43 Comments
User's avatar
Quoth the Raven's avatar

Let me just add to this that I tip ALL THE TIME for great service. When bathroom attendants keep shit clean and hand me towels, it's an instant $5 AT LEAST. On the NJ Turnpike the other day an Indian guy who had to be at LEAST 70 pumped my gas, washed all my windows, cleaned the leaves out from my windshield and fixed one of my wipers. That's a $20 without even thinking about it. There's nothing wrong with tipping for exceptional service, when it's not begged for. It's when the service sucks and the expectation is 30% that's insulting. eom

Blue Sky's avatar

That’s great. I never know what I should do in NJ when it comes to tipping for a standard gas-up with no extras. Most locals tell me not to tip…but I’m not from NJ, just transiting 6 times a month.

Quoth the Raven's avatar

I almost always tip $5 when someone is nice and fills my tank, and does the windows.

Quoth the Raven's avatar

One of my Twitter followers writes:

"It’s an intelligence test. Transaction total is on the pay screen, then the machine asks me, “Are you an idiot?” I click no. Helpful I guess?"

https://x.com/wrightmylife/status/1961796619822829900

Walker's avatar

I'm a Boomer so I really know what it used to be like and I miss it. It actually made one feel good to recognize excellence. Not surprisingly, I am in total agreement with you POV!

dcross0's avatar

Amen, brother. I have never had a problem giving a generous tip when I got great service but like you hate it when the machine makes it hard to give a fair tip when the service hasn't been that great. Try to bring cash too for the tip so the management can't get their hands on it.

Chris's avatar

Just came back from Europe and couldn’t agree more. Not only do the servers let you enjoy your meal and conversation instead of checking in on your table every three minutes. But only one out out of over a dozen sit down places asked for a tip, and the options were 10/12/15%

Rick's avatar

Best part of waking up is NOT Folgers in my cup… It’s a hilarious QTR rant!

Quoth the Raven's avatar

I bought Folgers for the first time during Covid, fearing I was going to run out of coffee. When it became clear there would be no shortages, I made myself drink it, since I bought it and paid for it. It tasted like kerosene someone drained from an old power washer that hadn't been used in 20 years.

Dena's avatar

Given the crap in our food, it probably was.

Steve S's avatar

Reminds me of the following:

Woman: You hate me, you think I'm a pig!

Man: Yes, but I like pigs.

Paul Julian's avatar

TIP is an acronym - To Insure Promptness, and was given ahead of an experience, not after. It has turned into a game to see how poorly someone can treat you and still get you to shell out more money for a so-so or even shitty experience.

ronetc's avatar

Well, yeah, "people got fed up with nickel-and-diming airlines" . . . but what did said people actually DO about it? Near as I can tell, more airlines are actually starting to nickel and dime flyers (looking at you SW).

Dewey Hildebrand's avatar

It’s a peer pressure guilt trip. I’ll tip like a happy drunk for good service and a smile. Entitlement attitude, act like you’re doing me a favor and slow service? GTFO. I tended bar for a bit way back and smiled at your recollections. Hell, I had one barf all over my bar once.

Steponbugs's avatar

100% in agreement…I’m so f-cking over the tip racket, like others have stated, I generously tip servers who enhance my experience or fix shit that goes sideways (always in cash). But it seems like half the time, it’s a matter of “I didn’t spit on your food, I deserve 20%”. Bullshit.

And the whole program of upselling, nudges, add-ons or upgrades everywhere makes me want to lash out irrationally. Like, I know, I actually remember looking at the f-cking shoes on your website 10 minutes ago. I don’t need an email reminder. I didn’t buy them then, and I’m sure as hell not going to buy them now, since you seem to want to browbeat me into doing so.

And don’t get me started on what AI is going to turn all of this into…

Andrew P's avatar

Some of the worst offenders here are wineries. If they take cash, though (some don't), they usually won't ever show you that tip screen, although some places (like 12 Ridges) tell you up front that a 20% service fee is added to all purchases for on-site consumption.

Kira Mason's avatar

100% agree that tip culture is broken and also kind of reminiscent of mutual aid, but I'd argue that in many cases, tipping culture DOES help workers. You know I worked in the service industry for a decade, and me and many of my coworkers would pull in close to six figures a year. Closer to $150k at high-price, high-volume restaurants like steakhouses. We worked our asses off for it. Harder, I'd argue, than many similarly compensated professions, but there's no chance employers would be able to match that. Not even close. So to change tip culture will mean a leveling of a playing field for service workers... the lowest paid will make more, and the highest paid will make much much less. There's an argument to be made that this would be a good thing, but that's another question.

Kira Mason's avatar

But fuck outta here for 20% on a coffee, come on...

Quoth the Raven's avatar

I knew you'd see it my way :)

Jason Nelson's avatar

I remember a year or two a girl that worked at a restaurant called Texas Roadhouse made a tiktok about how much money she was making as a waitress because people were massively over tipping due to these screens. She was making, on average, something like $50 to $60 an hour just in tips. People who went to this restaurant saw this video and started commenting that they didn't realize how much they were over tipping and they were going to stop doing it. More comments came from other servers, telling this girl to delete the video as it started to affect their tips at other restaurants. I hate this tech bro culture we have created. It's only going to get worse and the 60 million baby boomers are going to be fleeced by all of the AI scams coming out and the response is going to be "oh,well, tough grandpa". Nothing being done to stop the onslaught of these things.

Marty Weil's avatar

Someone had to say it!

Burnt taco's avatar

Those automated tips are likely not going to the staff without a cut for the house and the credit card company. Tip in cash. And make sure you tip explicitly for the kitchen also. They get shit pay and no tips!!

DLB's avatar

And it's getting worse. At many establishments, in particular the sport stadiums or arenas, you can't dodge this action by using cash, they won't take it. So every time you order a beer, you have to pull out the credit card and that little machine tells you what the price is and how much do you want to tip. I hit the "no tip" every time now, and I don't feel any worse for doing so.

It's also prudent to check you tab everywhere. I have seen a few places where the tip is added to the bill already. If there is no sign in the place or the menu doesn't tell me a tip is mandatory, I tell them to take it off before offering my credit card to pay. So look around as you walk to your table and be sure to read the front of the menu as well as the back in addition to the item you order.