I still remember when the housing boom took off in the early 2000s in Southern California. Interest rates were dropping and the real estate agents were telling buyers they could afford higher priced houses with the lower mortgage rates. Ergo, the upward doom loop of housing prices which eventually infected the entire country as well as many industrialized nations. Now people are stuck in their houses and the government/Federal Reserve are stuck with $40 trillion in debt.
Part of the problem is the cost of building a new home has jumped up dramatically in recent years- due to more and more red tape, an aging trades force, restrictive zoning, and buyers' entitlement for more bells and whistles.
I suppose it could be close to 10% on a low priced build (e.g., 400k). Maybe, if you count solar (in CA). On a more typical mid level build, say ~$700k, less. On a $3 mil build, much less. Most of those reg costs aren't in the form of fees, it's stuff that actually adds value to the building -- efficiency, comfort, longer life, etc.
The insulation requirement in my area jumped up the cost of insulating a house 300% to 400% a couple of years ago. It made houses more airtight which requires mechanical air intake. The code now requires air blower tests for houses to test for air tightness. The insulation upgrade has caused the need for foam insulation, either spray foam or foam sheathing boards- both ignite in a fire.
The cost savings for heating and cooling houses will never recoup the upgrade in the insulation costs. Math is hard for the idealogues.
The Scratch, I have to disagree. Insulation is a small slice of the building budget. The building envelope efficiency cost and fuels for heating/cooling cost are tradeoffs.
In the mountains of Colorado upgraded efficiency in the building envelope does pay for itself in around 8-12 years, generally depending on inside the home temperature preferences. As fuel prices increase this payoff will decrease. Foam does ignite in a fire, as do wooden studs. Not that big of a deal.
Mc Mansion sized houses do drive up both sqft and cost per sqft due to engineering complexity.
Material costs have doubled or tripled in many cases; concrete, shingles, lumber, and the cost of the trades all factor in.
Location neutral workers are destroying Mountain town ecosystems as engineers are outbidding lifties and waiters for the housing stock.
Fundamentally, nobody cares what they pay for a house, they just want to have a monthly payment they can manage.
Ever tightening building codes rank up there with death and taxes; that's why one of my investment themes is energy efficient construction products.
My house meets the 2015 IECC insulation requirements and if I were to rebuild it to meet the 2021 IECC insulation requirement it would take about 30 years at 0% to recoup the extra costs.
Over the past 10 years I've prepared a couple hundred ResCheck (software developed by US Dept of Energy) calculations for clients. Regarding my own house, switching my house data from 2015 to 2021 would reduce my energy loss by 13%. My electric bill (geothermal) excluding appliances, well, etc. is about $2500 per year (NYC suburbs). Thus the 2021 insulation envelope would save me about $325 per year. If I were to rebuild, the extra costs for insulation, mechanical system for introducing fresh air, blower test, etc. of the 2021 requirements versus 2015 would be about $10,000.
The math doesn't work.
Our house, that meets the 2015 IECC requirement, is so much more efficient than a house built in the 1980s or 1990s which is so much more efficient than a house built in 1960. The upgrades were very beneficial and necessary.
The point though, going forward, it's diminishing returns.
The 2024 IECC, becomes really ridiculous. They've snuck in sneaky what they call "enhancements". You have to choose 10 enhancements from a list of 46. One of the enhancements is to meet a window requirement of U=0.25. For most window manufacturers, that means a triple pane window.
This all goes back to my original comment that new housing costs are going through the roof. People calling the shots have no sense of reality.
An example of the bells and whistles is larger interior spaces, which is the main reason for higher lumber costs that builders cite.
Lumber, at least dimensional lumber, is cheaper today on an inflation basis than the 1980s and 1990s, but lumber packages are much higher. The entitlement for bigger rooms and fewer columns has switched lumber packages from dimensional to engineered lumber. An engineered floor system can cost 4 times as much as a conventional dimensional lumber floor system.
I’ve been in the home building biz for 30+ years. Since before, during and after the GFC, I said you can’t socially engineer the housing market and artificially suppress interest rates. You will create a generation of buyers who will sit it out and wait for that low, low rate. The first house we bought in 1988 came with an adjustable rate that started at 9%! By the time we sold a few years later it was about 11%. Years prior my brother had a pan assumable home loan at 17%.
Great analysis Chris. I live in a nice neighborhood in a southern city near the Gulf coast about to get pummeled by a Isaias. Homes used to sell in a week or two, with no home often available. Boy, how things have changed. There are now 3 homes on the market, 2 of which have been for sale for months. All the homes are similar in quality, however, the prices differ substantially. Good friends of ours want $172 a sqft and a while ago offered a $1500 price drop 😊. The other two homes are priced at $128 and $122 sq ft with the lowest priced house just issuing a $20K price cut after just two weeks. The home with the large price cut is being sold by the Probate Court so it will be very interesting to see what price the court will accept vs regular people selling their homes. All kinds of people are anchored on the old prices and can't stomach the idea that their homes are worst considerably less than they think. So....they sit with a sign in their yard and, in one case above, pay for two mortgages.
Considering that we are well into the current Fourth Turning I would guess that the "housing" situation overall will continue to exhibit massive amounts of "unaffordability" for all the reasons stated and other, novel, ones as well. If it's necessary to move for eventual "survival" then bite the bullet and do it soonest - as cost-effectively as possibly - but get it done. Particularly true re getting the Hell out of "Blue" cities east of the Mississippi and on the "left" Coast.
Low interest rates and the resulting inflation are the issue today, not just with home prices but with everything. In the late 1980's and into the 90's, an average new home could be built by budgeting about $30 @ square foot for direct costs, which included materials and labor. It didn't include the land, insurance, or other costs associated with building a new home. Today, inflation has pushed those direct costs to over $100 @ square foot. This includes the wages paid to those who produce the materials, and to those who supply the labor to build the homes. Those who supply this labor are not going to be able to take wage cuts that would bring the price of the home down very much. The other costs are not likely to change much either, such as the cost of the land the home sits on. Then other costs like insurance and taxes are not going to come down, and the fees and taxes the state demands from the one who builds the home are not going to come down either. The builder's profit margin is based on total costs. If that margin is too low, the builder, whether a local, small company, or one of the large, national builders, will soon find themselves "going out of business".
More than likely home sales will "cool" for the next several years until inflation brings wages up to meet existing home prices.
One solution that will probably happen in the near future is that new homes will be much smaller than they are now, and local governments will allow density to increase so that more homes can be built on the same amount of land. Both will reduce the average price of a new home.
You are right about what mortgage rates have been on average for the last 50 years, which is in the 7 to 7.5% range. This supports your view that long term mortgages mirror the US Treasury 10 year Bill, which has a yield of 6% on average for the last 50 years. Prior to Covid and the response by the federal government, long term mortgage rates generally would run about 1 to 1.5% higher than the 10 year yield. That yield may come down, and with-it, long-term mortgage rates may come down, but to bring the down the average price of a new home today, more than likely will require smaller homes to be built on smaller lots.
The "high" prices are the result of the collusion between commercialized residential industry and local/state governments. Locals have been awash in ever increasing revenues while claiming they haven't raised taxes as the industry inflates pricing year over year.
The point that mortgage rates track the 10-year rather than the fed funds rate is the key one here; with a 5.3% auction yield, Fed cuts alone will not unlock existing-home turnover until prices adjust.
My first mortgage was in 1985 for 30 years and was adjustable in a 6-9% range. But I got a steal on the house at $42K or about $15K below market. There is far too much uncertainty in the world today to justify a 30 year mortgage. Look around..the US is a tinderbox and all those trillions of dollars are becoming more worthless by the day. Risks are rising demonically.
And broke ass immigrants, sneaking across a border, aren’t packing sacks of cash to buy a median price home at $400k, so they aren’t driving up prices.
High mortgage rates are going to “fix” some of these high prices (are already). The other “fix” will be AI tech job losses.
They’ll never come down much as those high prices are needed to justify the “investments” holding up pension funds and retirement accounts.
I still remember when the housing boom took off in the early 2000s in Southern California. Interest rates were dropping and the real estate agents were telling buyers they could afford higher priced houses with the lower mortgage rates. Ergo, the upward doom loop of housing prices which eventually infected the entire country as well as many industrialized nations. Now people are stuck in their houses and the government/Federal Reserve are stuck with $40 trillion in debt.
……and rising……..quickly.
Part of the problem is the cost of building a new home has jumped up dramatically in recent years- due to more and more red tape, an aging trades force, restrictive zoning, and buyers' entitlement for more bells and whistles.
I read recently that government regs add about 30% to the cost of building a new home.
I suppose it could be close to 10% on a low priced build (e.g., 400k). Maybe, if you count solar (in CA). On a more typical mid level build, say ~$700k, less. On a $3 mil build, much less. Most of those reg costs aren't in the form of fees, it's stuff that actually adds value to the building -- efficiency, comfort, longer life, etc.
There's a lot of truth to that.
The insulation requirement in my area jumped up the cost of insulating a house 300% to 400% a couple of years ago. It made houses more airtight which requires mechanical air intake. The code now requires air blower tests for houses to test for air tightness. The insulation upgrade has caused the need for foam insulation, either spray foam or foam sheathing boards- both ignite in a fire.
The cost savings for heating and cooling houses will never recoup the upgrade in the insulation costs. Math is hard for the idealogues.
The Scratch, I have to disagree. Insulation is a small slice of the building budget. The building envelope efficiency cost and fuels for heating/cooling cost are tradeoffs.
In the mountains of Colorado upgraded efficiency in the building envelope does pay for itself in around 8-12 years, generally depending on inside the home temperature preferences. As fuel prices increase this payoff will decrease. Foam does ignite in a fire, as do wooden studs. Not that big of a deal.
Mc Mansion sized houses do drive up both sqft and cost per sqft due to engineering complexity.
Material costs have doubled or tripled in many cases; concrete, shingles, lumber, and the cost of the trades all factor in.
Location neutral workers are destroying Mountain town ecosystems as engineers are outbidding lifties and waiters for the housing stock.
Fundamentally, nobody cares what they pay for a house, they just want to have a monthly payment they can manage.
Ever tightening building codes rank up there with death and taxes; that's why one of my investment themes is energy efficient construction products.
My house meets the 2015 IECC insulation requirements and if I were to rebuild it to meet the 2021 IECC insulation requirement it would take about 30 years at 0% to recoup the extra costs.
Over the past 10 years I've prepared a couple hundred ResCheck (software developed by US Dept of Energy) calculations for clients. Regarding my own house, switching my house data from 2015 to 2021 would reduce my energy loss by 13%. My electric bill (geothermal) excluding appliances, well, etc. is about $2500 per year (NYC suburbs). Thus the 2021 insulation envelope would save me about $325 per year. If I were to rebuild, the extra costs for insulation, mechanical system for introducing fresh air, blower test, etc. of the 2021 requirements versus 2015 would be about $10,000.
The math doesn't work.
Our house, that meets the 2015 IECC requirement, is so much more efficient than a house built in the 1980s or 1990s which is so much more efficient than a house built in 1960. The upgrades were very beneficial and necessary.
The point though, going forward, it's diminishing returns.
The 2024 IECC, becomes really ridiculous. They've snuck in sneaky what they call "enhancements". You have to choose 10 enhancements from a list of 46. One of the enhancements is to meet a window requirement of U=0.25. For most window manufacturers, that means a triple pane window.
This all goes back to my original comment that new housing costs are going through the roof. People calling the shots have no sense of reality.
An example of the bells and whistles is larger interior spaces, which is the main reason for higher lumber costs that builders cite.
Lumber, at least dimensional lumber, is cheaper today on an inflation basis than the 1980s and 1990s, but lumber packages are much higher. The entitlement for bigger rooms and fewer columns has switched lumber packages from dimensional to engineered lumber. An engineered floor system can cost 4 times as much as a conventional dimensional lumber floor system.
I’ve been in the home building biz for 30+ years. Since before, during and after the GFC, I said you can’t socially engineer the housing market and artificially suppress interest rates. You will create a generation of buyers who will sit it out and wait for that low, low rate. The first house we bought in 1988 came with an adjustable rate that started at 9%! By the time we sold a few years later it was about 11%. Years prior my brother had a pan assumable home loan at 17%.
Great analysis Chris. I live in a nice neighborhood in a southern city near the Gulf coast about to get pummeled by a Isaias. Homes used to sell in a week or two, with no home often available. Boy, how things have changed. There are now 3 homes on the market, 2 of which have been for sale for months. All the homes are similar in quality, however, the prices differ substantially. Good friends of ours want $172 a sqft and a while ago offered a $1500 price drop 😊. The other two homes are priced at $128 and $122 sq ft with the lowest priced house just issuing a $20K price cut after just two weeks. The home with the large price cut is being sold by the Probate Court so it will be very interesting to see what price the court will accept vs regular people selling their homes. All kinds of people are anchored on the old prices and can't stomach the idea that their homes are worst considerably less than they think. So....they sit with a sign in their yard and, in one case above, pay for two mortgages.
Considering that we are well into the current Fourth Turning I would guess that the "housing" situation overall will continue to exhibit massive amounts of "unaffordability" for all the reasons stated and other, novel, ones as well. If it's necessary to move for eventual "survival" then bite the bullet and do it soonest - as cost-effectively as possibly - but get it done. Particularly true re getting the Hell out of "Blue" cities east of the Mississippi and on the "left" Coast.
Low interest rates and the resulting inflation are the issue today, not just with home prices but with everything. In the late 1980's and into the 90's, an average new home could be built by budgeting about $30 @ square foot for direct costs, which included materials and labor. It didn't include the land, insurance, or other costs associated with building a new home. Today, inflation has pushed those direct costs to over $100 @ square foot. This includes the wages paid to those who produce the materials, and to those who supply the labor to build the homes. Those who supply this labor are not going to be able to take wage cuts that would bring the price of the home down very much. The other costs are not likely to change much either, such as the cost of the land the home sits on. Then other costs like insurance and taxes are not going to come down, and the fees and taxes the state demands from the one who builds the home are not going to come down either. The builder's profit margin is based on total costs. If that margin is too low, the builder, whether a local, small company, or one of the large, national builders, will soon find themselves "going out of business".
More than likely home sales will "cool" for the next several years until inflation brings wages up to meet existing home prices.
One solution that will probably happen in the near future is that new homes will be much smaller than they are now, and local governments will allow density to increase so that more homes can be built on the same amount of land. Both will reduce the average price of a new home.
You are right about what mortgage rates have been on average for the last 50 years, which is in the 7 to 7.5% range. This supports your view that long term mortgages mirror the US Treasury 10 year Bill, which has a yield of 6% on average for the last 50 years. Prior to Covid and the response by the federal government, long term mortgage rates generally would run about 1 to 1.5% higher than the 10 year yield. That yield may come down, and with-it, long-term mortgage rates may come down, but to bring the down the average price of a new home today, more than likely will require smaller homes to be built on smaller lots.
The "high" prices are the result of the collusion between commercialized residential industry and local/state governments. Locals have been awash in ever increasing revenues while claiming they haven't raised taxes as the industry inflates pricing year over year.
The point that mortgage rates track the 10-year rather than the fed funds rate is the key one here; with a 5.3% auction yield, Fed cuts alone will not unlock existing-home turnover until prices adjust.
My first mortgage was in 1985 for 30 years and was adjustable in a 6-9% range. But I got a steal on the house at $42K or about $15K below market. There is far too much uncertainty in the world today to justify a 30 year mortgage. Look around..the US is a tinderbox and all those trillions of dollars are becoming more worthless by the day. Risks are rising demonically.
Thank you.
And broke ass immigrants, sneaking across a border, aren’t packing sacks of cash to buy a median price home at $400k, so they aren’t driving up prices.