead. It was a similar 30 years from 1929.

The other thing to keep in mind is the corporate profits are the mirror image of the government deficit. The savings rate is around 0 and foreign inflows / outflows aren't a big factor. It's an accounting identity. At some point the deficit will need to come down and corporate profits will too. That's the E in PE.

Amgmt's avatar

Don't disagree...there will be a reckoning, however there aren't the same dynamics / variables today as back then, super compute, algorithms, instruments etc, collusion and massive control institutions like blackrock vanguard state street and the lot who can exert enormous influence on the market.

How it unwinds and recovers is anyone's guess, this amateurs guess it will be quick and just as quick recovering after wiping out trillions.

Stable coin and bitcoin likely will play the next part in the new ponzi that props the dollar and market up.

If we had a crystal ball we'd all be billionaire's.

Constance Miner's avatar

Great article that fills in some of the reasons for the market rise. Further to the comment on GAAP earnings, one should also pay attention to how much “unrealized gain on investments” are part of various tech company earnings statements. Another very odd earnings development.

rtko's avatar

Has anyone looked into Aschenbrenner—his family, background, and connections? The conspiracy theorist in me can’t help but wonder about someone who was able to bounce as quickly as he did, seemingly in rhythm with what today’s market wants to keep going.

And what about automated trading? Are the individual models actually programmed to discover new opportunities, or are some effectively designed to keep the music playing?

David Buffalo's avatar

I like this and all I did was read the title! (I will read the post this afternoon).

Allan Richard Wasem's avatar

That's the thing about the "digital" world - it can appear "real" up to the point that you actually have to get the replacement auto parts to the mechanic in order to repair your vehicle. That's when you find out the specific part is on "back order" and the actual delivery date is unknown!

Brad's avatar

At this point, it’s clearly the tail wagging the dog as far as options and the market goes. Also, I would love to take a peek at what Musk’s family office is doing.

Brett Howser's avatar

When you are the scapegoat your family doesn’t care how you were treated. They only care about your reaction to the treatment.

Amgmt's avatar

Excellent post and perspective.

Thanks for the work QTR