40 Comments
User's avatar
Tim's avatar

These debates have been done to death by now. Schiff engages in them for publicity, same reason half his tweets are about bitcoin. Good engagement.

Tokenized gold still has the problem of: trust and centralization - why hold a promise to a bearer asset when you can hold the real thing, which goes back to golds other problems - portability, verifiability, divisibility, etc.

Regarding intrinsic value, monetary premium is a large portion of golds value, if gold were to reprice to its industrial and cosmetic use, price would be significantly lower.

Anyway, I guess just buy both.

george's avatar

Gold remains when the grid collapses.

badnabor's avatar

Exactly, physical precious metals are the superior asset. IMO any physical asset with an actual value of use is superior. BTC is just a digital equivalent to a Federal Reserve Note. The valuation is based faith in a technology as opposed to faith in nation's promise of value. I don't claim to understand the technology, but with the burgeoning claims of AI capabilities, personally, I can't afford faith to an "asset" that could be vulnerable to loss once encryption begins to be compromised.

Tim's avatar

Code can be verified and does not require faith.

This would be like saying I don't understand science but I have faith we won't be able to convert copper to gold at low cost.

Prabir Talati's avatar

👏🏻 The key difference! 🔥

Allan Richard Wasem's avatar

Gold has been MONEY FOR OVER 3000 YEARS MINIMUM. Apparently humans are "hard-wired" to utilize it, and it alone, as such. As J. P. Morgan said: "Gold is Money; everything else is Credit". And now "Fiat Debt" - no intrinsic value whatever.

Tom's avatar

Yes, I think the main advantage of Bitcoin over Gold in terms of value independent of speculative demand lies in counterparty risk assessment and self-custody characteristics. Arguing that a tokenized Gold could do the same thing doesn't deal with reality today. As it stands, this does not exist to my knowledge. Whereas for Bitcoin you can self-custody without the same pitfalls that self-custody of Gold runs into (cumbersome in travel, more risk to seizure/theft by an attacker, laborious process to verify, etc).

There are certainly trade-offs and self custody/ownership of Bitcoin is not without its own risk profile. But for now, it does offer something Gold cannot. Ammous may have had missed an opportunity to address Schiff's point here during their debate.

badnabor's avatar

The state of Texas is currently in the process of implementing a gold backed, transferable alternative. A deposit of your personal physical precious metals in the Texas Bullion Depository, to my understanding, will be made transferable by issuance of a "tokenized" representation (much like a debit card) of your account's current value. The practicality of this remains to be seen, but it shows promise.

Shelly Exline's avatar

Agreed, “monetary premium”, specifically USD. All the layers. Tokenized gold has only the value given, and trust re: whole SLV futures debate. Schiff argues that BTC stability and security as well as fractionability have no bearing. BTC continues to hope that it will remain unhackable and find a way to be useful for common transactions.

Both are still largely servant to the great USD.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Apr 7
Comment deleted
Tim's avatar

Gold is a bigger ponzi until proven otherwise. It's been even more years.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Apr 7
Comment deleted
Tim's avatar

Can you elaborate? It's not really something that can be fixed.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Apr 7Edited
Comment deleted
Tim's avatar

It's no different from backing the USD with gold.

Unless you can zap the gold into your possession via the blockchain, it requires trust and a central authority / custodian, same as my OP sad.

Putting something on a blockchain doesn't magically solve any of the problems gold has in the digital age.

Better ditch the blockchain and ship the gold, that way you have custody, you just need to verify it is real.

Vishal Agrawal's avatar

The tokenized gold point hurts Schiff's case. The moment you tokenize gold, you reintroduce everything Bitcoin was designed to eliminate. Custodians, trust, seizure risk, auditing. You're bolting blockchain onto a system that still requires you to trust Tether or Paxos to actually hold your gold

Mark Heywood's avatar

Right, it might make your holdings useful if you limit your tokenized gold while still getting appreciation.

The Radical Individualist's avatar

I'm a reasonably intelligent, experienced, rational person. And I still don't get Bitcoin.

Allan Richard Wasem's avatar

Chris - wasn't aware of the Debate - thanks for bringing it to our attention. As he has been for DECADES - Peter Schiff is absolutely right about Gold and Bitcoin (digital "nothingness") as he has been about EVERYTHING (MAN DESERVES A MEDAL!). A (purely speculative) price and no "value" whatever.

Mark Heywood's avatar

Great podcast debate, I had not seen this before either. Thanks for sharing.

David Saggau's avatar

Will block chain survive the coming quantum age? Tokenized anything may not be secure.

Eric Reasons's avatar

I'm a goldbug, and my "debasement trade" stance is comprised of around 90% gold, 10% BTC. But listening to the debate, I don't hear how every argument laid against BTC's value can't also be leveled against Gold's value. Both derive their value from being a store of purchasing power. Gold doesn't "do" anything more than BTC does. It just has a longer history of holding the role.

Second, tokenized gold still has the same counterparty risk with whatever entity is holding the backing metal. Schiff knows this, and Ammous dropped the ball by not immediately rebutting the claim.

Still, I stack both. I'm growing bored of watching the Sound Money crowd engage in a circular firing squad when we should be trying to spread the gospel to the unwashed fiat masses.

Steve S's avatar

What gets me about this debate and all those who debate the values and pricing of gold and bitcoin is the negativity towards bitcoin. Those who argue for bitcoin don't have negative things to say about gold, they don't attack, but are put on the defense from the outset because it is bitcoin that is being attacked. From a debating platform posture, being put to defense from the outset is a losing position. Best you can do is demonstrate bitcoin has both value and pricing, but gold remains untouched because Ammous wasn't attacking gold, whereas Schiff was attacking bitcoin from the outset. It was like watching an MMA fight or boxing match where one fighter A is on the attack and fighter B never attacks, just defends himself. Best Fighter B can do is survive and come to a draw, but without attacking can never win.

Shelly Exline's avatar

Good point. Most bitcoiner I know simply don’t want to be bothered with gold. They see it as a different class altogether. I don’t see us going back to using physical metals as a mode of exchange. Nor as it stands BTC. I mean, maybe btc? But it would need a reframe.

fritzy_boo_boo's avatar

To me gold is more a fallback position. For example if the currency starts breaking. Right now you might have a nice induction stove but if the electricity goes down it might be nice to have some matches and wood. And if the s*** really hits the fan you need to have the physical gold. Because in my opinion there's a lot more paper gold out there than there is actual gold. Tokenized gold has some issues in my opinion. You are relying on somebody to count the actual gold to create the tokens. Tokens represent the gold. Bitcoin is not a representation. It is the thing.

Bitcoin is more in the camp of can we improve money. Can we control the money supply so that we don't have crazy inflation. Can we stop governments doing what they always seem to do. Can we make money faster and more permissionless.

And I would argue that neither has great intrinsic value. Or the intrinsic value has a lot to do with how much society has broken down. Neither can sustain life like food shelter and water. But gold would definitely beat Bitcoin if society really breaks down. I don't expect that.

So if society doesn't completely break down The value in Bitcoin is just a better money. And if you look at the trajectory of history we have been continually improving money. From shells to gold to promises of gold and probably well managed Fiat. Although with all money there will be attempts to game it. So in my view people pay for Bitcoin because it's just a better form of money. That's the value of it. It's the same reason people hold dollars over a lot of other foreign currency. And for the last 15 years people have paid this premium for Bitcoin and a lot of money has been made. But I think this will gradually slow down and people will just hold Bitcoin because it's better money. But it won't be this great investment. Of course this all hinges on it continuing to be better money. Just like the dollar must maintain itself as better money if it wants to be a global reserve.

So I'm a fan of Bitcoin but watching it closely. It needs to maintain or expand its adoption. It needs to maintain its integrity in terms of money supply. It can't be hacked by something like quantum computing. There are a lot of things that it needs to continue to do.

MR's avatar

If we only consider value for uses other than money, then maybe bitcoin is worth nothing but gold is worth next to nothing. How does Schiff’s central argument not apply to gold? The price is $4000 but the value is $150. Why would I pay that? Just because something has a little bit of residual value after the monetary use is wiped out doesn’t make it better money. Money is the use we care about. There must be value in the monetary use case or they are both massively overpriced.

Studlyshoe's avatar

Bitcoin and Gold and Barry Bonds Rookie cards are all the same thing. They are priced at what someone else will pay real DOLLARS for them.

The biggest advantage Gold has over Bitcoin is a longer PR campaign. It was a gift to Jesus in the Bible.

In the book of Genesis, they make the most important things out of gold.

An opinion could be made that Lead should hold a better value (not price) than Gold. As it can be used to defend and protect life. It’s always funny to me Gold and Lead are next to each other in the periodic table.

Matt Cook's avatar

You can make any number of crypto coins; there's no scarcity whatever and bitcoin is really a lousy crypto coin. There are much better ones. It's tulip bulbs all over again

Makakoa's avatar

Tokenized gold would still be inflationary.

Schiff's argument that there could be an alternative Bitcoin is nonsense. The genesis of bitcoin (complete decentralization) would be nearly impossible to replicate and it's first-mover network effect would be too much to overcome.

Shimon's avatar

With tokenized gold, one has to trust the issuer. If Tether decides that you are a bad person, Tether can not exchange your tokens for physical gold. You have to trust the issuer (Tether) not to do that. Bitcoin is a trustless system and merely having the coins in an address you control is ownership (similar to having gold coins in a physical wallet).

Gold has real world uses, but those uses are suppressed by gold's high price. As a result, nobody suffers if gold's price increases greatly. A metal that is really useful in many different use cases, like copper, cannot be used as money because the monetary use suppresses all other uses.

Dnevermore's avatar

Gold and silver are the only money that retains value independent of governments. I think the reason is that God reserves it for Himself. Haggai 2:8 “The silver is mine and the gold is mine declares the Lord of hosts”. Bitcoin I think will prove to be Satans money. Useful and as good as any fiat as a tool but in the end its value depends on lies and deceit.

Steve's avatar

The gold vs Bitcoin argument is a bit tedious. People have their convictions but as the old Old El Paso commercial says "Por qué no los dos?"