16 Comments
User's avatar
Marty Weil's avatar

The U.S. housing market’s deep freeze in 2025 isn’t just about high mortgage rates or cautious buyers—it’s also about the houses themselves. Beneath the macroeconomics lies a structural decay few analysts address: much of America’s housing stock is either falling apart or poorly built. Buyers see it.

Older homes, which make up the bulk of inventory, now represent deferred maintenance on a national scale. Roofs, HVAC systems, plumbing, and foundations have not been maintained or upgraded. A Harvard Joint Center study found that the nation now spends more maintaining old homes than building new ones, signaling that much of the existing stock is simply being kept alive. For many owners, the next sale would mean confronting tens of thousands in repairs they’ve delayed for years.

New construction isn’t the safe alternative it once was. Builders often cut corners, relying on inexperienced labor and low-grade materials. The results are showing early—leaks, cracks, warped floors, and failing systems within just a few years of completion. Warranty disputes and defect litigation are quietly rising, feeding buyer distrust.

Leskunque Lepew's avatar

Well said and quite true.

Ted's avatar

Excellent contribution to the article's premise. TY.

The Radical Individualist's avatar

Great post.

Does anyone have thoughts concerning the shake-out of homomers as part of the 2008 collapse? Tens of thousands of previously owner-occupied homes were bought up and are now rentals owned by real estate trusts. That's got to be a big damper on home ownership.

Allan Richard Wasem's avatar

Good comments on the additional factor of corporate ownership of a large portion of the housing stock. As insurance and maintenance cost rise, real estate taxes increase and the pool of renters becomes increasingly "problematic", the profitability of the properties will inevitably decrease to the point that the institutional owners will start to sell in order to "redeploy" the capital more profitably. Should in fact be happening about now and I expect we will start seeing the results soon.

Petty Rage Machine's avatar

They wrote an article about the housing problem in America and listed off 7 reasons, revolving around supply, but left off the main problem: corporate/institutional ownership of single family homes and rentals. The numbers are staggering. Feel free to read the grok breakdown and add to it if you like. My question is why wouldn’t they add that to the list of supply problems? Did I miss it somewhere?

TLDR: 43% in 2001 to 54% today.

https://grok.com/share/bGVnYWN5LWNvcHk%3D_7eb4f493-2090-4610-8d03-31eea6e6e0bb

sadie's avatar

Per a recent Realtor article, only 1% of single family homes are owned by the big guys. And Grok states that as well. 95% is owned by people who own 1-50 homes. Not sure I believe all these stats. There are thousands of rentals in the Phoenix area and the management firms do not at all care about calling you back. After Obama let his buddies buy up foreclosures en masse, he then had the govt backstop any months of vacancy because they complained that it was onerous work to be a big time landlord. Not sure what the answer is but it definitely involves transparency and oversight.... and maybe limiting homes owned?

Petty Rage Machine's avatar

This is defined in my very link. If you limit it only to Blackstone then yes. Expand it to any entity that is in the business of buying houses and renting or flipping and NOT putting on market for fair value to actual humans and their families and it’s what my link stated. Like I said it all in the link.

Tankster's avatar

The knock on effect reduced hiring, and layoffs mean that no matter what your mortgages rate is, if you can't pay it, you have to sell. No more kicking the can down the road. Melody Wright reports that Q4 had Q 1&2 of next will see a ahit ton of mortgages foreclosures. I represent condo and HOA assassinations in FL and our collection business is exploding. Unlike say 2008-12, but the odd thing is that few mtg foreclosures are happening. Yet.

Bill Theobald's avatar

OK, well here’s the latest podcast from Adam Taggart and Nick Gerli on the housing market, have been following him for years on Adam Taggart’s / Thoughtful Money. Nick is the go to guy for this type information.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BmWuf_8RLU4

sadie's avatar

If they would do away with the gains tax on homes that would help people who have a lot of equity to be willing to sell.

george's avatar

I blame collusion between the Government and Realty in order to consistently raise appraisals which raised revenues without "increasing taxes." Zillow is in competition with my town to see who can estimate the highest.

Brittany's avatar

I’m glad someone is admitting that the housing market is slow, hardly anyone will admit it. I think there is more to it though. Private equity buying up huge swaths of residential real estate, along with flipping houses and polishing a turd to charge astronomical prices for, is the root cause of the increase in house prices. Notice I didn’t say value. The lack of supply is further artificial due to people making poor financial decisions and paying $100s of thousands of dollars more than a house is worth. They can’t sell that house because it wasn’t worth the price they paid then, and it’s certainly not worth the price now. The government needs to do one of the few jobs they legitimately have in the marketplace and kick the growing monopoly of private equity out of residential real estate. While they are at it, kick out foreign buyers of real estate as well, not just making Chinese entities register. That means nothing. If no one has heard of it, there are people from Asia buying property in ridiculous places like Kansas (how do they know it even exists?!). It all works out for coordinated rent and price control when there are so many entities hoovering up houses. It operates like the large corporations during the pandemic. Specifically, they can let the severely overpriced house for sale or rent stay on the market for months while they are making money in a different area. A normal person will react to the market and lower the price.

Moody Millennial's avatar

The government wrote the law after the 2008 financial crisis that allowed private equity to buy residential real estate. Big government and big business work together.

sadie's avatar

And then said the govt would backstop any months of vacancy because they complained it was so hard to manage large portfolios. Obama signed that right before he left office. Which is why I found it impossible to get a response from anyone on empty homes... they always said it was being spruced up for next tenant... for months and months. No incentive to act fast.