26 Comments
User's avatar
Bryan L's avatar

The Robert Heinlein quote is apt here:

Throughout history, poverty is the normal condition of man. Advances which permit this norm to be exceeded — here and there, now and then — are the work of an extremely small minority, frequently despised, often condemned, and almost always opposed by all right-thinking people. Whenever this tiny minority is kept from creating, or (as sometimes happens) is driven out of a society, the people then slip back into abject poverty.

This is known as "bad luck.”

Allan Richard Wasem's avatar

"Time Enough For Love".

Rah, Rah, RAH! Greatest ever!

Read "Starship Troopers" - one of the greatest "political" treatises ever written.

Greg's avatar

You had me at strikethrough.

Dewey Hildebrand's avatar

If the rich are not paying enough, the definition of rich quietly expands until it includes whoever is still around.

Best line and absolutely true. Although the strike through was close.

Money is mobile. Confiscatory taxation leads to flight or fight. You would think there are no history books used by left wingers. The formation of this country was triggered by an oppressive tax.

Davemon's avatar

All Communists work day and night to promote the suffering every man, woman and child. They are quite literally hell-bent on destroying all that is true, good and successful in this world and once you see that it makes it all easier to understand. Run! don’t walk away from NY City and State and all the demonic communist hell-holes. Your life and your ability to live it as free men and women depends on it. Voting with your feet is the best option for anyone who is a productive US citizen. Leave them to collapse under the weight of their own pure concentrated evil.

Andy Fately's avatar

This is all very true. Of course, I couldn't help but laugh at Governor Hocul's recent comments on asking rich folks who have already left NY to come back and start paying taxes again, for the good of the state. It tells you a great deal about the mental illness that drives the liberal mindset that they are able to ignore the obvious to seek their goals which are diametrically opposed to that obvious outcome

ScottyG's avatar

Also, she’s a freaking idiot.

Graham Seibert's avatar

Perverse incentives are indeed perverse. In my case it was DEI.

I quit IBM in 1979 when it was obvious that promotions to management were going to other than white guys. I started my own consulting company.

I folded that company in 1997 when it was clear that the government was directing business to women and minority owned businesses - including Indian immigrants.

I had been pretty productive. I could have continued to contribute to the economy and the tax man. I chose instead to retire.

White guys the world over have been making similar decisions. Changes in incentives keep them from working hard, marrying, having children, leading things like Boy Scouts, investing in real estate, leading homeowners' associations.... The effect cannot be measured, but can certainly be observed.

K Tucker Andersen's avatar

I am constantly amazed at how often incentives( nor only in the economic realm } are either misunderstood or blindly or perhaps even willfully ignored. As you point out, taxes are a frequent subject of such behavior, often because the incentive for short term gain benefits the politicians currently in power and the problems are left for their successors.

Of course the structure of many “ welfare “ benefits are in the same category, as the subsequent imposition of work requirements showed when Clinton agreed to that reform proposed by Gingrich.

The same is true of the majority of corporate incentive plans established by most companies, particularly the ones with public shareholders. They claim that their option plans align the interests of management and long term shareholders, but given the way most are structured this is almost never the case. Management captures the upside in the stock but is shielded from the downside, and often has an incentive to focus on short term results that coincide with expiration of their options to the detriment of long term investments. And if the stock declines , they often simply get their options repriced or sim ply move to a new company and revive a new swath of options. Compare this with a practice that would truly align incentives but is almost never utilized , restricted stock grants based on clear criterial being achieved and which then only vests in tranches over several years.

Imagine how quickly the Federal Budget would be balanced if 50% of our Senators and Representatives salaries were dependent on each FY not having a deficit. 🙂🙂🙂

badnabor's avatar

I don't mean to be argumentative, but Senators and Representatives salaries are just window dressing. A significant bulk of their incomes are derived from quid pro quo sources. Ethics aren't high on their list of required behavior.

The Scratch's avatar

A financial/tax guy told me it was estimated Master Charge had 200,000 accounts set up in the Cayman Islands in the name of Americans, with an average of $200,000 in each account. And that the transactions made in these accounts were off limits to the IRS. Visa is bigger than MC, thus probably even more accounts.

I asked if lobbyists would pass out these cards to politicians and he said it was a possibility. Politicians create the laws that have these accounts off limits to the IRS.

He said his boss would take high net worth clients on junkets to the CI to set up these accounts. Many did this to protect assets from lawsuits, divorces, the taxman, etc.

TimCNY's avatar

My wife and I moved to Florida in 2022 and kept our vacation house in upstate NY. The property taxes in NY are $8,000; most is school taxes. It's a rural property with well and septic. No police force. Volunteer fire. No garbage collection. They maintain the roads - that's it for services. A chunk gets kicked up to the country which funds the sheriff and jail - the biggest budget line item - and social services, of which there are surprising many. Drug addiction and poverty are a big issues in rural NYS.

In Florida, we have better schools at 1/3 the cost per pupil, and total taxes are less than $3,000 for properties with equal market value (~ $400k). New York is completely dysfunctional and getting worse. A decade ago, a low quality politician like Hotchul would have no chance at statewide office. But she's a puppet and probably grateful she made it to governor because she didn't earn it.

Terry's avatar

Didn't Earn It = DEI

Matt's avatar

As someone who has lived in one of the low tax states you mentioned for 20+ years (NH), please move somewhere else. I wouldn't live in Mass or NY if you gave me a house and paid me to do so. Votes have consequences, keep the dysfunction isolated

Steve S's avatar

Surprised New York and Massachusetts haven't passed an Exit Tax, that is a tax of 50% of a person's net worth consisting of a total of the value of all assets, realized or unrealized, plus all gross income before all credits, deductions, and exemptions. The tax would be payable if net worth was greater than $3 mllion, upon change of residence from these states to any other state. The legal challenges to such a tax would become great entertainment and fodder for betting on polymarket and kalshi as to whether the challenges would be successful.

Leskunque Lepew's avatar

IMHO....Mandami is a WEF sock puppet that was chosen by low turn out and a bevy of useful idiots who may not be eligible voters.

Mandami is another arrow into the destruction of the framework of this country. The US Socialist party ( formerly the Democratic party) is aimed at destroying the very principles of the constitution. Sadly the Republicans are not much different.

I do not consider the current administration as Republican. Its more third party. This is why the Transnational gangsters are trying to sabotage the actions of the current administration with they're main weapon, the captured MSM.

Mandami is part & parcel of the assault.

Greg Brophy's avatar

Here's the scary part. It's entirely possible that the people who think like this and implement these policies will be fully in charge in 2029. To where do you escape when they do this nationwide?

craazyman's avatar

If it's 4% **after** $1 million, there will be people who already believe they make enough. And they won't care. There is no incoming asteroid from this. It's frankly pretty trivial.

These people tend to be empathetic and altruistic, and they understand they got lucky somewhere along the way. And yet, in that weird symmetry between good and evil -- they also tend to be most prone to political psychosis.

They don't understand why anybody would have a problem taxing 4% AFTER $1 million. If you can't live well on $1 million, really, you have some serious psychiatric issues. Really. And if you can't look at somebody digging ditches for $15 per hour and think "You know what, if my 4% can help him eat I'll feel good."

That's all good on paper. But when the revolution actually comes -- those are the people holding the clipboards in the concentration camp. ecce homo

fab's avatar

What keeps me awake ; The USA thanks to its federalism offers alternatives but I have the bad feeling that, give it another crisis and a decade, Congress will look like Cali ; 70% liberal supermajority. Then alternatives will be cancelled.

fab's avatar

They are coming for the money. 5 % wealth tax on the ballot in Cali this November. Also what they can't account for is the money that could have come but will not ; people check the cost of government "services" before moving somewhere.

David “Cow” Gurney's avatar

Blackbird, 

      Your post last week that Mamdani is a f***ing moron was exactly right and that the fundamental failure of socialists/communists is math and economics.  Fascinatingly, they imagine themselves highly intelligent, but insist upon connecting the dots between human nature and altruism.  There are no dots between human nature and altruism!  This is where they invoke force upon free people.  Damn them.  WE ARE FREE MEN, NOT CHATTEL!