30 Comments
User's avatar
The Radical Individualist's avatar

On the other hand, pre-Trump America was soaring to new heights.

Ha ha, just kidding. America has been sinking into more debt ever since the 1970s. NAFTA and free trade with China decimated the manufacturing sector in America, long before Trump came on the scene. We have been on an unsustainable path for decades.

Is Trump making it worse or better? He could hardly make it worse, he might be making it better.

Say It Aint So's avatar

The same Americans who are bitching about higher prices are the same Americans who continually live beyond their means...Yes you can go all the way back in time to the 1970's but the younger generation needs to look no further than the Great Financial Crisis...where people were buying houses they could not afford with mortgages that were disastrous...I remember vividly my mortgage broker asking me in 2006 to consider a "low variable rate for the first 3 years" and then it balloons...I just cancelled a credit card (US Bank) who is now charging 27% interest...and I do not carry balances...

The Radical Individualist's avatar

I remember it well. We could see the collapse coming. Those of us who are rational made plans around the impending collapse. Those who wanted to buy as much as possible as soon as possible, signed their lives away, oblivious to reality.

Obey The Pug's avatar

Banks and US gov are oblivious to reality also. We had 1 trillion in USA debt in 1981. We could not and would not pay, and haven't paid that back. Now its 39 trillion and we won't, can't and absolutely will not pay the 39 trillion owed. So what does the amount matter if we are not going to pay it anyway. $39 trillion or $$$390 trillion? The Fed and US banks are not going to kill the golden goose of American citizens. Refinancing in brand new and improved programs where all old debt is placed in a LOCKBOX protected by Al Gore.

It is absurd beyond imagining, but the banks make the rules and Americans will continue like we have for the last 250 years. Of course, sane Americans want all debts paid and obligations paid in full, but that is not in the best interest of bankers. Paying the debts to banks is not what matters to them. Loaning more and more and reloaning the same loans over and over is their game. The rest of the world bankers just follow along doing the same thing to their citizens. I used to bloviate like you, about following the rules while bankers made new rules along the way.

The Radical Individualist's avatar

Bloviate? In what sense?

You're saying what I'm saying, and I did it in a shorter space.

I would only disagree to the extent of not directly blaming bankers. It is our elected government officials who are directly responsible. Interest payments on the national debt, and the printing of money to cover that debt, reduces that value of everyone's money. It's a hidden tax, on top of all the other taxes.

The Scratch's avatar

The mid-70s was when our trade surplus switched to a trade deficit, almost to the year that the Federal debt as a percentage of GDP stopped decreasing and started to increase. The debt to GDP in the 1970s dropped to around 30 to 40%. Today its back to the post WWII level of over 100%. But we had a trade surplus back then that allowed us to decrease the percentage.

Today we have a massive trade deficit- there's no way of dealing with the Federal debt without dealing with the trade deficit.

The Radical Individualist's avatar

Absolutely. A country's economy is essentially the same as a family's economy, only bigger. If more money goes out than comes in, the difference can only be covered with debt. And the more debt, the more difficult to get out of debt. Absolutely nothing changes, just because it's a government and not a family.

george's avatar

The BRICS summit is at the end of this month. While I don't want to bet against America, war with Iran I think is a watershed moment. Trump was lied to by our MIC or he is compromised. I'm curious how many other countries will want to offer tenders for invite?

Bill Lacey's avatar

If you're one of the Koch brothers, then de-industrializing the country and sending critical industries abroad, including to our enemies, represented Pax Americana. To people living in Western PA and West Virginia who haven't yet learned to code, it was anything but "rising living standards and unprecedented economic growth".

The biggest tell in why this article was written was declaring tariffs can't help in rebuilding industries destroyed by globalism, so why even try. It even went so far as to declare those industries "obsolete". Really, steel is obsolete? Textiles? Furniture? Consumer electronics?

Why not just come out and tell the American people - you're getting raped, there's nothing you can do about it, so sit back and enjoy it. Free advice from the folks at the American Institute for Economic Research, the multinational Koch Industries funded "think tank".

Good fucking grief.

Aja's avatar

You nailed it, Bill…

The Scratch's avatar

The globalists agree with this article's agenda of painting tariffs as wrong.

When a London School of Economics educated economist was asked why American MBA schools won't teach American federal deficits pay for trade deficits, he said it doesn't fit the globalists' agenda.

Another British economist Wynne Godley fled the U.K. for the U.S. because of the U.K.'s disfunctual globalist trade policies but we are one step behind the U.K..

Godley taught "sectoral balances", that the "trade deficit"= "public sector deficit" + "private sector deficit".

DM Rigby's avatar

QTR you make unsupported general statements, " these tariffs cannot revive declining industries". Also I see no mention of all the countries that have existing long term tariffs on USA made goods, Trumps new tariffs are simply leveling the playing field with' many countries.

Terry's avatar

QTR did not write the article.

Leskunque Lepew's avatar

"America raises its trade barriers, the rest of the world is lowering theirs"

Hmm....you sure about that?

Blaming the current administration for the economic shambles we face is quite myopic. This economic mess has been kicked down the road for a very long time by many prior administrations. Our representatives made a nice living off of this mess. How patriotic.

The current administration is trying to reverse this decay but many do not want to help.

The Transnational gangsters have their claws deep inside the Beltway.

I hope this will change soon or it will be the end of the Pax Americana.

Harley Oien's avatar

Your article is 1/2 excellent. We Pax Americana citizens watched as our leaders of the past endorsed the buildup of Mao China to a modern juggernaut of business and trade. Those leaders watched USA industry dissolve as manufacturing and manufacturing jobs fled to low labor cost China. We got cheap, low quality products in return as our labor force milled about aimlessly on EBT cards and drugs. Idle people lose hope and resort to daily survival. I recently purchased Chinese produced, "certified" stainless steel wire which failed due to corrosion within less than a year. NOT stainless steel!! I asked Chinese producer if their product met ASTM standards for stainless steel wire and our discussion of the issue ceased abruptly. They had touted their product for ZIP line use (just imagine the lawyer stampede when that happens). Then the USA became totally leaderless for four years of Biden absence. Imagine any organization succeeding when the leader is never present to guide policy and actions of the organization. Add to that the fact that Congress has been basically absent for the past decades, as members focus upon enriching themselves and ignoring the problems of the Republic. Add to that, the fact that many of the Judicial Branch have abandoned their sworn responsibility to defend the Constitution of America and have assumed duties of the Legislative Branch to generate law, which does not support the Constitution. QED: NO leadership for an entire four years of USA existence, NO Congressional duties exercised, NO Judicial actions focused upon Constitutional fact and you get our current society of cheap, shoddy products and a work force with nothing to do. Citizens focus upon personal benefits and ignore our plight!!

How could our current circumstances be any different?

William Gary IV's avatar

Chris, this guy is not your friend, nor a friend to America and the Alexander Hamilton school of industrialism to fuel home grown economic development. The gals at Promethian Action wrote an ebook called “It’s the British Who Killed Our Presidents”. This guy is siding with that system of global slavery centered from the banksters in the City of London. Run away.

Aja's avatar

Run away and don’t turn your back…

george's avatar

Cheap goods made by slaves are important to our economy. I remember when China was filled with starving peasants and now they are a Strategic threat. America did that without tariffs. Our country was wealthiest before we replaced tariffs with taxes.

ericzd's avatar

You and your Wall-Street buddies know nothing about national security and the state of our industrial base. You are absolutely crazy to be parroting this garbage. Hopefully, you can see the geopolitics at play and the reason why we need a strong industrial base. Or maybe not, financial engineers, globalists, and wall street goons have facilitated destroying our industrial base!

Eamon O'Ceallaigh's avatar

You are correct that tariffs are a tax paid by Americans and fall hardest on low income earners. Tariffs are effectively a targeted consumption tax. (Note: Those politicians screaming the hardest about tariffs would love to see higher corporate taxes) Other hidden taxes that fall to consumers are corporate taxes, restrictive employment laws, and over regulation, all of which are being addressed by the current administration. I look at tariffs much like climate change. The EU recently confessed that it made a massive blunder giving up its nuclear program which has increased its dependence of foreign energy and gutted out its world leading manufacturing base, (Exhibit A: Germany). It just doesn't work if the entire world sucks up the cheap energy and secures a competitive advantage. Free trade is great if embraced by all players. Not so great when it is no longer fair trade. Tariffs are a tool and like all tools if used correctly can achieve the stated goal. In this case, reorganizing world trade and reestablishing US manufacturing and reducing its dependence on key resources (rare earth)...I'm open to hearing other strategies to achieve these key goals. Please share if you have them.

Jim Johnson's avatar

I'm not buying it. so far, we have not seen inflation. sure some companies don't like it. they would love to have American's subsidize their business by eating other countries tariffs. the bottom line for me is: are their tariffs on the US the same as our tariffs on them? if not, why not. of course the answer is again, get those dumb Americans to pay for our welfare. Some economists think that is somehow the natural way of the universe. those days are over. everybody pays their own way.

Curtis's avatar

The term “global free trade” is an oxymoron.

Allan Richard Wasem's avatar

Selective tariffs for limited periods of time have their utility. Large blanket tariffs for lengthy periods do not.

Say It Aint So's avatar

The rationalization has always been the US is now a Service industry country...and no longer a manufacturer...Thus China has taken up where Mexico has fallen...and there are many Americans who have made billions from this...starting with Jeff Bezos of Amazon...

In the second 1992 Presidential Debate, Ross Perot argued:

We have got to stop sending jobs overseas. It's pretty simple: If you're paying $12, $13, $14 an hour for factory workers and you can move your factory South of the border, pay a dollar an hour for labor, ... have no health care—that's the most expensive single element in making a car— have no environmental controls, no pollution controls and no retirement, and you don't care about anything but making money, there will be a giant sucking sound going south.

... when [Mexico's] jobs come up from a dollar an hour to six dollars an hour, and ours go down to six dollars an hour, and then it's leveled again. But in the meantime, you've wrecked the country with these kinds of deals.[1]

rob's avatar

We have given other countries open access to our markets . They have reciprocated by opening their markets to us.

Say It Aint So's avatar

But is this considered Free Trade?

george's avatar

Yes. Trade deficits are good for the economy, remember?

Bo Underwood's avatar

"China’s meteoric rise". Uhh, their GDP growth is now the lowest since the early 90's... and this guy is some sort of economist?

Give me a break.