Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Crimson Possum's avatar

As someone who has successfully used heroic doses of psilocybin to help me break free of crippling anxiety, I remain skeptical. This is just my personal experience. Psilocybin breaks down walls, in a sense. We all develop rigid patterns of thought, conscious and subconscious. When those rigid patterns are maladaptive, they create depression and/or anxiety. These patterns are virtually impossible to recognize, and even with an expert therapist helping us to identify them, they are just as virtually unshakeable. Imagine trying to understand what you look like in a world with no mirrors or reflective surfaces. Now imagine trying to correct your facial deficiencies with self-guided plastic surgery. That's the closest I can come to explaining it.

Psilocybin can shatter these ingrained patterns of thinking, creating brain plasticity, and allowing new patterns to become established. One must be careful about what is offered as a new "format" at this point; replacing one set of maladaptive behaviors with another can do much more harm than good.

This is to say that psilocybin is not a silver bullet. It may be (for some, or many, or even all--I only have my experience) a new opportunity for beginning. For me it was a key that opened a door to possibilities.

I say I am skeptical about the prospects for its long-term success because the vast majority of people are unlikely to put in the effort or make the hard choices required to find that new roadmap of thought. My suspicion is that much of the early reports of success are due to self-reported wishful thinking.

My 2 cents. I hope I am wrong, because it was a crucial piece of my puzzle. I'd like it to be available for others, even if it ultimately helps a minority.

Marty Weil's avatar

The Big Pharma lobby won’t go quietly. It’ll take a high-profile medical breakthrough and a strong advocate to push through this barrier. JFK’s presence is a help but he’s not going to spend political capital on it.

14 more comments...

Ready for more?