Yes, of course it could. I think the central problem here is a problem of language.
What is "government"? And how is govt decree enforced?
Wherever a group of people exist together, there is some animating organizing principle. Across history, when tribal members defy that principle, bad things happen. Organizing principles such as totems, taboos, clans, castes, priestly rule, shaman rule, or warrior states. there is always an organizing principle that constrains behavior.
That seems to me is what a government is. There is no individualist utopia anywhere in human history. There is always some organizing principle. Unless you're a religious hermit living in a tree in the desert (nothing wrong with that! just an example).
Part of the problem is when a 'government' has enough power to overpower neighboring lands and cultures. In my experience, differing cultures can rub shoulders within a city peacefully (not always!) as long as they respect each other, and no government inserts its own 'oversight'.
Kevin Muir at Macro Tourist has a perspective on MMT worth considering. He notes that so much of what they say, such as the proscriptive parts of MMT, should be thrown away out right. However, he has concluded that they have the best description of the modern monetary system, as it is. Not what was. Not what should be. What is actually happening. Specifically, in the modern system, that the government can, with enough will, spend money into existence. He notes that MMT accurately described the fiscal response to the onset of the pandemic.
So I am not surprised that MMT is probably wrong about the history of money. The origins of money are outside the realm of current fiscal practical reality.
Golly, reading this article leads me to an even more modern MMT creation having no store of value, no medium of exchange, no existence: TADA, that would be BITCOIN, a virtual, nonexistent thing, resting upon real Block Chain accounting and a guarantee that total existence will never be increased. Please, help me to stop laughing!!!!!
We need to have a discussion about what money actually means to us. A store of value. A means of exchange. Or, a method of controlling people. Apparently the latter is what applies at the moment. It would be quite nice if the former were reinstated.
I don't think these two views are irreconcileable. Consider a local tribe in ancient Europe during cave painting era -- 40,000 to 15,000 or so B.C,
The local culture evolves a barter system where something easy to carry (like medicinal herbs or paint pigments) becomes widely accepted as a proxy for any tradable good. In effect, it becomes "money".
Then let's say some ornery people decide they don't want it. OK, the merchant can refuse sale. OR the tribal leaders get together and say "Look, Fred Flinstone, you've gotta accept this because that's how we run the show around here. Put it this way, it's an offer you can't refuse. Either that, or hit the road."
Well, Fred thinks "Oh man, either accept the herbs and pigments or I have to take my whole dog and pony show over yonder beyond those mountains where the barbarians live."
so Fred bucklles under.
There you have "government enforcement". That's not implausible. Eventually when the tribes become big enough they need some organizing system that can lubricate trade and economic activity. If everybody wants their own private money, then it's like everyone speaking their own private language. It would never work.
OK, so the gold bugs say "gold is money". To some people it is, but maybe in a truly free society not to others. Everybody has to agree on a universal financial language for the society to function -- you can call that language "money". And if you want everyone to participate for the good of the group, you can call that "government fiat."
Both the MMTers and the money arose from barter folks can be correct here.
As a mental exercise, consider whether an economy, including money, could exist where the is no government. My answer is, yes, it could.
Yes, of course it could. I think the central problem here is a problem of language.
What is "government"? And how is govt decree enforced?
Wherever a group of people exist together, there is some animating organizing principle. Across history, when tribal members defy that principle, bad things happen. Organizing principles such as totems, taboos, clans, castes, priestly rule, shaman rule, or warrior states. there is always an organizing principle that constrains behavior.
That seems to me is what a government is. There is no individualist utopia anywhere in human history. There is always some organizing principle. Unless you're a religious hermit living in a tree in the desert (nothing wrong with that! just an example).
Security is a strong motivator to organize a society.
Part of the problem is when a 'government' has enough power to overpower neighboring lands and cultures. In my experience, differing cultures can rub shoulders within a city peacefully (not always!) as long as they respect each other, and no government inserts its own 'oversight'.
Wouldn't value be more important than money if government did not exist?
Value and money can have an equivalency, especially if governments don't muck it up with fiat currency that they control.
Kevin Muir at Macro Tourist has a perspective on MMT worth considering. He notes that so much of what they say, such as the proscriptive parts of MMT, should be thrown away out right. However, he has concluded that they have the best description of the modern monetary system, as it is. Not what was. Not what should be. What is actually happening. Specifically, in the modern system, that the government can, with enough will, spend money into existence. He notes that MMT accurately described the fiscal response to the onset of the pandemic.
So I am not surprised that MMT is probably wrong about the history of money. The origins of money are outside the realm of current fiscal practical reality.
Golly, reading this article leads me to an even more modern MMT creation having no store of value, no medium of exchange, no existence: TADA, that would be BITCOIN, a virtual, nonexistent thing, resting upon real Block Chain accounting and a guarantee that total existence will never be increased. Please, help me to stop laughing!!!!!
What is the most significant unit of society? The State or the Individual? Your answer will then determine your view of money.
We need to have a discussion about what money actually means to us. A store of value. A means of exchange. Or, a method of controlling people. Apparently the latter is what applies at the moment. It would be quite nice if the former were reinstated.
I don't think these two views are irreconcileable. Consider a local tribe in ancient Europe during cave painting era -- 40,000 to 15,000 or so B.C,
The local culture evolves a barter system where something easy to carry (like medicinal herbs or paint pigments) becomes widely accepted as a proxy for any tradable good. In effect, it becomes "money".
Then let's say some ornery people decide they don't want it. OK, the merchant can refuse sale. OR the tribal leaders get together and say "Look, Fred Flinstone, you've gotta accept this because that's how we run the show around here. Put it this way, it's an offer you can't refuse. Either that, or hit the road."
Well, Fred thinks "Oh man, either accept the herbs and pigments or I have to take my whole dog and pony show over yonder beyond those mountains where the barbarians live."
so Fred bucklles under.
There you have "government enforcement". That's not implausible. Eventually when the tribes become big enough they need some organizing system that can lubricate trade and economic activity. If everybody wants their own private money, then it's like everyone speaking their own private language. It would never work.
OK, so the gold bugs say "gold is money". To some people it is, but maybe in a truly free society not to others. Everybody has to agree on a universal financial language for the society to function -- you can call that language "money". And if you want everyone to participate for the good of the group, you can call that "government fiat."
Both the MMTers and the money arose from barter folks can be correct here.