17 Comments
User's avatar
Mark1's avatar

That wave of returning money is what interests me. As long as foreigners can buy oil and respectable weapons with the dollar, it’ll probably stay on top ( not ahead) of the currency devaluation “race to the bottom”.

If it doesn’t, what then? Massive inflation as those dollars look for something to buy? Would the foreign holders buy stocks? It’s certainly the easiest way to dump cash (and a way to lose it, too). Or would they buy farm land and real property? Hmmm, already happening. An old timer once told me that deficit spending was ultimately selling off parts of the country to foreign interests. Gold is just one signal.

Attila Rebak's avatar

Interesting historical analogy and thought-provoking scenario.

However, I tend to think the deeper driver behind gold is much simpler and more structural.

Economic theory and history both suggest that goods whose supply grows slowly tend to preserve their value relative to those whose supply expands more rapidly.

Gold mining increases the above-ground stock by roughly 1.5 per cent per year, while fiat currency supply has typically grown much faster over long periods.

This helps explain why currencies also tend to depreciate relative to one another, depending on their respective rates of supply growth. The euro has weakened against the Swiss franc, and the Swiss franc, in turn, has weakened relative to gold.

Governments can finance spending through three main channels: taxation, debt issuance, and money creation. The last option is often the most politically convenient and the least immediately visible to voters. Throughout history, many governments have relied on this source of financing, frequently with negative consequences for long-term currency stability.

From this perspective, the key question may not be whether gold can reach 10,000 or even much higher levels. The more relevant question is under what conditions, and over what time horizon, such a repricing could occur.

Don C.'s avatar

This is a VERY well written article, it's laid out perfectly. Personally, I am a big fan of the ancient Rome analogies as I believe people in general and Americans in particular do not study history nearly enough and fail to see the clear parallels. Nice job James!

rtko's avatar

Maybe we should return to the practice of having our political leaders be on the front line of the military conflicts they promote as they did in Roman times. Then after the first one gets captured, we’ll see far fewer wars and there will be a speedy turnover of war mongers.

Don C.'s avatar

1000% agree. Look how Bush Sr volunteered & flew airplanes in WW 2 but by the time Vietnam came around he got George Jr into the USAF reserve - this is very telling!

Mike's avatar

As a layman I've been saying for over a decade...there are 4 pillars to our dollar. Marines. Army. Air force. Navy. This past few days of dollar strength kind of jive.

badnabor's avatar

It's almost as if Mr. Hickman read my thoughts. Our current trajectory is unnerving. However, it's important to be clear about the dollar pricing of gold. I think to some, it appears to be a value generating asset. It isn't. It is a very good value preserving asset. If your 1 ounce gold coin that is selling for $5,000 dollars today is bringing $10,000 at a future date, congratulations! You just made $5,000 of even more worthless fiat dollars. I know that most of OTR's readers fully understand this, but right or wrong, I think it needs to be pointed out from time to time, as newer investors enter the markets. Don't get me wrong, I happen to be a big believer in gold as an asset, and in short term trading scenarios it will, at times, be profitable. I just think that it bears repeating, it's main upside is that it remains a reliable, long term store of value.

TA's avatar

until it gets confiscated - see AOC, Mandami and ilk…

Walker's avatar

I've been in the sector since 1996. I think that number could be low. The metals and miners have been ridding itself of hot money and weak hands of late. This is a very good thing.

DLB's avatar

The US Dollar's status as a reserve currency and as the primary currency to conduct trade has been diminishing for the last decade or so. The current crisis with Iran has another consequence which is not an accident. That is to punish those who have chosen to move away from the Dollar and to warn others who are thinking about it. The economy in America is dependent on foreigners continued use of the Dollar as a reserve currency and to conduct trade

george's avatar

The input costs for miners is going to increase. Should I stay or should I go now?

Bob Nixon's avatar

If I go, there will be trouble

And if I stay, it will be double

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Mar 12
Comment deleted
george's avatar

Russia and China have a proxy too.

"We will do everything, together with other peace-loving members of the international community, to contribute to creating an atmosphere that will make this operation completely impossible" - Sergei Lavrov

"A war with the West is inevitable. The West is preparing for it at an accelerated pace. Iran is already at war. It didn't start it, but it's fighting back desperately. If Iran falls, we'll have almost no allies left. Until it falls, it's a combat unit. By entering the war now, Russia will take the initiative. If we wait for Iran to fall, there will be no one left around to open a second front. They'll attack us from all sides." - Alexander Dugin

If people knew of John Halford Mackinder, they would see we are in the final stretch of the Geopolitical Pivot of History.

barnabus's avatar

Unless Trump is prepared to trade Iran for Novorossiya, Armenia and the Baltics. Maybe getting Greenland as part of the package. We'll see.

Russia doesn't need Iran with missiles and nukes. All it needs is Iran with a modern land army and control of the Strait of Hormus. Dugin is an Anti-Zionist fool. Without October 7th, Republicans would have scuttled US support for Ukraine by the end of 2023.

Thomas Hauber's avatar

I expect that in the next few years the US Treasury will start offering T-Bills with a gold clause in them. Not many at first, but a few, and at a substantially lesser interest rate.

barnabus's avatar

Even with current prices (inflation etc), Gold could go to 30k$ if trade and credits would need to rely on Gold instead of fiat money. That's simply due to the fact that while one can do fractional banking with Gold too, the fractional lending would be 2-3:1 rather than the 10:1 possible with fiat money. Because Gold is much less forgiving than fiat.

Allan Richard Wasem's avatar

The US has already LOST military "dominance". We are no longer capable of putting substantial numbers of "boots on the ground" in a reasonably short time frame - say 2 - 4 weeks. A few Brigades perhaps but not 3 -4 Divisions and all of their support and logistical backup.

And as every war starting with WWII has proved, you can't "bomb" a country into "regime change".