32 Comments
User's avatar
NJ Transit Commuter's avatar

Hard to blame Mamdani for having no understanding of economics, the guy has an Africana Studies degree. I’d bet my house that he couldn’t explain what a debit or credit is, or anything else an 18 year old with a semester of community college Accounting 101 under their belt could explain.

He’s done very well for a 35 year old, so it’s hard to criticize his educational or career choices. The fault lies with NYC voters who elected someone with narrow life experience and a shallow knowledge of how an economy or large organization works…

Leskunque Lepew's avatar

The captured MSM played a huge role is getting him elected.

barnabus's avatar

No, there were tons of former students that were taught sh*t studies at university, who voted for him. Plus many US citizens hailing from 3rd world countries. Democracies are fragile - that's why many European ones collapsed in the 1920s and 1930s, and Latin American ones in 1960s and 1970s.

Kurt's avatar

Being a socialist means the person is blind to second order effects. Rent too high? Rent control! Want higher wages? Jack the minimum wage! The world is comically clear to them. Just ask Bernie.

george's avatar

Smoke and mirrors. Commie is as commie does.

barnabus's avatar

Even Lenin and Stalin developed the New Economic Plan for a short while in the 1920s.

Norb Warnes's avatar

I appreciate the article and its salient points that perhaps Econ 101 is finally making a visit to New York City Hall. My intuition, however, is that the political zeitgeist and momentum that Mamdani and Company have fostered and continue to abet will continue to be the operative model,. What some critic has labelled the new Business Council as performative may be spot on (i.e. window dressing to give Mamdani cover to be able to say "Hey, I'm flexible, I'm adapting, I get it, etc." The Mamdani phenomenon is not an isolated: manifestation of the the tax-tax-tax mentality; that thinking and approach is endemic at all levels of government throughout New York State, especially with the top echelons in Albany. If you want a preview of where New York is headed economically, ideologically, politically look to the great state of California. Raise your hand if you like what you see and shout "that's for me!"

Jeff Harris's avatar

First of all, the “Lesbian Seagull” line was spectacularly funny! Socialism / Communism has and will always fail. Mamdani is a slick bullshitter completely capable of seducing ignoramuses, especially those who were coddled their entire lives and are looking for villains when they discover that life is hard. People in NY and CA should leave and the Federal government should NOT bail out these failed states. Only then will people realize that decisions have consequences and they had better elect competent leaders.

MAD97123's avatar

I can think of one truly slick bullshitter completely capable of seducing ignoramuses who happens to be running the country. No wars and lower prices -slick bullshit indeed.

PETER GUDER's avatar

D.T. Has completely re-written the Geopolitical Calculus. Oil and the straight of Hormuz are no longer the Leverage That Must Not Be Tested . . . but the leverage that failed, like the Great and Powerful Oz behind the curtain. This, and other things, will eventually be realized by the TDS and Mind Virus afflicted.

craazyman's avatar

Mamdani is a predictable 2nd order effect from decades of capitalist class bailouts. The capitalist class (in particular the banking/finance class) doesn't tolerate free markets when they go against it. Only when they enrich it. Per all the Fed policy, pork barrel deficits, and crisis bailouts we all critique here.

What is the difference between Mamdani and that?

Not much, actually. We can mock him but let's not mistake the larger reality here.

It's the millenia old capital-labor dialectic known to the Greeks and Romans as a purely a political force, since they lacked the vernacular of modern "economics".

Economics is just politics adorned with a newer formal language. I'm not sure it says anything new though.

Anti-Hip's avatar

"Mamdani is a predictable 2nd order effect from decades of capitalist class bailouts. "

Agreed. The rises of both Trump and Mamdani are symptoms. Same effects, but different constituencies mean different explanations are sold.

barnabus's avatar

It wasn't a capitalist class bailout. The collapse of real-estate secured credit in 2008 was a government instituted policy.

craazyman's avatar

that probably will be debated forever without consensus. but even if it is true -- where was the risk management? the large firms (if they actually believe in free markets) should have identified the market risks from govt policy and hedged or adjusted behavior accordingly.

but they did not.

Instead, as Citi's Chuck Prince famously said "As long as the music's playing you have to keep dancing."

Oh? Really? Says who? Well, maybe you'll lose business if you don't? But is there a gun to your head? NO. There is no gun.

This was a money grab and they lost when markets do what markets do.

And then they had the gall to invoke "sanctity of contracts" to payout their enormous bonuses after Fed bailouts.

You can't make this shlt up.

Mamdani with his govt groceries and penny-ante handouts for the working class is a bit player compared to the finance capitalists, who have made feeding at the public trough into an art form.

barnabus's avatar

There is extreme amount of regulatory pressure. For example, if you don't extend credit into poor neighborhoods, you are not allowed to expand by buying small banks. But if you can't grow by buying you stay small, and at some point you are yourself bought. And then, no-one needs you, former CEO and you are dismissed. Smart people - smart enough to become a CEO - know this.

Cranky Frankie's avatar

"Success is evidence of a crime."

"...lose an argument with reality."

"Apparently somewhere beneath City Hall is a giant money faucet that previous mayors were simply too cowardly to turn on."

You have learned how to turn a phrase.

PETER GUDER's avatar

You can give an Idiot lessons, but you can't make him learn. The invitees should all tell him to fuck right off - anything else legitimizes the Idiocy.

Leskunque Lepew's avatar

A minority of "Democratic " voters voted this WEF/Transnational gangsters muppet into office. Their captured MSM played a huge part in his election.

New Yawkers had a viable candidate in Curtiss Sliwa who knows the city inside out.

Now they have Mandummy who knows how to use social media but is clueless regarding the city he governs. His lack of experience is showing.....badly.

It will get worse.

ScottyG's avatar

He recently dismissed the board members of the Mayor’s Fund who were in charge of raising money for city programs. He’s going to replace them with true NYC “workers”. This is all performative. He’s surrounded himself with same minded socialist idiotlogues who wouldn’t know how to run a lemonade stand on the street corner.

craazyman's avatar

Performative is right.

But all around.

The NY Wall Street / tech A-team isn't there now -- that's only 'cause they're waiting to see if he's real.

If Mamdani shows real promise for a Senate run or Governorship -- they'll be standing there behind him as he champions some sort of public-private partnership. And he will.

This guy has Barack Obama written all over him.

Communist/socialist my ass. I don't doubt he has some real sympathy for the working class. But he's an ambitious politician and he'll bend and shape to what's needed. I'm not being critical; that's a millenia-old syndrome that has some valid basis in advancing representative democracy.

Corvo Nero's avatar

Yup, take a deeper dive into the entire charade . He wants the name Mohamed to be the number 1 name given to male born children in this country . Just like in the UK . Just more destruction from the inside out and financed by evil once again .

My God , his right hand was on the Quran when he pledged the oath into office ! WTF ?

Ken Braun's avatar

A socialist mayor takes over South Park & gets sued by the Multicultural Business Council. Ten years ago that would have been a hilarious episode.

The Color Of Air's avatar

Yet another failed government (NYC). The only way things can be made to be free is if the taxpayer is further burned at the stake and pays for it...in addition to rising borrowing...which is more debt and a deeper hole.

99% of the DC Cesspool has no clue as to how economics really work. All of these government wankers are putzes devoid of any real world experience.

What is going to happen down the road is that digital control of all money accounts will force taxpayer savings, investments and retirement accounts into buying government bonds to support the Olympus Mons debt mountain that the government is building like clockwork.

The troubles in NYC are one small stone in the ocean of deep state tyranny. Hey, keep voting and you see the results. There is no escape from these tyrants who run on slogans and platitudes more than they do on reality.

Steve's avatar

One business leader told the magazine that five major CEOs declined invitations.

“I know of five major CEOs who said ‘no,’ so this was not the group that they initially targeted,” the source said.

As a businessman, we all know that some things just have to "play out" in order for the "lesson" to be learned. In this case, the mayor will learn nothing, and anything good coming out of this group will be looked at and graded by his voters as his success and that his policies are working for them. I would have helped him, but he'd/it would have had to crash and burn publicly first.

Anti-Hip's avatar

"Mamdani appears to have made an ironic discovery: He needs people who know how an economy actually works to help him."

Maybe you missed the point of his election: He's not interested in running the city; that is, making it operate well. No. He and his ilk, like all true politicians I've ever known, are interested in *controlling* it. That, and the adoration from his crowds of his (idiot) peeps, and his national fame.

Running the city is an annoyance that, maybe, he though he could freestyle, but no matter -- he'll completely turn 180 deg, as needed, and behind the scenes, as needed. Don't get me wrong, he may not even be aware of what he's doing. But *this is who he is.*

So watch out. This guy is slick as f*ck. B. Clinton and Obama have nothing on him.

Tony's avatar

Aren’t New Yorkers pleased with this guy? I’ve only heard of the successes. What specifically has gone poorly because of his decisions?

direwolff's avatar

Another bright side to this council is that perhaps the adults will be able to explain his rationale in an understandable manner. If things go south there, we may also get much needed insight into just how off-the-mark the rationale really is. As it relates to Kevin Ryan at least, he’s a very smart and savvy businessman, and very rational, so I will use his participation and continued involvement as a barometer of what’s happening there (short of knowing what gets discussed in these meetings). If he walks, then that will also say a lot.