8 Comments
User's avatar
The Radical Individualist's avatar

Yes, high tariffs tend to be short-lived. That will be the case with Trump's tariffs. There is no one who doesn't know that Trump did this to get other nations to sit at the table and hash things out. One thing I've figured out about Trump: while other policy makers take meetings and engage in the process, Trump aims straight for results. To paraphrase a FedEx commercial, Trump moves at the speed of business.

And we should all pause and contemplate the graph of federal gov't revenue as a percentage of GDP. I like the left side of that graph a lot better.

RU's avatar

Excellent points.

It's almost as if high tariffs are meant to be short-lived...Trump has said exactly this. It's now up to the other countries to drop their tariffs on the US. If we want free markets, we somehow need to get others to drop the barriers they've constructed. One learning from this episode for many, it seems, is that free markets do not and have never existed.

And - looking at that graph - it's almost as if the introduction of personal income tax, social safety net tax, and corporate taxes as means of funding the government somehow increased the size and role of the government. The left side is much more appealing.

Most importantly, I have yet to hear even one alternative solution to the real problems caused by the previous status quo - basically the right side of that graph. Until the people arguing vehemently (often incoherently) against tariffs start offering some solutions that don't amount to "more of the same," there is no reason to take anything these people say seriously.

RICH's avatar

Interesting. What was the trade imbalance, National debt, and personal debt during that time? Let's see. 2024 trade imbalance was just over $900b. Our combined national and personal debt is $52t. Our global communications are instant. DJT is using tariffs as a tool to adjust the aforementioned results of previous Washington management skills. What is your solution?`

cfrog's avatar

Nice write-up of previous high protective tariff implementation. There is definitely a lesson there.

The implementation of the Tariffs, with all the bad math is unfortunate. I get the intent and the '4d chess' argument. Regardless, this is a bad way to pursue the goals outlined in the Executive Order. It is sugar policy; tastes great in the moment, low on long term nutrition, and bad in large amounts.

The lack of consistency with National Security Policy is worse (Q: how do you get Japan, South Korea, Vietnam, Australia, the Philippines, and China to make common cause? A: You don't, unless you are making a strategic mistake.).

Allan Richard Wasem's avatar

Perhaps the shortest-lived in history, except for China?

Stay buckled up and watch your leverage - it's going to be a very bumpy ride.

Randy's avatar

“claims that high protective tariffs were a mainstay of past American policy are wrong, as they only existed for four brief periods (1828–32, 1842–46, 1890–94, and 1930–34). The harmful economic effects resulted in landslide wins for the opposition party after each of those enactments (which, as it turns out, was the Democratic Party in all four instances).”

And now we’re in countdown mode for landslide wins for Democrats in 2026 snd 2028. Republicans never learn.

W Gary Johnson's avatar

You left out the 1860 Morrell tariff, which prompted 7 states to secede from union.

Dean Whiting's avatar

Short lived indeed. Look at the market this afternoon.