The Fed created Trump too. We have maligned populist entities on both sides fueling fantasy politics. Not that Trump or a Democrat doesn't occasionally do something right but on the whole I suspect the bizarre last decade is a form of escapism from this burgeoning debt that remains unresolved, not to mention housing and stock bubbles, inflation, etc.
Totally agree. But I would also point out that allowing a depression to let everyone suffer equally as the politicians and fed inadvertently did in the 1930’s does not end well either. We ended up with FDR, who continually tried to prime the pump with government spending and was in initial proponent ( fortunately unsuccessfully ) of packing the Supreme Court. IMHO - the three biggest reforms that would counterattack such tendencies are term limits for Congress, a rules based monetary policy, and some sort of budgetary restraint on spending by the government ( I personally favor percentage of GDP at 15% or lower} .
“For indeed any city, however small, is in fact divided into two, one the city of the poor, the other of the rich; these are at war with one another; and in either there are many smaller divisions, and you would be altogether beside the mark if you treated them all as a single State.”
Sliwa know more about the five boroughs in his pinky than Madummy will ever accumulate in his lifetime.
Every person that served in Congress, The Senate & White House for the last six decades is responsible for the current national situation. Yeah....I know...its Trumps fault...
Agree, but my belief is you have to go all the way back to 1913 when Woodrow Wilson, a democrat, entered the white house and the democrats controlled all of congress. That is the year we were "given" the Federal Reserve and the new federal income tax. It's been a spend and borrow regime every year since.
He is a feature of the system, not a bug. Both side expand government power in different ways and then sell the expansion as a solution to the problem. Its just a consolation of power to the government.
Trump has acted more like a communist than Mamdani has. The mayor is opening a few city owned grocery stores in areas of the city which lack grocery stores, while the federal government is buying large stakes in many companies. Back in 2010 the Tea Party would have called this choosing the winners and called President Obama a communist for supporting the bank bailout.
Mamdani isn’t kidnapped people off the street and bringing the to American concentration camps, the Trump administration is.
Seems to me, that your dear leader is much closer to being a communist than the popular mayor of the greatest city on earth.
You gotta be retarded to believe Trump is “more communist” than Mamdami
We might different opinions on politics, immigration, role of government, etc and should welcome discussion. But nobody will take your opinion seriously if this is your starting point
Nailed it. In some ways you can't blame regular folks who are pissed off and looking for any alternative. Unfortunately they are going to elect the worst possible people to throw gasoline on the fire
I have no clue what the demographics of QTR are, but imagine being 25 or 30 now with student debt, a worthless degree, 8% mortgages and AI hysteria. Socialist messages just might resonate.
Any body want to wager on when Mamdani joins the board of a major financial institution? Hahaha. It could be only after he becomes a Senator or Governor. Probably not before. but maybe! Or maybe he’ll go right to President Mamdani? Direct to the White House? I wouldn’t say never. He will become a combo of Teddy Roosevelt and FDR. Maybe he’ll run against JD? But only on JD’s 2nd term election. No shit. This is America. God Bless It. You start out a communist if you have to, like Huey Long. Then you become a socialist or a capitalist. Whatever. Just words. The reality is the election. And the constitution. That’s it. If Mamdani is the president he will be a public-private partnership guy — FDR. Teddy. And JP Morgan all mixed together. I can almost hear Woody Guthrie’s banjo. Nothin ever changes. Ever. You think it’s new only because we experience it in our lives, and it’s the first time we’ve seen it.
Spending can't decline meaningfully. The deficit is 6% of the economy. Even cut that in half -- which is still a trillion of added debt per year -- and you've got a nice recession. No administration has the courage to deliver that medicine.
That leaves inflation and growth/productivity as the tools. Both still require debt to grow slower than either of them. The likely "solution" from here is pretty much what we are seeing today, the lazy man's easiest path -- extremely pro-growth leadership that hopes the inflation side of the equation lags the growth side.
The poor and middle class are certainly worse off than they were 20 years ago, but are they really worse off than "previous generations"? When my parents grew up in the 1930's and 40's, they lived in bare floor shacks without electricity, couldn't even dream of owning a car, and barely had enough to eat. And they were not unusually poor. The "huge" house that the village doctor lived in would be modest by today's standards and, while he owned a car, he certainly didn't own two. Literally no one took vacations "down south" and most people had precisely 2 sets of clothes--one for weekdays, one for Sunday. Even when I was a kid in the 1970's, people expected MUCH less than they do now.--e.g., only the "rich" families had 2 cars or went on vacations to Florida. I could go on, but you get the picture.
Don't you think the real problem now is the mismatch between expectations and reality, rather than reality itself? The "poor" and middle class in the USA are among the richest people of any place and any time. I agree that the direction of travel is wrong and that government policy is partly to blame for this, but I wish people would stop perpetuating the lie that "previous generations" had it so much easier. It helps create the resentment that leads to the socialists like Mamdani gaining power.
Yes. This is driven by our culture making wealth appear to be so prominent. It makes people envious, and distorts their perception of what they don't have, versus what would truly make them happy.
I cannot speak to the 1930s and 40s, but in the 1950s, 60s and some years thereafter it was possible for a family to own a house, car and take a simple vacation on one middle-class income and no stock market wealth. That has been a pipe dream for a long time.
I grew up in a 1300 sq foot house with one tiny bathroom and 7 people. One crappy car. Vacations were camping within a day's drive away. I bought my first car at age 28. I lived in crappy apartments all through my school years, and shopped very carefully. I had no credit card until I was 25 or so, and didn't really use it.
Now many (?most) of the students I know have cars. They travel on weekends and stay in hotels. They don't work part time. Then they graduate with a theatre degree huge loans and complain about how expensive things are and move into their mom's basement.
OTOH, the 30-yr-old electrician who just redid our panel owns a very nice house, several vehicles, and employs an assistant. I suspect he will be financially able to retire by age 50.
The average house today is over 2200 sq ft, with finishes that we only would have seen in mansions in the 70's when I grew up. Hedonic adjustment is a real thing.
The Fed created Trump too. We have maligned populist entities on both sides fueling fantasy politics. Not that Trump or a Democrat doesn't occasionally do something right but on the whole I suspect the bizarre last decade is a form of escapism from this burgeoning debt that remains unresolved, not to mention housing and stock bubbles, inflation, etc.
I concur.
Totally agree. But I would also point out that allowing a depression to let everyone suffer equally as the politicians and fed inadvertently did in the 1930’s does not end well either. We ended up with FDR, who continually tried to prime the pump with government spending and was in initial proponent ( fortunately unsuccessfully ) of packing the Supreme Court. IMHO - the three biggest reforms that would counterattack such tendencies are term limits for Congress, a rules based monetary policy, and some sort of budgetary restraint on spending by the government ( I personally favor percentage of GDP at 15% or lower} .
And Hoover?
“For indeed any city, however small, is in fact divided into two, one the city of the poor, the other of the rich; these are at war with one another; and in either there are many smaller divisions, and you would be altogether beside the mark if you treated them all as a single State.”
-Plato’s Republic, Book 4
“You are on your own”* —QTR disclaimer
*Disclaimer takes effect the moment you’re born—the economic regime doesn’t change the terms.
LOL well said...
Sliwa know more about the five boroughs in his pinky than Madummy will ever accumulate in his lifetime.
Every person that served in Congress, The Senate & White House for the last six decades is responsible for the current national situation. Yeah....I know...its Trumps fault...
Agree, but my belief is you have to go all the way back to 1913 when Woodrow Wilson, a democrat, entered the white house and the democrats controlled all of congress. That is the year we were "given" the Federal Reserve and the new federal income tax. It's been a spend and borrow regime every year since.
He is a feature of the system, not a bug. Both side expand government power in different ways and then sell the expansion as a solution to the problem. Its just a consolation of power to the government.
Trump has acted more like a communist than Mamdani has. The mayor is opening a few city owned grocery stores in areas of the city which lack grocery stores, while the federal government is buying large stakes in many companies. Back in 2010 the Tea Party would have called this choosing the winners and called President Obama a communist for supporting the bank bailout.
Mamdani isn’t kidnapped people off the street and bringing the to American concentration camps, the Trump administration is.
Seems to me, that your dear leader is much closer to being a communist than the popular mayor of the greatest city on earth.
You lost everyone after typing "American concentration camps"
You gotta be retarded to believe Trump is “more communist” than Mamdami
We might different opinions on politics, immigration, role of government, etc and should welcome discussion. But nobody will take your opinion seriously if this is your starting point
Fucking clown
Nailed it. In some ways you can't blame regular folks who are pissed off and looking for any alternative. Unfortunately they are going to elect the worst possible people to throw gasoline on the fire
I have no clue what the demographics of QTR are, but imagine being 25 or 30 now with student debt, a worthless degree, 8% mortgages and AI hysteria. Socialist messages just might resonate.
Any body want to wager on when Mamdani joins the board of a major financial institution? Hahaha. It could be only after he becomes a Senator or Governor. Probably not before. but maybe! Or maybe he’ll go right to President Mamdani? Direct to the White House? I wouldn’t say never. He will become a combo of Teddy Roosevelt and FDR. Maybe he’ll run against JD? But only on JD’s 2nd term election. No shit. This is America. God Bless It. You start out a communist if you have to, like Huey Long. Then you become a socialist or a capitalist. Whatever. Just words. The reality is the election. And the constitution. That’s it. If Mamdani is the president he will be a public-private partnership guy — FDR. Teddy. And JP Morgan all mixed together. I can almost hear Woody Guthrie’s banjo. Nothin ever changes. Ever. You think it’s new only because we experience it in our lives, and it’s the first time we’ve seen it.
Wow! I actually agree with EVERYTHING you wrote. Kudos to a job well done. It is both as complicated and simple as you wrote.
Realistically, how do we go from here knowing that the government will never really try to reduce spending enough to end this cycle?
Spending can't decline meaningfully. The deficit is 6% of the economy. Even cut that in half -- which is still a trillion of added debt per year -- and you've got a nice recession. No administration has the courage to deliver that medicine.
That leaves inflation and growth/productivity as the tools. Both still require debt to grow slower than either of them. The likely "solution" from here is pretty much what we are seeing today, the lazy man's easiest path -- extremely pro-growth leadership that hopes the inflation side of the equation lags the growth side.
Great piece and dead right on!!!
Wow. I only just subscribed and there's my money's worth in one article. Keep them coming.
Sliwa is a stunatz.
It may be too late - as Hunter S Thompson would say “the hog is in the tunnel”
The poor and middle class are certainly worse off than they were 20 years ago, but are they really worse off than "previous generations"? When my parents grew up in the 1930's and 40's, they lived in bare floor shacks without electricity, couldn't even dream of owning a car, and barely had enough to eat. And they were not unusually poor. The "huge" house that the village doctor lived in would be modest by today's standards and, while he owned a car, he certainly didn't own two. Literally no one took vacations "down south" and most people had precisely 2 sets of clothes--one for weekdays, one for Sunday. Even when I was a kid in the 1970's, people expected MUCH less than they do now.--e.g., only the "rich" families had 2 cars or went on vacations to Florida. I could go on, but you get the picture.
Don't you think the real problem now is the mismatch between expectations and reality, rather than reality itself? The "poor" and middle class in the USA are among the richest people of any place and any time. I agree that the direction of travel is wrong and that government policy is partly to blame for this, but I wish people would stop perpetuating the lie that "previous generations" had it so much easier. It helps create the resentment that leads to the socialists like Mamdani gaining power.
Yes. This is driven by our culture making wealth appear to be so prominent. It makes people envious, and distorts their perception of what they don't have, versus what would truly make them happy.
I cannot speak to the 1930s and 40s, but in the 1950s, 60s and some years thereafter it was possible for a family to own a house, car and take a simple vacation on one middle-class income and no stock market wealth. That has been a pipe dream for a long time.
Chiming in on my wife's above post.
I grew up in a 1300 sq foot house with one tiny bathroom and 7 people. One crappy car. Vacations were camping within a day's drive away. I bought my first car at age 28. I lived in crappy apartments all through my school years, and shopped very carefully. I had no credit card until I was 25 or so, and didn't really use it.
Now many (?most) of the students I know have cars. They travel on weekends and stay in hotels. They don't work part time. Then they graduate with a theatre degree huge loans and complain about how expensive things are and move into their mom's basement.
OTOH, the 30-yr-old electrician who just redid our panel owns a very nice house, several vehicles, and employs an assistant. I suspect he will be financially able to retire by age 50.
The average house today is over 2200 sq ft, with finishes that we only would have seen in mansions in the 70's when I grew up. Hedonic adjustment is a real thing.
-Chris