These folks came on TV during 2015 and 2016 and openly advocated for "anti fascist" violence and forced speech shut down....simply over the immigration debate. (No human illegal yada yada) then the BLM. Then the TRANS care. Silence=violence.
I mean it's so far off the rails now. Just a week before Kirks murder I snapped a Pic of a white mom driving a Subaru in my town with a Luigi bumper sticker.
And these same folks are about to take over the largest city budget in the nation.
I'm so out of it, I had to look up what Luigi bumper sticker meant. I kept visualizing Mario Bros! 🤪
I'm in agreement with you about the celebrated violence but what does one expect from a culture that is saturated with propaganda honoring violence (music, tv, movies, video games, forever wars, ...)? All these folks that spouted out 'I don't see color' a decade ago (how stupid is that?) yet not a single one would tutor or assist a young, black person or sponsor an immigrant in their own home.
The hypocrisy is only heightened by those who admire/support a 'cultural christianity' that has noting to do with the teachings of the Prince of Peace who admonishes us to 'love one another'.
What a revealing window this Substack has become on a group that feels its privilege is threatened by affording the same privileges to groups historically dominated, suppressed and exploited. The fervour with which the writer feels his views are right and just is, frankly frightening. It strips one of any hope of reconciliations.
Prima facia example of an individual who has zero intrest in debating the issue in good faith. Nothing in the written piece even ventures in to any of the cause de celebre the radical left chooses to take up arms for.
It's the orgy of arms taking up this essay looks to intelligently point out to a reader.
For me...this easay was confirmation among my personal intellects...the ones I tend to look to for consensus....that they get the picture and are going to do something about it. Start pulling up corrections busses in Portland and booking these people into Fed Crim cases. Start to lock up and perp walk all the billions litteraly stolen through USAID scams. UNH? I've got news for you. Every single time a D touched Healthcare to "make it more affordable" it evolved into an ever bigger monstrosity of cost and in-efficincy...all the while as Medicaid got expanded over and over. Started with Hillarys pet projects in the early 90s with HMOs.
Then Obama Care..which mind you its explicit intent was to draw more EARNED dollars into the system believing buyers with ''skin in the game" translation=$$$$- would make wise health decisions. . Got that right. You should see my family's over all premiums for emplyer sponsored plans. Pushing 40k annual And we don't even use it. As people who walk across the border get handed gold card med ins. On the public dollar.
If anything has been revealed in the crucible the past few years it's the unholy alliance of mega corporations..legacy press and big money with political violence and mayhem.
Absolutely agree on the filtering of public funds.
Also strongly believe in everyone having equal rights. These two things are not exclusive. No doubt they are very linked. There’s corruption going on both sides, as one guy put it they're two cheeks of the same ass. The identity politics is a useful smoke screen. Behind it are individuals with rights and some who have less agency who deserve to have that agency enabled.
You know Christine. I drafted my reply and looked at your profile first. I refrained from treash talk tonthe extent I am able but thought after the send...to myself...I bet the farm she and I will agree on a lot absent the extremities. There is hope. We have to compromise. I agree we need immigtants....not dumping 100 mill in in one shot. I agree on both sides needing long fed time....I agree homelessness needa to be helped.....not an endless steam of cash box LLCs doing squat and ever more municipal employees making 175k a year shooting 2 emails a week. We're getting played. And as of recently getting killed.
Thanks that’s a great point, people are people and want the same things. Searching for the roots of the extreme polarisation we are experiencing among people who yes have the privilege of paying taxes and getting to vote, is imo a good place to start to find what compromise that would benefit ordinary tax paying voters would look like. We all have pretty much the same outcomes required for our interests to be met. Why do you think that murder is cropping up as a political tactic whether it be those on the left or on the right perpetrating it?
A search on murders committed by political extremists in past 2 years comes up with this,
For the years 2024 and 2025, data from the Anti-Defamation League (ADL) and the Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS) shows the following regarding murders committed by political extremists in the U.S..
2024
* Far-right murders: All 13 extremist-related murders in 2024 were committed by far-right extremists.
* Eight of these killings were linked to white supremacists.
* Five were connected to anti-government extremists.
* Far-left murders: There were no documented extremist-related murders attributed to far-left extremists in 2024.
* The total of 13 extremist-related murders was the lowest annual total since 2000.
2025
* Shifting trends: For the first time in over 30 years, data from early 2025 shows that attacks and plots from the violent far-left outpaced those from the far-right.
* Left-wing attacks increase: While starting from very low levels, left-wing terrorist incidents were on pace for a record-breaking year by July 2025.
* Right-wing attacks decline: Conversely, far-right terrorist incidents saw a dramatic drop in the first half of 2025.
* Notable incidents (as of July 2025):
* Right-wing: One incident resulting in murder was documented: the murder of Minnesota state legislator Melissa Hortman and her husband in June 2025.
* Left-wing: The assassination of conservative activist Charlie Kirk and an attack on an ICE facility in Dallas were cited as part of the uptick in left-wing violence in 2025.
I thought the writer might be going there until reaching the end. I believe he still supports individual liberty for all in this country, and is reinforcing the point that "your right to swing your fist ends when it hits my face". That you can't use the doctrine of self-defense to attack and hurt your perceived oppressors. At least, that's what I hope the message is.
Reading a book now To Overthrow the World: The Rise and Fall and Rise of Communism by Sean McMeekin and while I was aware of the atrocities of Stalin, Mao etc… I really didn’t appreciate them until reading this book. The callous attitude they had toward human life and the violence inflicted on their own people was catastrophic beyond what I had imagined. Yet, they justified it because the imperialists and Bourgeoisie must be punished for their sins and practically eliminated. Yet that spread even to the proletariat when they were imprisoned, tortured, and killed as deserters or traitors if they didn’t toe the line. Now I’m not accusing the American left of that, but their rhetoric has that theme imbedded deep within it. So while Trump’s generous use of executive power does worry me some, there is the conundrum of how do we swing the pendulum back without it. We certainly weren’t doing it with mainstream republicans. So while my constitutional concerns I believe are valid, I really don’t see how we can right the ship without a disruptor such as Trump.
Check out The White Pill by Michael Malice. Not many people out there connected the modern day leftists with Communism and Marxist ideologies at first, but it’s gaining traction. Easily hidden in the jargon they shout designed to ensnare an emotional response with the focus on an empathy. Empathy is a powerful weapon of the American Communist. Modern day communists focus on emotional responses and mostly gave up on economic issues. The economic battle they lost but the West is particularly vulnerable to the new breed of Marxist propaganda: race, gender, immigration, climate change, abortion “woman’s health care “ and colonialism. All emotionally charged topics.
The left in the US ( Democrats, if you will) have been bought by the Transnational gangsters and have become the shaft of the spear ( the tip bring the captured MSM) that is destroying the US. It's being done so subtly that the majority of the electorate has no clue.
It's all on Eyewitless news BUT first a drug commercial
I think the challenge we’re experiencing is not just tied to the identitarians and the progressive left wing. We howled and complained during the Biden years over cancel culture and the ridiculous identity mandates being promoted in universities and other institutions. We watched as many of these same people also overlapped with the COVIDians who asserted government authority to in effect shutdown basic rights protected under the Constitution. Lots of censorship was thrown into this mix. Add in a touch climate fanaticism and you had our government running amok in support of the lunacy of what we now know to be a minority group. However, with the changing of the guard we begin to see signs of a conservative government also running amok in the opposite direction. Sure, deporting illegal immigrants should be the mandate, but the notion of dropping them off in prisons in random places is a lil’ nuts. The notion outlawing certain speech (think Israel “hate speech” whatever that means), was anathema to conservatives just a few short years ago, but now it’s being embraced in “special cases”. Meanwhile, we also see President that is cleaning up some of this craziness while simultaneously enriching himself and his family by legitimizing what can only be called the crypto scam. If Nancy Pelosi’s insider trading insanity can be treated as criminal (which it very much should), don’t we have to equally view Trump’s “World Liberty Financial Token” with even greater skepticism? It will dwarf the money that Pelosi made when it’s all said and done, but this is coming from the Executive-in-Charge of the country, which makes it that much more pernicious.
My concerns are that there is crazy behavior coming from all sides with retaliation happening at every changing of the guard. The lawfare the Democrats pulled against Trump was a waste of time, money and other resources, all built on scams. But likewise, Trump’s lawfare back now against his political opponents and folks he just doesn’t like Federal Reserve Governor Lisa Cook, is equally stupid and outrageous. Wasted payer dollars to have the entire military brass gather from around the world for a dress down by Pete Hegseth was utterly ridiculous given what our armed forces are being asked to do on the battle field. If anyone heard Hegseth’s speech and thought there was anything there that would motivate our armed forces, then they’ve learned from motivational speakers. This was the antithesis of that.
It’s clear that the identitarians lack pragmatism and robust sense of reality. The trans topic demonstrates serious evidence here since it’s difficult to ask others to respect people who don’t respect themselves or their natural born bodies. On the surface though, this could be allowed to pass and their lives to be left alone, but when they make it an issue of it, then it’s no longer about them, it’s about right to react. My hope is that Trump and those around him start focusing less on retaliation and more advancing progress. Less about telling others how f-ed up they are, and more building up our country without plundering on behalf of corporate special interests. All this to say that while this article does a good job explaining the identitarian phenomena, it needs to balance this with the fact that the current strain of conservatism is creating challenges in how it’s being manifested that in some areas rivals the crazy of the left.
I am sorry I beg to differ. There is way to much to unpack but this im gonna jump out in. Hammas sitting in front of Jewish homes, businesses, mosques and schools....litteraly being targeted for round the clock harassment just for being Jewish. Nope. If that were white supmermist nazis (which are practically non existent) doing that to any race it would not be tolerated. The thrice tiered justice syetem and application of "hate crime" laws as well as civil rights legislation is what is at debate.
Well written. The Charlie Kirk assassination showed it, you are correct. Then what happened after the violence? Conservatives held vigils not riots. Quietly assembled, prayed and so on. No looting, burning or other destruction. A huge difference in reactions left versus right.
What these people that promulgate violence need to fear is the quiet man that just wants to be left alone. Should this idiocy continue then I fear sooner or later that will happen. Once roused that will be terrible imo.
Not normally a bible quote guy, but glance at Ecclesiastes 10:2, “ 2 The heart of the wise inclines to the right,
ACTIONS have consequences -and as certain SPEECH can be an action for the Left it MUST also be so for the Right. Regrettably, in self-defense, when speech clearly threatens violence it must be met with violence; there is NO CHOICE if we are to maintain a civilization.
I prefer "presumption" rather than "assumption" and yes - that conclusion seems most likely. However, there are some troubling aspects that remain to be resolved: the absence of the bullet for example. At this point I am reserving final judgment.
However, my point doesn't really depend on the identity of Kirk's murderer but relates, as I stated, to the response of those on the Left to the event who clearly INTENDED to provoke further such acts (which legally constitutes a Criminal Conspiracy).
One of the better Mises Screeds but it's still vacuous. The worst traits of the lunatic left is not even mentioned -- If you compare the number of people of African descent killed by lynchings from 1865 to 1960s (about 4 to 5 thousand per NAACP), it doesn't even come close to the ritual sacrifice of war captives by the West African cultures they came from. One year it's in the tens of thousands.
The Englightenment happened for a reason. European history is not much better, maybe no better -- just read the Witch Mania.
The worst traits of the lunatic left is their almost unbelievable historical ignorance (world history not just US history from 1619), their unbelievable hypocrisy (if they really don't want to be Westernized Americans, they are expropriating a value system they did not create nor did it exist where they came, from to make moral judgments about the society they are in). How far would they have gotten in the Kingdom of Dahomey? Well they would have lost their heads. Literally.
Well. Whatever.
You can't expect clarity of thought, consistency, erudition, historical awareness, or even basic decency.
And as for the Mises Freaks. "Do whatever you want" doesn't work and has never worked anywhere in the world ever (I mean evah). Evah. It's the law of the jungle. It's the kind of justice that Thraysymachus famously defined in Plato's Republic "The advantage of the stronger."
Honestly, the libertarians are derivative philosophers from the Lockian schools of property that arose from Enlightenment philosophy. Derivative philosophers. And shallow ones at that. It is not worth making a fetish of these people. Although they have every right to bloviate anywhere they want. LOL. Just like me!
"Unlimited tolerance must lead to the disappearance of tolerance. If we extend unlimited tolerance even to those who are intolerant, if we are not prepared to defend a tolerant society against the onslaught of the intolerant, then the tolerant will be destroyed, and tolerance with them." -- Karl Popper
I'm nowhere as articulate as Ms. Njoya, but the article places a number of people, perhaps a majority or plurality as being caught in a squeeze. She states: "Today, the split in the right wing is growing even deeper, as nationalist conservatives launch a campaign to impose “consequences” on their ghoulish opponents by getting them fired from their jobs. In this context they have little patience for the doctrines of individual liberty."
This is how we're having troops in cities, The National Security Presidential Memorandum (NSPM-7) on "Countering Domestic Terrorism and Organized Political Violence". It directs U.S. agencies to investigate and disrupt individuals and organizations involved in political violence and intimidation. While the order does not specifically name "left-wing groups," the administration has publicly pointed to left-leaning groups and ideologies as justification for the initiative.
What individual liberties are infringed by this action, along with the PATRIOT Act and its progeny, we have a surveillance state the PRC can be proud of.
Meanwhile, she states: "When individual liberty departs from reason it becomes grotesque, a sinister parody of itself, and fuels the deadly notion that violence is justified if anyone feels his individuality is being “disrespected” by his ideological opponents. This is now the hallmark of the identitarian left—that failing to respect their stated pronouns, or failing to respect their legacies of oppression and pay them their “reparations,” amounts to “erasing” them and thereby justifies them in being violent."
What in the world are rational, liberty minded people to do when the spectrum is not a linear "left v, right" as opposed to a circle where the extremists bend toward each other at one point. Nihilistic ideology calls for and causes violence towards perceived (or real) enemies. Contrary to what is espoused by Pravda and Izvestia, what count as out Fiat News (h/t Ben Hunt) the violence is not exclusive to the so-called left. See, e.g., the madman who drove into the Mormon church and killed many.
People are quick to blame all violence on the left. "Mostly peaceful" burning and looting of cities is not acceptable. We live in a post-truth world where, as Karl Rove said in 2004, that journalists belong to the "reality-based community," a group he claimed believed that solutions "emerge from your judicious study of discernible reality". He dismissed this view as obsolete, concluding, "We're history's actors... and you, all of you, will be left to just study what we do".
Hannah Arendt argued that pervasive lying in politics has a more insidious effect than simply deceiving people:
it destroys the foundation of shared factual reality and systematically erodes the public's ability to think, judge, and trust in anything. In her analysis, this widespread destruction of a common ground of truth is the central precondition for the rise of totalitarianism.
These folks came on TV during 2015 and 2016 and openly advocated for "anti fascist" violence and forced speech shut down....simply over the immigration debate. (No human illegal yada yada) then the BLM. Then the TRANS care. Silence=violence.
I mean it's so far off the rails now. Just a week before Kirks murder I snapped a Pic of a white mom driving a Subaru in my town with a Luigi bumper sticker.
And these same folks are about to take over the largest city budget in the nation.
🍿
I'm so out of it, I had to look up what Luigi bumper sticker meant. I kept visualizing Mario Bros! 🤪
I'm in agreement with you about the celebrated violence but what does one expect from a culture that is saturated with propaganda honoring violence (music, tv, movies, video games, forever wars, ...)? All these folks that spouted out 'I don't see color' a decade ago (how stupid is that?) yet not a single one would tutor or assist a young, black person or sponsor an immigrant in their own home.
The hypocrisy is only heightened by those who admire/support a 'cultural christianity' that has noting to do with the teachings of the Prince of Peace who admonishes us to 'love one another'.
The truth is not something we Americans do well.
What a revealing window this Substack has become on a group that feels its privilege is threatened by affording the same privileges to groups historically dominated, suppressed and exploited. The fervour with which the writer feels his views are right and just is, frankly frightening. It strips one of any hope of reconciliations.
Prima facia example of an individual who has zero intrest in debating the issue in good faith. Nothing in the written piece even ventures in to any of the cause de celebre the radical left chooses to take up arms for.
It's the orgy of arms taking up this essay looks to intelligently point out to a reader.
For me...this easay was confirmation among my personal intellects...the ones I tend to look to for consensus....that they get the picture and are going to do something about it. Start pulling up corrections busses in Portland and booking these people into Fed Crim cases. Start to lock up and perp walk all the billions litteraly stolen through USAID scams. UNH? I've got news for you. Every single time a D touched Healthcare to "make it more affordable" it evolved into an ever bigger monstrosity of cost and in-efficincy...all the while as Medicaid got expanded over and over. Started with Hillarys pet projects in the early 90s with HMOs.
Then Obama Care..which mind you its explicit intent was to draw more EARNED dollars into the system believing buyers with ''skin in the game" translation=$$$$- would make wise health decisions. . Got that right. You should see my family's over all premiums for emplyer sponsored plans. Pushing 40k annual And we don't even use it. As people who walk across the border get handed gold card med ins. On the public dollar.
If anything has been revealed in the crucible the past few years it's the unholy alliance of mega corporations..legacy press and big money with political violence and mayhem.
Absolutely agree on the filtering of public funds.
Also strongly believe in everyone having equal rights. These two things are not exclusive. No doubt they are very linked. There’s corruption going on both sides, as one guy put it they're two cheeks of the same ass. The identity politics is a useful smoke screen. Behind it are individuals with rights and some who have less agency who deserve to have that agency enabled.
I thought Disney closed "Its a Small World". Can some one tell me wtf is going on here?
Privilege? What ....to pay taxes?
You know Christine. I drafted my reply and looked at your profile first. I refrained from treash talk tonthe extent I am able but thought after the send...to myself...I bet the farm she and I will agree on a lot absent the extremities. There is hope. We have to compromise. I agree we need immigtants....not dumping 100 mill in in one shot. I agree on both sides needing long fed time....I agree homelessness needa to be helped.....not an endless steam of cash box LLCs doing squat and ever more municipal employees making 175k a year shooting 2 emails a week. We're getting played. And as of recently getting killed.
Thanks that’s a great point, people are people and want the same things. Searching for the roots of the extreme polarisation we are experiencing among people who yes have the privilege of paying taxes and getting to vote, is imo a good place to start to find what compromise that would benefit ordinary tax paying voters would look like. We all have pretty much the same outcomes required for our interests to be met. Why do you think that murder is cropping up as a political tactic whether it be those on the left or on the right perpetrating it?
A search on murders committed by political extremists in past 2 years comes up with this,
For the years 2024 and 2025, data from the Anti-Defamation League (ADL) and the Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS) shows the following regarding murders committed by political extremists in the U.S..
2024
* Far-right murders: All 13 extremist-related murders in 2024 were committed by far-right extremists.
* Eight of these killings were linked to white supremacists.
* Five were connected to anti-government extremists.
* Far-left murders: There were no documented extremist-related murders attributed to far-left extremists in 2024.
* The total of 13 extremist-related murders was the lowest annual total since 2000.
2025
* Shifting trends: For the first time in over 30 years, data from early 2025 shows that attacks and plots from the violent far-left outpaced those from the far-right.
* Left-wing attacks increase: While starting from very low levels, left-wing terrorist incidents were on pace for a record-breaking year by July 2025.
* Right-wing attacks decline: Conversely, far-right terrorist incidents saw a dramatic drop in the first half of 2025.
* Notable incidents (as of July 2025):
* Right-wing: One incident resulting in murder was documented: the murder of Minnesota state legislator Melissa Hortman and her husband in June 2025.
* Left-wing: The assassination of conservative activist Charlie Kirk and an attack on an ICE facility in Dallas were cited as part of the uptick in left-wing violence in 2025.
I thought the writer might be going there until reaching the end. I believe he still supports individual liberty for all in this country, and is reinforcing the point that "your right to swing your fist ends when it hits my face". That you can't use the doctrine of self-defense to attack and hurt your perceived oppressors. At least, that's what I hope the message is.
Thanks for your considered comment. Are you a pacifist?
Well, while I believe that war is generally a loss for both sides, I do not consider myself a pacifist. Strong believer in defense of self and country
You're correct - and we are well aware there is no hope of reconciliation with those such as yourself.
Well Hells Bells, the answer is simple. You can't argue with crazy.
Reading a book now To Overthrow the World: The Rise and Fall and Rise of Communism by Sean McMeekin and while I was aware of the atrocities of Stalin, Mao etc… I really didn’t appreciate them until reading this book. The callous attitude they had toward human life and the violence inflicted on their own people was catastrophic beyond what I had imagined. Yet, they justified it because the imperialists and Bourgeoisie must be punished for their sins and practically eliminated. Yet that spread even to the proletariat when they were imprisoned, tortured, and killed as deserters or traitors if they didn’t toe the line. Now I’m not accusing the American left of that, but their rhetoric has that theme imbedded deep within it. So while Trump’s generous use of executive power does worry me some, there is the conundrum of how do we swing the pendulum back without it. We certainly weren’t doing it with mainstream republicans. So while my constitutional concerns I believe are valid, I really don’t see how we can right the ship without a disruptor such as Trump.
Check out The White Pill by Michael Malice. Not many people out there connected the modern day leftists with Communism and Marxist ideologies at first, but it’s gaining traction. Easily hidden in the jargon they shout designed to ensnare an emotional response with the focus on an empathy. Empathy is a powerful weapon of the American Communist. Modern day communists focus on emotional responses and mostly gave up on economic issues. The economic battle they lost but the West is particularly vulnerable to the new breed of Marxist propaganda: race, gender, immigration, climate change, abortion “woman’s health care “ and colonialism. All emotionally charged topics.
Will check that out, thanks.
The left in the US ( Democrats, if you will) have been bought by the Transnational gangsters and have become the shaft of the spear ( the tip bring the captured MSM) that is destroying the US. It's being done so subtly that the majority of the electorate has no clue.
It's all on Eyewitless news BUT first a drug commercial
LOVE that last line.
I think the challenge we’re experiencing is not just tied to the identitarians and the progressive left wing. We howled and complained during the Biden years over cancel culture and the ridiculous identity mandates being promoted in universities and other institutions. We watched as many of these same people also overlapped with the COVIDians who asserted government authority to in effect shutdown basic rights protected under the Constitution. Lots of censorship was thrown into this mix. Add in a touch climate fanaticism and you had our government running amok in support of the lunacy of what we now know to be a minority group. However, with the changing of the guard we begin to see signs of a conservative government also running amok in the opposite direction. Sure, deporting illegal immigrants should be the mandate, but the notion of dropping them off in prisons in random places is a lil’ nuts. The notion outlawing certain speech (think Israel “hate speech” whatever that means), was anathema to conservatives just a few short years ago, but now it’s being embraced in “special cases”. Meanwhile, we also see President that is cleaning up some of this craziness while simultaneously enriching himself and his family by legitimizing what can only be called the crypto scam. If Nancy Pelosi’s insider trading insanity can be treated as criminal (which it very much should), don’t we have to equally view Trump’s “World Liberty Financial Token” with even greater skepticism? It will dwarf the money that Pelosi made when it’s all said and done, but this is coming from the Executive-in-Charge of the country, which makes it that much more pernicious.
My concerns are that there is crazy behavior coming from all sides with retaliation happening at every changing of the guard. The lawfare the Democrats pulled against Trump was a waste of time, money and other resources, all built on scams. But likewise, Trump’s lawfare back now against his political opponents and folks he just doesn’t like Federal Reserve Governor Lisa Cook, is equally stupid and outrageous. Wasted payer dollars to have the entire military brass gather from around the world for a dress down by Pete Hegseth was utterly ridiculous given what our armed forces are being asked to do on the battle field. If anyone heard Hegseth’s speech and thought there was anything there that would motivate our armed forces, then they’ve learned from motivational speakers. This was the antithesis of that.
It’s clear that the identitarians lack pragmatism and robust sense of reality. The trans topic demonstrates serious evidence here since it’s difficult to ask others to respect people who don’t respect themselves or their natural born bodies. On the surface though, this could be allowed to pass and their lives to be left alone, but when they make it an issue of it, then it’s no longer about them, it’s about right to react. My hope is that Trump and those around him start focusing less on retaliation and more advancing progress. Less about telling others how f-ed up they are, and more building up our country without plundering on behalf of corporate special interests. All this to say that while this article does a good job explaining the identitarian phenomena, it needs to balance this with the fact that the current strain of conservatism is creating challenges in how it’s being manifested that in some areas rivals the crazy of the left.
I am sorry I beg to differ. There is way to much to unpack but this im gonna jump out in. Hammas sitting in front of Jewish homes, businesses, mosques and schools....litteraly being targeted for round the clock harassment just for being Jewish. Nope. If that were white supmermist nazis (which are practically non existent) doing that to any race it would not be tolerated. The thrice tiered justice syetem and application of "hate crime" laws as well as civil rights legislation is what is at debate.
Fair.
Well written. The Charlie Kirk assassination showed it, you are correct. Then what happened after the violence? Conservatives held vigils not riots. Quietly assembled, prayed and so on. No looting, burning or other destruction. A huge difference in reactions left versus right.
What these people that promulgate violence need to fear is the quiet man that just wants to be left alone. Should this idiocy continue then I fear sooner or later that will happen. Once roused that will be terrible imo.
Not normally a bible quote guy, but glance at Ecclesiastes 10:2, “ 2 The heart of the wise inclines to the right,
but the heart of the fool to the left.”
ACTIONS have consequences -and as certain SPEECH can be an action for the Left it MUST also be so for the Right. Regrettably, in self-defense, when speech clearly threatens violence it must be met with violence; there is NO CHOICE if we are to maintain a civilization.
Example please.
Charlie Kirk - and the response of the left to his murder - clearly intended to provoke more murderous assaults on conservatives.
That assumes we both agree he was assassinated by a extreme leftist. Thats where I fall on the coin. How about you?
I prefer "presumption" rather than "assumption" and yes - that conclusion seems most likely. However, there are some troubling aspects that remain to be resolved: the absence of the bullet for example. At this point I am reserving final judgment.
However, my point doesn't really depend on the identity of Kirk's murderer but relates, as I stated, to the response of those on the Left to the event who clearly INTENDED to provoke further such acts (which legally constitutes a Criminal Conspiracy).
One of the better Mises Screeds but it's still vacuous. The worst traits of the lunatic left is not even mentioned -- If you compare the number of people of African descent killed by lynchings from 1865 to 1960s (about 4 to 5 thousand per NAACP), it doesn't even come close to the ritual sacrifice of war captives by the West African cultures they came from. One year it's in the tens of thousands.
The Englightenment happened for a reason. European history is not much better, maybe no better -- just read the Witch Mania.
The worst traits of the lunatic left is their almost unbelievable historical ignorance (world history not just US history from 1619), their unbelievable hypocrisy (if they really don't want to be Westernized Americans, they are expropriating a value system they did not create nor did it exist where they came, from to make moral judgments about the society they are in). How far would they have gotten in the Kingdom of Dahomey? Well they would have lost their heads. Literally.
Well. Whatever.
You can't expect clarity of thought, consistency, erudition, historical awareness, or even basic decency.
And as for the Mises Freaks. "Do whatever you want" doesn't work and has never worked anywhere in the world ever (I mean evah). Evah. It's the law of the jungle. It's the kind of justice that Thraysymachus famously defined in Plato's Republic "The advantage of the stronger."
Honestly, the libertarians are derivative philosophers from the Lockian schools of property that arose from Enlightenment philosophy. Derivative philosophers. And shallow ones at that. It is not worth making a fetish of these people. Although they have every right to bloviate anywhere they want. LOL. Just like me!
"Unlimited tolerance must lead to the disappearance of tolerance. If we extend unlimited tolerance even to those who are intolerant, if we are not prepared to defend a tolerant society against the onslaught of the intolerant, then the tolerant will be destroyed, and tolerance with them." -- Karl Popper
I'm nowhere as articulate as Ms. Njoya, but the article places a number of people, perhaps a majority or plurality as being caught in a squeeze. She states: "Today, the split in the right wing is growing even deeper, as nationalist conservatives launch a campaign to impose “consequences” on their ghoulish opponents by getting them fired from their jobs. In this context they have little patience for the doctrines of individual liberty."
This is how we're having troops in cities, The National Security Presidential Memorandum (NSPM-7) on "Countering Domestic Terrorism and Organized Political Violence". It directs U.S. agencies to investigate and disrupt individuals and organizations involved in political violence and intimidation. While the order does not specifically name "left-wing groups," the administration has publicly pointed to left-leaning groups and ideologies as justification for the initiative.
What individual liberties are infringed by this action, along with the PATRIOT Act and its progeny, we have a surveillance state the PRC can be proud of.
Meanwhile, she states: "When individual liberty departs from reason it becomes grotesque, a sinister parody of itself, and fuels the deadly notion that violence is justified if anyone feels his individuality is being “disrespected” by his ideological opponents. This is now the hallmark of the identitarian left—that failing to respect their stated pronouns, or failing to respect their legacies of oppression and pay them their “reparations,” amounts to “erasing” them and thereby justifies them in being violent."
What in the world are rational, liberty minded people to do when the spectrum is not a linear "left v, right" as opposed to a circle where the extremists bend toward each other at one point. Nihilistic ideology calls for and causes violence towards perceived (or real) enemies. Contrary to what is espoused by Pravda and Izvestia, what count as out Fiat News (h/t Ben Hunt) the violence is not exclusive to the so-called left. See, e.g., the madman who drove into the Mormon church and killed many.
People are quick to blame all violence on the left. "Mostly peaceful" burning and looting of cities is not acceptable. We live in a post-truth world where, as Karl Rove said in 2004, that journalists belong to the "reality-based community," a group he claimed believed that solutions "emerge from your judicious study of discernible reality". He dismissed this view as obsolete, concluding, "We're history's actors... and you, all of you, will be left to just study what we do".
Hannah Arendt argued that pervasive lying in politics has a more insidious effect than simply deceiving people:
it destroys the foundation of shared factual reality and systematically erodes the public's ability to think, judge, and trust in anything. In her analysis, this widespread destruction of a common ground of truth is the central precondition for the rise of totalitarianism.
So where are we to go?