Discussion about this post

User's avatar
balazs's avatar

I'm a physician (internist and nephrologist). I have been practicing medicine for almost 20 years now (in Europe mostly). Here's what I have been thinking about lately. If you read the Medscape Survey for physicians' compensations for the US, you can draw some interesting consequences:

https://www.webmd.com/corporate/press/20230413/medscapephysicians-compensationreport

The average physician had a salary of 262k in the US in 2023. It looks like a nice sum of money, however, you get a completely different picture if you consider the details.

1. medical school is 3 years of college and 5 years of medschool in the US. So if you are lucky and start at 18, you finish at 26.

2. The average collage graduate from med schools has a debt of 200k when they start their career: https://www.forbes.com/advisor/student-loans/average-medical-school-debt/

3. Then you have residency. Residency in the US means you work 100 hour work weeks and earn 30k a year for 6-8 years. So this adds another 8 years to you basically losing money, which means you start actually earning anything at the age of 34.

4. So you are 34, most likely your 200k student loan is now MUCH more because of high rates (6-14% right now) AND you have been working your ass off for 16 years (8 years of the hardest universities then 100 hour work weeks for another 8 years with next to no pay), you have no sex life, no private life, you are either never married or already divorced (this is my case, actually). Now you start making money. You make 262k. Except this is before taxes. Since most states in the US have a progressive taxation system, and you are a high earner, most likely you lose at least half of this to federal, state and local taxes, insurance fees, legal fees, board membership fees, training costs, etc. Let's say you keep 130k. That is a little over 10 k a month.

5. However, you still most likely have your student loan debt, which most likely increased VASTLY since you left med school, since you were making 30k a year for 8 years AND rates are now 6-14%. If rates remain this high, I don't think its an exaggeration to suggest that your average trained doctor after finishing residency will look at a 500k debt pile by the time they start working as a trained doctor. I mean, at 10%, a 200k debt is increases by 20k in the first year, 22k in the second, and so forth, after 8 years, with a geometrical sequence you are looking at 389k on your student loan alone, supposing you didn't take out a loan for something else, like getting a car, helping with your living expenses, medical training fees, etc. etc. You obviously have to start paying this back. If you want to pay back 500k over a 10-year period, given that only your rates on this are about 10%, you will have to contribute AT LEAST 100k a year to pay it back in 10 years. So you pay 50k on the 10% rate and another 50k to decrease the principal, now you paid it back in 10 years. Well, also you only have something like 30k left to live on, but hey, you are now used to this lifestyle from your 8-year residency, so Status idem, as we say in Latin.

6. Hooray, you are now out of debt in 10 years. You are 44, still no sex life, still no private life, no wife, no kids, but now you get to keep your whole 10k salary a month for yourself. Except you are burnt out, haven't had a partner in 20 years, biologically you are 60-70 years old because of the 26 years of non-stop work and struggle, you don't have a house, you don't have a car. Good luck starting your life!

Is anyone wondering why we see reports like this?

https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/medscape-physician-burnout-and-depression-report-burnout-worsening-depression-increasing-301732504.html

You see everyone I ever talked to kept telling me if I want to make it big, I should go to the USA. Well, given the consequences from the above calculation, I think I'll stick to my locum business in Switzerland.

If I were a US citizen, I would DEFINITELY expect my medical bills to rise STEEPLY in the near future...

Chris DeMuth Jr's avatar

Student lending reform idea: all institutions accepting third party payers post the % of graduates that are able to fund their loans with work relevant to their degree and that % can be used as a major selling point to potential students. Then they, the university, gets transferred the loan from the taxpayer at face value for any discrepancy beneath their claimed %. So if they say that 60% of their nurses get nursing jobs that can be used to service their debt but only 50% of a class gets hired as nurses, then the government or third party payer can take the loan off their book and transfer it to the (often richly endowed) school.

14 more comments...

Ready for more?