32 Comments
User's avatar
Dr Pete's avatar

Remember that “health insurance” is not insurance but pre-payment for healthcare. When “Insurance” pays for minor illness or physicals it’s the equivalent of using your auto insurance to pay for oil changes. Obamacare outlawed high deductible catastrophic insurance that was actually very affordable.

Terry's avatar

Absolutely agree! This year's expenses are next year's premiums. Health insurance should be like car insurance. Let the free market dictate healthcare costs and allow consumers to be consumers and shop for quality and price instead of having insurance making patients indifferent to the actual cost of health care. The only insurance should be for catastrophic needs. Regular "maintenance" would be akin to getting your oil changed and paid out of pocket as opposed to being run through insurance.

Mike's avatar

Never mind my own fiasco.

13 yo needed a root canal.

Dentist doesn't do them.

Needed "endodontist referral"

only 1 could be sourced, with United Healthcares help. Locating providers alone impossible. Rep was super helpful...but it took hours and tag team resources (time/energy) between spouse and I.

Said endodontist....30 miles away and appointment over 1 month out...at wich time he evaluates need for root canal and submits to UNH. When UNH decides to approve...another appointment needs to be made another month out.

Almost 2.5 months burned cumulative.

All the while pumping a 13 year old w pain killers and managing a super pissed wife.

This was an un adulterated fiasco for absolutely no other reason except to feed an absolutely out of control blob of beuracracy at every level.

Randy's avatar

Sorry, but your 13 y/o did not need a root canal. Root canals can ruin a person’s entire life until they’re removed. Please read “Judas Dentistry” and reconsider. You can buy the paperback from Amazon, etc., or download the PDF for free from the author’s Substack site (he considers the information so important that he has made it freely available to everyone, with no paywall):

https://robertyoho.substack.com/p/314-freaking-finally-judas-dentistry

The Radical Individualist's avatar

"But price caps don’t lower costs — they reduce supply. " Oh, yes!

When bureaucracies are in charge, you get bigger, better bureaucracies, at the expense of healthcare, or education, or retirement, or housing, or..

Dean Whiting's avatar

Old enough to remember when Obamacare was going to fix all this. Now we have all of the costs that entailed plus cries to keep giving free healthcare to anyone who crosses the border.

As other commenters note, the money is running out soon.

Terry's avatar

And don't forget that if you didn't have insurance you were fined/taxed but they want to give away healthcare to illegals.

Allan Richard Wasem's avatar

We are fast approaching a point where the current system will cease to function at all. As with so many other govt. programs - that which cannot continue - won't

Terry's avatar

There are those that have long theorized this is by design. Overburden the system so that it fails and then go to single payer.

Allan Richard Wasem's avatar

Entirely possible that was an element of the overall Great Reset (delusional) scheme to murder 80 - 90% of the World's population (for the benefit of the .01 - .001% "elite".

Terry's avatar

There are some crazy, screwed mentally ill people in this world who I have no doubt would like to do this.

Allan Richard Wasem's avatar

They're called "Psychopaths" and they run the WEF, most "Western" Governments, the big Universities, the influential Colleges, almost all media companies, etc., etc., etc.

Soujourner's avatar

Replace the word 'health' with 'medical' and the article gets a tad closer to the truth.

It's not about health. That is the scary part.

george's avatar

You're expected to hand money over to people that don't know the difference between a boy and a girl and never heard of the Spanish Flu.

Leskunque Lepew's avatar

But.......but if we empower patients. ....what will happen to Safe & Effective Big Pharma?

Steve Mudge's avatar

While those ideas may help, a simple across the board Medicare for All is more efficient. Less paper pushers than with even what was proposed. Medicare can control costs (the idea that the free market should control costs in the first place is why we have Medicare! Insurers used to regularly drop people around age 60 when they needed it most). No more complicated bureaucratic programs like Obamacare, Medicaid, Workman's Comp or Auto Insurance medical portions, not to mention literally thousands of other Federal, state, and county level subsidy programs. Employers are relieved of the burden of large HR depts and providing health insurance. Wait times? We already have them with the private insurance industry and complicated bureaucratic combination!

Will this get enacted currently, resulting in lower incomes and profits for the industry (but with perhaps a concomitant reduction in clinical testing costs and timing with A.I.?) Doubtful. But if the massacre that QTR sees coming to pass this kind of system might just look pretty darn good.

PutativePathogen's avatar

I prefer to choose, and pay, my doctor without anyone's "approval". I prefer for doctors to be innovative, curious, and discerning. I prefer that kind of incentive, believing that it will help attract and retain the highest quality healthcare professionals.

There is no governmental solution that hasn't grown hair and diminished quality of service, to my knowledge.

Steve Mudge's avatar

That's why Medicare is better, IMO (as opposed to many private insurance plans)---you can choose any doctor you want. I might also point out, and this comes from from my cousin, an orthopedic surgeon, private insurers are really putting the screws to doctors, so much so that he has changed his mind about opposing Medicare for All in the last decade.

Terry's avatar

And that is why we should get rid of private insurance for routine medical care. The only insurance should be for catastrophic medical expenses.

PutativePathogen's avatar

Well, yes. The "screws" are to corral us in one direction, where everyone is trapped in one system. Do you believe that, 15 years down the road, it won't be corrupted? I do not.

Randy's avatar

There is no “Medicare for all.” What Democrats propose is “VA for all” a.k.a socialized medicine. See my reply to you above.

Randy's avatar

Whst you’re describing is “Concierge Service.” Some doctors don’t take insurance. They bill the patient for their services, like most other service providers from the lawn guy to plumbers. Usually, a patient contracts with a doctor or a doctors’ group to provide service as-needed, for a certain amount per month. Regular monthly income from patients allows the doctor to spend more time with each patient (no 10-minute billing blocks) and provide more personalized service. Blood work is typically included, but imaging studies or surgical procedures are extra (you use your catastrophic coverage insurance for those). It’s expensive, though, which is why it’s mostly for rich folks.

PutativePathogen's avatar

We're certainly not rich - but the $3-4,000 per year for two adults is preferable to the $10,800 we're currently paying in premiums. Add on co-pays and any "not covered" services, and it's a no-brainer. To be sure, we're healthy, not on any prescriptions, and therefore it'd work for us. (We've been on a wait-list for a concierge doc for 2 years now.)

There are many not so fortunate. But that's an illustration of why "one-size fits all" isn't a good option. And Medicaid for All would have no price caps (tax cap). It's also proven to lead to rationed "care".

Randy's avatar

“Medicare for all” is a Democrat scam. Medicare is run through private insurance companies, using private doctors and hospitals. That’s not what Democrats propose. They want medical care run by government bureaucrats, like socialized medicine in other countries. We already have a template for this: the Veterans Administration. The VA is medical care run by the government, using government-employed doctors in government-owned hospitals. The myriad of problems and SNAFUs in the VA system are legendary, just as in socialized medical care in Canada and Great Britain.

But frankly, you folks have already proven that you should not be allowed anywhere our healthcare system. Obamacare was the Democrats’ fever dream for medical care. It mandated stupid, extreme coverage, like gender mutilation surgery for children and pregnancy care for men. Such wacko mandates are the exact reason no one can afford Obamacare unless it’s subsidized by taxpayers. If you want socialized medicine, Steve, move to Canada and die on a waiting list.

Steve Mudge's avatar

Government employed healthcare is not at all what I proposed here and I have not read that Democrats support that (though I'm sure there are lots of versions floating around). I mean, duh, England showed us how to avoid that decades ago. Meanwhile, private insurer system wait times are as bad here as anywhere so I don't know what you're holding out for.

Steve Mudge's avatar

I have been on Medicare for two years now and I have no complaints, generally speaking. And uh, "wait times in Canada" is a political talking point.

Randy's avatar

I’m old enough to be on real Medicare. My insurer is Humana, and I would not go to a government-run healthcare facility. Excessive “private insurer wait times” is a political talking point. My insurer is private; I can call my PCP today and see him tomorrow. The “secret” is to have an established relationship with your doctor(s). People who bounce in and out of Emergency Rooms seeking medical care will never have a relationship with a doctor, so they will never be a priority or have consistent care. “Government-run healthcare for all” will only make that worse, because they will likely never see the same doctor twice in a row, like in the VA.

Andrew Simpson's avatar

Good luck. Corporate money talks in the U.S. And people whose employers are paying that $24K in annual premiums don't care. They're not paying it.

Tankster's avatar

And one more thing. The AMA has a stranglehold on licensed medical schools. Mises Institute has written about this. Throttle physician numbers, shortages occur. Let supply and demand apply.

Tankster's avatar

As a country we are morbidly obese, don't exercise, food-like substances (h/t Michael Pollan) receive subsidies, e.g., corn feeds cows, sugarcane is suppressed by that lobby, hence high fructose corn syrup (neither are "good" but everything in moderation). TV has endless commercials for fast food, kids don't have gym class or outside exercise. We have a disease care system, not a health care system.

dk's avatar

I’m not a fan of “socialized healthcare”, but…

When I was in Argentina they had a two tier healthcare system. The public system and supplemental care. The public system would “patch you up”, the private system would take care of you.

Example: if you broke your arm, the public system would cast it, then push you out the door immediately afterwards. The private system would ensure if your arm needed pins, or if staying in the hospital would lead to better healing, or if you needed PT, that would happen.

This country could use such a system. Public patients don’t get frills, but they do get some help. No sex-changes, no organ transplants, no extraordinary treatment. Just not bankrupting you for breaking your arm.

Rond's avatar

These are "owned problems". Suggesting they can be fixed gets you escorted out of the party. and maybe buried in a ditch if it's a real good idea.