For decades, federal regulators controlled airline prices and routes, limiting competition and keeping fares high. The Airline Deregulation Act changed everything.
I recall being an impossibly young and ignorant "airline industry analyst" at a Wall Street research firm in the early 1980s trying to figure out what the fukk to put in my "research" reports. But I did try to learn. It's true -- there were lots of economic analyses back then that said airline deregulation was impossible given the marginal revenue/marginal cost-driven economic structure of airline seats. It would be a boom-bust of discounting below cost for market share, resulting bankruptcy and then sharply higher fares. Total chaos for air travellers.
There were "serious economists" who said it would never work. That was an early lesson in the value of economic analysis.
Well, it did -- as this article accurately points out.
But let's be historically clear on the genesis of the regulate-it mindset that is now too easy to criticize. Let's not forget the 1929 crash and Great Depression. The "economic planners" of that era didn't have a 40-year bull market and repeated successful bailouts of financial capitalism's mistakes to show the obvious benefit of a light touch. They had the opposite -- a complete economic disaster as living history. Hindsight is always 2020.
Recalling a long-ago episode of The McLaughlin Group. John was griping about airports and airlines post-deregulation. A panelist said "John, you're just unhappy now that you have to share the skies with the commoners."
Going in the opposite direction, running a high regulation fever, is the looming "bipartisan" "Taxpayer Assistance and Service" bill being promoted by Sens. Wyden and Crapo. Hidden in there is a huge expansion of an IRS sub-bureaucracy to regulate tax preparers. Big Tax loves it - makes it harder for local independents to compete. It'll just raise costs for consumers with only marginal quality benefits. It does nothing about the mega-errors on the near-50% of tax returns now self-prepared by citizens with pricey Big Tax cloud software (and yes, I have stories). The real answer involves tax simplification but Wyden and Crapo haven't figured that out in their combined 77 years in D.C. Neither have the geniuses in NY, CA, OR who have already enacted stricter regulation at the state level.
Flying may have been more expensive decades ago but it was certainly more comfortable than the cattle cars-no frills flights we have today. The increased size of planes and ability to stuff more people on a flight might also have put downward pricing pressure. For a three or four hour flight it's no big deal to be more cramped but an economy seat on a long flight is a chore.
Nope, this is incorrect. The *price of a comfortable (business/first) has fallen dramatically as well. The “comfy” economy seat of 50 years ago in screaming loud cabins with smoking was as, or more expensive than a business class seat these days. So folks who yearn for yesteryear when the seats were comfortable we’re paying more than a business class seat today. So buy a business class seat.
Very interesting. I remember when air travel was deregulated, and knew that flights became affordable. I did not know the story behind deregulation. Thank you.
Yes…but allowing anyone the ability to fly can also leave you with a plane load of fools
So What! The fools are everywhere. At last in an airplane THEY'RE NOT DRIVING!!!
At least driving they’re not in my car. In my airplane I’m stuck with the fools
As I said - they're ubiquitous! Headphones are extremely useful!
I recall being an impossibly young and ignorant "airline industry analyst" at a Wall Street research firm in the early 1980s trying to figure out what the fukk to put in my "research" reports. But I did try to learn. It's true -- there were lots of economic analyses back then that said airline deregulation was impossible given the marginal revenue/marginal cost-driven economic structure of airline seats. It would be a boom-bust of discounting below cost for market share, resulting bankruptcy and then sharply higher fares. Total chaos for air travellers.
There were "serious economists" who said it would never work. That was an early lesson in the value of economic analysis.
Well, it did -- as this article accurately points out.
But let's be historically clear on the genesis of the regulate-it mindset that is now too easy to criticize. Let's not forget the 1929 crash and Great Depression. The "economic planners" of that era didn't have a 40-year bull market and repeated successful bailouts of financial capitalism's mistakes to show the obvious benefit of a light touch. They had the opposite -- a complete economic disaster as living history. Hindsight is always 2020.
Recalling a long-ago episode of The McLaughlin Group. John was griping about airports and airlines post-deregulation. A panelist said "John, you're just unhappy now that you have to share the skies with the commoners."
Going in the opposite direction, running a high regulation fever, is the looming "bipartisan" "Taxpayer Assistance and Service" bill being promoted by Sens. Wyden and Crapo. Hidden in there is a huge expansion of an IRS sub-bureaucracy to regulate tax preparers. Big Tax loves it - makes it harder for local independents to compete. It'll just raise costs for consumers with only marginal quality benefits. It does nothing about the mega-errors on the near-50% of tax returns now self-prepared by citizens with pricey Big Tax cloud software (and yes, I have stories). The real answer involves tax simplification but Wyden and Crapo haven't figured that out in their combined 77 years in D.C. Neither have the geniuses in NY, CA, OR who have already enacted stricter regulation at the state level.
Flying may have been more expensive decades ago but it was certainly more comfortable than the cattle cars-no frills flights we have today. The increased size of planes and ability to stuff more people on a flight might also have put downward pricing pressure. For a three or four hour flight it's no big deal to be more cramped but an economy seat on a long flight is a chore.
Nope, this is incorrect. The *price of a comfortable (business/first) has fallen dramatically as well. The “comfy” economy seat of 50 years ago in screaming loud cabins with smoking was as, or more expensive than a business class seat these days. So folks who yearn for yesteryear when the seats were comfortable we’re paying more than a business class seat today. So buy a business class seat.
*price as measured by average man’s wages.
IMHO....its a little too deregulated.
Spectacular example of a (mostly) free market in operation!
It came at the expense of service. They'd pack you into tubes if it reduced cost a buck. Kids these days have no clue how it used to be.
GREAT all around article!
Very interesting. I remember when air travel was deregulated, and knew that flights became affordable. I did not know the story behind deregulation. Thank you.