Im not so sure I bite the cake on that one. Id wager that report and inquiry was heavily massaged with many a cause factor colloquialy explained away in odd, never before heard terms, New-speak and a smattering of "its his fault".
Im not going to launch into a rant for or against. But I will state that there has been nothing but lies, obfuscation and outrite fantasy with the roll out of this infrastructure and technology. Why expect honesty now. Solar can not yet provide the minimum base load power generation a developed nation requires to keep the juice flowing at civilizational minimums. Period.
I don't think any government is in any danger of being called overly rational. Merkel was a friggin' idiot.
Fukushima is nowhere on the statistical charts concerning nuclear. It's like saying that a red Ford Taurus had a fatality, so we must stop producing red Ford Taurus. Even with Chernobyl, the safety record on nuclear is excellent. I'd bet that more people have been killed in sludge pit disasters from coal ash than from nuclear. It just doesn't get the headlines.
Nuclear waste is a NIMBY problem, but not a real problem.
They've been working on fusion for over half a century. I'm not sure we'll see a viable system soon, but when/if we do, it will be a game changer. But there will still be fires from power lines, and I don't think large planes will ever fly on batteries. There is no one solution to everything.
Was not massaged. In order to avoid that the electrical authorities of ES and PT where not in the independent panel with experts from across the EU (and they look bad in the final report)
In Spain, the deterioration of public institutions and state-owned enterprises under the current government is alarming (power outages, broken railroad tracks leading to a fatal accident, unjustified public aid to bankrupt companies during the COVID-19 pandemic, etc.).
A year after the blackout, no one has taken responsibility. The president of Redeia, a state-owned company and the main entity responsible for the blackout as the electricity system operator, has neither resigned nor does she intend to resign. She is busy blaming private companies.
The reality is that there were problems with uncontrolled voltage fluctuations in the days leading up to the blackout, and no measures were taken. There was a desire to set a record for renewable energy use for ideological reasons, even though the grid was not prepared. At the time of the blackout, the gas-fired power plants were offline, as were half of the nuclear plants and the hydroelectric facilities.
On the other hand, we shouldn’t pay too much attention to the statements made by the Spanish Prime Minister. He can completely reverse them the very next day if it serves his personal interests, without further explanation. He has an army of speechwriters—paid for by all of us—to say whatever is convenient at any given moment to mitigate his poor electoral prospects. He has gone three years (the entire legislative term) without presenting a budget to parliament because he would lose the vote.
The disaster was caused by lack of failure effect and modes analysis, with no recognition of funnelling low latency electricity generation into a system engineered around high latency electricity generation. It certainly woke up governments across the other EU27 members, but not the UK Government fools.
Most electricity not generated by photovoltaic panel arrays or sub sonic air flow wind turbines has inertia, and generates in AC at 50 Hz. 'Solar' and 'wind' generally produce AC simulated from DC, and are low inertia systems meaning they can be switched on or off really quickly.
What the Iberian peninsula affair showed was the requirement for not one but two power distribution systems. Running these two types of electricity generation on one network, as this example demonstrated, greatly increases the risk of massive power cuts lasting many hours.
'Solar' can not generate power at night, and 'wind' can not generate power if the air speed is too low or too high - in both cases the turbine uses electricity to hold the turbine when it is 'off'. Further, both can switch on or off faster than the specified inertia, and they require running inertia devices (a complete waste of energy) to meet that obligation.
So, yes, 'renewables' did cause the disaster... one solar panel inverter messed up, triggering a cascade at the very same time as 'renewable' suppliers switched off their devices to prevent supplying 'free' energy to customers. The problem was there in plain sight, but nobody had seen it play out at this scale before. The minority of conventional electricity generators were unable to hold the 50 Hz phase, and the whole system stopped - cutting off millions of consumers.
The expense of a separate distribution system for 'renewables' needs a political discussion, but objectively if we use large scale renewables rather than small units fitted to our homes, then this is required. The politicians are going to need to learn a lot, and quickly.
Aside from being one of the last bastions of socialist woke transgendered islamo-greenism, Spain has a geography (unlike Germany's) that makes solar much closer to viable, although even in Spain it does occasionally rain on the plain. And some extreme right-wing pundits claim that every night it turns dark.
Anyone who reads Gail Tverberg is well aware that RENEWABLES CANNOT KEEP THE LIGHTS ON! If you're deliberately attempting to END CIVILIZATION (as much of the Left is, in fact, trying to do) then by all means go "Green"!
En el articulo se omite el papel de Teresa Ribera antigua ministra de transición energética totalmente en contra de la nuclear en España y cuando llega a Europa a favor, ahora obstenta un alto cargo en la UE .
“So our nation is trimmer, happier and eating healthier than in the '60s? Got it. Seems to me they are fat, depressed, disconnected and writing Manifestos. “
well we didn’t eat all that healthy back then either. What we didn’t have was social media and a 1000 channels on TV. So we played outside, went to the community pools and played team sports all summer. Actually had to socialize face to face with friends instead of over phones. Read books so our attention span was greater then 15 seconds. We weren’t inundated by influencers on tick toc on how we should think or how to feel about ourselves. We were healthier because we were active and more socially involved. I personally blame social media for the the current state of our youth today. The likes of meta and tic tok only care about the ad revenue and engagement not about the kids they try to addict to their platforms.
Well, I wasn’t making a political statement about either party as they both have their ideologies, particularly on the extreme left and right.
My comments were directed specifically at RFK Junior, whose preconceived beliefs about vaccines is not based on science. He cherry pics studies he thinks support his anti vaccine beliefs yet it’s obvious he doesn’t actually read the studies which in many cases support vaccine use. He also tries to suppress any studies that contradict what he believes. He’s not a medical train professional or a scientist. He’s a lawyer.
There is no doubt that the added complexity from connecting “renewables” makes network management far more difficult and reduces resilience - which is antithetical for an electricity grid. Nukes would provide far larger and more reliable energy than random multitudes of solar panels. But western societies now produce Influencers and Socialists, while eastern societies produce engineers and strategists. Whose standard of living and prospects look better?
Vindicated?
Im not so sure I bite the cake on that one. Id wager that report and inquiry was heavily massaged with many a cause factor colloquialy explained away in odd, never before heard terms, New-speak and a smattering of "its his fault".
Im not going to launch into a rant for or against. But I will state that there has been nothing but lies, obfuscation and outrite fantasy with the roll out of this infrastructure and technology. Why expect honesty now. Solar can not yet provide the minimum base load power generation a developed nation requires to keep the juice flowing at civilizational minimums. Period.
I don't think any government is in any danger of being called overly rational. Merkel was a friggin' idiot.
Fukushima is nowhere on the statistical charts concerning nuclear. It's like saying that a red Ford Taurus had a fatality, so we must stop producing red Ford Taurus. Even with Chernobyl, the safety record on nuclear is excellent. I'd bet that more people have been killed in sludge pit disasters from coal ash than from nuclear. It just doesn't get the headlines.
Nuclear waste is a NIMBY problem, but not a real problem.
They've been working on fusion for over half a century. I'm not sure we'll see a viable system soon, but when/if we do, it will be a game changer. But there will still be fires from power lines, and I don't think large planes will ever fly on batteries. There is no one solution to everything.
Was not massaged. In order to avoid that the electrical authorities of ES and PT where not in the independent panel with experts from across the EU (and they look bad in the final report)
I'm sure "glow in the dark" sushi is a hot item in Japan.
In Spain, the deterioration of public institutions and state-owned enterprises under the current government is alarming (power outages, broken railroad tracks leading to a fatal accident, unjustified public aid to bankrupt companies during the COVID-19 pandemic, etc.).
A year after the blackout, no one has taken responsibility. The president of Redeia, a state-owned company and the main entity responsible for the blackout as the electricity system operator, has neither resigned nor does she intend to resign. She is busy blaming private companies.
The reality is that there were problems with uncontrolled voltage fluctuations in the days leading up to the blackout, and no measures were taken. There was a desire to set a record for renewable energy use for ideological reasons, even though the grid was not prepared. At the time of the blackout, the gas-fired power plants were offline, as were half of the nuclear plants and the hydroelectric facilities.
On the other hand, we shouldn’t pay too much attention to the statements made by the Spanish Prime Minister. He can completely reverse them the very next day if it serves his personal interests, without further explanation. He has an army of speechwriters—paid for by all of us—to say whatever is convenient at any given moment to mitigate his poor electoral prospects. He has gone three years (the entire legislative term) without presenting a budget to parliament because he would lose the vote.
The disaster was caused by lack of failure effect and modes analysis, with no recognition of funnelling low latency electricity generation into a system engineered around high latency electricity generation. It certainly woke up governments across the other EU27 members, but not the UK Government fools.
WEF colony.
This article is not accurate.
Most electricity not generated by photovoltaic panel arrays or sub sonic air flow wind turbines has inertia, and generates in AC at 50 Hz. 'Solar' and 'wind' generally produce AC simulated from DC, and are low inertia systems meaning they can be switched on or off really quickly.
What the Iberian peninsula affair showed was the requirement for not one but two power distribution systems. Running these two types of electricity generation on one network, as this example demonstrated, greatly increases the risk of massive power cuts lasting many hours.
'Solar' can not generate power at night, and 'wind' can not generate power if the air speed is too low or too high - in both cases the turbine uses electricity to hold the turbine when it is 'off'. Further, both can switch on or off faster than the specified inertia, and they require running inertia devices (a complete waste of energy) to meet that obligation.
So, yes, 'renewables' did cause the disaster... one solar panel inverter messed up, triggering a cascade at the very same time as 'renewable' suppliers switched off their devices to prevent supplying 'free' energy to customers. The problem was there in plain sight, but nobody had seen it play out at this scale before. The minority of conventional electricity generators were unable to hold the 50 Hz phase, and the whole system stopped - cutting off millions of consumers.
The expense of a separate distribution system for 'renewables' needs a political discussion, but objectively if we use large scale renewables rather than small units fitted to our homes, then this is required. The politicians are going to need to learn a lot, and quickly.
Aside from being one of the last bastions of socialist woke transgendered islamo-greenism, Spain has a geography (unlike Germany's) that makes solar much closer to viable, although even in Spain it does occasionally rain on the plain. And some extreme right-wing pundits claim that every night it turns dark.
Anyone who reads Gail Tverberg is well aware that RENEWABLES CANNOT KEEP THE LIGHTS ON! If you're deliberately attempting to END CIVILIZATION (as much of the Left is, in fact, trying to do) then by all means go "Green"!
They've certainly managed to drive themselves insane!
En el articulo se omite el papel de Teresa Ribera antigua ministra de transición energética totalmente en contra de la nuclear en España y cuando llega a Europa a favor, ahora obstenta un alto cargo en la UE .
Incongruencias.
Another great read. Thanks for sharing!
Some re-assembly required.
*Batteries not included.
330 million Euros for what? Fusion? Fugouddahere. Go away. These people are delusional.
Here's what the EU will actually do:
1) Continue to chest thump about how their latest bureaucratic initiative is going to solve things.
2) Burn increasing amounts of brown lignite to make up for baseload demand and silence anybody who notices.
3) Use electricity rationing as method of political coercion.
The EU system is long past sclerotic, all they can do is political theatre and spoils.
Ideology over logic and science, sounds like RFK jr approach.
“So our nation is trimmer, happier and eating healthier than in the '60s? Got it. Seems to me they are fat, depressed, disconnected and writing Manifestos. “
well we didn’t eat all that healthy back then either. What we didn’t have was social media and a 1000 channels on TV. So we played outside, went to the community pools and played team sports all summer. Actually had to socialize face to face with friends instead of over phones. Read books so our attention span was greater then 15 seconds. We weren’t inundated by influencers on tick toc on how we should think or how to feel about ourselves. We were healthier because we were active and more socially involved. I personally blame social media for the the current state of our youth today. The likes of meta and tic tok only care about the ad revenue and engagement not about the kids they try to addict to their platforms.
rant over.
Well, I wasn’t making a political statement about either party as they both have their ideologies, particularly on the extreme left and right.
My comments were directed specifically at RFK Junior, whose preconceived beliefs about vaccines is not based on science. He cherry pics studies he thinks support his anti vaccine beliefs yet it’s obvious he doesn’t actually read the studies which in many cases support vaccine use. He also tries to suppress any studies that contradict what he believes. He’s not a medical train professional or a scientist. He’s a lawyer.
According to https://www.google.com/url?sa=i&source=web&rct=j&url=https://www.nytimes.com/2025/01/17/health/rfk-jr-covid-vaccines.html&ved=2ahUKEwi24OrRrYyUAxUHtokEHfDdNNoQy_kOegQIARAB&opi=89978449&cd&psig=AOvVaw0O8O5a0SNlhpgW5-NttzgD&ust=1777321758560000, Robert F. Kennedy Jr., while overseeing health agencies, moved to delay or suppress scientific reports confirming the efficacy of COVID-19 vaccines. Key actions included stalling a CDC study on vaccine effectiveness and restricting data, which sparked significant conflict with career health officials
https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/rfk-jr-demanded-study-on-vaccines-and-aluminum-be-retracted-the-journal-said/
There is no doubt that the added complexity from connecting “renewables” makes network management far more difficult and reduces resilience - which is antithetical for an electricity grid. Nukes would provide far larger and more reliable energy than random multitudes of solar panels. But western societies now produce Influencers and Socialists, while eastern societies produce engineers and strategists. Whose standard of living and prospects look better?
Spain is a lovely country blessed with excellent wine and olive oil, that's it.
....and weather, and coastline, and architecture, and....
True