29 Comments
User's avatar
Andrew P's avatar

Wait a minute. Is monetary policy part of the Executive Branch at all? The power "To coin Money, regulate the Value thereof, and of foreign Coin, and fix the Standard of Weights and Measures;" is explicitly delegated to Congress by the Constitution. Congress doesn't want to be setting interest rates every week to regulate the value of the currency, so they delegate that power to a central bank.

Kevin's avatar

I think the issue is in your last sentence. When Congress chooses to create an Office, Agency, or Bureau to delegate authority then that new entity is managed by the Executive branch. Congress could pass a set of laws/rules to set interest rates automatically but once they use people to exercise judgement then those people report to the President.

Rick Ludowese's avatar

Is there a constitutional impediment to Congress creating an Office that is managed by the Legislative branch?

Andrew P's avatar

Yes. If the agency is purely reporting only to Congress, they can do this. But the Federal Reserve is a department that exercises mostly legislative power and some executive power. Its executive functions are executing the laws regulating banks. The Constitution requires that principal officers of Departments only be appointed by the President with the advice and consent of the Senate. Inferior officers can only be appointed by the President alone, the heads of Departments, or the Courts of Law.

Rick Ludowese's avatar

Thanks. You're right - this matches up with the Constitution split of powers. Which is problematic when the Executive does not faithfully execute the law (assuming Congress get's off its butt to pass said law).

Bill Lacey's avatar

You mean like the Congressional Budget Office, the Government Accountability Office and the Congressional Research Service?

Andrew P's avatar

I think SCOTUS will ultimately rule that agencies that primarily exercise executive power (carrying out well-defined laws passed by Congress) must be under the full control of the President, but agencies that exercise narrowly delegated legislative power can be partially insulated from full presidential control. It will be a messy decision, but I think that is where they are, based on their past decisions and writings.

John Horst's avatar

Exactly... There is a problem, but it has nothing to do with the Executive Branch. Back during the Clinton admin, Congress gave the President a "line item veto" - and SCOTUS killed it based on the "non-delegation" doctrine. Congress was basically delegating away its power of the purse, and SCOTUS said: "Nope, Can't do that."

This is the issue with the Fed. Congress has delegated its power to coin money and regulate its value to a privately owned banking network. It might pass the smell test as long as "money" means gold and silver because "coin money" meant taking "money" (the specie) and striking it into the coinage of the United States. Regulating its value means determining how may grains of silver = a Dollar and how many grains of gold = an Eagle. See the Coinage Act of 1792 for an example. (Don't miss this: The USD had a "price" in silver - not the other way around.)

This was what "regulating the value" of money meant. Go away from that and then charter a privately owned banking cartel to issue the country's currency - and forcing it upon the country as the only federally recognized legal tender, and you have violated the non-delegation doctrine.

Andrew P's avatar

The Constitution does not limit Congress to issuing hard sound money.

SCOTUS has allowed Congress to delegate its powers as long as the delegation is limited and well defined. The power of the purse is the primary power that Congress has. They really can't delegate that. But they can delegate the power to regulate the value of a fiat currency.

John Horst's avatar

I don't see how you can logically get from "coin money and regulate its value" to an authority to create/regulate fiat... "Coin money" does not mean "determine what money is." It means take what was assumed to be money - silver and gold - and establish coinage that would be recognized throughout the U.S. Regulating its value, then, meant determining the money content required for a coin.

The best indication of this is the enabling legislation - the Coinage Act of 1792. Section 9 set the "price" of a USD coin: "...three hundred and seventy-one grains and four sixteenth parts of a grain of pure, or four hundred and sixteen grains of standard silver." The US Eagle coin was to be: "...of the value of ten dollars or units, and to contain two hundred and forty-seven grains and four eighths of a grain of pure, or two hundred and seventy grains of standard gold."

If you take 1/10th of the weight of the Eagle in gold (as the Eagle was to be equivalent to 10 Dollars), and divide it by the weight of the silver in a USD, the value ratio of silver to gold is 15:1. (Milton Friedman explains why in his Money Mischief" book). The most interesting thing about this is the fact that the USD had a price in silver, not the other way around. The idea that gold and silver are valued in dollars is the central conceit of the Alice in Wonderland upside down economy.

Paper money (fiat) was a very big part of the problems that fulminated into the Daniel Shays Rebellion. The need to have a single authority for defining the monetary value of coinage was part of the larger need to have bankruptcy and legal tender laws - powers granted to Congress in Article I. The abusive debt collection practices inflicted on war veterans (many of whom did not even get their paper money salary) was what caused the Shays rebellion - which was the last straw for the Articles of Confederation and led to the Constitutional Convention.

Now, we can say that SCOTUS has permitted Congress to delegate to some extent. It does this all the time when allowing Executive Branch officials to promulgate regulations needed to execute the laws. If we extend this to the creation of fiat money under the premise that there are limitations to the delegated power, how does one respond when interest rates go to zero? What are the limits on QE? Where are the limits in the overnight repo market? If there are to be limits on the delegated power, where are they under the current regime?

BobbyD's avatar

Congress should not be "setting" interest rates; the free market sets rates where supply/demand factors determine the appropriate rate. There is no need for this intervention, and in practice, the Fed has exacerbated market volatility and boom/bust cycles as a result. The fallacy lies in thinking that rates need to be controlled or that the "value" of fiat currency should be controlled, when in fact this is done in order for societies' most powerful manipulators (politicians and banksters) to control wealth and influence. Nothing independent or free about it; just bad policy with nefarious intent.

Andrew P's avatar

Regardless of whether it is good policy or bad policy, the Constitution delegates to Congress the power to regulate the value of the currency that Congress authorizes the issuance of.

badnabor's avatar

"the "value" of fiat currency"...LOL. Fiat currency has NO intrinsic "value". It is basically an IOU from a bully with a rather large military. It's not much different, in principle, than a basic, mafia run loan sharking operation.

Andrew P's avatar

It has value in that you need it to pay your debts to the US Government.

John Horst's avatar

You made his point about the bully quite nicely there.

And anyway, that is not value, that's utility. If I work an hour and accept a one oz. bar of iron, I am storing the "value" of my labor in that bar of iron - and the value of my labor dissipates at exactly the rate the iron rusts.

This is why gold and silver have been money for all of recorded history. If I accept a one oz. bar of silver for an hour of labor, the value of my labor does not dissipate because silver is a Noble Metal - it does not rust. (The same is true of gold, platinum, and palladium - there is no redox between them and the oxygen in the atmosphere.)

Fiat has no value - there is nothing to it that naturally preserves the value stored by accepting it. The shopping cart should be screaming this truth to us every time we buy groceries.

And if you really want to see this math up close, note that 1964 was the last year the Quarter Dollar was minted with roughly 90% silver. The minimum wage was $1.25 then - five quarters. Take those quarters and melt them down and you have about 0.90 oz of silver. Back before COVID when people were arguing for a $15 minimum wage, the price of an ounce of silver was roughly $15.

Look at it now! What has not changed (IMHO) is the validity of the signal - if you want to see what the minimum wage ought to be given the purchasing power of the USD, just look at the price of an ounce of silver. QTR talks about the "blowoff valve." If you want to see how close society is getting to a blowoff of civil disorder, just track the delta between the average minimum wage (ballpark $11 and change across the 50 states right now) and the price of an ounce of silver. This shows that the problem is not the wage, but the money the wage is paid in.

Leskunque Lepew's avatar

Great point. Congress has morphed into a very useless political entity.

David Bradshaw's avatar

There is no government function necessary for monetary policy if we return to what the constitution says - that gold and silver are money and nothing else. Coining money and setting the standards for weights and measures has nothing to do with interest rates. The market can set those on its own and did so until the creation of the Fed

george's avatar

This COULD be eliminated with Legislation. Too bad the Republicans don't have a majority in congress.

PrinceOfTheRavens's avatar

Well said.

QTR started as a fringe 2-3 drink minimum commentator & has evolved into a thoughtful dare i say intellectual commentator. That is an impressive evolution Sir.

Well done.

MattJ's avatar

I'd rephrase as the alternative frightens the elite rich minority that has been the insulated focus of the Feds policy, not the decreasingly wealthy masses who have been ignored by that policy.

David Bradshaw's avatar

It is a well framed argument, but ignores the initial separation from the Constitution - that gold and silver are money and nothing else. Congress was only to set weights and measures - the size of coins for commerce that shall be minted. The Fed is the longest lasting Cartel, sanctioned to allow Congress to spend at will (but we will call it monetary policy instead of inflation/debasement/tax), and so they shall promise and spend. More stimmies please!

Chuck Sarahan II's avatar

The fed is a bit of a unique bird in that it is a public private partnership. The regional banks are private while the Board is federal. How this will be sorted out remains to be seen but not comparable to other agencies like the CFPB.

J R's avatar

Hell yeah

Get rid of all the alphabet agencies to the dust bin of history they are all illegal every last one of them

Allan Richard Wasem's avatar

Congress has legislated with regard to money (gold and silver; the US is bimetallic). What it can't constitutionally do is create an agency to perform these functions that is independent of political accountability. Don't like that result? Work to amend the Constitution.

DLB's avatar

Congress, the executive branch and the supreme court, can all debate if the Fed is a valid entity in America and who can control it, but nothing that is said or decreed is going to change much of anything. But as the rest of the world continues to turn its back on the Dollar, then all of us, from the richest to the poorest, will find out how we were all misled and lied to for over 112 years. As most who read this column already know, physical assets are the only way to prepare for what is coming. So don't worry as to what the supreme court decides, our future has already been written.

fab's avatar

That's a very good analysis (not only because I agree with it!). Anyway, it's time for a change because institutions always drift away from their founding principles and become corrupted with time. And that's because sometimes the principles that led to their foundation work too well and they are given too much slack and power. Do you remember Times' magazine cover page ; The Committee to Save the World ?

craazyman's avatar

Might as well eliminate the Tooth Fairy. There were booms & busts under gold standard, as well as debasements and all sorts of political meddling.

Money at scale != money at individual level

It's like beating the devil.

You're beating up on human nature at scale. You might as well beat up on your own behind and call it "instruction". But at least be aware whose behind you're beating. it could be yours!

Paine Of Glass's avatar

Kalshi odds starting to climb for expressing this via Lisa Cook Removal. I think she’s going, what that portends for the Fed itself remains to be seen. Thanks for sharing the article!

Andrew P's avatar

Lisa Cook's removal is a side issue. The Federal Reserve Act allows the President to remove her "for cause", which is not explicitly defined in the legislation. The question is - what does that mean?