14 Comments
User's avatar
WBev's avatar

Thank God the Libertarians defeated the Nazis in WW2!

Oh, wait...

Allan Richard Wasem's avatar

Too bad you don't know any History. The Japanese attacked us first (Pearl Harbor) and then Hitler (pursuant to the German-Japanese Security Treaty) declared War on the United States (although technically, under the terms of said Treaty he was not "required" to). In the case of both countries, therefore, the US was waging a "defensive" war - which was supported by that period's equivalent of contemporary Libertarians. In addition, Libertarians today definitely support the concept of National Defense - just not the unprovoked attack on other nations - which is what the current Iran conflict is.

It would clearly not be a good idea for you to attempt to have a rational argument with a contemporary Libertarian - it would be like an unarmed man facing down a Mossberg 12-gauge at 10 yards.

WBev's avatar

SO KNOWLEDGEABLE!!! Please tell me more!!!

I intentionally did not say that the USA declared war on Germany or Japan.

I DID however say that we beat the Nazis and that was not a defensive action. The USA could have easily just defended our shipping and homeland without sending troops to Europe, leaving Europe's problems to Europe. I believe that Mr. Paul would have voted that way.

The USA sent troops TO Europe, which makes it OFFENSIVE.

Next time aim before you fire.

And by all means make sure to be as insulting as possible again. That makes arguments SO MUCH more compelling!

Allan Richard Wasem's avatar

I'm not going to bother trying to debate basic meanings of words with you. Keep talking - you words are my best argument. I won't respond further - I don't waste time with fools.

barnabus's avatar

Come on, USA was putting an economic stranglehold over Japan, particularly in terms of oil supply. With Germany, the USA was basically arming Britain and then also Soviet Union for free.

It is all a consequence of split government (President & Congress). In a parliamentary system where the government by definition enjoys parliamentary confidence, declaring war is much easier.

Allan Richard Wasem's avatar

Never said that the US didn't provoke the Axis powers, particularly Japan. Just stated facts.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Apr 3
Comment deleted
Allan Richard Wasem's avatar

Lol - there are no "easy answers" - particularly not now. there are only "hard" choices.

Kirk the Captain's avatar

Always interesting that the Libertarians profess to hold a "high ground" from which judgement is issued. Yet they never hold the responsibility of leadership.

Bill Petersen's avatar

It's sad that his attractive libertarian ideas are increasingly taking on a tone (not substance) of James Carville.

badnabor's avatar

I agree with Dr. Paul...in principle. The sad fact remains though, just as there are disagreements between co-workers, neighbors, families, etc., there will always be disagreements between governments. It is an unavoidable evolutionary trait of our species (survival of the fittest). The subject matter of the conflict is almost irrelevant and almost always ushered in through subterfuge. It boils down to establishing a pecking order. The government's abuses of liberty, to perpetuate tribal compliance, are not a side effect, but a historically standard feature.

Leskunque Lepew's avatar

Interesting.

Mr Paul glossed over many things regarding the Transnational captured MSM.

By the way, the income tax was implemented during WW1 to finance it. Mr Paul claims it was WW2.

IMHO..I find it hard to believe Ron Paul wrote this.

Marcus Chuicus's avatar

He said income tax "witholding", about which he is correct.

Allan Richard Wasem's avatar

Trump appears increasingly "unhinged". Typical narcissist who doesn't get his "way". Much more of the current insanity and it will be necessary to invoke the 25th.

hepps's avatar

Isn't part of the "Public Interest" responsibility "equal time?" That applies to campaigns but could also be considered to apply to issues as well. I'm not a lawyer but my first thought was in this direction rather than censorship. This is where Kimmel got crosswise with the government.