32 Comments
User's avatar
Rick's avatar

The psychopathic Netanyahu, who funded embryonic Hamas so that there would never be a Palestinian State, and who has been screeching about the boogey man Iran for 40 years, has sent the world into a cataclysm disaster. His lapdog, Zion Don, willingly followed his master’s dog whistle. Now we have a massive pile of shit plopped on us, once again. For what? For AIPAC campaign donations.

Bill Petersen's avatar

His faith in experts is is unfortunate in light of the now obvious facts , exposed by the war, that Iran was building an arsenal if increasingly sophisticated and longer range misfires, along with progress towards building the bomb. Such capabilities in the hands of lunatics who have preached death America for decades was unacceptable. Trump is not the first to recognize the problem. Every president since Carter said leaders in Congress as well spoke about the threat. It was politics that let it fester and grow. Trump said enough. Imagine this intervention has the result Reagan’s polities towards Russia that ended the Cold War.

Roger's avatar

Iran has not attacked other countries, but has been attacked multiple times. Yes, they do fund proxies, but so do we. We have screwed around in Iran many times starting with the overthrow of their elected government in 1953 and the installation of the brutal shah. They have every reason to be angry with the USA. Their development of advanced missiles was a smart decision given they were attacked. If they had not, they would have been immediately crushed. If the nations of the world learn one thing is nuclear weapons command respect and caution by aggressors like Israel and the USA. We should just leave the ME and stop fucking around in other peoples disputes.

Mark Heywood's avatar

Iran should have been dealt with years ago. Next Hamas needs to be wiped out completely. Yes we need to get out, when it's finished.

fab's avatar

You're free to go. The Don is asking for help.

Wade Burleson's avatar

People would prefer counter-arguments of substance. Not ad-hominem comments. Your singular comment against Mark Heywood caused me to follow his newsletter - not yours. :)

fab's avatar

"Hamas needs to be wiped out completely" , ha, ha, the epitome of a substantial argument, something akin to the Wannsee Conference.

Alfalfamale's avatar

" ... the worst military disaster in US history." " ... no military options beyond ... the use of nuclear weapons." When did QTR start publishing such obviously false garbage?

craazyman's avatar

If the state goal was regime change -- and that's what it was said to be -- Ron Paul is correct. Iran has largely rallied behind institutional power structures. There are 90 million Iranians. Physically changing the regime would likely involve: 1) a U.S. draft, 2) creation of a 2-3 million invasion force, 3) 12 to 18 months of preparation, 4) WW2 style casualties in a ground war OR nukem into a parking lot.

If it's more complicated than regime change and regime change was only part of the psy ops -- well, OK. That's not entirely unusual in geopolitics. I suspect that's how it will be frame in hindsight. I think the odds of a national draft and 2 million invasion force are zero. and U.S.A. use of nukes is zero.

So it's a Clauswitz Moment -- diplomacy by other means including rhetorical strategies, psyops and strategic air strikes. that's where we are.

Will it work? No matter how it ends up it will be said to have worked. that's luxury of being a superpower, even your mistakes are victories.

Steve S's avatar

Regime change had nothing to do with Trump's objectives in finally retaliating against Iran for its decade long attacks on Americans abroad. The objectives were to degrade and destroy for the time being Iran's ability to develop nuclear weapons and long range ballistic missiles, and at the same time put existing regime leadership in the grave. These goals have largely been accomplished, with minimal loss of American lives. Israel has borne the brunt of attacks from Iran, which was anticipated.

craazyman's avatar

Nothing to do? I mean, this is just a comment section for a blog but even for a blog comment section (where we can bloviate whatever we want) that's a really hard comment to engage with. If that's your personal opinion, OK, no worries, it's your right. But the regime change motivation was all over the internet from mainstream media all over the world. I don't have a hotline to President Trump so I can't say from personal knowledge. Here's just one:

"President Donald Trump said Tuesday his goal of regime change in Iran is complete—while also saying he doesn’t know who the new leader is—continuing his renewed optimistic rhetoric regarding Iran, despite continued strikes and reports of new deployments to the Middle East."-Forbes

https://www.facebook.com/forbes/posts/president-donald-trump-said-tuesday-his-goal-of-regime-change-in-iran-is-complet/1314116890578298/

Steve S's avatar

The regime has changed. The old leaders are in the grave.

James's avatar

Meet the Director of the Ron Paul Institute.

https://i.imgflip.com/anq9sc.jpg

CamperCO's avatar

It was an amazing read right up the the word "experts"... I am a former employee of one of the "experts" so I can expertly claim there are no experts there.

Peat's avatar

You break it, you own it

William Gary IV's avatar

QTR, I understand your respect for Ron Paul. His Austrian economics and sound money advocacy are spot on. But, this is not. Ron’s non-interventionist POV would leave the US utterly vulnerable to global forces. Iran is a Rook on the chess board… powerful, but limited to move only for war and violence. The Queen is where the leader’s son holds $170m in property… London, and more specifically, the City of London. This is the controlling Harlot that holds the world hostage using her Rooks and Bishops (castles and robes; warmongers and religions) to keep humanity under her sway. Trump is removing the Rook. The Queen’s hand (Starmer) has exposed her position, and DJT called her out. For real education in this Great Game, follow the ladies at Promethian Action on YouTube. They understand the board and DJT’s plays to empower the White teams players. Lastly; pray. “Thy Kingdom Come, Thy Will Be Done, ON EARTH, AS IT IS IN HEAVEN”. Amen.

rtko's avatar

It’s time for J.D. to take the reins and to take Trump to a padded room where he can’t do any more harm. All the campaign promises he’s gone against are easily found but his reasoning for this catastrophe has not been expressed.

Trump, the guy who was gonna end the Ukraine war and put Lindsey Graham in his place. I really don’t want the dems to win in November but Trump has almost guaranteed that with this fiasco.

Will the dems win in 28 and open the borders to all the refugees we’re creating with our pals in Israel. If that happens, Trump is to blame.

The Radical Individualist's avatar

Is a war that has claimed only 14 service member really a war?

The Vietnam war claimed an average of about 50 per day. And that's nothing compared to WWII.

And I've heard enough about "Mission Accomplished." That was a banner on a ship that wasn't even about Bush. Every time I hear the expression, it reminds of how clueless some people are. It's right up there with "Hands up, don't shoot."

Jace Files's avatar

A different take on the situation (scroll down to global energy crisis section)

https://www.coffeeandcovid.com/p/the-leverage-plan-saturday-march

Charles K's avatar

Most of you dunking on this opinion by Paul don't get the position we put ourselves in. The Iranian regime's missile and drone capabilities give them effective WMDs and this is what they've threatened to do.

They can render the whole region unproductive and/or uninhabitable. This would be globally catastrophic. We have a mutually assured destruction situation, except one side thinks they can win - the exact scenario (nobody can win) that keeps nuclear arsenals from being used is broken here.

It doesn't matter that the Iranian regime is evil, the only winning move we have is to not play the game.

Harley Oien's avatar

Dr. Paul should make an Rx for himself and just fade away. He never proposes a fix to any problem, only doom porn!!

Bill Petersen's avatar

More to my earlier comment: The UAE is a peaceful country of some 11 million people. I was not aware that the UAE has had to deal with far more missiles, drones, etc. from Iran than Israel has — in fact, more than Israel and all other countries combined!

The UAE has not attacked Iran, so what justifies this? What major threat is the UAE to Iran — other than a business competitor? It appears that Iran is attacking the UAE, as it’s a small neighboring prosperous Muslim country with a lot more freedoms than in Iran — and they don’t like the contrast.

Reading between the lines here, this appears to be more clear evidence that Iran is little more than a terrorist state — even to peaceful Muslim countries. But draw your own conclusions.

Steve S's avatar

I appreciate the nonsense from Ron Paul was reprinted for satirical purposes.