27 Comments
User's avatar
Chris DeMuth Jr's avatar

The should. My cynical take on why they won't -- the government wants to always be able to accuse people of mail fraud if they can't get them on anything else. It is a convenient catchall accusation and there is no UPS fraud or FDX fraud.

Iris Graham's avatar

Chris DeMuth Jr ...insert the words 'and racism' after 'mail fraud' for a more accurate 'catchall accusation'.

Cranky Frankie's avatar

That statute could easily be expanded to any fraud using a common carrier or third party uninvolved intermediate.

TheSovereignRevolution's avatar

Kramer, tried, and failed, to stop the mail.

Allan Richard Wasem's avatar

My son and I use the USPS fairly extensively in our fine and rare book business. Have generally been well-satisfied - at least as well as with FedEx and UPS. There IS also the counter-argument: that the USPS was instituted and should remain a "Public Service" to promote the general welfare. As such - "privatization" would not serve the common good".

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Apr 3Edited
Comment deleted
Allan Richard Wasem's avatar

In many cases we do - our economic system is definitely "mixed" - for better or worse. I don't have time to get "into the weeds" on economics this morning but, yes, in some cases the "general welfare" clause of the Constitution leads to "public" provision of services in order to promote that end. Striking the best balance is now what we have to strive for - after this Fourth Turning concludes.

mm2712's avatar

While the USPS is not operated with complete efficiency, many people fail to recognize that providing doorstep pickup and nationwide delivery of a standard 1-ounce letter for $0.78 remains remarkably inexpensive—among the lowest rates in the industrialized world. The Postal Service operates under a structural disadvantage stemming from its universal service obligation, which requires it to deliver to every address in the United States at uniform, affordable prices, including many low-density and high-cost residential routes. In contrast, private carriers such as FedEx and UPS have focused primarily on higher-margin segments like time-sensitive express services and parcels, often partnering with the USPS for last-mile delivery in areas where their own networks would be less economical.

This arrangement has left the USPS bearing a disproportionate share of the least profitable residential pickup and delivery responsibilities while attempting to compete in a more open market for packages. Expecting the USPS to match private carriers on price, given these mandates and fixed costs, places it at a significant competitive disadvantage.

In my view, the challenges facing the USPS highlight the need for thoughtful structural reforms to level the playing field, rather than a simple division of home delivery responsibilities—which could undermine the efficiencies of a single integrated national network. Like any large organization, the USPS has areas of inefficiency that could be addressed, and government agencies in general would benefit from rigorous audits to reduce waste and improve operations. The agency has reported substantial net losses in recent years (approximately $9 billion in fiscal year 2025 and ongoing quarterly deficits), underscoring the urgency of efficiency gains. However, I do not believe full privatization is the appropriate solution, as it could risk eroding the universal service that benefits all Americans, particularly in rural and underserved areas.

Tankster's avatar

People in BF Nowhere need that Universal Service promise. In private hands, they'd need to pay $25 and drive to get their mail. OTOH, I guess if AMZN can deliver there, they could include that in their bid.

IanDavidLea's avatar

I love USPS I ship from the UK to US and it always gets there on time

RH's avatar

Not if it goes through Kansas City

BobbyD's avatar

Agreed. Two generations of mail carriers in my family would also agree. They complain about the ridiculous bureaucracy that prevents their suggestions for improvements from being heard and the top-down rulemaking that delivers disincentives to efficiency. The systems are antiquated and the workers demoralized.

I visited my local office yesterday to send a simple package. I asked the desk agent to create a label for my package and was told that she could do that, but it wouldn't have the recipients name on it or the suite number of the address; I would have to manually write them next to the new label. I stupidly questioned this and received a scowl as well as an answer with a tone that suggested I was asking a silly question. "The machine won't let me". How's that for an apt metaphor?

Bill Lacey's avatar

Using the Post Office is Trump's fallback plan if the SAVE Act doesn't pass. He's laid out a plan where each state is going to have to submit to the USPS verified lists of voters eligible to receive a mail-in ballot, the ballot mailed will have a bar code matched to their identity and returned ballots will be under the control of Executive Branch officials until counted.

Apparently, he'll be able to do this since the USPS is under Executive Branch control. I'm sure Democrats will challenge this as stopping illegal voting and denying Democrats unlimited power is clearly racist. But we'll see if it come to that and if he's successful.

BobbyD's avatar

This could be a way to get Dems on board with privatizing it so Trump can't have control?

Cranky Frankie's avatar

That's a magic strategy that works for everything these days. Find some angle that Trump won't like and Dems are all over it. On a positive note, it requires little thinking, a process that often gets Democrats in trouble.

Igor's avatar

It should be restructured and modernized, agree. But privatization is a no-go from me. It's a core public service provided by the government and it's not meant to be profitable, it just need to be "reasonable" in quality and pricing. Commercial services at a premium price are already available.

Mike's avatar

Today's USPS is an effigy to the entire Federal Aparatus. .

David Ebbern's avatar

It boggles my mind that the USPS delivers 6 days a week when most of the items are ads. Regular mail delivery 2 or 3 days a week would be adequate, e.g. M/W/F for business and T/Th for residential. Makes too much sense for govt.

Leskunque Lepew's avatar

Currently, the USPS can't do its only job.

J-9's avatar

The post office? Yawn. We knew that fifty years ago. Reader's Digest probably reprinted a piece or two. Chasing it is a waste of time. Even after an economic apocalypse, USPS will be the cockroach that survives Until then, look for Speaker Jeffries to throw billions more at it, with special set-asides for Underserved urban communities of course. With Republican support. Such as from Sen. McCormick (R - Pa.) if he would pause for a moment from pushing for more money to throw down the NIH rat hole.

When Marjorie Failure Scream chaired the so-called "DOGE Subcommittee" of the Oversight Committee as a springboard for her ridiculous Senate ambitions, she ignored the trillions that Elon's DOGE kids were uncovering. She didn't go after Somali daycares or any big EBT or Medicaid scams. She wasted weeks holding hearings on the Post Office. When you're trillions in the hole, reach down between the sofa cushions and maybe you'll find a nickel.

So much to look forward to. "Vote Republican to bring back 59-cent first class stamps."

John's avatar

Have for years believed they should get rid of Saturday delivery. For every 5 delivery people there is another on the payroll to cover their day off. 17% reduction in delivery personnel (and probably more with the back office) with no realistic difference in service.

Walker's avatar

I was just thinking Amazon would be the ideal buyer. But, I suppose there are too many people on the gravy train to ever let it happen.

Tankster's avatar

I thought DeJoy was going to drain that swamp.

Chris's avatar

It takes over a week (in business days) to deliver a birthday card in the mail to my mom who lives a 16 hour drive away…my fatass could’ve walked there and hand delivered it in that time