This Explainer will cover where the government takes revenue from, how it spends those dollars, how it prioritizes spending, and what’s projected for the future.
If they have been investing a portion 50% of Social Security and Medicare funds into the broad stock market - there would be zero issues. The issues that we had trillions sitting in treasuries yield next to nothing for 20 years.
Still think if DOGE goes through and cuts all waste / fraud. They will be able to cut at least a Trillion.
Getting to a balanced budget would be ideal - soon. From there you shrink the government and let the private sector operate in areas where the government wastes spending. I look at education - you let the private sector take over and probably will do it for 50 cents on the dollar that the public schools do today. You take teachers out of the state pension programs - that strengthen local budgets.
Yeah, waste/fraud is the #1 issue and neither was mentioned in the article at all. Thanks to DOGE's work, none of our government's spending has any legitimacy for the majority of the country, which should be a featured point in an article like this. The mandate for change is there.
We know every one of the buckets of spending outlined in the article is filled with fraud, and likely half of the budget is wasted in one way or another. The famous $200 toilet seats and such, illegitimate wars, and massive contracts handed out to political allies at NGOs. Those are the core issues when discussing the government's spending. We can't pretend like it's all legitimate and all of it goes to where it says it goes in the chart the author shared.
To your point - US Public education is basically the laughing stock of the world. We spend more than just about anyone per student and get results on par with developing nations. Baltimore recently had a year where not a single student across all of their schools could read, write, and do math at proficiency. Not even one kid! How is that humane or compassionate, as the left likes to frame these things?
Of course, in medicine we spend more per patient than anyone in the world and have the lowest - and declining - life spans of any of the developed nations, worse even than some developing nations.
So, it's time to try new things. Anything to do with either of those fields should be sunset at the national level and turned over to private co's and local gov'ts to run. Meaning: DoE, Medicaid, Medicare, CDC, NIH.
Soc Sec also has to go, as it's a basic Ponzi scheme, meaning unless your society has constant, high levels of population growth it's going to run out of funds.
Cutting all waste/fraud in "discretionary" and "defense" (warfare state) current spending MAY realistically yield "savings" up to 20% or $300 - $400 billion $$ or so. The combination of current "non-discretionary" spending and interest payments (also basically non-discretionary) total more than current income tax collections. So without either substantial cuts to non-discretionary spending and/or huge tax increases there is no possibility of balancing the fedgov budget. All assuming no "recession" or even a "slowdown" in the economy at any time in the future - an unlikely prospect.
I appreciate the fact-based and well-explained layout of where the money comes from and goes. Note that where it goes is right back to "Americans". Maybe not the same ones it's taken from! (An understatement, to be sure, and source of a lot of political heat and pushback).
But it goes right back into "the economy" -- healthcare, social security, defense, even net interest goes to bond investors, about half or more are Americans. This is somebody's revenue or income. That money gets spent and spurs economic development.
Those are facts too, not opinions. Does the money that flows right back into the economy create seeds of future prosperity? Is there a multiplier effect that kicks in? If there were no government sector, and everything mapped here was considered private free enterprise, where people purchased the same services (OK, the argument is they wouldn't, it's confiscation of taxes and services forced down their throat, that's reasonable I agree), how would the phenomenon be interpreted -- would "the debt" still be a problem?"
These are reasonable questions, but often they don't get answered or even recognized as questions. There is a philosophical bias here in favor of unlimited freedom where taxation is reprehensible, or at least should be minimized. That's reasonable, I agree. The USA ran that way for a long time, why not now? A reasonable question. It's all political economy, there is no determinism anywhere.
I think you are taking 'money' too seriously. Given that our money has no basis in reality (it is fiat currency), we might as well base our economy on the unicorn population.
It is far better to measure our economy in terms of productivity. If it hasn't been produced, you can't buy it, regardless of how many unicorns you own. So, what does the federal government's money manipulation contribute to productivity? It does contribute to some extent, but nowhere near as effectively as private markets.
If money changes hands as part of the process of production, good. If money changes hands from one un-productive bureaucrat to another, bad.
OK but the federal government does fund private enterprises, which can grow into substantial businesses. The examples are too numerous to list -- defense spending has created a massive Military Industrial Complex, the internet came from DARPA, which produced today's tech sector.
I don't think there's a clean analytical distinction between "government spending" and private enterprise. I appreciate that many folks make that distinction in their minds, but it seems to me that's a political opinion not an economic fact.
I have no problem with that opinion, as an opinion. But they'll jump the shark and start thinking it's somehow an objective fact.
First and foremost, it is not the federal government's job to engage in enterprise. That doesn't mean it shouldn't, but its primary purpose is to defend borders(!), make treaties with foreign powers, prosecute war, and make various regulations.
Business' job is to make money. The only legitimate way for them to do that, and most businesses are legitimate, is to produce goods and services that have value to customers. The greater the value, the more sales that are made.
We agree that you cannot precisely separate the two, yet there are obvious distinctions. Governments that attempt to take charge of production, i.e. communism, fascism and, to a lesser extent, socialism, never measure up to the productivity of free markets.
Here's a thought: Instead of more government takeover of business, let's have more business takeover of government. Yes, that's absurd. As far as I'm concerned, it's absurd either way you consider it.
"Here's a thought: Instead of more government takeover of business, let's have more business takeover of government."
That's not absurd at all! It's called "privatization" and it happens all the time. Private operators are big players in global infrastructure, which used to be mostly government run -- airports, ports, highways, etc. You may recall the hoopla when a private infrastructure operator took over Chicago's city parking and jacked up parking rates. Not only isn't it absurd, it's routine business as usual across much of the world. There's even public companies like Macquarie that do this. At times they do a better job than government did, sometimes not as good. Depends on management quality and specifics of the local oversight.
If they have been investing a portion 50% of Social Security and Medicare funds into the broad stock market - there would be zero issues. The issues that we had trillions sitting in treasuries yield next to nothing for 20 years.
Still think if DOGE goes through and cuts all waste / fraud. They will be able to cut at least a Trillion.
Getting to a balanced budget would be ideal - soon. From there you shrink the government and let the private sector operate in areas where the government wastes spending. I look at education - you let the private sector take over and probably will do it for 50 cents on the dollar that the public schools do today. You take teachers out of the state pension programs - that strengthen local budgets.
Yeah, waste/fraud is the #1 issue and neither was mentioned in the article at all. Thanks to DOGE's work, none of our government's spending has any legitimacy for the majority of the country, which should be a featured point in an article like this. The mandate for change is there.
We know every one of the buckets of spending outlined in the article is filled with fraud, and likely half of the budget is wasted in one way or another. The famous $200 toilet seats and such, illegitimate wars, and massive contracts handed out to political allies at NGOs. Those are the core issues when discussing the government's spending. We can't pretend like it's all legitimate and all of it goes to where it says it goes in the chart the author shared.
To your point - US Public education is basically the laughing stock of the world. We spend more than just about anyone per student and get results on par with developing nations. Baltimore recently had a year where not a single student across all of their schools could read, write, and do math at proficiency. Not even one kid! How is that humane or compassionate, as the left likes to frame these things?
Of course, in medicine we spend more per patient than anyone in the world and have the lowest - and declining - life spans of any of the developed nations, worse even than some developing nations.
So, it's time to try new things. Anything to do with either of those fields should be sunset at the national level and turned over to private co's and local gov'ts to run. Meaning: DoE, Medicaid, Medicare, CDC, NIH.
Soc Sec also has to go, as it's a basic Ponzi scheme, meaning unless your society has constant, high levels of population growth it's going to run out of funds.
Wow - could not say it better than myself
Social Security and Medicare are paid for by deductions from paychecks.
An interesting article would be where did these fund$ go? They are not being used for their intended purpose.
Cutting all waste/fraud in "discretionary" and "defense" (warfare state) current spending MAY realistically yield "savings" up to 20% or $300 - $400 billion $$ or so. The combination of current "non-discretionary" spending and interest payments (also basically non-discretionary) total more than current income tax collections. So without either substantial cuts to non-discretionary spending and/or huge tax increases there is no possibility of balancing the fedgov budget. All assuming no "recession" or even a "slowdown" in the economy at any time in the future - an unlikely prospect.
Is this paywalled? Everyone needs to read it. Everyone
Good stuff.
I appreciate the fact-based and well-explained layout of where the money comes from and goes. Note that where it goes is right back to "Americans". Maybe not the same ones it's taken from! (An understatement, to be sure, and source of a lot of political heat and pushback).
But it goes right back into "the economy" -- healthcare, social security, defense, even net interest goes to bond investors, about half or more are Americans. This is somebody's revenue or income. That money gets spent and spurs economic development.
Those are facts too, not opinions. Does the money that flows right back into the economy create seeds of future prosperity? Is there a multiplier effect that kicks in? If there were no government sector, and everything mapped here was considered private free enterprise, where people purchased the same services (OK, the argument is they wouldn't, it's confiscation of taxes and services forced down their throat, that's reasonable I agree), how would the phenomenon be interpreted -- would "the debt" still be a problem?"
These are reasonable questions, but often they don't get answered or even recognized as questions. There is a philosophical bias here in favor of unlimited freedom where taxation is reprehensible, or at least should be minimized. That's reasonable, I agree. The USA ran that way for a long time, why not now? A reasonable question. It's all political economy, there is no determinism anywhere.
I think you are taking 'money' too seriously. Given that our money has no basis in reality (it is fiat currency), we might as well base our economy on the unicorn population.
It is far better to measure our economy in terms of productivity. If it hasn't been produced, you can't buy it, regardless of how many unicorns you own. So, what does the federal government's money manipulation contribute to productivity? It does contribute to some extent, but nowhere near as effectively as private markets.
If money changes hands as part of the process of production, good. If money changes hands from one un-productive bureaucrat to another, bad.
Hey. Unicorn bitcoin!!
OK but the federal government does fund private enterprises, which can grow into substantial businesses. The examples are too numerous to list -- defense spending has created a massive Military Industrial Complex, the internet came from DARPA, which produced today's tech sector.
I don't think there's a clean analytical distinction between "government spending" and private enterprise. I appreciate that many folks make that distinction in their minds, but it seems to me that's a political opinion not an economic fact.
I have no problem with that opinion, as an opinion. But they'll jump the shark and start thinking it's somehow an objective fact.
First and foremost, it is not the federal government's job to engage in enterprise. That doesn't mean it shouldn't, but its primary purpose is to defend borders(!), make treaties with foreign powers, prosecute war, and make various regulations.
Business' job is to make money. The only legitimate way for them to do that, and most businesses are legitimate, is to produce goods and services that have value to customers. The greater the value, the more sales that are made.
We agree that you cannot precisely separate the two, yet there are obvious distinctions. Governments that attempt to take charge of production, i.e. communism, fascism and, to a lesser extent, socialism, never measure up to the productivity of free markets.
Here's a thought: Instead of more government takeover of business, let's have more business takeover of government. Yes, that's absurd. As far as I'm concerned, it's absurd either way you consider it.
"Here's a thought: Instead of more government takeover of business, let's have more business takeover of government."
That's not absurd at all! It's called "privatization" and it happens all the time. Private operators are big players in global infrastructure, which used to be mostly government run -- airports, ports, highways, etc. You may recall the hoopla when a private infrastructure operator took over Chicago's city parking and jacked up parking rates. Not only isn't it absurd, it's routine business as usual across much of the world. There's even public companies like Macquarie that do this. At times they do a better job than government did, sometimes not as good. Depends on management quality and specifics of the local oversight.