43 Comments
User's avatar
Marty Weil's avatar

Zohran Mamdani victory is only the latest step in a project that began a century ago. The seed was planted the 19 20s. In 1921 the League for Industrial Democracy opened its New York office and started mailing socialist lesson plans to public-school teachers while comrades in the New York Teachers Union pressed the same line from inside the classroom.  

Once voters were primed, operatives moved into Washington. Treasury official Harry Dexter White leaked Bretton Woods drafts to Moscow; State-Department lawyer Alger Hiss steered post-war diplomacy until VENONA decrypts exposed him; the Rosenberg ring delivered Manhattan-Project blueprints that ended America’s nuclear monopoly.   

Driven from Europe, Frankfurt-School exiles set up shop at Columbia in 1934 and reframed Marxism as “critical theory,” training a professoriate that taught the teachers. Their shock-troops, Students for a Democratic Society, exploded to 300 campus chapters by 1969 and graduated straight into newsrooms, law firms, and public-sector unions.  

Michael Harrington’s new Democratic Socialists of America rejected third-party quixotism and burrowed into Democratic primaries. Membership crawled until the Sanders wave; then it rocketed from roughly 6,000 in 2015 to more than 95,000—enough canvassers to dominate every low-turnout race they target.  

Armed with those cadres, the movement captured leverage offices—district-attorney posts, city-council seats, state legislatures—and finally New York City’s 2025 Democratic mayoral primary, where 33-year-old Mamdani upended Andrew Cuomo on a socialist platform of rent freezes, city-run grocery stores, and universal free buses. 

The lesson. Every generation secured a chokepoint—schools, federal agencies, universities, a major party, then the nation’s media capital—ratcheting policy until independence looks cruel and state dependency feels inevitable. Mamdani isn’t the beginning of the danger; he’s proof that the long march is inside the gates and heading for the White House next.

craazyman's avatar

You really ought to ask yourself: why does his message resonate?

Why did Russia have a revolution?

People don't wake up, make the espresso, make an omlette, look out the back window across their deck, the lake, the boat, ready for a day of country living, and say "You know what, honey, you know that revolution we've been talking about? How about we start it today!"

"But we're sailing today, aren't we? I packed a lunch!"

"I know, we talked about sailing but we do that all the time. We lay out by the pool, we garden, we watch movies in our entertainment room. The lake is always there. Let's have that revolution . . . "

Nobody does that.

Revolutions are made by very unhappy people. why are they unhappy? Mostly because society largely doesn't work for them. Not every one, for sure. Some are natural troublemakers or political grifters looking for a mob to lead. But why would a message like Mamdani's resonate?

Please Chris/QTR -- think and write a post on that. Even the founders thought about that, hard, and they made a list, all the things that made them revolt. And they wrote " all experience hath shewn, that mankind are more disposed to suffer, while evils are sufferable, than to right themselves by abolishing the forms to which they are accustomed."

It's not a thing to take lightly, seizing the means of production, risking your life by revolting. Why the heck doesn't this guy get laughed off whatever soapbox he's on?

Answer: There is a lot of pain out there, and a lot of it is honest pain. I've learned that lesson in life: there is a lot of luck to being "successful". Not if you're an NFL player, or a rock start. But for most of us, we need luck. Not everybody gets lucky. And there isn't much of a soft landing.

Quoth the Raven's avatar

I've been saying for years, there's a major growing wealth divide in the country for sure. But this is a monetary policy problem that no one wants to talk about. A third rail. The sick thing is Dems push even more abusive MMT ideologies that would only speed up the widening inequality gap. I understand people being unhappy. Ignoring the real problem and aiming to usher in communism isn't the answer.

The Radical Individualist's avatar

And yet the poor in America are better off than ever. Am I supposed to feel sorry that we can't all afford a fifty million dollar wedding in Venice? I frequently point out that rich people blowing money that they could have left in the portfolio advantages the very people who complain about them doing it. Where did that 50 mil go? To restaurants, maids, gondoliers, gift shops, florists, dress makers and on and on. I'd say it all worked out fine. I have a bias. I've done work for very wealthy people who didn't really need to spend the money. God bless 'em.

The 'poor' are not rising up in unison as a result of oppression. They are rising up because of a well coordinated effort by RICH people to use the useful idiots to gain power, which they use to their own advantage, not the poor's.

Illinois Entrepreneur's avatar

I don't think there as many "poor" people as the Left likes to whine about.

When you have a cell phone, internet service, a car, car insurance, housing, streaming subscriptions and can afford to eat out once in a while you are not poor.

The poorest people I see are the ones who have drug problems, a disability or mental illness. They certainly deserve our compassion, but let's be honest about who is "poor" and who is not. The vast majority of our society is nowhere near poor.

Don C.'s avatar

Now with THIS I agree completely!

craazyman's avatar

I don't think anybody is rising up in today's USA. It's just do a fraction of voters decide "you know what, after rent and healthcare every month I'm broke. I can't save anything. I'll never own a home. I can barely afford a car. I'm one accident away from complete destruction. Maybe I'll give this guy Mamdani a chance. See what he can do. Maybe he'll make my life a bit better"

I live in a red state in Appalachia. There's alot of money here (part time residents) but a lot of low income people.

Some of the low income people here are my friends. Believe me, they work hard. Two jobs. Night shifts. They're good people. The deserve better than what they get.

The Radical Individualist's avatar

That's the problem. "...give this Mamdani guy a chance." Would they "give a brain surgeon guy a chance" to save their child? Complex issues need more than giving a guy a chance. Mamdani is no surgeon in any sense of the word. He will destroy whatever he touches. The first step in solving any problem is to understand the genesis of the problem.

I live in Cincinnati. There is a large Appalachian population going way back. Like any culture, there's the good and the bad. But I love their overall self-reliance, which parallels my on outlook on life. Only one person is responsible for making sure I have a nice life. Me. That's true of every adult, with the exception of a relative few who are physically or mentally disabled. And they should do what the can for themselves, for the sake of their own self-respect.

Speaking of self-respect, how much self-respect do the Mamdani supporters have? Have you noticed that there is not a shred of personal pride, no desire for accomplishment, only a childish desire to be taken care of. It's strange to talk in terms of what we should do to help them, when they are the problem.

craazyman's avatar

No disagreement "in theory". I appreciate you're not a one-note Charlie on free markets. I appreciate you are a thoughtful guy. I wouldn't be here if you werent! I suspect the mainstream Dems are tacitly (or even overtly) supporting this guy. He's out there beating the bushes, riling up the base, pulling in disaffected voters. Could be a mid-terms get out the vote tactic.

Maybe they'll trot out some kind of guaranteed income. That likely will get lots of pushback, but I was out mowing the lawn and thinking about the 20th century. Early union movement pushback was extreme. Unions were gonna destroy the nation, it was un-American!, should be thankful for the job alone!, etc. etc. Violence, beatings, murders, etc.

I doubt we'd have had decades of post WW2 prosperity without them. So many 10-, 20-, 30-baggers in stock market, all due to middle class prosperity.

Would a guarenteed income cause inflation? Like MMT is supposed to? Well? What about supply response? What about entrepreneurs, small business formation, etc. What about cultural differences versus Mises' Austria from 100 years ago?

I my view this stuff gets really really complicated. Really complicated. Ideological lenses in my view often distort more than they reveal. Just my two cents . . . nothing more.

Illinois Entrepreneur's avatar

What does that mean, "...society doesn't work for them?"

craazyman's avatar

Looking globally across history, it usually means the perceived quality of life become so low that they risk death to make it better. Often absolute poverty/hunger are triggers, but sometimes it's relative poverty/hunger.

It can be relative. The US founders weren't peasants, mostly aristocrats, but they rebelled anyway. Not everybody agreed, some thought they were nuts.

Rebellion is an pyschologically interesting topic, per Albert Camus' THE REBEL. It's a very high dimensional psychological/political space.

Denis Cowley's avatar

First off, this dude is just running for the mayor of a town. What's the big deal if he screws them up? The saying goes, "The cure for high prices is more high prices." Well...the cure for fucked up leadership is a more fucked up leadership and once people truly see things don't work, they will change. NYC needs this type of convoluted, fucked up leader in the very worse way. Something shocking and stunningly stupid to bring them back to reality. Fingers crossed he wins and delivers on every promise...that will be a taste of reality that won't rinse out of the mouth any time soon.

Illinois Entrepreneur's avatar

I love this post, because it's so true. Moderate socialism just delays the inevitable hard socialism and then communism. If it happens faster it makes it easier for Democrats to connect the dots and perhaps learn some things about economics.

It's too bad that we have to turn the real world into a classroom in order to demonstrate it to them.

Soujourner's avatar

"Dragons" arise, they spew their fire toward their perceived enemy, while their tails damage the citizenry they pretend to be fighting for....nevertheless, they continue, over and over again. These patterns!

One of two things might occur: 1) NYC will empty out and refill when someone sane finally takes over or....2) the insanity will take hold and spread throughout the cities, competing with the oligarchs as they degrade the US Constitution in order to concentrate power. Either way, it's just a matter of time before the bubble bursts (my goodness, look at Germany! They are 'saying' they are going to rearm and go after Russia, with a country filled with migrants, a printing press and while they are in deindustrialization because they have no cheap energy....because, well 'green') as they torment their citizens with more extreme censorship.

What we are witnessing all around us is the most extreme display of boasting whose parent is PRIDE!

Crimson Possum's avatar

Agreed. It will be especially instructive if and when the government literally attempts to seizes the means of production at the point of a gun. That's never been tried in a country that has more guns than citizens.

Don C.'s avatar

I agree with you to an extent. The difference between the state of the city at the moment versus how the city was under Mayor Giuliani is DRAMATIC. I moved away in '06 because I could see the writing on the wall, but this guy will create something entirely new that I can't even imagine, and then HOW do you fix it?

Bill Lacey's avatar

Take a look at what Democrat-run government looks like in New York. Garbage not being collected regularly, street takeovers by aggressive youths, a filthy, dangerous transportation system, the homelessness and drug addicts everywhere, store items locked behind plexiglass due to unpunished shoplifting and sky-high taxation while simultaneous running billion dollar budget deficits.

So, what does this Mamdani guy propose? More government! Including running the government-owned food stores!

"Hey, you know the rat-infested, crime-riddled, urine-smelling subway system? Let's duplicate that. Only this time with food!!"

And there are New Yorkers falling for this stuff? Good grief.

WesternSky's avatar

When the US spends trillions on forever wars that do absolutely nothing for Americans at home but bury us deeper into debt. Create more debt bailing out wall street. To the point $1 trillion goes to interest annually on that debt. But nothing gets invested back into the USA. The most expensive healthcare in the developed world. Rediculously over priced housing. You can see how the masses start to be open to this guy's loony crap.

Moody Millennial's avatar

I know people who work three to four part-time jobs where I live. The average rent is $2,000 a month for something decent. The average price for a house is now $550k where I live.

Only about the top 10%-20% of the population are in the stock market and own enough to make a difference.

Even with insurance, a regular doctor visit costs around $200. That doesn't include extra specialty care someone may need, depending on particularly health issues or surgeries.

The Radical Individualist's avatar

When has government seizing the means of production ever failed? Every time, that's when.

Check out Venezuela. Check out Cuba. Check out early Russia/Soviet Union. Check out China, which is now relatively affluent because the CCP has backed away from absolute control.

Oh, and check out Animal Farm. I wonder how many people who voted for Mandani have read it. Clearly, none of them understood it.

Moody Millennial's avatar

How well read do you think the typical American is with history? Poorly. I remember talking to someone from Romania who hated the government with fervor because her parents were killed during a time of communist rule. She came from an affluent family. She's now an orphan.

Mark Heywood's avatar

Mamdani, Cortez and Omar should have a threesome in the bed of WTF.

Dena's avatar

I think the dems are so desperate for a win that they’ll back this communist if they think he can win & then perhaps try & control him. Ha! The something for nothing crowd is easy to manipulate. I hope you’re wrong that the dems win in 2028 if they stop this guy.

Jim Brown's avatar

“Seize” means to take by force. That is violence.

Mark's avatar

Thank you for you thoughful and direct criticism of the threat that Mamdani represents.

I don't understand, though, your connection of a Mamdani defeat to a deserved return of the Democrats to the White House in 2028.

Cranky Frankie's avatar

"Seizing the means of production" might have had currency in the smokestack days of the late 19th Century but today's economy is about knowledge. You cannot seize the brains of those creative enough to start a business. Even the locations of businesses is a subject for debate as online selling ostensibly occurs in servers located all over.

Mandani will maybe get a store or two open, struggle to keep them staffed and stocked, declare victory and blame capitalist pigs when they eventually fade to black. The merchandising emphasis will be on what elites think poor people should be eating so you can imagine how that will go as an enterprise. Shoplifting won't be a problem because nobody wants to steal spinach. Meanwhile the bodegas whose proprietors are good at stocking what their customers want will survive.

This, too, shall pass. His votes are women who fantasize about him and college educated whites who need to assuage their guilt about their privilege, so long as that privilege is not forfeit. Mandani, if he wins, will be displaced in four years by the next shiny object coming down the line.

Randy's avatar

Yes, this, too, shall pass, but not in 4 years. The USSR was born in December, 1922, and died in December, 1991 — 69 years later. No one alive when communism collapsed in the Soviet Union could remember pre-communist Russia. Will anyone alive in 2094, 69 years from now, remember that New York City used to elect its leaders?

Cranky Frankie's avatar

The Bolsheviks took the capitol after an armed civil war. I don't see that in NY if for no other reason than the Mandani crowd is deathly afraid of firearms.

Tankster's avatar

Loved Nobody wants to steal spinach. What's the difference between parsley and uh, you know? Nobody eats parsley

Burnt taco's avatar

This not about just his commie philosophy or the useful idiots , the AWFLs, the brainwashed students carrying Palestine flags and becoming a pestilence in their own right. This is about the Crusade of Islam against The Judeo-Christian western democracies. Witness the utter and complete shitshow in the UK, France, Germany, Sweden, etc. the anarchy of the jihadists is fed by their desire to subjugate all non believers into poverty and despair then ultimately to death.

He is the tip of a ruthless spear beginning to show itself in the US. Even Texas is not immune- Epic city is their proposed sharia law state within a state.

Economics and disenfranchised lower classes feed their takeover.

Trump happens to be the civil answer to the corruption of class warfare for now, but give these Muslim Brotherhood acolytes an inch and they will burrow under your skin.

Obama started all this and now we have to fight it with all we are.

They want us dead, and our future generations enslaved.

Do not fuck around!

Leskunque Lepew's avatar

And.....who is financing this?

Tankster's avatar

Ask Mondavi: What's the difference between Capitalism and Communism? In Capitalism, one man gets rich off the sweat of the brow of another. In Communism, it's the other way around." That being said, consider the enthusiastic demographic he's rallying. Under 30. What have they witnessed? The GFC, with Hank Paulson walking over to Congress with an $800 billion bailout of the people who almost brought down the system. Obama did -0-. He would have been a hero if he had appointed a then-sane Giuliani to investigate and fully prosecute the perps—instead, Dick Fuld and Repo 105, off Scot-free. Angelo Mozillo made $470 million in stock sales of Countrywide and was fined $60 million, rather than serving time in prison. Conde Nast ranked Mozilo second-worst on their list of "Worst American CEOs of All Time. Diamon, Ken Lewis at BofA.

Then a string of excrable FED people. Including Geitner, Ben "I don't see any contagion" Bernanke, Kashkari, Kauffman, Yellen, and now Jay Pow, all going on to make millions giving speeches and then working for the entities they "regulated." Zero interest rates for 10+ years, causing untold enrichment of the top .1% Read Rudy H about all that.

That's just a sample of the Fuckery perpetrated on people by the "system," and Crony Capitalism. I get it, and we're doing nothing to offer them a reason to not listen to this Commie Jihadi. I thought they were mutually exclusive. Say and do anything to gain power, just like every politician I've seen since I raised $25 selling campaign swag for HHH in 1968 in 8th grade. Outsiders trying to get in get crushed, although Trump is a force of nature, like Taz. He got in and turned the GOP into his party. More spending, more debt, clumsily killing energy and R&D (ask Doomberg). We need millions of immigrant farmworkers, and when crops start rotting in the fields, maybe we'll get it.

What a revoltin' development this is--Chester Riley (and The Thing).

Steve Mudge's avatar

Democrats and Republicans rearranging the deck chairs on the Titanic. I question why a moderate candidate doesn't seize the disparity but this schizophrenia may be unconscious, a rebellion to a country losing its way. That and no sane candidate would try and right a sinking ship (not from an iceberg but because of debt).

PETER GUDER's avatar

". . . . shouldn't have Billionaires . . . ". These Morons never think that we shouldn't have parasites, layabouts, grifters, thieves and "victims". Although many Billionaires share many of these traits, for every Billioniare there are millions of Scumbags who do much greater damage to society than the Billionaires do.