30 Comments
User's avatar
Cranky Frankie's avatar

Whatever regulation is imposed by government will follow the traditional course. Legislation largely written by representatives of the incumbent industry will create barriers that lightly inconvenience the current crop of industry giants. It will also deeply burden any new entrants to the market. This is because such regulation represents the only way incumbents can survive in an environment where the hardware bought today, like an ice cube melting in your hand, depreciates at light speed as new, better hardware hits the market. A good part of the LLM's code is public or practically indefensible under copyright law. New entrants can just hire engineers, buy land, order GPUs and wire them up, instantly leaping forward because their stuff is the latest and greatest.

Yeah, the call for regulation is self serving. Why else would anyone ask for government to stick its nose in your business?

Branson Edwards's avatar

OK, but in response to both Quoth the Raven and Crazy Frankie here, I interpret Huang as saying the opposite of what Amodei, Altman etc. are saying (arguing in favor of the government allowing them to create monopolies through unnecessary regulation). Nobody believes in the free market anymore, and I agree we no longer have free markets here in the US or anywhere else on the planet because of the merger of state and corporate interests (that merger probably being the best working definition of "fascism"). Free market competition is the only regulation that works.

If we implemented term limits and actually "threw the bums out" every six years or so, corporate capture would be less of the existential threat it's clearly become. I'm with the "open source" crowd suggesting there ought to be countless AI companies, and unilateral AI efforts in enterprises large and small around their own data and workflows. Categorizing the Altmans, Amodeis, Bernie Sanders types, et.al. in technical language (apologies), most of these people claiming the world/ humanity is coming or will come to an end, for whatever reason, are what honest social prognosticators call "assholes", all acting in un-enlightened self interest. They should all be defenestrated along with their "public service" enablers (who also fall into that same social science category).

We lowly citizens only have three levers to pull (other than individually trying to work hard, do the right thing, and mind our own business): voting, and in the absence of that, the 1st and 2nd Amendments. In re: the 2nd, I like Bonaparte's line: "Revolution is an idea that's found its bayonets." Let's hope it doesn't come to that, but so far these people seem intent letting the rest of us eat cake.

Cranky Frankie's avatar

The guy with GPUs to sell would logically want no barriers to the genesis of new customers for his products.

Amgmt's avatar

Your dialectics logic is revealing.

Amgmt's avatar

Altman being the first mouthpiece wayyy back on the dangers of eh aye and the need for regulations (to protect our monopoly) with his multiple government testimonies .

Spider senses tingling ever since.

The Musk Altman rivalry is also a ruse.

DLB's avatar

Translation; Nvidia needs Washington to make it more difficult for others to compete with their dominant position so they can remain at the top.

Those who live in America have to understand that much of our industry left to build overseas, not for tax reasons so much, but more so for the overwhelming amount of regulations that the government created for the last 60 years. If they want the future of A.I. to go overseas, just keep adding more regulations. I'm sure the Chinese would love this.

Mark1's avatar

I keep wondering is it’s to protect themselves from the Chinese, just like we’re being protected from Cineese electric cars and robots.

Amgmt's avatar

One could posit the need to download / offshore all the open models before they are made illegal.

When stripe buys openrouter one should pay attention.

Norb Warnes's avatar

Thank you for articulating the apparent conflict of interest in the pronouncements and opinions from the illuminati and thought-leaders sitting atop every industry silo. The tea leaves aren't clear about any aspect of AI but the risk/reward continuum seems to point to more benefits with increasing development. There is always the danger, however, of unintended consequences. The situation is truly is a conundrum.

craazyman's avatar

I think he's probably right about the engineering. The AI Apocalypse is waay oversold in my view. But that doesn't mean he's not also a shovel salesman. Or maybe even a backhoe salesman.

Other tech revolutions changed physical reality -- from canals changing long-haul commerce, railroads enabling cross-continent transportation, autos/airlines tranforming mobility, telephone/radio/TV transforming communication.

What is AI transforming?

Nothing. It's like a giant encyclopedia that gives you instant tailored answers to your question. That's pretty neat. Not denigrating it in any way. And It's cool to sit at your computer and make videos from text prompts.

But the only thing it really changes is the amount of time people stare at their computers. And on the margin it makes certain business processes more streamlined by squeezing inefficiences.

But does it make anything in the world really new? the way canals, railroads, telephone, radio, TV, transistors and even computers did?

I don't see that. It creates a world where people spend even more time sitting in front of their computer. OK, well TV did that too. So did computer hardware evolution.

But where does it all stop. When the entire population are zombies being tube-fed by machines run on AI where AI handles all farming, mining, manufacturing, distribution, delivery, etc.

This is our future? This is where our "economy" is heading? Of course the market will go up, no doubt until it reaches infinity, and the one person left in reality will be the richest human on earth.

Mezzanotte's avatar

You might be underestimating the extent to which many are planning on handing over control of important systems to AI. That's well beyond just a killer encyclopedia.

Steve S's avatar

The costs of compliance would create burdens and obstacles for small companies and start ups, not so much for established giants like Nvidia already in the market with hordes of cash.

Reader6789's avatar

I have trouble believing anything from someone whose only financial interest is to keep the bubble inflated as long as possible to keep up those daily 10b5 -1? stock sales to the tune of $12-15 million per day according to AI. He only wants to postpone any day of reckoning and have squirreled away the necessary generational wealth to still live high on the hog when the inevitable accounting scandals, SEC investigations and lawsuits arrive imho.

Leskunque Lepew's avatar

Convenience = Loss of freedom.

Currently, I do not need AI.

The Military Industrial Complex, the Medical Industrial Complex and other monopolistic blocs that run everyday life on this gorgeous spinning blue rock we live on, do. They are bent on running the show just like the CCP does.

Better believe it.

I dont think they have us in mind.

ClarabelleVonH's avatar

No company owner ever screams, "Regulate me harder and pull my hair." without an ulterior motive.

Jeff's avatar

Good work presenting both sides. That provides value. Kudos!

Dewey Hildebrand's avatar

Excellent.

With the enormous sums he stands to continue making on the build out there’s zero chance of an unbiased view. Letting the fox tell you how to close the hen house.

The circular financing done and promises of hyperscaler backing also cloud the possibility of objectivity imo.

Herschel Savage's avatar

Good to point out the conflicts of interest, not enough of that nowadays. Judges are obligated to recuse themselves where they have conflicts of interest. But the fiduciary duty of CEOs clearly put their obligations to shareholders first, non-shareholders second. If I'm interested in the moral compass of CEOs, I watch how they treat customers, employees, suppliers, and humankind in general (remember "Do No Evil")? But if I'm interested in custodians of my investments, then I decide on the balance between my willingness to be offended vs my desire not to lose money. If I want Effective Altruism, I have other investment choices. Not looking to Jensen for that.

The Color Of Air's avatar

Corporations have become so corrupt, they will do anything to ensure the profits keep rolling in. Smoke a joint with the prez, buy off congress, or suck out every last drop of consumer privacy.

Yo's avatar

tangent food 4 thought: https://softwarecrisis.dev/letters/llmentalist/

"The LLMentalist Effect: how chat-based Large Language Models replicate the mechanisms of a psychic’s con"

Bill D's avatar

To quote Charlie Munger show me the incentives and I’ll show you the outcomes

badnabor's avatar

Government regulation "for the good of the people" has never happened preemptively. They will name all sorts of reasons why we need regulation, in typical swamp language that even the lawyers will argue about for years to come. Preemptive regulation is always a slight of hand trick to achieve a goal that is far from the talking points. Government regulation that actually is "for the good of the people" only gets enacted AFTER great harm and or death to the people has raised enough outrage to threaten congress' election outlook.

Brian Clavin's avatar

Chris

“ There is something almost comical about watching the man standing closest to the cash register explain why everybody needs to keep shopping.”

Nailed It.