19 Comments
User's avatar
craazyman's avatar

It seems to me trading has been taken over completely by 1) "can I resell it for more?" as opposed to 2) "how much is it worth?".

#1 has competely taken over market psychology. Nobody seems to ask about fair value or even try to figure it out. I don't watch any market TV coverage but I almost never hear about it: What's fair value? What LT assumptions -- growth, margins, GDP, earnings, etc. etc. Just crickets.

Maybe AI nirvana is the one nod at predicting the future. Oy vey.

The value players have gotten run over and given up. It's been this way for years. There is going to be -- at some point -- a classic Wily E. Coyote moment.

By analogy -- you buy a house for $1 million that rents for $50,000 for a 5% return (ignore expenses to keep it simple). Then it gets bid to $1.25M, then $1.5M, then $1.75M. do we hear $2M . . . sure! why not! Bingo. $2M. Why not $2.5M? Why not? Bingo. $2.5M

US stocks are Chinese property from a few years ago. That bubble was so obvious for years, but it didn't burst until finally it did.

Quoth the Raven's avatar

Excellent perspective and well said.

"It seems to me trading has been taken over completely by 1) "can I resell it for more?" as opposed to 2) "how much is it worth?"."

Tankster's avatar

Definition of a Sardine. Hold it only so long as a Bigger Fool wants to relieve you of it. Squeeze it and it pops into his hands.

Bnim85's avatar

Earlier this year, I mentioned to a coworker that made a lot of money on NVIDIA that maybe it made sense to sell some or buy some puts to take some risk off the table, looks like I’m the dumbass. I honestly don’t think there is a price high enough for him to sell. Markets only go up, buy the dip and never sell. I wonder if there is a price low enough for him to sell…

Mrs Bucket's avatar

Are all the old sayings out of date? eg, 'The man who sold early never went bust'.

Tankster's avatar

Meanwhile $NVDA has an evil cousin, CoreWeave that they supported to get it's IPO off the ground. Just a short time ago, CoreWeave leveraged quickly depreciating GPUs as collateral to raise debt equal to its previous valuation, amounting to $2.3 billion. Methinks something is rotten in the state of trade. CoreWeave puts are as expensive as the stock, so I'm not the only one.

Tankster's avatar

Moving to penny changes in price was the worst decision ever made. The "democratization" of the market (why doesn't it trade 24/7?) has resulted in turning it into a gambling, er gaming parlor, gamified by HOOD, and apps that are more similar to Fan Duel than Think or Swim. We can't even see metrics like PEG, Current Ratio, stochastics, and many other technical analysis on HOOD. But they do clear my deposits for trading instantly...

Tankster's avatar

Oh yes and one more thing. I guess all the fuss about HFT and gutting buildings on the west side of Manhattan to build data centers that can make and spoof orders in 30 milliseconds to move millions of shares a penny, thousands of times a day doesn't matter anymore? Knight Capital lost $500 million in less than hour by doing that. I guess that's peanuts to the WSB Redditors squeezing $GME with calls, cost Marvin Capital $2 billion so $HOOD shut trading for a day to allow the screwees to regain their footing and wipe out the WSB crew.

Steve S's avatar

Whenever I've tried to gamble on meme stocks I've taken a loss. Problem is it's a short term trade and I'm not a day trader, not even a 5 day swing trader. On July 15th when OPEN was trading at $1.04 I almost bit. It was a sane gamble, heavily shorted, technicals looked good with 8D EMA above the 21D EMA, 5D EMA above the 13D EMA. Problem is you get greedy when the position spikes and fail to bail, expecting your 3 bagger to turn into a 10 bagger. So I never entered the trade. OPEN peaked at close to $5 on 7/21, now trading at $2.26. I would have bailed when it doubled. Oh well, next time, maybe not.

Steve Mudge's avatar

I've been wondering what the hell is going on since housing exploded in the early 2000s where I was living in San Clemente, CA. I'd just gotten old and experienced enough to get use to the rhythm of the 'old' business and real estate cycles...hah! take that! How long can it go? Japan, which has preceded the US in aging demographics and is REALLY in the debt hole has been able to string it along for decades--granted probably kept afloat by global debt spending. And I'll say this, at least the money they've printed has gone to a lot of nice infrastructure, a tangible asset. What do we have to show for $37 trillion? Oh, lower taxes!

WesternSky's avatar

The market might not be efficient. But that doesn't mean most retail investors will ever make any money over the long term trying to time their way in and out of stuff. "Trading" is mostly just a gigantic waste of time for probably 99% of retail investors. Even just "tactically shifting" in and out of this or that etf sector most retail investors will get wrong. They will get in too late, out to late and waste gigantic portions of their lives worrying about all this crap and trying to learn about it. None have any edge. But wall street fee collectors, picks and shovels sellers in the financial biz, etc... will laugh all the way to the bank.

george's avatar

You can buy low, I find I get in a little too early and dread the doldrums. As Gold went up, I bought and sat on SBSW since last year , watched it go down, bought more, it went down, I bought more then said what the heck am I doing? I now wish I had bought more and it's the getting out that becomes the question.

Allan Richard Wasem's avatar

You're not "early". As far as investment is concerned the market has been debilitated/deranged/dysfunctional since the GFC and the decision by the Deep State to trash Bretton Woods and destroy the middle class (the basis of any civilized order in the world) in order to bail out the .001%. At that point "iacta est" - and the juggernaut of the mother of all speculative bubbles is set in motion. Now we see the Endgame - "No Exit" except hyperinflation or depression.

David Wilson's avatar

YOY I'm up 59.86 percent and you would think that I would be dancing in the streets. But I tell you I'm about as nervous as a long tailed cat in a room full of rocking chairs. I usually don't hold many positions longer than a couple of days and I'm hedged liked a mofo. I got my finger on the trigger because when it blows it's gonna slaughter some people. When? WhoTF knows. Right now I'm just grinding day after day shaking my head.

george's avatar

I would say nervous is probably an understatement if it's like me. "Sell High," they say. haha

Average_Geo's avatar

When I started my hand at trades back in the 1980's, it cost me a percentage of the trade to make it. In the 90's fixed price trading was a thing and it was still ~$20/trade. Now it costs basically nothing to make the trades. It is no wonder we have the market that exists today.

I am just sitting on the sideline with these recent "meme" stock trading events and watching the mud being slung around to see how many institutional investors can end up with mud on their faces. I find it hilarious in some ways, but the more it is happening the more concerned I am getting with the down the road effects and how it may ultimately crash my personal investments.

Gone are the days of casual focus on my investments...

Wild times indeed!

Dean Whiting's avatar

A good column and I feel the forces described will be ignored until it’s too late.

Mrs Bucket's avatar

Markets are definitely not normal, fair or efficient and it's not just meme stocks. The Trump Tariff Tantrum early April MASSAGED MASSIVELY by the media saw colossal drops of big and small, and since then the S&P is up 30%+, madness. How much of the designer panic was program driven down and back up now to record levels? It cannot last.

Mark Heywood's avatar

You can also throw bitcoin into the mix, talk about what craazyman said, bit coin is the ultimate "can I sell it for higher?" as intrinsically it is worth nothing.