31 Comments
User's avatar
Jason Nelson's avatar

Sounds right. There is a tic Tok video of Jeffrey Sachs giving a three minute explanation of how the U.S. was responsible for starting the war and keeping it going that is very succinct. It's worth looking up. Also plenty of podcasts have had clips that never air on mainstream media where the head of the NATO or the U.N. admits that the war was caused by the U.S. trying to get Ukraine to join NATO which everyone knew would trigger this response from Russia.

DLB's avatar

I agree, and you are one of the very few who have bothered to investigate news of this war outside of what the MSM allows us to see.

It's also worth noting that the "insurrection" that took place in Feb, 2014 happened after the then democratically elected president of Ukraine, Yanukovych, rejected NATO's plan to include Ukraine.

I would also add that in 2014 the people of eastern Ukraine petitioned Russia to annex and declare them to be part of Russia, after Russia had done the same with Crimea. But Russia refused to act on this at the time.

It should also be noted that after this happened, Poroshenko, the one chosen by the deep state, and Zelensky's predecessor, sent the Azov Battalion, comprised exclusively by Nazi's, into eastern Ukraine with the intention of "changing the minds" of the local citizens. 1000's of eastern Ukrainians, many of whom were descendants of Russia, were killed by the Azov Battalion, sent there by Poroshenko and then Zelensky.

Steve S's avatar

Jeffrey Sachs is far from a credible source. He gets most everything wrong, enjoys bashing anything aligned with western values. No need to dilute good points made by Anton with mention of Sachs.

Jason Nelson's avatar

The two or three interviews I have heard with him, he seems very informed and intelligent and can cite sources. If you don't like Sachs, then you could look at the RAND corp report from 2014 called "Extending Russia" that specifically states using Ukraine as a proxy against Russia to destroy Russia's military capabilities.

Steve S's avatar

Appreciate the suggestion to look at the RAND Corp report. Suggest you take a look at the 2016 RAND Report describing the Russian "Firehose of Falsehood" Propaganda Model.

https://www.rand.org/pubs/perspectives/PE198.html

Crimson Possum's avatar

I just read the 2016 Rand report. To say that it is problematic is to say almost nothing. Gaslighting comes to mind, but that's also a major understatement.

I would earnestly ask anyone who wants to cut through the noise of Western OR Eastern propaganda to take a challenge: for one year, read at least one article 5 days a week, Monday through Friday, from the Wall Street journal, the New York times, the Washington post, or Fox News or cnn. In that same time frame, read at least one article from rt.com. Judge for yourself who is manipulating and lying and who's being balanced and straightforward.

Crimson Possum's avatar

For the definitive work on the Ukraine war, you can also read Scott Horton's "Provoked."

Crimson Possum's avatar

Trump seems to be doing what should have been done since 1991. He is treating the Russians as potential partners and looking for mutually beneficial arrangements. Since the implosion of the Soviet union, Russia has not been our enemy. However, we have been hers. We have lied to Russia, cheated them, and demonized them and their leaders with virtually no cause for three decades, pushing them into a corner and not only provoking this war, but essentially orchestrating it. The Biden Administration, along with neocon never-trumper Republicans, didn't make mistakes. They wanted this war to weaken Russia (and to keep the MIC money flowing) and they were willing to watch hundreds of thousands die on both sides while they gleefully smiled at it. Our propaganda machine went into full swing as Americans flew Ukrainian flags on they social media, not knowing that they were just putting a rubber stamp of approval on a slaughter and a war that was lost before it began.

I have studied Putin for two decades, looking for evidence of this vicious, lying, brutal dictator. Because the onslaught of propaganda was so strong, I thought I must be missing something when, for the first 10 years of studying him, I couldn't find those traits. Going against the tide of media isn't easy.

It was the authoritarian policies of our own country during covid-19 that opened my eyes. We were being lied to on a daily basis about this virus, and I thought to myself, perhaps we are also being lied to about Putin. As soon as I consider that possibility, my eyes opened.

It's true that Vladimir Putin is not a man to be trifled with. You need to look no further than Yevgeny Prigozhin to see that. However, he is no more brutal and no more dictator than many American presidents. What he is is the most competent leader on the world stage in the last 50 years. He is transparent in his foreign policy and intelligent and measured in his dealings with the world. He has been honest and forthright to the point if night sweats in dealing with America. He seems to lead by one central guiding force: what is best for Russia.

He and Donald Trump are wildly different men, but I think that they have this in common. They both want what is best for their people. And I think that is why future meetings with the two will lead to progress. Putin will be cautious, however. He knows that when he is dealing with the United States government, Donald Trump aside, he is dealing with something that cannot be trusted.

Fingers crossed.

Leskunque Lepew's avatar

It always amazes me how Beltway wonks have no clue of Russian/European history.

Sometimes I speculate over the influence of the Military Industrial Complex within Beltway decision making.

Ike was right.

American Psycho's avatar

Thanks for the article, Raven. The worst outcome is that nothing gets resolved and boys, men, and citizens continue to die. Best case scenario is that peace develops and the rebuilding can begin. Let’s see how the story develops. And who knows, maybe one day i’ll get my Lukoil shares back ;)

Enjoy the weekend!

Paine Of Glass's avatar

Here’s to dreams of peace, avoiding WW3 and much much more importantly—my Russian stock shares getting unlocked someday.

Tankster's avatar

Per Lee Corso, not so fast my friend. Putin is a skilled KGB agent. Trump is the easiest mark in the world. Setting aside the utter lawlessness of the invasion, and the gross incompetence of the Russian military, do we reward him? I know that the US helped overthrow Yanukovich ten years ago, that’s no excuse to invade to decapitate the government. Trade and tourism would be great, but Trump and Putin are not carving up Ukraine to award Luhansk and Donetsk like Sykes and Picot, the bastards. Europe can openly buy US weapons, and the Patriot, best in class is a defensive weapon, taking out the vaunted Krisals. If Europe wants to pony up for the defense of Ukraine, why not, it’s their back yard. All the benefits of peace come later. Look at Vietnam. We should not impose peace on anyone. Same with the war on Hamas. Don’t reward the aggressor, it never works. See, e.g., the Sudetenland.

Leskunque Lepew's avatar

The People that live in those areas should have a say ss to who they want to be aligned with.

Andy Fately's avatar

As is often the case, I think the observation that seeing who is complaining is an excellent signal of the benefit of the issue. that the neo cons and europeans are crying tells me, as well, that things are better now than before the meeting

Mike's avatar

I cant seem to shake the complete conviction that almost 1 million lay dead and millions more displaced all the result of basic filthy American political corruption. Not to say Putin/Russia isnt corrupt. But a certain someone's unique and clearly connected by dots corruption has spilled so much blood and it will all go un accounted for.

Dont forget who was sent in at the last minute to pre-empt hostilities.

Love to see an audit as a well. My Lithuanian co-worker described the Spanish villas all the corrupt Ukrainian low level bureaucrats were buying w US dollars.

Every bit of this could have been prevented.

Paine Of Glass's avatar

I feel like the point getting glossed over in a lot of these arguments for and against -is that they had a low key civil war going before Russia ever invaded. That’s probably not going away unless the part that wants to leave gets to leave. And no, sorry, it wasn’t all make believe Russian propaganda-the mortar shells were quite real. #FREERSX

george's avatar

Shhhh. You're not allowed to be honest.

Allan Richard Wasem's avatar

You’re never certain that it’s true until it’s been “officially” denied.

DLB's avatar

I hope the war ends soon and there are many others who wish for this to happen.

A recent Gallup Poll taken in Ukraine, indicated that 75% of the people, the citizens of Ukraine, want the war to end soon.

No conditions were mentioned, it appears they just want the war to end.

dk's avatar

The history some seek can be found here, accurate & contemporaneous. What the war hawks & press won’t tell you.

https://x.com/exfactorbass/status/1672769552713912320?s=46&t=G-kXXBF42z220X6Hrp6f1w

Steve Mudge's avatar

I tend to agree though I think the biggest mistake, if the US wanted Ukraine in NATO, was to not mass NATO troops along the Russian border in response to Russia's initial buildup. Nip it in the bud, war might not have ever started. That would be Biden's and other Euro leaders failure in my opinion. As far as nukes go Putin knows retaliation will obliterate Moscow, ending what's left of the Russian empire. Patton said we would have to fight the Russians eventually anyway, and look what happened to Eastern Europe for decades because we ceded so much.

Cartero Atómico's avatar

Just curious. What did "we" cede and to whom did we cede it? Maybe if the US government didn't break Baker's promise of not moving NATO eastward that he made to Gorbachev this war never would have happened. Instead of listening to Patton maybe we should have listened to Eisenhower's warning about the MIC. The MIC loved the NATO expansion - more clients for their overpriced weaponsm

Steve Mudge's avatar

The Eastern Bloc? Remember the invasion of Czechoslovakia? Bulgaria, Poland, Romania, etc. all came under the Soviet whip.

As far as Gorbachev and Baker that was assuming Russia was becoming more westernized, not reverting to a former KGB member's desire to retake the former empire.

Cartero Atómico's avatar

If you're going back to the USSR don't forget that Stalin was from Georgia. Where is the evidence that Russia, not the USSR, wanted to retake the former empire? You do know that the US engineered the 2014 Ukraine coup and that even Victoria "Fuck the EU" Nuland admitted that the US had biolabs in Ukraine. Plus, the Minsk Agreements were designed to bring a peaceful settlement of the civil war in Ukraine but Merkel and Hollande admitted that they didn't want peace but rather signed the agreementsvto give the Azov Boys time to rebuild their forces.

Now tell me what the US would do if China or Russia established military bases and biolabs in Mexico or Canada? Remember what happened when the USSR put nukes in Cuba?

george's avatar

Your mistake is thinking Russia would allow Ukraine into NATO. Are you not paying attention?

dk's avatar

The Russians lost TENS of millions in WWII. As much as I admired Patton, the US would have been routed by the Russians as well.

george's avatar

They also destroyed over 80% of the Nazi Army and marched from Stalingrad to Berlin, beating the allies, but hey, we can take them!

Steve Mudge's avatar

This was supposed to be a reply to Tankster...

Don C.'s avatar

This war is due to American actions and I pray that this President will get it resolved as quickly as possible. I will not make a huge post as I have written on this topic extensively. I'll just leave us with the words of the late Dr. Stephen F. Cohen, professor of Russian studies at Columbia who said in 2014 "We are leading Ukraine down the primrose path"

Let's all hope that this killing will stop.

george's avatar

It should be noted that winners never ask for ceasefires. Only losers do.

RS Carvey's avatar

From what we believe of the outcomes, there's a tacit agreement to revert back to the 2015 status quo, and the primary direct Russian national cost of the "special operation" to go beyond that has been demographic devastation. The rest of the BRICS will gladly take advantage of that over the next 25 years. Advantage: BICS.