22 Comments
User's avatar
Cranky Frankie's avatar

Out of the outrageous $100 billion spent across higher education Harvard gets almost 10%? How many hundreds of colleges are there in the US? That alone is reason enough to cut them off.

Dewey Hildebrand's avatar

Excellent point. I’m fine with cutting them off. On one of the above comments, if it’s research, then let them apply for funding specifically for that research and assure the money goes there. I have no issue with that. To continue to fund colleges, many which already have large endowments from alumni, is not the best current use of our dollars.

American Psycho's avatar

and how much of this endowment money is tied up in silly private equity / private credit 'investments.' I listened to a Gundlach interview and he mentioned Harvard, with a 60+ BB endowment just raised 2 or 3BB to fund their overhead. In a different story he talked about setting up a distressed asset fund many years ago and was meeting with Stanford's investment team to pitch them on the deal. They loved the opportunity but could not muster $10MM to investment despite having 10s of BBs in AUM.

cfrog's avatar

Connor makes a fair point but....research, especially physics and medicine is an exception. It is too important to the public good to leave to entirely private funding. I do think the Federal government is right to 'force us to pay' by funding research in these areas. There is a significant material benefit from these programs, outside of any political or cultural debates. Reducing or re-evaluating percentages per research program? That's fair and perhaps neccessary. If you want to lean up a research program, funding cuts can do that without eliminating the research. Discipline a University? But to lump all funding in the same bucket is like saying every part of the cow is the same when it comes to making dinner. You can get rid of the hoof and undertail soup; me...I'll keep eating filet with a smile.

cfrog's avatar

Fair enough. I was basically saying that, while I don't think you are naive, your comment was very naive. Universities are learning institutions. Learning means education and research. Research is a big part of post grad education. Thus, sometimes, oftentimes, research is just as important as undergrad education. In addition, in the 'market', universities that gain and retain a bright reputation for research can attract top tier talent (and students). So Universities will of course 'gun for the best grant rainmaking talent'. It's good business to continue both public and private funded research. That leads to a virtuous loop with the University being able to maintain good undergrad and post grad programs.

Coco McShevitz's avatar

But why does research have to be done at universities? I thought the purpose of universities was to educate kids. Why not leave it at that and if the government wants to fund research, establish research-only institutions funded by the government? It is ridiculous how universities gun for the best grant-rainmaking talent, knowing that most of those people will do little to no actual teaching, leaving it to graduate assistants and untenured adjuncts. When you conflate the mission of education with the mission of bringing in the sweet sweet grant money you get our current Frankenstein situation.

cfrog's avatar

Are you new? A huge part of university graduate programs is an efficient way to facilitate research and education. Yes, in the past, in the present, and in the future, we have Bell Research Labs....where did/do they get their people from? Reality is a harsh mistress.

Coco McShevitz's avatar

New to what? I really have no idea what you are trying to say here.

Andrew P's avatar

Basic scientific research is almost totally dependent on government grants, and it is done almost exclusively at universities. Some is also done in government labs, but the university research is necessary to train the graduate students who will eventually go to work for the government and industry.

Of course, there are lots of graduate students who will go back to China after they graduate, and do we really need to be paying to train their scientists?

American Psycho's avatar

I work in an academic research lab and what you say is true. Most all fundamental research is funded by the government and there could be a discussion about the appropriateness of that funding. I will say that graduate school, at least in my experience, is populated with way too many students (foreign and domestic) who see it as an extension to their undergraduate studies or a buffer between academia and the 'real world' and do not approach it as a full-time job where they are trying to obtain the highest degree possible in their field. The graduate programs (in natural sciences) could probably be cut in half and no one would notice. In fact, cutting these programs might make them more efficient.

RKO's avatar

And least we forget, the Feds were more than legislatively accommodating to the student loan lenders by exempting student loans from being discharged through bankruptcy…

Mick Connors's avatar

I tend to agree that all federal funding should be stopped. Yet, the bigger issue is how much this exposes how much our politicians get absolutely dog-walked by Israel. Whether it’s because they’re paid off, blackmailed, pressured or some combination the Zionist lobby has way too much power. They’re cracking down on free speech for the sake of a foreign country. It doesn’t matter what you say about the US, but you better not talk about Israel!! The Zionists use the exact same identity politics and victim card as the woke left, except they have way more power. Anybody that isn’t completely partisan can see this plain as day

Andrew P's avatar

Harassing Jewish students and blocking them from entering classroom buildings goes far beyond "free speech".

Israel and the Palestinians are waging a tribal war. These kind of wars can only end with the total extermination or total ejection of one side or the other. That is fine, but don't bring your war here. If you want to support the Palestinians, grab a gun and travel to the Middle East to fight.

Mick Connors's avatar

Retarded, pampered take. “Go fight in Palestine” because I don’t want Zionists to keep restricting free speech in America on behalf of a foreign country? The whole narrative that first amendment should be nullified because Jewish students are being harassed is pure propaganda. There’s plenty of open Muslim hate speech and harassment as well as all kinds of tribalism. No special rules and treatment for Jewish supremacy

Leskunque Lepew's avatar

"The Zionisr lobby has too much power"....take off your blinders and look again.

Tankster's avatar

What's the first rule of the Endowment Club? You don't spend the endowment. During 2020, I don't think any school touched its endowments to help bare ends meet, and some still charged full-bore tuition to provide half-assed virtual programs. That piece of paper with the Harvard logo is worth a lot of money in the Real World, hence all of these weekend MBA (Married But Available) programs. Ben Hunt wrote excellent commentary on the financialization of the piece of paper. Clear eyes, full heart, can't lose.

Brandy's avatar

Exactly what I have been saying. I don't care if they agree to every bit of it. Our money should not be going there. Period.

Branson Edwards's avatar

I agree with your basic pemise that taxpayer student loan guarantees and federal funding of universities should stop, period. I disagree with this one small part of your overall argument: you say that loan guarantees drove student "demand," allowing universities to increase prices. I say, and Grok just backed me up with some figures, that through 2000 most of the increase in student demand was baked into the increased wealth and preference of boomers/ early genx to educate their children as they were educated. From 2010 to today college enrollment is essentially flat. What student loan guarantees did was just allow an explosion in price and obscene expenditure on administrative bloat (369% from '87 to '12 while faculty only grew by 69%). Most of this is also contained in your arguments, so I'm not arguing against you, or the basic truth you point out: the outsized funding of universities and student loans by the feds is a corrupt giveaway, has turned the universities into non-productive vote farms for the establishment (mostly for Dems), and has hurt the U.S. and our children immeasurably.

James B's avatar

Liked the headline. Now I’ll read the rest of it.

CRBY's avatar

funding for STEM should be retained but subject to way more scrutiny so it is not a money laundering operation. No grants for anything else unless if is in the interest of national security. tax exempt status? hell no. these institutions are not simply educating- they are indoctrinating. tax dollars cannot continue to be used to undermine the very system that generates the tax dollars those school use to destroy the fabric of our country. And the contributors lose their charitable deductions. the schools will very quickly change their currricula.

Steve Mudge's avatar

Sure, cut the blindly sent money to wealthy universities but don't throw the baby out with the bathwater---so much progress has been made by public financed research, research that is necessary but won't be supported by private money. SpaceX didn't just appear with innovations out of nowhere, it was built on the back of decades of reach and innovation by the public sector. Its fashionable to trash the government as wasteful but having the public sector proceed into research where investors fear to tread has had a lot of payoffs. Its really the best of both worlds where the government initially sets things in motion and later when sufficient progress is made it can be handed off to the private sector.