24 Comments
User's avatar
The Radical Individualist's avatar

There is no shortage of one-sided tripe online, but this one takes the cake.

Ian's avatar
Apr 21Edited

No. You’re wrong. There are some moral absolutes and one of them is that wars of choice are evil, destructive, and a result of deep moral, intellectual, and character failures. It is clear from economic research that they do not generate nearly as much multiplier effects as endeavors of peace, like infrastructure spending. But we have had for many decades now a flailing empire bent on world domination at the expense of its own people and those it chooses to do war with.

The Radical Individualist's avatar

Anything that people disagree on is not absolute. That's Critical Thinking 101.

Speaking of critical thinking, there are a multitude of thought questions concerning what a person would/should do if they encounter a situation in which they can save one person now, but it will cost dozens of lives later. To look at an immediate situation without considering the before and after is dangerous and pointless.

Iran, in 47 years, has killed hundreds of thousands of people. Left to its own devices. it would continue to kill more hundreds of thousands in the future. How many lives should be expended today to save all those lives in the future? There is no solid answer, but to not even consider the question displays ignorance.

Ian's avatar

I would like a source on your figure of Iran killing hundreds of thousands? I wonder how many Israel is responsible for by comparison?

Also, do you purport to be able to predict the future, or you know someone who can? Your supposed logical premise rests entirely on the ridiculous assumption that you or someone else can accurately predict the future.

The Radical Individualist's avatar

Evasive answer. I responded to you, now you respond to me.

Or not. No one has to continue this conversation. But I won't let it be one-sided, so don't bother trying.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Apr 21Edited
Comment deleted
Ian's avatar

You’re hilarious bro. Made me smile, and that’s worth a lot.

Mrs Bucket's avatar

10000%. Mises is the same old defeatist, leftist poison dripped into ears to make our civilisation weak and ripe for destruction. 'Not our war' mentality meant the US entered WW2 late, and that cost vastly more young soldiers lives than if they'd dealth with Japan years earlier; it was very clear after mass Japanese atrocities in China in 1936 that this enemy had to be defeated, properly. The same blind spot is happening in New York right now.

Charles Larkin's avatar

We should have bombed Tehran in 1981 after their wretched kidnapping of Americans for over a year. Also, Regardless of how far along Iran’s nuclear program goals are, the US did not have a choice in this matter - Iran’s stated goal has been to fund terrorism and the “death to America” chant has gone on long enough. Should ee wait until after they have a nuclear capability? Offensive war? America hasn’t had a choice and it took 47 years but this is a defensive war. Get some perspective!

Steve S's avatar

George Ford Smith clearly isn't fond of Trump, or of Israel, but has nothing ill to say about Iran. I wonder why?

Mrs Bucket's avatar

Just plain stupid perhaps?

Leskunque Lepew's avatar

Well....that's one way of looking at things.

Here's another....

Riyadh is about 900 miles from Tehran. As the overseas sourced hyper sonic missile travels, that's a blink of an eye.

Would Sunni Saudi Arabia tolerate a nuclear Shi'a Iran?

Once again US & Israeli military are doing the Saudis dirty work and the thousand yrar old Sunni/Shi'a rivalry continues on with deadlier weapons.

Mrs Bucket's avatar

My enemy's enemy is my friend. And a delicate position for the Saudis being that close.

The Color Of Air's avatar

..."the sky’s the limit, at least until people wise up or the ink runs dry on its printing press."...neither have any chance of happening. Most people seldom learn (the nature of being human) and the Fed's electronic Pesos from Heaven spigot will never run dry. As long as there is electricity.

Throughout history, governments have proved a million times that they love murdering humans...many times their own citizens. Virtually all governments proved that during the fake covid pandemic and that wasn't even a real war.

Jim Johnson's avatar

this guy is clever in his recounting of history. he should be somebody's propagandist. real life is/way that simple. he might try working through the counterfactual (always wanted to use that word) cases. what if Lincoln had not responded to Ft Sumpter provocations, issued the emancipation? same exercise for most of the awful things the US has done.

zaporozhe's avatar

If The Republic has an original sin, it was the Spanish-American War.

PETER GUDER's avatar

War, the 'Politics of Last Resort' - where Immovable Object meets Irresistible Force. Walking away takes TWO. It was ever thus.

fab's avatar

The world will revolt against the USA. Because they start to understand a concept dear to the USA : taxation without representation. Very well educated people all over the planet have their lives depend on the vote of some guy, proud citizen of Pétaouchnok, who may not have finished high school (ca 40%).

https://ofy.org/blog/the-high-school-completion-crisis-why-40-of-teen-students-dont-finish-high-school/

Jm1129's avatar

No governments, all of them bleed the nation. Wars are just another excuse

Mike's avatar

I never thought I would say this. But I agree with Pete Buttigige. We showed our hand and its a weak one.

God help us if we ever have to go all in.